Repository navigation
Too much complexity. #213
Description
The latest 127 commits are full of shit, a project that would just brings a simple yet complete settings widgets for your app is now a full blown unwanted abstraction to UI designs, including but not limited to fluent and adwaita which aren't flutter standard, and instead of using fluent_ui and yaru, u just reinvented the wheel duh. ur code at this d671283 point is pristine, after that, everything can be dropped.
the commit bca95ef, the latest at the moment of writing, has 24590 LOC on lib/ and test/ dirs, while the commit d671283 only has 2449. (Complexity vs Simplicity)
btw if a user sees this issue other than devs here, I forked the library to add my own stuff, feel free to use it https://github.com/iWisp360/flutter-settings-ui.
Activity
[-]Too much complexity, this library is already good on its own.[/-][+]Too much complexity.[/+]yadaniyil commentedon Oct 8, 2026
More than half of new code is tests.
#215 makes code better and simpler, more bugfixes included.
Not using
fluent_uioryaruis deliberate: the package adds no dependencies to any app, including phone-only ones.iWisp360 commentedon Oct 8, 2026
Meaning u added more than 12k lines of pure tests.
63 commits adding 2k loc on the way doesn't make ur code simpler in any sort of way, no matter how much bugs u fixed, it's like having a plastic bottle with piranha's solution in it and adding tape so it doesn't leak.
Is it deliberate? I feel bad for u fr, ur making some rly bad decisions. Adding dependencies is not in any way bad, reinventing the wheel is.