[Review required] SDD onboarding: webex-android-sdk-example

[ciscoRankush]

Automated Spec-Driven Development onboarding.

Run outcome

❌ FAILED — review required. Do not merge until the blocking checks are resolved.

• Time taken: 1h 19m

• Cost: $26.0133 reported + additional unknown cost

• Automated answer source: config-fallback (preconfigured assess-only assumption; not human-verified).

Failure context

• Code: repair_budget_exhausted
• Detail: repair_budget_exhausted: semantic validation remained blocked in generated-doc after 3 repair round(s): spec-validator: A0 ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: Component Interaction and Dependency / Interaction Topology repeat substantially the same UI, WebexViewModel, WebexRepository, Webex SDK, and FCM relationships in separate diagrams and tables without distinct concern-specific information. Repair: Consolidate the repeated interaction atoms into one canonical interaction view and replace the other occurrence with a short purpose-specific cross-reference.; A0 ai-docs/RULES.md: The hardcoded AES-key and logged-FCM-token violations are repeated across Logging, Security, and Secrets Policy, including repeated remediation and enforcement-gap details. Repair: Keep each violation's full detail in one canonical section and use concise cross-references elsewhere.; A0 ai-docs/SECURITY.md: The hardcoded AES-key and logged-FCM-token findings are fully described in Secret & Credential Handling and repeated again in Known Sensitive Areas & Accepted Risks. Repair: Retain the detailed risk, evidence, and remediation once and make the secondary section reference that canonical entry without restating it

Provenance

• Execution identity: repo-annotation@0.7.1+workflow.1#sha256:9a7f571ecf9282b928794c9cb3267ebff9e81030881908f4bec568921440faa8
• Plugin source bundle: repo-annotation@0.7.1+workflow.1#sha256:2ef31be4a1df7cf9e6540b042a733a47f106f53e64d97eddc60f1a360735e21f
• Claude runtime projection: claude-plugin@v1#sha256:bfb77cdf774f8c709191b111c839cc7c5da0d9ce7fc27eee1f0b7a02ca92b0bc
• Plugin upstream commit: db85453ba5c24cbe15f53f76e3bd2666f1e8e870
• Workflow overlay: workflow.1
• Target repository commit: a0f5876b6aa973330c1a02b8c6f33fe23ae46ebe

Validation

Gate: BLOCKED

• Outcome: repair_budget_exhausted
• Proof: not established
• 🔒 manifest-schema (deterministic): pass
• 🔒 plugin-conformance (deterministic): pass
• 🔒 source-fidelity-inventory (deterministic): pass
• 🔒 heading-conformance (deterministic): pass
• · manifest-parity (deterministic): fail
  • Medium hf_747fb6fa11ebb4abdf4fbeda1b036e8a0e210aef8150c283198d2129483cae36: ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: auth/env var "CLIENT_SECRET" is in the docs but not in the manifest
  • Medium hf_28c3283325d7c0a43c5ddaa32d3d6f2a5ef89a78fdfdd78f4978023e03d870e3: ai-docs/SECURITY.md: auth/env var "CLIENT_SECRET" is in the docs but not in the manifest
• 🔒 workspace-coverage (deterministic): pass
• 🔒 spec-validator (llm): fail
  • execution: succeeded; runtime codex-sdk; model gpt-5.6-sol; tools 131; evidence 74/74
  • Blocking vf_29acc3a9258859f74517f5e7cea62f2edcdff94c71799df584d370ba5e5e053d @​ ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: A0 ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: Component Interaction and Dependency / Interaction Topology repeat substantially the same UI, WebexViewModel, WebexRepository, Webex SDK, and FCM relationships in separate diagrams and tables without distinct concern-specific information. Repair: Consolidate the repeated interaction atoms into one canonical interaction view and replace the other occurrence with a short purpose-specific cross-reference.
  • Blocking vf_b563602238b80e0578da72f897cacf39b4dc655bf5d1fa02770893b2a85bbd26 @​ ai-docs/RULES.md: A0 ai-docs/RULES.md: The hardcoded AES-key and logged-FCM-token violations are repeated across Logging, Security, and Secrets Policy, including repeated remediation and enforcement-gap details. Repair: Keep each violation's full detail in one canonical section and use concise cross-references elsewhere.
  • Blocking vf_2e6ada1fcb865d651f07c5138f6c188eb21b553c41ca3d2d8b07fce77cd5c329 @​ ai-docs/SECURITY.md: A0 ai-docs/SECURITY.md: The hardcoded AES-key and logged-FCM-token findings are fully described in Secret & Credential Handling and repeated again in Known Sensitive Areas & Accepted Risks. Repair: Retain the detailed risk, evidence, and remediation once and make the secondary section reference that canonical entry without restating it.
  • Blocking vf_b3daaf820c9712cf074045b1a1e1659602ef93b48ad92a520c695dbb3d80a630 @​ app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: A0 app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: The same direct-SDK-caller architecture—WebexViewModel calling Webex directly, WebexRepository owning observer/state behavior, and KitchenSinkFCMService bypassing through repository.webex—is repeatedly explained in Overview, Design Overview, Data Flow, Sequence Diagram(s), and Class / Component Relationships with extensive overlapping atoms. Repair: Assign ownership and rationale to Design Overview, movement to Data Flow, operation ordering to Sequence Diagram(s), and type edges to Class / Component Relationships; remove repeated explanations while preserving unique details.
  • Important vf_c70460c6aef86ec2128f47131d87f6ed5f6f2f8697c662d886711a3184271b61 @​ app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: A11 app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: modules[0].section_profile.has_design_tradeoff is null. The required Key Design Trade-off scaffold is present with [NEEDS HUMAN INPUT], but the applicability decision remains unresolved. Repair: Obtain and record the human decision for has_design_tradeoff, then retain and complete or remove the conditional section accordingly.
  • Important vf_54d39007fadaa4230da9816a21364909df31966c4786329511b90bae680c5e72 @​ AGENTS.md: A12 AGENTS.md: Claims cite broad directories and basename-only anchors such as app/src/main/, KitchenSinkApp.kt, WebexRepository.kt, and WebexViewModel.kt rather than exact repository-relative files. Repair: Replace every broad or basename-only evidence anchor with the exact repository-relative source file path.
  • Important vf_0f9c3b95f960d886299ea129feb60085be9f399fc15433771d74e831684ebe2f @​ ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: A12 ai-docs/ARCHITECTURE.md: Multiple claims use basename or symbol-oriented anchors including WebexRepository.kt, WebexViewModel.kt, KitchenSinkApp.kt, auth/LoginActivity.kt, and WebexModule.kt without their exact repository-relative paths. Repair: Render exact repository-relative paths for all cited implementation evidence.
  • Important vf_e4fab9bedd94b08d259fc5be1af751ae729c4e1fc0f21f49d7ba5028923ac6ad @​ ai-docs/CONTRACTS.md: A12 ai-docs/CONTRACTS.md: Dependency evidence uses basename or directory anchors such as WebexRepository.kt, firebase/, and buildSrc rather than exact files. Repair: Replace these anchors with exact repository-relative native source or build files.
  • Important vf_092127eac087721310113fbdb04d7de8919c376980f65e156290a2c94662decf @​ ai-docs/GETTING_STARTED.md: A12 ai-docs/GETTING_STARTED.md: The JDK prerequisite cites the abbreviated path buildSrc/.../Dependencies.kt and symbols instead of the exact file buildSrc/src/main/java/com/ciscowebex/androidsdk/build/Dependencies.kt. Repair: Use the exact repository-relative build configuration path without ellipses or symbol-only substitution.
  • Important vf_1bd5fd190a0a3e9f259ccac14681a0f362eb4ccfd136fcfe2832c242eab905a3 @​ ai-docs/GLOSSARY.md: A12 ai-docs/GLOSSARY.md: Authoritative-location cells use external symbols, basename-only files, and directories such as com.ciscowebex.androidsdk.Webex, WebexRepository.kt, auth/LoginActivity.kt, messaging/spaces/, and cucm/UCLoginActivity. Repair: Link each term to an exact repository-relative source file; label purely external SDK symbols as native-reference/external rather than repository file evidence.
  • Important vf_936dbb4280205bac550afb16907a7252be3943a1ac8c3d0852da5b07be6919d8 @​ ai-docs/RULES.md: A12 ai-docs/RULES.md: Naming, error-handling, and concurrency claims cite basename-only files such as WebexModule.kt, KitchenSinkApp.kt, and WebexRepository.kt. Repair: Replace every basename-only anchor with its exact repository-relative source path.
  • Important vf_81dd068989a6409342fd511978f83ad3194671410cc3381a246b02da0a584a16 @​ ai-docs/SECURITY.md: A12 ai-docs/SECURITY.md: Authentication and session claims cite auth/LoginActivity.kt, WebexRepository.kt, auth/OAuthWebLoginActivity, and utils/SharedPrefUtils without complete repository-relative file paths. Repair: Use exact repository-relative source files for each security claim.
  • Important vf_d803cfb3c4b050a11822599ff5d8b6d9bf73475b790ebf42e6679515c8e9e94f @​ ai-docs/SERVICE_STATE.md: A12 ai-docs/SERVICE_STATE.md: Event and feature-flag rows cite symbols and basename-only anchors such as WebexRepository.setSpaceObserver, WebexRepository.CallEvent, AndroidManifest.xml, AppConfiguration, and utils/SharedPrefUtils. Repair: Add exact repository-relative defining files for each event, store, and flag claim.
  • Important vf_b58941062a818af62eae92efb9f534ca721518aab42b77eb8d6d78dec64044ff @​ app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: A12 app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: Requirements, key-file rows, flows, and use cases repeatedly cite basename-only or directory anchors such as WebexRepository.kt, WebexViewModel.kt, KitchenSinkApp.kt, auth/LoginActivity.kt, messaging/, firebase/, and ExampleUnitTest.kt. Repair: Replace every basename, directory, symbol, or ellipsis anchor with an exact repository-relative native file path.
  • Blocking vf_15cdf8a5382d3435477ecc849c29de7a505b5e1355e110caae48946880af3427 @​ app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: A13 app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: Although all universal sections and profile-selected scaffolds are present, the module spec repeats the same SDK-collaboration architecture across five major sections, so module-spec completion does not satisfy the uniqueness portion of the output contract. Repair: Perform a lossless section-by-section merge that retains each unique architecture, flow, sequence, and relationship atom only in its canonical section.
  • Important vf_28c46606c032363cb702ae8db40b66f9336074d8a2c814e017d65e8061a59d4c @​ AGENTS.md: A16 AGENTS.md: The Essential Commands table renders ./gradlew as an Install command, but .sdd/manifest.json has no command entry whose command equals ./gradlew and no install-role command. Repair: Add the verified install command to manifest.commands with appropriate provenance and role, or remove/rephrase the runnable command if it is not a supported repository command.
  • Important vf_9ef1c8dcea73beb0b5e915910baa89868d225140a94d6e34f54f17bef61ace4a @​ ai-docs/GETTING_STARTED.md: A16 ai-docs/GETTING_STARTED.md: The document renders ./gradlew, ./gradlew help, and ./gradlew installFullDebug without equal manifest.commands entries. It also requires JDK 17 and an Android SDK while the manifest records JDK with origin unknown and no version, and has no Android SDK toolchain entry, despite Dependencies.kt declaring Java 17 and Android SDK levels. Repair: Reconcile the verified commands and toolchain facts into .sdd/manifest.json, including repo-config provenance, then render the document from those entries.
  • Medium vf_807c3f0940839735790435a88f73746884a2c90cea9983e4d6b34e9d6eb4fb19 @​ app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: B7 app/ai-docs/app-spec.md: The real app/src tree also contains full/, meeting/, message/, and wxc/ flavor source sets omitted from the documented tree. The instrumented tree contains a substantial Espresso test harness and concrete HomeActivity and OAuth login-flow tests, contradicting the statements that no substantive suite and no auth-flow test were found. Repair: Update Folder / Package Structure to include and explain all four flavor source sets, and revise Test-Case Strategy to inventory the existing instrumented tests accurately while retaining narrower gaps such as missing coverage for all three login types.
  • Important vf_154035d3841cb489bd65fc754014d503359cea4d5194820a0570a6bf3a897d6d @​ ai-docs/SERVICE_STATE.md: B5 ai-docs/SERVICE_STATE.md: `WebexRepository.CallEvent` contains operation-result values such as DialCompleted, DialFailed, AnswerCompleted, and AnswerFailed, but it has no Connected or Disconnected values. Connected and disconnected notifications are separate `CallObserver` callbacks forwarded by `WxCallObserver`, so the catalog conflates two event types and does not name the actual payload contract accurately. Repair: Separate call operation-result events from `CallObserver` lifecycle callbacks and name their exact source types and event names.
  • Medium vf_94e7930ccfe2f5260f2ae4461cd0503e1c3f7dddc6eb68f588b23b0421656c56 @​ ai-docs/SECURITY.md: B7 ai-docs/SECURITY.md: `.github/pull_request_template.md` exists and contains a description prompt and review checklist. Repair: Update the repository review-path inventory to acknowledge the existing pull-request template while retaining any accurately evidenced gaps such as the absence of CODEOWNERS or a security-specific gate.
  • Important vf_6d53aff2daf67d5a36f31ca4575086892c11b5f504c97d9bce000aafe4a45500 @​ .sdd/manifest.json: B11-cmd .sdd/manifest.json: The recorded invocation strings `./gradlew assembleFullDebug`, `./gradlew testFullDebugUnitTest`, and `./gradlew connectedFullDebugAndroidTest` do not occur in `app/build.gradle`; `./gradlew build` and `./gradlew clean` do not occur in `build.gradle`. The files configure or generate the underlying Gradle tasks, but they do not contain the recorded commands as required by B11-cmd. Repair: Record command provenance in committed configuration that contains each exact invocation, or revise each command/source-file pair to an exact committed source that satisfies the command-containment contract.

Coverage

• Specced-module coverage: 0% (0/1 modules).

Status	Modules	Meaning
Specced	0	Surface documented to the policy threshold
Partial	1	Documented but below the threshold
Untracked	0	No specification yet

⚠️ 1 of 1 modules are not yet Specced. The generated coverage-review report in .generated/ names the highest-impact remaining gaps and the next required action for each; treat that as the work list rather than this summary.

Next steps

1. Review the blocking validation findings and the generated diff.
2. Correct the documentation on this review branch, or fix the workflow if the finding is not repository-specific.
3. Re-run the onboarding job and confirm every blocking check passes before merging.

Harness job: 5e79de6d-c566-40b2-a632-49e6222f3694