diff --git a/docs/verification/README.md b/docs/verification/README.md index 05591847d0..dcb2730ebe 100644 --- a/docs/verification/README.md +++ b/docs/verification/README.md @@ -16,6 +16,13 @@ node --experimental-strip-types scripts/control-omb.ts launch Run the foreground launcher directly rather than through `pnpm`; this ensures it receives Ctrl-C and can stop its child before removing the temporary data. +Automated parents can spawn `launch` or `ui launch` with a Node IPC channel +(`stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"]`) and send `"control-omb:stop"`. +That requests the same cleanup on every OS, including Windows where +`child.kill("SIGINT")` forcibly terminates the launcher. Disconnecting the +parent's IPC channel also requests cleanup. Wait for the launcher's exit +before checking that its temporary data has been removed. + It gives the child a temporary data directory and home, chooses a free harness/webhook port pair, installs only the repository's fake engine, prints the URL, PID, data directory, and persistent log path, then stays attached to @@ -53,6 +60,10 @@ Use only mapped, tested commands: - [Welcome flow and guided tour](onboarding.md) - [Channels](channels.md) - [In-chat team coordination](room-coordination.md) +- [Coordination regression coverage and migration](coordination-test-migration.md) +- [Optional addressed room routes](room-handoffs.md) +- [Required discussion in each layer](room-discussion.md) +- [Branching three-layer organization](room-pyramid.md) - [Chief access to additional teams](team-access.md) - [Engines and Doctor](engines.md) - [Claude coordination and turn-scoped tools](claude-tool-lifecycle.md) @@ -217,6 +228,12 @@ sent mentions, multiline scrolling and responsive wrapping in real chat views. The [Group and Goal Local VM recipe](group-local-vm.md) checks per-speaker desktop routing, cancellation, and computer authority cleanup. +The [addressed room work recipe](room-handoffs.md) checks opt-in routes, +recipient-only execution, cancellation and return routing. The +[discussion recipe](room-discussion.md) and [three-layer organization](room-pyramid.md) +exercise discussion, member assignment and downstream branching through the +shared control surface and the real injected agents MCP proxy. + ## Evidence The [persistence responsiveness benchmark](persistence-performance.md) measures diff --git a/docs/verification/coordination-test-migration.md b/docs/verification/coordination-test-migration.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3b45259c5d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/coordination-test-migration.md @@ -0,0 +1,77 @@ +# Coordination regression coverage + +Ordinary chats use `coordinate_bots`: the source finishes its provider turn, +the harness dispatches a pinned recipient task, and the result resumes the +source conversation. `ask_bot`, `delegate_bot` and teammate `start_thread` +remain on the separate legacy completion path used by routines. Ordinary +direct user turns can open bounded self-owned jobs with `start_thread`, as +restored by upstream #1166. Coordinated child turns cannot recursively open +self-owned jobs, and ordinary teammate handoffs use `coordinate_bots`. + +The former ordinary-chat tests still called those hidden legacy tools. This +migration originally kept all 25 cases together (9 pure tests and 16 server/MCP +tests). After upstream #1166, `server/comms.test.ts` retains the upstream pure +and actual-routine legacy tests, including removed-tool protocol errors. +`server/coordination-acp.e2e.test.ts` retains the 16 ordinary ACP coordination +cases separately. Shared fixture code replaces repeated setup and polling; +no behavioral scenario is removed or skipped. The 15 changed scenarios map as follows: + +| Previous scenario | Current contract and retained checks | +| --- | --- | +| ACP synchronous question and reply | Real injected MCP request; actual recipient result in resumed context; sender/recipient attribution; linked request/result receipts; recipient's old conversation unchanged | +| Gemini/Antigravity peer call | Real temporary ACP MCP mount and result return; no global Gemini MCP configuration written | +| Chief creates and delegates to an operator | Actual `create_bot`; same section/model; no Chief, automatic approval or connected-app privilege; actual subsequent addressed work | +| Asynchronous handoff after source settles | Child stays queued until source provider finishes; exactly one request and result receipt; source resumes on its original task | +| Chief stays available while peer works | A separate Chief task answers while the recipient runs; returned report reaches only the original task | +| Busy peer fallback | Work queues into a separate recipient task; its current conversation and output are preserved | +| Busy fallback across provider reload | Approved queued work completes after reload; no second approval or duplicate delivery | +| Synchronous timeout converts to durable work | Coordinated work outlives the old ask timeout; actual late result returns once | +| Empty successful reply | Completed child and successful terminal receipt, even without text | +| Provider reload interrupts work | Running child reaches a failed/cancelled terminal state; failure reaches the resumed source context | +| Crashed peer | Failed child, failed receipt and failure details in resumed source context | +| Target cannot start | Deleting a queued recipient prevents execution and recreation of its task | +| Allow contact | Real approval card and exact authorization key; no recipient execution before Allow; exactly one execution and approval | +| Deny contact | Actual MCP error; no recipient task created or provider started | +| One-hop recursion guard | Bounded multi-hop work succeeds; return to an ancestor is rejected; legacy tools remain hidden from coordinated child turns | + +`server/independent-threads-api.test.ts` retains its actual provider approval +socket and verifies waiting, one delivery, a separate recipient task, and +automatic return through coordination. `server/peer-allowlist.e2e.test.ts` +asserts the current prompt's restriction on granting access, impersonating +peers and creating bots; all existing endpoint/allow-list checks remain. + +`server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts` keeps all eight cases. A new human +request in a finished routine's execution thread now uses coordination and +must not alter that routine's recorded output or completion timestamp. + +`server/thread-aware-bots.e2e.test.ts` retains upstream's nine cases for +self-owned ordinary jobs and coordinated teammate work. The separate +`server/legacy-thread-tools.e2e.test.ts` retains ten legacy admission, +concurrency, approval, notification, deletion and visibility cases. Before +testing retained legacy endpoints with its existing scoped-capability fixture, +it verifies that a real ordinary-chat capability cannot create a legacy +teammate thread. An additional case obtains a **real routine provider capability**, +verifies `start_thread` delivery and result return, and verifies that the +routine cannot invoke `coordinate_bots`. The synthetic capability does not +replace this real mode-boundary check. + +The fake ACP adapter calls the real agents MCP subprocess from its supplied +entry, including its turn-scoped credentials. It reuses the existing scripted +coordination provider, rather than synthesizing successful tool responses. +It also retains updated MCP entries on ACP session load/resume, so subsequent +user turns exercise the fresh capability. All files and processes belong to +disposable fixture homes. + +Run the migrated cases with: + +```sh +pnpm exec vitest run server/comms.test.ts server/coordination-acp.e2e.test.ts server/legacy-thread-tools.e2e.test.ts server/independent-threads-api.test.ts server/peer-allowlist.e2e.test.ts server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts server/thread-aware-bots.e2e.test.ts +``` + +The scheduler's depth, request and execution budgets remain covered by +`server/room-handoffs.test.ts`; ordinary direct coordination, permission +revocation and cancellation remain covered by +`server/direct-coordination.e2e.test.ts`. Run these and the ACP driver contract +alongside the migrated cases, then run the normal full CI including broker, +Electron, packaged-server and native smoke stages. Do not treat a focused +pass as a successful full suite. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/README.md b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..20c2f3668d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,80 @@ +# Room hierarchy evidence — 2026-09-12 + +Upstream comparison base: `2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c`. +Proposal: [#1124](https://github.com/milind-soni/OpenMausBot/issues/1124). + +A subsequent [live Claude Code / GLM-5.3 run](live-2026-09-12/README.md) on this +same upstream base completed all five groups and records the real discussions, +generated artifacts, screenshots and unresolved acceptance findings. The record +below remains the earlier deterministic scripted run. + +The run uses an isolated `launchVerificationServer` fixture, the real server, +the real injected agents MCP proxy, and scripted provider responses. The React +screenshots show the resulting persisted conversations. No live application data +was used. This is **not** a fresh GLM-5.3 run or a semantic acceptance test of CSV +output. In particular, the scripted leaf replies are placeholders for work, not +the promised production artifacts. + +## Recorded workflow + +| Layer | Group / chair | Existing responsible members | Downstream destination | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1 | Executive / ミナト (Minato) | アオイ (Aoi), ユイ (Yui) | Development / Sales | +| 2 | Development / レン (Ren) | リツ (Ritsu), マコ (Mako) | Implementation / QA | +| 2 | Sales / コウ (Kou) | サキ (Saki), トワ (Towa) | Local execution | +| 3 | Implementation / ソラ (Sora) | ヒナ (Hina), ナギ (Nagi) | Local execution | +| 3 | QA / レオ (Leo) | メイ (Mei), ハル (Haru) | Local execution | + +Five groups, fifteen bots, seven discussion rounds, ten member assignments, five +work nodes and forty-five provider turns were recorded. Every node reached +`completed`. Assertions check that downstream requests belong to the assigned +member, later speakers receive earlier opinions, results return to the requesting +member and chair, and group membership remains unchanged. + +The chair proposes and decides in the same group. Assigning a member does not +create a new organizational layer. The return path is data plus a continuation; +it does not send another work request to the downstream recipient. + +## UI comparison + +The **before** image uses the unmodified upstream renderer from the comparison +base against the **same completed fixture data**. It demonstrates the UI delta, +not successful pre-change execution of this workflow. The **after** images use +the feature renderer. Screenshots are unmodified browser captures at 1280 × 720. + +| Before: group view without incoming-work controls | After: explicit incoming route and required discussion | +| --- | --- | +| ![Before](before-development.png) | ![After](after-incoming.png) | + +The Development incoming route was unchecked in the UI, observed as zero routes +after a reload, and checked again. The saved setting returned to Executive-only. +The required-discussion setting remained checked. No browser console errors were +reported for the inspected feature page. + +## Each group's discussion and return + +| Group | Discussion | Assignment/results | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Executive | [Proposal, concerns and revision](executive-discussion.png) | [Reviewed returns and final report](executive-results.png) | +| Development | [Incoming request and first discussion](development-discussion.png), [second round and decision](development-decision.png) | [Returns to Ritsu and Mako, then Ren](development-results.png) | +| Sales | [Incoming request and discussion](sales-discussion.png) | [Member assignments and report](sales-results.png) | +| Implementation | [Incoming request and discussion](implementation-discussion.png) | [Member assignments and report](implementation-results.png) | +| QA | [Incoming request and discussion](qa-discussion.png) | [Member assignments and report](qa-results.png) | + +[transcripts.json](transcripts.json) preserves the text messages, synthetic +identities, tree edges, participants and terminal states without machine paths, +credentials, or private configuration. [sha256.txt](sha256.txt) records the exact +image and transcript hashes. + +## Interpretation and reproduction + +Run the [three-layer recipe](../../room-pyramid.md) to reproduce orchestration. +The [basic handoff](../../room-handoffs.md) and +[discussion](../../room-discussion.md) recipes cover refusal, cancellation and +ordering behavior. The PR records the separate full-suite and baseline results; +these screenshots do not imply that the full suite is green. + +Scripted ordering/context assertions do not measure real-model tool selection, +reasoning quality, token costs, correctness across generated artifacts, or support +across every engine. A leader can still incorrectly accept a result. The bounded +scheduler does not replace acceptance review by the leader or human. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/after-incoming.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/after-incoming.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..f39aa5b25c Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/after-incoming.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/before-development.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/before-development.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6d5e83fa02 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/before-development.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-decision.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-decision.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..11d70585c2 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-decision.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3902da512a Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9caf2e33a0 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/development-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..87a90a28b3 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d534ee0aaf Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/executive-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8bc873694f Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..426300d445 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/implementation-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/.gitattributes b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..748e47e087 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +*.json -text +*.txt -text diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/README.md b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3ade864b69 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +# Integration with upstream coordination, 2026-09-13 + +Baseline: upstream `536b7893549924c3e2b71eb2e9564ea2986a146a`, including #1136, +#1153 and #1147. The containing merge commit retains upstream `coordinate_bots`, +direct-chat coordination, explicit Chief team grants and compact request receipts. +Structured room discussion and source-group restrictions are optional settings. + +## UI comparison + +The actual React application ran against disposable fixture servers on loopback. +The baseline used an independent worktree at the exact upstream commit. Both +settings fixtures contained Executive and Development groups with existing bots. +Screenshots were captured through the in-app browser at 1280 x 720. + +| State | Screenshot | Supporting evidence | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Upstream baseline | [before-group.png](before-group.png) | [DOM](before-dom.txt) | +| Integrated default, collapsed | [after-default.png](after-default.png) | [DOM](after-default-dom.txt) | +| Discussion required; Executive allowed | [after-configured.png](after-configured.png) | [DOM](after-configured-dom.txt), [saved settings](after-configured-settings.json) | +| Incoming restriction disabled again | [after-unrestricted.png](after-unrestricted.png) | [DOM](after-unrestricted-dom.txt), [saved settings](after-unrestricted-settings.json) | + +The saved settings were read back from the fixture API after browser interaction. +Disabling the restriction persists `incomingGroupIds: null`; enabling discussion +does not create or invite any members. Default upstream coordination remains +available when these settings are absent. + +## Three-layer execution + +```sh +pnpm exec vite build +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts .omb-scratch/integration-pyramid/verification.json --preview +``` + +The merged server and actual injected agents MCP proxy completed 45 scripted +provider turns in five groups with fifteen existing bots. The durable tree has +five work nodes (including the root), ten member assignments and seven discussion +rounds; every node completed. Existing memberships stayed unchanged. +[pyramid.json](pyramid.json) retains the rooms, request tree and transcripts. + +| Layer | Group | Discussion | Decision / work / result | +| --- | --- | --- | --- | +| 1 | Executive | [screenshot](executive-discussion.png) | [screenshot](executive-results.png), [DOM](executive-dom.txt) | +| 2 | Development | [screenshot](development-discussion.png) | [screenshot](development-results.png), [DOM](development-dom.txt) | +| 2 | Sales | [screenshot](sales-discussion.png) | [screenshot](sales-results.png), [DOM](sales-dom.txt) | +| 3 | Implementation | [screenshot](implementation-discussion.png) | [screenshot](implementation-results.png), [DOM](implementation-dom.txt) | +| 3 | QA | [screenshot](qa-discussion.png) | [screenshot](qa-results.png), [DOM](qa-dom.txt) | + +Executive's Aoi requests work from Development's Ren, while Yui requests Sales's +Kou. After Development's discussion, Ritsu requests Implementation's Sora and +Mako requests QA's Leo. Each lower group discusses and assigns its own members; +results resume the responsible members and then their chairs. + +This is a deterministic workflow and UI regression, **not a new GLM-5.3 run**. +The scripted opinions and deliverables are placeholders. They prove ordering, +speaker identity, routing, and continuation, not useful deliberation or acceptance +of a generated CSV. The historical live-model evidence in the sibling directories +remains pinned to its earlier implementation and retains failed final CSV-column +acceptance. It must not be relabeled as evidence of this merged implementation. + +## Validation + +- Integration-focused scheduler/lifecycle/discussion/pyramid: 4 suites, 37 tests. +- Final review regressions after the atomic settings save, cancellation and + original-request preservation fixes: 4 suites, 51 tests passed (116.42 seconds). +- Default upstream room-tool visibility regression: passed after making + `discuss_room` visible only in rooms with the discussion setting enabled. +- Broader upstream direct coordination, Chief setup, MCP and room integration: + 175 tests initially passed; the one tool-visibility failure was fixed and its + targeted test passed. Final full-suite/CI results are recorded in the PR. +- Typecheck, lint, locale validation and production UI build passed. +- Earlier review fixes were reproduced with Python 3.9.25 and real child-process + exit tests; all 32 historical live-evidence manifest entries remained unchanged. + +`sha256.txt` covers the captured screenshots, DOM, settings and request evidence. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4202d70829 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pearl Rename Pearl Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pearl" + - button "Rename Pearl": Pearl + - generic: Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pearl threads": + - button "New folder under Pearl": + - button "Actions for Pearl": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" + - paragraph: Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here. + - checkbox "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work" [checked] + - text: Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work + - checkbox "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups" [checked] + - text: Restrict incoming requests to selected groups + - checkbox "Executive" [checked] [active] + - generic: Executive + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-settings.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-settings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3d4eed8829 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured-settings.json @@ -0,0 +1,13 @@ +{ + "id": "ef327f9c-e095-43e1-9c04-b1adc863551b", + "name": "Development", + "memberIds": [ + "a4f0095b-ebbd-4a0d-a831-eed11ccfc46c", + "e226c662-63d4-4cbe-b080-edff18f43b2a", + "ef6c5e09-ee97-4641-bc97-49f90c4f7ee4" + ], + "requireRoomDiscussion": true, + "incomingGroupIds": [ + "7b25ca83-d13e-45e2-971c-18c620d233ed" + ] +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ef1a24be02 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-configured.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4293e156e5 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,105 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development" [active]: + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pearl Rename Pearl Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pearl" + - button "Rename Pearl": Pearl + - generic: Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pearl threads": + - button "New folder under Pearl": + - button "Actions for Pearl": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5e7aea4e2a Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-default.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5b83f7a5f2 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pearl Rename Pearl Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pearl" + - button "Rename Pearl": Pearl + - generic: Hi, I'm Pearl. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pearl threads": + - button "New folder under Pearl": + - button "Actions for Pearl": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" + - paragraph: Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here. + - checkbox "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work" [checked] + - text: Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work + - checkbox "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups" [active] + - text: Restrict incoming requests to selected groups + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-settings.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-settings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..1591aa688b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted-settings.json @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +{ + "id": "ef327f9c-e095-43e1-9c04-b1adc863551b", + "name": "Development", + "memberIds": [ + "a4f0095b-ebbd-4a0d-a831-eed11ccfc46c", + "e226c662-63d4-4cbe-b080-edff18f43b2a", + "ef6c5e09-ee97-4641-bc97-49f90c4f7ee4" + ], + "requireRoomDiscussion": true, + "incomingGroupIds": null +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..98813ec34d Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/after-unrestricted.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3e8355b109 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development" [active]: + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pebble Rename Pebble Hi, I'm Pebble. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pebble" + - button "Rename Pebble": Pebble + - generic: Hi, I'm Pebble. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pebble threads": + - button "New folder under Pebble": + - button "Actions for Pebble": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-group.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-group.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0a0d661b8f Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/before-group.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2dbba1c603 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..884bfde67a --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,352 @@ +- complementary "ボットとナビゲーション": + - button "サイドバーをアバターだけに畳む": + - button "サイドバーの表示密度を選ぶ" + - button "新規または共有": + - textbox "ボットとメッセージを検索": + - /placeholder: 検索 + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - 'button "レオ メイ +1 QAチーム レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "レオ" + - img "メイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: QAチーム + - generic: "レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand QAチーム threads": + - 'button "ソラ ヒナ +1 実装チーム ソラ: 実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "ソラ" + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 実装チーム + - generic: "ソラ: 実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 実装チーム threads": + - 'button "コウ サキ +1 営業部 コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "コウ" + - img "サキ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 営業部 + - generic: "コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 営業部 threads": + - button "レン リツ +1 開発部": + - img "レン" + - img "リツ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 開発部 + - button "Collapse 開発部 threads" [expanded]: + - group "開発部 threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ミナト アオイ +1 経営会議": + - img "ミナト" + - img "アオイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "Collapse 経営会議 threads" [expanded]: + - group "経営会議 threads": + - button "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - generic: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…" + - button "Actions for @ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ボット" [expanded]: + - generic: ボット + - button "Ivy Ivy の名前を変更 Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ivy" + - button "Ivy の名前を変更": Ivy + - generic: Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ivy threads": + - button "New folder under Ivy": + - button "Actions for Ivy": + - button "検証会社" [expanded]: + - generic: 検証会社 + - button "ハル QAチームの異常系担当 ハル の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ハル" + - generic: QAチームの異常系担当 + - button "ハル の名前を変更": ハル + - generic: Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ハル threads": + - button "New folder under ハル": + - button "Actions for ハル": + - button "メイ QAチームの境界値担当 メイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "メイ" + - generic: QAチームの境界値担当 + - button "メイ の名前を変更": メイ + - generic: Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand メイ threads": + - button "New folder under メイ": + - button "Actions for メイ": + - button "レオ QAチームのリーダー レオ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レオ" + - generic: QAチームのリーダー + - button "レオ の名前を変更": レオ + - generic: Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レオ threads": + - button "New folder under レオ": + - button "Actions for レオ": + - button "ナギ 実装チームのデータ検証担当 ナギ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ナギ" + - generic: 実装チームのデータ検証担当 + - button "ナギ の名前を変更": ナギ + - generic: Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ナギ threads": + - button "New folder under ナギ": + - button "Actions for ナギ": + - button "ヒナ 実装チームのCSV作成担当 ヒナ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: 実装チームのCSV作成担当 + - button "ヒナ の名前を変更": ヒナ + - generic: Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ヒナ threads": + - button "New folder under ヒナ": + - button "Actions for ヒナ": + - button "ソラ 実装チームのリーダー ソラ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: 実装チームのリーダー + - button "ソラ の名前を変更": ソラ + - generic: Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ソラ threads": + - button "New folder under ソラ": + - button "Actions for ソラ": + - button "トワ 営業部の営業運用担当 トワ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "トワ" + - generic: 営業部の営業運用担当 + - button "トワ の名前を変更": トワ + - generic: Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand トワ threads": + - button "New folder under トワ": + - button "Actions for トワ": + - button "サキ 営業部の顧客説明担当 サキ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "サキ" + - generic: 営業部の顧客説明担当 + - button "サキ の名前を変更": サキ + - generic: Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand サキ threads": + - button "New folder under サキ": + - button "Actions for サキ": + - button "コウ 営業部の部長 コウ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "コウ" + - generic: 営業部の部長 + - button "コウ の名前を変更": コウ + - generic: Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand コウ threads": + - button "New folder under コウ": + - button "Actions for コウ": + - button "マコ 開発部の品質担当 マコ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "マコ" + - generic: 開発部の品質担当 + - button "マコ の名前を変更": マコ + - generic: Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand マコ threads": + - button "New folder under マコ": + - button "Actions for マコ": + - button "リツ 開発部の実装担当 リツ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "リツ" + - generic: 開発部の実装担当 + - button "リツ の名前を変更": リツ + - generic: Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand リツ threads": + - button "New folder under リツ": + - button "Actions for リツ": + - button "レン 開発部の部長 レン の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レン" + - generic: 開発部の部長 + - button "レン の名前を変更": レン + - generic: Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レン threads": + - button "New folder under レン": + - button "Actions for レン": + - button "ユイ 経営会議の営業担当 ユイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ユイ" + - generic: 経営会議の営業担当 + - button "ユイ の名前を変更": ユイ + - generic: Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ユイ threads": + - button "New folder under ユイ": + - button "Actions for ユイ": + - button "アオイ 経営会議の開発担当 アオイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "アオイ" + - generic: 経営会議の開発担当 + - button "アオイ の名前を変更": アオイ + - generic: Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand アオイ threads": + - button "New folder under アオイ": + - button "Actions for アオイ": + - button "ミナト 経営会議の議長 ミナト の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ミナト" + - generic: 経営会議の議長 + - button "ミナト の名前を変更": ミナト + - generic: Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ミナト threads": + - button "New folder under ミナト": + - button "Actions for ミナト": + - paragraph + - button "ツール": + - generic: ツール + - button "あなた": + - generic: "?" + - generic: あなた +- main: + - generic: 開発部 + - button "すべてのスレッド": + - generic: すべてのスレッド + - generic: "1" + - button "会話内を検索": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "グループの作業フォルダー": + - generic "通常のメッセージは レン に届きます。@メンションが優先されます": + - combobox "既定の応答者": + - 'option "リード: レン" [selected]' + - 'option "リード: リツ"' + - 'option "リード: マコ"' + - option "全員が応答" + - option "メンションされたときだけ" + - button "メンバーを管理 — このグループにボット 3 体": + - generic "レン": + - img "レン" + - generic "リツ": + - img "リツ" + - generic "マコ": + - img "マコ" + - generic "グループの協働設定" + - button "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レンは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。": + - generic: 企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レンは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。 + - log "Group chat 開発部": + - generic: 今日 14:09 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: アオイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:01": + - paragraph: "@レン 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レン" + - generic: レン + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: 開発部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: 【議論】@リツ @マコ 開発部第1巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "リツ" + - generic: リツ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: リツ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "マコ" + - generic: マコ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:03": + - paragraph: マコ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レン" + - generic: レン + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:04": + - paragraph: 開発部修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:04": + - paragraph: 【議論】@リツ @マコ 開発部第2巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "リツ" + - generic: リツ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: リツ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "マコ" + - generic: マコ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: マコ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "リツ" + - generic: Sent to リツ + - img "マコ" + - generic: Sent to マコ + - img "レン" + - generic: レン + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:06": + - paragraph: 開発部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:06": + - paragraph: "@リツ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ソラ Sent to ソラ · 実装チーム": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: Sent to ソラ · 実装チーム + - img "リツ" + - generic: リツ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:07": + - paragraph: リツ担当として下層へ依頼しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レン" + - generic: レン + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:07": + - paragraph: "@マコ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "レオ Sent to レオ · QAチーム": + - img "レオ" + - generic: Sent to レオ · QAチーム + - img "マコ" + - generic: マコ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:08": + - paragraph: マコ担当として下層へ依頼しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ソラ ソラ replied · 実装チーム": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: ソラ replied · 実装チーム + - button "レオ レオ replied · QAチーム": + - img "レオ" + - generic: レオ replied · QAチーム + - img "リツ" + - generic: リツ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:14": + - paragraph: リツ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "マコ" + - generic: マコ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:14": + - paragraph: マコ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レン" + - generic: レン + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:15": + - paragraph: 開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ファイルを添付": + - button "みんなで仕上げる": + - text: 目標 + - textbox "開発部 へのメッセージ": + - /placeholder: 開発部 へのメッセージ — レン が応答します \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8cf6e0cefc Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/development-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2e90327dda Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9f12c8ba2e --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,346 @@ +- complementary "ボットとナビゲーション": + - button "サイドバーをアバターだけに畳む": + - button "サイドバーの表示密度を選ぶ" + - button "新規または共有": + - textbox "ボットとメッセージを検索": + - /placeholder: 検索 + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - 'button "レオ メイ +1 QAチーム レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "レオ" + - img "メイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: QAチーム + - generic: "レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand QAチーム threads": + - 'button "ソラ ヒナ +1 実装チーム ソラ: 実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "ソラ" + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 実装チーム + - generic: "ソラ: 実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 実装チーム threads": + - 'button "コウ サキ +1 営業部 コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "コウ" + - img "サキ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 営業部 + - generic: "コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 営業部 threads": + - 'button "レン リツ +1 開発部 レン: 開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "レン" + - img "リツ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 開発部 + - generic: "レン: 開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 開発部 threads": + - button "ミナト アオイ +1 経営会議": + - img "ミナト" + - img "アオイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "Collapse 経営会議 threads" [expanded]: + - group "経営会議 threads": + - button "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - generic: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…" + - button "Actions for @ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ボット" [expanded]: + - generic: ボット + - button "Ivy Ivy の名前を変更 Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ivy" + - button "Ivy の名前を変更": Ivy + - generic: Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ivy threads": + - button "New folder under Ivy": + - button "Actions for Ivy": + - button "検証会社" [expanded]: + - generic: 検証会社 + - button "ハル QAチームの異常系担当 ハル の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ハル" + - generic: QAチームの異常系担当 + - button "ハル の名前を変更": ハル + - generic: Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ハル threads": + - button "New folder under ハル": + - button "Actions for ハル": + - button "メイ QAチームの境界値担当 メイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "メイ" + - generic: QAチームの境界値担当 + - button "メイ の名前を変更": メイ + - generic: Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand メイ threads": + - button "New folder under メイ": + - button "Actions for メイ": + - button "レオ QAチームのリーダー レオ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レオ" + - generic: QAチームのリーダー + - button "レオ の名前を変更": レオ + - generic: Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レオ threads": + - button "New folder under レオ": + - button "Actions for レオ": + - button "ナギ 実装チームのデータ検証担当 ナギ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ナギ" + - generic: 実装チームのデータ検証担当 + - button "ナギ の名前を変更": ナギ + - generic: Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ナギ threads": + - button "New folder under ナギ": + - button "Actions for ナギ": + - button "ヒナ 実装チームのCSV作成担当 ヒナ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: 実装チームのCSV作成担当 + - button "ヒナ の名前を変更": ヒナ + - generic: Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ヒナ threads": + - button "New folder under ヒナ": + - button "Actions for ヒナ": + - button "ソラ 実装チームのリーダー ソラ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: 実装チームのリーダー + - button "ソラ の名前を変更": ソラ + - generic: Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ソラ threads": + - button "New folder under ソラ": + - button "Actions for ソラ": + - button "トワ 営業部の営業運用担当 トワ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "トワ" + - generic: 営業部の営業運用担当 + - button "トワ の名前を変更": トワ + - generic: Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand トワ threads": + - button "New folder under トワ": + - button "Actions for トワ": + - button "サキ 営業部の顧客説明担当 サキ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "サキ" + - generic: 営業部の顧客説明担当 + - button "サキ の名前を変更": サキ + - generic: Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand サキ threads": + - button "New folder under サキ": + - button "Actions for サキ": + - button "コウ 営業部の部長 コウ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "コウ" + - generic: 営業部の部長 + - button "コウ の名前を変更": コウ + - generic: Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand コウ threads": + - button "New folder under コウ": + - button "Actions for コウ": + - button "マコ 開発部の品質担当 マコ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "マコ" + - generic: 開発部の品質担当 + - button "マコ の名前を変更": マコ + - generic: Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand マコ threads": + - button "New folder under マコ": + - button "Actions for マコ": + - button "リツ 開発部の実装担当 リツ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "リツ" + - generic: 開発部の実装担当 + - button "リツ の名前を変更": リツ + - generic: Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand リツ threads": + - button "New folder under リツ": + - button "Actions for リツ": + - button "レン 開発部の部長 レン の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レン" + - generic: 開発部の部長 + - button "レン の名前を変更": レン + - generic: Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レン threads": + - button "New folder under レン": + - button "Actions for レン": + - button "ユイ 経営会議の営業担当 ユイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ユイ" + - generic: 経営会議の営業担当 + - button "ユイ の名前を変更": ユイ + - generic: Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ユイ threads": + - button "New folder under ユイ": + - button "Actions for ユイ": + - button "アオイ 経営会議の開発担当 アオイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "アオイ" + - generic: 経営会議の開発担当 + - button "アオイ の名前を変更": アオイ + - generic: Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand アオイ threads": + - button "New folder under アオイ": + - button "Actions for アオイ": + - button "ミナト 経営会議の議長 ミナト の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ミナト" + - generic: 経営会議の議長 + - button "ミナト の名前を変更": ミナト + - generic: Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ミナト threads": + - button "New folder under ミナト": + - button "Actions for ミナト": + - paragraph + - button "ツール": + - generic: ツール + - button "あなた": + - generic: "?" + - generic: あなた +- main: + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "すべてのスレッド": + - generic: すべてのスレッド + - generic: "1" + - button "会話内を検索": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "グループの作業フォルダー": + - generic "通常のメッセージは ミナト に届きます。@メンションが優先されます": + - combobox "既定の応答者": + - 'option "リード: ミナト" [selected]' + - 'option "リード: アオイ"' + - 'option "リード: ユイ"' + - option "全員が応答" + - option "メンションされたときだけ" + - button "メンバーを管理 — このグループにボット 3 体": + - generic "ミナト": + - img "ミナト" + - generic "アオイ": + - img "アオイ" + - generic "ユイ": + - img "ユイ" + - generic "グループの協働設定" + - button "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ミナトは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV出力の初期対象。仮案は全項目・全件出力。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求。2巡目で具体的な妥協案を再検討して決定する。": + - generic: 企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ミナトは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV出力の初期対象。仮案は全項目・全件出力。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求。2巡目で具体的な妥協案を再検討して決定する。 + - log "Group chat 経営会議": + - generic: 今日 14:08 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:55": + - text: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をcoordinate_botsで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。" + - generic: Sent through the API, not typed here + - generic: 14:08 + - img "ミナト" + - generic: ミナト + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:56": + - paragraph: 経営会議仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:56": + - paragraph: 【議論】@アオイ @ユイ 経営会議第1巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: アオイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:56": + - paragraph: アオイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "ユイ" + - generic: ユイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:57": + - paragraph: ユイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "ミナト" + - generic: ミナト + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:58": + - paragraph: 経営会議修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:58": + - paragraph: 【議論】@アオイ @ユイ 経営会議第2巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: アオイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:58": + - paragraph: アオイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "ユイ" + - generic: ユイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:08:59": + - paragraph: ユイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:08 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: Sent to アオイ + - img "ユイ" + - generic: Sent to ユイ + - img "ミナト" + - generic: ミナト + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:00": + - paragraph: 経営会議決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:00": + - paragraph: "@アオイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "レン Sent to レン · 開発部": + - img "レン" + - generic: Sent to レン · 開発部 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: アオイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:01": + - paragraph: アオイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ミナト" + - generic: ミナト + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:01": + - paragraph: "@ユイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "コウ Sent to コウ · 営業部": + - img "コウ" + - generic: Sent to コウ · 営業部 + - img "ユイ" + - generic: ユイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: ユイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "コウ コウ replied · 営業部": + - img "コウ" + - generic: コウ replied · 営業部 + - img "ユイ" + - generic: ユイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:08": + - paragraph: ユイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "レン レン replied · 開発部": + - img "レン" + - generic: レン replied · 開発部 + - img "アオイ" + - generic: アオイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:16": + - paragraph: アオイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ミナト" + - generic: ミナト + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:17": + - paragraph: 経営会議統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ファイルを添付": + - button "みんなで仕上げる": + - text: 目標 + - textbox "経営会議 へのメッセージ": + - /placeholder: 経営会議 へのメッセージ — ミナト が応答します \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4a4a418f68 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/executive-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d090527a9a Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c97968ab30 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,305 @@ +- complementary "ボットとナビゲーション": + - button "サイドバーをアバターだけに畳む": + - button "サイドバーの表示密度を選ぶ" + - button "新規または共有": + - textbox "ボットとメッセージを検索": + - /placeholder: 検索 + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - 'button "レオ メイ +1 QAチーム レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "レオ" + - img "メイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: QAチーム + - generic: "レオ: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand QAチーム threads": + - button "ソラ ヒナ +1 実装チーム": + - img "ソラ" + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 実装チーム + - button "Collapse 実装チーム threads" [expanded]: + - group "実装チーム threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - 'button "コウ サキ +1 営業部 コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "コウ" + - img "サキ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 営業部 + - generic: "コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 営業部 threads": + - button "レン リツ +1 開発部": + - img "レン" + - img "リツ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 開発部 + - button "Collapse 開発部 threads" [expanded]: + - group "開発部 threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ミナト アオイ +1 経営会議": + - img "ミナト" + - img "アオイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "Collapse 経営会議 threads" [expanded]: + - group "経営会議 threads": + - button "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - generic: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…" + - button "Actions for @ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ボット" [expanded]: + - generic: ボット + - button "Ivy Ivy の名前を変更 Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ivy" + - button "Ivy の名前を変更": Ivy + - generic: Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ivy threads": + - button "New folder under Ivy": + - button "Actions for Ivy": + - button "検証会社" [expanded]: + - generic: 検証会社 + - button "ハル QAチームの異常系担当 ハル の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ハル" + - generic: QAチームの異常系担当 + - button "ハル の名前を変更": ハル + - generic: Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ハル threads": + - button "New folder under ハル": + - button "Actions for ハル": + - button "メイ QAチームの境界値担当 メイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "メイ" + - generic: QAチームの境界値担当 + - button "メイ の名前を変更": メイ + - generic: Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand メイ threads": + - button "New folder under メイ": + - button "Actions for メイ": + - button "レオ QAチームのリーダー レオ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レオ" + - generic: QAチームのリーダー + - button "レオ の名前を変更": レオ + - generic: Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レオ threads": + - button "New folder under レオ": + - button "Actions for レオ": + - button "ナギ 実装チームのデータ検証担当 ナギ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ナギ" + - generic: 実装チームのデータ検証担当 + - button "ナギ の名前を変更": ナギ + - generic: Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ナギ threads": + - button "New folder under ナギ": + - button "Actions for ナギ": + - button "ヒナ 実装チームのCSV作成担当 ヒナ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: 実装チームのCSV作成担当 + - button "ヒナ の名前を変更": ヒナ + - generic: Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ヒナ threads": + - button "New folder under ヒナ": + - button "Actions for ヒナ": + - button "ソラ 実装チームのリーダー ソラ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: 実装チームのリーダー + - button "ソラ の名前を変更": ソラ + - generic: Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ソラ threads": + - button "New folder under ソラ": + - button "Actions for ソラ": + - button "トワ 営業部の営業運用担当 トワ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "トワ" + - generic: 営業部の営業運用担当 + - button "トワ の名前を変更": トワ + - generic: Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand トワ threads": + - button "New folder under トワ": + - button "Actions for トワ": + - button "サキ 営業部の顧客説明担当 サキ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "サキ" + - generic: 営業部の顧客説明担当 + - button "サキ の名前を変更": サキ + - generic: Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand サキ threads": + - button "New folder under サキ": + - button "Actions for サキ": + - button "コウ 営業部の部長 コウ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "コウ" + - generic: 営業部の部長 + - button "コウ の名前を変更": コウ + - generic: Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand コウ threads": + - button "New folder under コウ": + - button "Actions for コウ": + - button "マコ 開発部の品質担当 マコ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "マコ" + - generic: 開発部の品質担当 + - button "マコ の名前を変更": マコ + - generic: Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand マコ threads": + - button "New folder under マコ": + - button "Actions for マコ": + - button "リツ 開発部の実装担当 リツ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "リツ" + - generic: 開発部の実装担当 + - button "リツ の名前を変更": リツ + - generic: Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand リツ threads": + - button "New folder under リツ": + - button "Actions for リツ": + - button "レン 開発部の部長 レン の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レン" + - generic: 開発部の部長 + - button "レン の名前を変更": レン + - generic: Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レン threads": + - button "New folder under レン": + - button "Actions for レン": + - button "ユイ 経営会議の営業担当 ユイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ユイ" + - generic: 経営会議の営業担当 + - button "ユイ の名前を変更": ユイ + - generic: Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ユイ threads": + - button "New folder under ユイ": + - button "Actions for ユイ": + - button "アオイ 経営会議の開発担当 アオイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "アオイ" + - generic: 経営会議の開発担当 + - button "アオイ の名前を変更": アオイ + - generic: Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand アオイ threads": + - button "New folder under アオイ": + - button "Actions for アオイ": + - button "ミナト 経営会議の議長 ミナト の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ミナト" + - generic: 経営会議の議長 + - button "ミナト の名前を変更": ミナト + - generic: Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ミナト threads": + - button "New folder under ミナト": + - button "Actions for ミナト": + - paragraph + - button "ツール": + - generic: ツール + - button "あなた": + - generic: "?" + - generic: あなた +- main: + - generic: 実装チーム + - button "すべてのスレッド": + - generic: すべてのスレッド + - generic: "1" + - button "会話内を検索": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "グループの作業フォルダー": + - generic "通常のメッセージは ソラ に届きます。@メンションが優先されます": + - combobox "既定の応答者": + - 'option "リード: ソラ" [selected]' + - 'option "リード: ヒナ"' + - 'option "リード: ナギ"' + - option "全員が応答" + - option "メンションされたときだけ" + - button "メンバーを管理 — このグループにボット 3 体": + - generic "ソラ": + - img "ソラ" + - generic "ヒナ": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic "ナギ": + - img "ナギ" + - generic "グループの協働設定" + - button "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ソラは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。": + - generic: 企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ソラは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。 + - log "Group chat 実装チーム": + - generic: 今日 14:09 + - img "リツ" + - generic: リツ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:07": + - paragraph: "@ソラ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ソラ" + - generic: ソラ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:08": + - paragraph: 実装チーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:08": + - paragraph: 【議論】@ヒナ @ナギ 実装チーム第1巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: ヒナ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:09": + - paragraph: ヒナ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ナギ" + - generic: ナギ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:09": + - paragraph: ナギ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: Sent to ヒナ + - img "ナギ" + - generic: Sent to ナギ + - img "ソラ" + - generic: ソラ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:10": + - paragraph: 実装チーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:10": + - paragraph: "@ヒナ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: ヒナ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:11": + - paragraph: ヒナ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ソラ" + - generic: ソラ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:11": + - paragraph: "@ナギ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ナギ" + - generic: ナギ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:12": + - paragraph: ナギ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ソラ" + - generic: ソラ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:13": + - paragraph: 実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ファイルを添付": + - button "みんなで仕上げる": + - text: 目標 + - textbox "実装チーム へのメッセージ": + - /placeholder: 実装チーム へのメッセージ — ソラ が応答します \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..7b9ef8fd90 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/implementation-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/pyramid.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/pyramid.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d0955f95e3 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/pyramid.json @@ -0,0 +1,1819 @@ +{ + "ok": true, + "verifiedAt": "2026-09-13T05:09:17.638Z", + "live": false, + "model": "scripted", + "upstreamBase": "536b7893549924c3e2b71eb2e9564ea2986a146a", + "rooms": [ + { + "id": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "name": "経営会議", + "memberIds": [ + "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ミナトは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV出力の初期対象。仮案は全項目・全件出力。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求。2巡目で具体的な妥協案を再検討して決定する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276130799, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "name": "開発部", + "memberIds": [ + "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レンは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276131886, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "name": "営業部", + "memberIds": [ + "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者コウは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276133053, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "name": "実装チーム", + "memberIds": [ + "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ソラは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276134287, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "name": "QAチーム", + "memberIds": [ + "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レオは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276135775, + "active": true + } + ] + } + ], + "nodes": [ + { + "groupId": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "threadId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "id": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "key": "root", + "text": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をcoordinate_botsで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。", + "createdAt": 1789276136274, + "status": "completed", + "result": "経営会議統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 44, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "work", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "threadId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "id": "c8ef82db-887e-45b5-9f9c-1493b4fc78ff", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "key": "round-1", + "text": "経営会議第1巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276136274, + "status": "completed", + "result": "アオイ: アオイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。\n\nユイ: ユイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "threadId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "id": "f44fe827-b02b-4acf-8225-17bff3dccef0", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "key": "round-2", + "text": "経営会議第2巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276138271, + "status": "completed", + "result": "アオイ: アオイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。\n\nユイ: ユイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "threadId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "id": "da5f5ded-a257-4d6a-b3f7-941ba2627e1d", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "key": "owner-451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6:451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "text": "経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276140157, + "status": "completed", + "result": "アオイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "threadId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "id": "13026e88-db5a-4604-8cb6-3458537578b7", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "key": "owner-dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0:dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "text": "経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276140167, + "status": "completed", + "result": "ユイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "threadId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "id": "dcbb193d-a7ad-4373-a785-d64c83e647cd", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "da5f5ded-a257-4d6a-b3f7-941ba2627e1d", + "key": "to-1:1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "text": "経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。", + "createdAt": 1789276141281, + "status": "completed", + "result": "開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "work", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "threadId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "id": "36bb59e4-73f9-4760-9eb9-2e1a17272f0e", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "13026e88-db5a-4604-8cb6-3458537578b7", + "key": "to-2:e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "text": "経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。", + "createdAt": 1789276141977, + "status": "completed", + "result": "営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "work", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "threadId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "id": "0d79d808-17b3-4e5f-970c-3f912f49d246", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "dcbb193d-a7ad-4373-a785-d64c83e647cd", + "key": "round-1", + "text": "開発部第1巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276142021, + "status": "completed", + "result": "リツ: リツ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。\n\nマコ: マコ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "threadId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "id": "632183e2-9d9a-4e54-bc3f-59179f37756f", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "36bb59e4-73f9-4760-9eb9-2e1a17272f0e", + "key": "round-1", + "text": "営業部第1巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276142759, + "status": "completed", + "result": "サキ: サキ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。\n\nトワ: トワ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "threadId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "id": "257c096a-e9e1-4151-a3c7-330d5088c6e7", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "dcbb193d-a7ad-4373-a785-d64c83e647cd", + "key": "round-2", + "text": "開発部第2巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276144291, + "status": "completed", + "result": "リツ: リツ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。\n\nマコ: マコ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "threadId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "botId": "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "id": "9bf327ee-7e43-439a-837d-d084d1e67e22", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "36bb59e4-73f9-4760-9eb9-2e1a17272f0e", + "key": "owner-b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159:b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "text": "営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276145101, + "status": "completed", + "result": "サキ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "threadId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "botId": "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf", + "id": "08ea0456-de88-4bdd-a8a3-312735c6136e", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "36bb59e4-73f9-4760-9eb9-2e1a17272f0e", + "key": "owner-77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf:77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf", + "text": "営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276145110, + "status": "completed", + "result": "トワ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "threadId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "id": "a2900da4-013a-4d6e-8aab-c107c28ad956", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "dcbb193d-a7ad-4373-a785-d64c83e647cd", + "key": "owner-6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3:6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "text": "開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276146596, + "status": "completed", + "result": "リツ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "threadId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "id": "818cb516-0271-44fd-a6d3-b3f411df9a61", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "dcbb193d-a7ad-4373-a785-d64c83e647cd", + "key": "owner-f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984:f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "text": "開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276146607, + "status": "completed", + "result": "マコ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "threadId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "id": "7a9b3ca6-4f9d-42ee-8a0f-ef6bb9c0409e", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "a2900da4-013a-4d6e-8aab-c107c28ad956", + "key": "to-3:bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "text": "開発部決定を具体化した依頼。出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。", + "createdAt": 1789276147566, + "status": "completed", + "result": "実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "work", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "threadId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "id": "88633527-e171-4c73-b0c4-051d148c4066", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "818cb516-0271-44fd-a6d3-b3f411df9a61", + "key": "to-4:0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "text": "開発部決定を具体化した依頼。受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。", + "createdAt": 1789276148488, + "status": "completed", + "result": "QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "work", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "threadId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "id": "aed0a77e-dc57-4223-ad3a-54bed05471e5", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "7a9b3ca6-4f9d-42ee-8a0f-ef6bb9c0409e", + "key": "round-1", + "text": "実装チーム第1巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276148573, + "status": "completed", + "result": "ヒナ: ヒナ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。\n\nナギ: ナギ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "threadId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "id": "da27b36f-1ed5-4320-8a70-efd172363151", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "88633527-e171-4c73-b0c4-051d148c4066", + "key": "round-1", + "text": "QAチーム第1巡。修正案を検討", + "createdAt": 1789276149250, + "status": "completed", + "result": "メイ: メイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。\n\nハル: ハル懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "discussion", + "participants": [ + "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390" + ] + }, + { + "groupId": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "threadId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "botId": "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "id": "85e67379-3bf9-418a-be13-686fa4370193", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "7a9b3ca6-4f9d-42ee-8a0f-ef6bb9c0409e", + "key": "owner-84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7:84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "text": "実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276150735, + "status": "completed", + "result": "ヒナ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "threadId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "botId": "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1", + "id": "f5d9966f-ecb3-434b-ab7d-fa75d5fffa08", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "7a9b3ca6-4f9d-42ee-8a0f-ef6bb9c0409e", + "key": "owner-8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1:8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1", + "text": "実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276150748, + "status": "completed", + "result": "ナギ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "threadId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "botId": "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "id": "3f1c7c1a-afbd-4f7d-b2d5-726818e30e88", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "88633527-e171-4c73-b0c4-051d148c4066", + "key": "owner-8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4:8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "text": "QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276151296, + "status": "completed", + "result": "メイ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "groupId": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "threadId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "botId": "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390", + "id": "37024d75-d748-4374-af0b-00e5dcc599d1", + "rootId": "c3f9f797-6736-47d0-aab3-62fa0914435e", + "parentId": "88633527-e171-4c73-b0c4-051d148c4066", + "key": "owner-542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390:542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390", + "text": "QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "createdAt": 1789276151330, + "status": "completed", + "result": "ハル成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "reported": true, + "executions": 0, + "approvalGranted": false, + "kind": "assignment", + "participants": [] + } + ], + "transcripts": [ + { + "name": "経営会議", + "id": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "transcript": { + "channel": { + "id": "fd260b39-be00-4ec8-96ad-acadd5433c0a", + "name": "経営会議", + "memberIds": [ + "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ミナトは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV出力の初期対象。仮案は全項目・全件出力。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求。2巡目で具体的な妥協案を再検討して決定する。\n分担:アオイが開発部のレン宛てに依頼し、その結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告する。 ユイが営業部のコウ宛てに依頼し、その結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告する。担当者はlist_room_targetsから宛先IDを確認する。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝える。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "title": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…", + "createdAt": 1789276130799, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + "taskId": "17c5f7bd-d8c6-4ece-9b6b-101a48733723", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "3eed4075-1d34-40ff-9baf-96a4ad383cb2", + "at": 1789276135837, + "role": "user", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をcoordinate_botsで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。" + }, + { + "id": "dcadd59f-81e3-4b47-94fe-c54d7747a6ab", + "at": 1789276136296, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "経営会議仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "bd71027e-4cb9-4968-9df0-f07889dee5da", + "at": 1789276136515, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n経営会議第1巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "0d8d8b03-f28d-4713-8e18-c2592477d988", + "at": 1789276136935, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "アオイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "52ed21e0-2546-45f1-a6c9-d26ce82c3272", + "at": 1789276137324, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ユイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "253e13cb-fe2b-48b4-9479-b00840f2d223", + "at": 1789276138295, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "経営会議修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "6322b408-24b0-4a6f-b0f4-0a4089c90e0b", + "at": 1789276138346, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n経営会議第2巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "fa019691-66b7-46b9-a0b3-a0dc558b67d8", + "at": 1789276138788, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "アオイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "7f00a353-78b8-48d6-93de-c5aeb54244cb", + "at": 1789276139204, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ユイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "964b7b0e-7480-4118-a4b3-4844cdae443c", + "at": 1789276140161, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to アオイ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "e9d914bf-5333-4a04-9387-3096a9c26565", + "at": 1789276140171, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to ユイ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "bf5eaa89-e137-4241-8f23-8ef42618d8ba", + "at": 1789276140425, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "経営会議決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "cd5865f1-c41f-46d9-b926-bda20722ba93", + "at": 1789276140684, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@アオイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "9ac662d6-9d86-44f3-b148-75a907b9ba04", + "at": 1789276141294, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to レン · 開発部", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "20ec768b-acec-4568-a684-b897f9f8d3ea", + "at": 1789276141310, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "アオイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "3c724fb0-84be-43e6-a71d-0d2bb270a9c4", + "at": 1789276141472, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ユイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "e47ae981-50c5-49ec-aea9-b93fae396b58", + "at": 1789276141983, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to コウ · 営業部", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "ab01555d-a69f-45ea-b391-639054620aed", + "at": 1789276142003, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ユイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "40ee79d3-275f-47eb-8c94-2b81f67f99f3", + "at": 1789276147653, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "コウ replied · 営業部", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "c51e4154-8a35-4b2f-87a0-6866dd049cbc", + "at": 1789276148799, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ユイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "60b4a217-979b-4643-9b88-d1099dd59619", + "at": 1789276155742, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "レン replied · 開発部", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "3b34019a-26af-4473-b34f-dd78e21f8d62", + "at": 1789276156485, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "アオイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "8b40f365-4de2-43ab-bf28-4cc2b045bbea", + "at": 1789276157175, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "経営会議統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "02e36f8b-168b-4f6b-b8ba-2a952cb313b4", + "name": "ミナト", + "color": "blue" + } + } + ], + "hasMore": false + } + }, + { + "name": "開発部", + "id": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "transcript": { + "channel": { + "id": "e274171c-1dfa-4ffb-83eb-7ada551c660b", + "name": "開発部", + "memberIds": [ + "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レンは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し2巡行う。1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。\n分担:リツが実装チームのソラ宛てに依頼し、その結果をレビューしてレンへ報告する。 マコがQAチームのレオ宛てに依頼し、その結果をレビューしてレンへ報告する。担当者はlist_room_targetsから宛先IDを確認する。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝える。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276131886, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + "taskId": "d84be120-67c5-44fc-94d5-d7c5693a0733", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "4fb038d9-c8b3-4d73-b287-045b4ec90d59", + "at": 1789276141475, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@レン 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。", + "from": { + "botId": "451ee3d3-ac10-41fd-a2f1-6e712e7aeef6", + "name": "アオイ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "833698e5-2693-4a16-903b-e7ea8c5c13a4", + "at": 1789276142042, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "開発部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "9deafbe8-817d-48cd-9679-38aa5d2382da", + "at": 1789276142250, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n開発部第1巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "e8224b41-9399-4bee-8845-6238ecf0c4d8", + "at": 1789276142809, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "リツ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "465cbfde-dbd7-41ad-83f4-568fc0b0346e", + "at": 1789276143340, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "マコ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + } + }, + { + "id": "c234ae21-21c0-4118-8a31-636f9f75c7f1", + "at": 1789276144316, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "開発部修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "b9f355b0-9143-4042-b4ce-60012088693e", + "at": 1789276144569, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n開発部第2巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "af8766d2-805d-4d8d-8b7d-53ecb6697704", + "at": 1789276145108, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "リツ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "b5fddb38-8734-4d9a-a07a-9d9dbd0c4f00", + "at": 1789276145592, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "マコ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + } + }, + { + "id": "d7d3a073-aed3-474c-ae87-64ffe3e33ce2", + "at": 1789276146602, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to リツ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "853e7f03-5bfd-4f6a-acb1-f4104dd024b1", + "at": 1789276146611, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to マコ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "6d45dba4-181d-4dfd-a3fa-b920ccde62e0", + "at": 1789276146629, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "開発部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "9865f6d1-540d-4931-a89a-458acd394d8e", + "at": 1789276146896, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@リツ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "9e85b7fb-1ff8-413a-a142-866ce2ec0262", + "at": 1789276147571, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to ソラ · 実装チーム", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "01800484-7a8f-4a25-a7f3-64b0f80bf310", + "at": 1789276147588, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "リツ担当として下層へ依頼しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "d21a230e-7700-4d58-a477-9c48e843a51a", + "at": 1789276147668, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@マコ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "04412527-945d-4ead-8dd0-4c3630d70035", + "at": 1789276148497, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to レオ · QAチーム", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "13d48e84-25a0-4a84-868a-70f236f06ca9", + "at": 1789276148516, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "マコ担当として下層へ依頼しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + } + }, + { + "id": "37f5845a-bc34-436a-af99-cd7dafd9363c", + "at": 1789276153385, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "ソラ replied · 実装チーム", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "93dc0c71-31af-4d91-a820-4e73b3ae9a5c", + "at": 1789276153936, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "レオ replied · QAチーム", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "6206491d-babf-4ea3-9705-144e49d2a9f9", + "at": 1789276154196, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "リツ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "5708cbb8-07cd-4db8-8cc7-b971ef1dd1fd", + "at": 1789276154957, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "マコ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + } + }, + { + "id": "cea4a413-a67b-497f-a78a-debe932a3283", + "at": 1789276155676, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "1ef0bcf2-1ea8-48f8-94d3-783b96730409", + "name": "レン", + "color": "purple" + } + } + ], + "hasMore": false + } + }, + { + "name": "営業部", + "id": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "transcript": { + "channel": { + "id": "628c778b-3d53-4a46-898e-22c3fc4429ea", + "name": "営業部", + "memberIds": [ + "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者コウは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276133053, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + "taskId": "008c7257-f458-4675-99bb-c523796ce62c", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "2b6a0fc4-0e0a-49c8-a4f1-09f55dc17d02", + "at": 1789276142245, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@コウ 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。", + "from": { + "botId": "dbfa5fbe-bf1d-44a8-8885-26ed048d6ad0", + "name": "ユイ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "6f439e1f-9bb9-410d-ac09-a57ba0bccb76", + "at": 1789276142783, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "営業部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + }, + { + "id": "bbb77e3b-8566-4565-baa5-481d466cb341", + "at": 1789276143020, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@サキ @トワ\n営業部第1巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + }, + { + "id": "0fdcc8d0-a6fc-400a-9cb4-89c2d5e27df8", + "at": 1789276143548, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "サキ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "name": "サキ", + "color": "teal" + } + }, + { + "id": "492b040f-ae06-486f-a4c4-540aa3f390d7", + "at": 1789276144065, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "トワ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf", + "name": "トワ", + "color": "coral" + } + }, + { + "id": "265ec490-b114-49f2-8ae7-c5d881b863e6", + "at": 1789276145105, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to サキ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "78a41496-1bee-4108-bc84-b1752b8b889c", + "at": 1789276145116, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to トワ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "f1ad5886-2a12-4cc8-a8ab-a87ba3cc3341", + "at": 1789276145157, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "営業部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + }, + { + "id": "1c721077-2a0d-4e9c-9857-96920e60b863", + "at": 1789276145333, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@サキ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + }, + { + "id": "6d74e883-0aa1-49f7-a620-77ed4589b604", + "at": 1789276145787, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "サキ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "b0e939c9-6e4a-4091-be93-1cac33fdf159", + "name": "サキ", + "color": "teal" + } + }, + { + "id": "076dcd17-fd4a-4828-a013-d8b2ad9076f1", + "at": 1789276145855, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@トワ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + }, + { + "id": "a2cc07c2-ddea-4311-8b7e-402355596a1e", + "at": 1789276146396, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "トワ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "77ead2b6-0b20-4544-b814-5c58061969bf", + "name": "トワ", + "color": "coral" + } + }, + { + "id": "81013874-6bf4-45e0-a961-4d9359794023", + "at": 1789276147527, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "e92234c6-6c76-4c2a-9ccc-267a8ea46f46", + "name": "コウ", + "color": "yellow" + } + } + ], + "hasMore": false + } + }, + { + "name": "実装チーム", + "id": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "transcript": { + "channel": { + "id": "cafe2fa1-e14e-4b76-ae62-b5b203cea8ef", + "name": "実装チーム", + "memberIds": [ + "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者ソラは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276134287, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + "taskId": "e6a3d23b-0f6d-470a-8280-1be60abfb355", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "b8a3290a-0c1b-4aa4-b919-895107d1e06f", + "at": 1789276147673, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ソラ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。", + "from": { + "botId": "6827e882-47f5-4a8d-8745-ce934785b6e3", + "name": "リツ", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "267decee-740b-4e0f-b88b-1a20c417ff9d", + "at": 1789276148601, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "実装チーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + }, + { + "id": "1c7bc142-430f-4fdd-941f-7656dc3cde77", + "at": 1789276148713, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@ヒナ @ナギ\n実装チーム第1巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + }, + { + "id": "9674ee79-a6d3-42e7-954f-a6dc40b5c6db", + "at": 1789276149258, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ヒナ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "name": "ヒナ", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "e2d9a927-4e2d-44d6-a6a6-c9dc5cded60c", + "at": 1789276149741, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ナギ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1", + "name": "ナギ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "cb46ec80-3afd-46ee-98c0-879594ea7958", + "at": 1789276150741, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to ヒナ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "42cb00df-0e55-4809-9a4f-90fb4072fce7", + "at": 1789276150752, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to ナギ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "e7d54877-3e1d-4cf5-ba96-250d4b22122a", + "at": 1789276150772, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "実装チーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + }, + { + "id": "602941c4-f857-4a91-901c-7b9e555de67d", + "at": 1789276150802, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ヒナ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + }, + { + "id": "12e8df82-11b7-4957-a21b-3e36a2f6172c", + "at": 1789276151311, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ヒナ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "84ae3b90-3deb-4132-adb1-435d3a908fa7", + "name": "ヒナ", + "color": "blue" + } + }, + { + "id": "21582847-9cfe-481a-85d3-57f36b0751cb", + "at": 1789276151585, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ナギ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + }, + { + "id": "f698b83a-483f-4e66-8d83-e4044a1eb604", + "at": 1789276152096, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ナギ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "8bd763a1-0d77-4c4b-8702-8de5ba4cb7a1", + "name": "ナギ", + "color": "red" + } + }, + { + "id": "d5003db5-d414-408f-a3e1-eab298ac705e", + "at": 1789276153274, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "bc0c5e31-edad-4117-ae17-fa05038c9728", + "name": "ソラ", + "color": "green" + } + } + ], + "hasMore": false + } + }, + { + "name": "QAチーム", + "id": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "transcript": { + "channel": { + "id": "0f0a5f0b-068f-48e6-bef4-0700865188f2", + "name": "QAチーム", + "memberIds": [ + "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390" + ], + "bulletin": "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レオは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。", + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2" + }, + "section": null, + "directMessage": false, + "working": false, + "busyBotId": null, + "activeTaskId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "tasks": [ + { + "taskId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789276135775, + "active": true + } + ] + }, + "taskId": "41fc54f7-2d21-4555-9959-b9128e4028b9", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "4513549b-72c2-4ff1-a7b9-19490062c018", + "at": 1789276148708, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@レオ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。", + "from": { + "botId": "f99d3afb-6ff7-4496-a2dc-874981866984", + "name": "マコ", + "color": "pink" + } + }, + { + "id": "ab879d5c-8fc1-4e79-9e2e-7034a69f86cc", + "at": 1789276149308, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "QAチーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "af0acf54-cbe2-4308-a6aa-2d31c3a84c06", + "at": 1789276149474, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "【議論】@メイ @ハル\nQAチーム第1巡。修正案を検討", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "89c93450-201e-474c-8ea9-77935a064538", + "at": 1789276149936, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "メイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "name": "メイ", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "9e3c503c-63df-4541-890e-c8fa4db039d7", + "at": 1789276150393, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ハル懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390", + "name": "ハル", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "1a80294a-9d07-43d8-892e-cf3d0d66e7b5", + "at": 1789276151308, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to メイ", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "6d801bb6-69de-432a-8083-eb103410f57b", + "at": 1789276151335, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "activity", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + }, + "tool": { + "name": "Sent to ハル", + "ok": true + } + }, + { + "id": "df71f9ba-31da-45f6-8a32-8acf049e0143", + "at": 1789276151355, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "QAチーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "98cd9ff1-3750-4a47-91e0-0b57574d0f34", + "at": 1789276151589, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@メイ QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "9aadc8d8-5ef2-44e8-9afd-dbe353db1ae6", + "at": 1789276152120, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "メイ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "8b33edbd-3021-4f2c-bf9a-e5f89ceee8d4", + "name": "メイ", + "color": "purple" + } + }, + { + "id": "582f986b-e240-4d35-8732-625c31aeb1c6", + "at": 1789276152350, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "@ハル QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + }, + { + "id": "8255d92d-a7b3-4014-bafd-3bf3ab5ea159", + "at": 1789276152944, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "ハル成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。", + "from": { + "botId": "542deb27-1773-4b70-9aae-fda895d8c390", + "name": "ハル", + "color": "cyan" + } + }, + { + "id": "32e26f4f-65de-44e6-bcfa-2da80594aca5", + "at": 1789276153900, + "role": "bot", + "kind": "text", + "text": "QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。", + "from": { + "botId": "0e633b7d-2530-4dfc-a7a9-e68226980bf2", + "name": "レオ", + "color": "orange" + } + } + ], + "hasMore": false + } + } + ], + "providerTurns": 45 +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a31956eb8a Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8c9fbb28ff --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,310 @@ +- complementary "ボットとナビゲーション": + - button "サイドバーをアバターだけに畳む": + - button "サイドバーの表示密度を選ぶ" + - button "新規または共有": + - textbox "ボットとメッセージを検索": + - /placeholder: 検索 + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "レオ メイ +1 QAチーム": + - img "レオ" + - img "メイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: QAチーム + - button "Collapse QAチーム threads" [expanded]: + - group "QAチーム threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ソラ ヒナ +1 実装チーム": + - img "ソラ" + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 実装チーム + - button "Collapse 実装チーム threads" [expanded]: + - group "実装チーム threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - 'button "コウ サキ +1 営業部 コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。"': + - img "コウ" + - img "サキ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 営業部 + - generic: "コウ: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + - button "Expand 営業部 threads": + - button "レン リツ +1 開発部": + - img "レン" + - img "リツ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 開発部 + - button "Collapse 開発部 threads" [expanded]: + - group "開発部 threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ミナト アオイ +1 経営会議": + - img "ミナト" + - img "アオイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "Collapse 経営会議 threads" [expanded]: + - group "経営会議 threads": + - button "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - generic: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…" + - button "Actions for @ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ボット" [expanded]: + - generic: ボット + - button "Ivy Ivy の名前を変更 Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ivy" + - button "Ivy の名前を変更": Ivy + - generic: Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ivy threads": + - button "New folder under Ivy": + - button "Actions for Ivy": + - button "検証会社" [expanded]: + - generic: 検証会社 + - button "ハル QAチームの異常系担当 ハル の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ハル" + - generic: QAチームの異常系担当 + - button "ハル の名前を変更": ハル + - generic: Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ハル threads": + - button "New folder under ハル": + - button "Actions for ハル": + - button "メイ QAチームの境界値担当 メイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "メイ" + - generic: QAチームの境界値担当 + - button "メイ の名前を変更": メイ + - generic: Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand メイ threads": + - button "New folder under メイ": + - button "Actions for メイ": + - button "レオ QAチームのリーダー レオ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レオ" + - generic: QAチームのリーダー + - button "レオ の名前を変更": レオ + - generic: Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レオ threads": + - button "New folder under レオ": + - button "Actions for レオ": + - button "ナギ 実装チームのデータ検証担当 ナギ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ナギ" + - generic: 実装チームのデータ検証担当 + - button "ナギ の名前を変更": ナギ + - generic: Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ナギ threads": + - button "New folder under ナギ": + - button "Actions for ナギ": + - button "ヒナ 実装チームのCSV作成担当 ヒナ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: 実装チームのCSV作成担当 + - button "ヒナ の名前を変更": ヒナ + - generic: Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ヒナ threads": + - button "New folder under ヒナ": + - button "Actions for ヒナ": + - button "ソラ 実装チームのリーダー ソラ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: 実装チームのリーダー + - button "ソラ の名前を変更": ソラ + - generic: Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ソラ threads": + - button "New folder under ソラ": + - button "Actions for ソラ": + - button "トワ 営業部の営業運用担当 トワ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "トワ" + - generic: 営業部の営業運用担当 + - button "トワ の名前を変更": トワ + - generic: Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand トワ threads": + - button "New folder under トワ": + - button "Actions for トワ": + - button "サキ 営業部の顧客説明担当 サキ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "サキ" + - generic: 営業部の顧客説明担当 + - button "サキ の名前を変更": サキ + - generic: Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand サキ threads": + - button "New folder under サキ": + - button "Actions for サキ": + - button "コウ 営業部の部長 コウ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "コウ" + - generic: 営業部の部長 + - button "コウ の名前を変更": コウ + - generic: Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand コウ threads": + - button "New folder under コウ": + - button "Actions for コウ": + - button "マコ 開発部の品質担当 マコ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "マコ" + - generic: 開発部の品質担当 + - button "マコ の名前を変更": マコ + - generic: Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand マコ threads": + - button "New folder under マコ": + - button "Actions for マコ": + - button "リツ 開発部の実装担当 リツ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "リツ" + - generic: 開発部の実装担当 + - button "リツ の名前を変更": リツ + - generic: Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand リツ threads": + - button "New folder under リツ": + - button "Actions for リツ": + - button "レン 開発部の部長 レン の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レン" + - generic: 開発部の部長 + - button "レン の名前を変更": レン + - generic: Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レン threads": + - button "New folder under レン": + - button "Actions for レン": + - button "ユイ 経営会議の営業担当 ユイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ユイ" + - generic: 経営会議の営業担当 + - button "ユイ の名前を変更": ユイ + - generic: Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ユイ threads": + - button "New folder under ユイ": + - button "Actions for ユイ": + - button "アオイ 経営会議の開発担当 アオイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "アオイ" + - generic: 経営会議の開発担当 + - button "アオイ の名前を変更": アオイ + - generic: Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand アオイ threads": + - button "New folder under アオイ": + - button "Actions for アオイ": + - button "ミナト 経営会議の議長 ミナト の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ミナト" + - generic: 経営会議の議長 + - button "ミナト の名前を変更": ミナト + - generic: Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ミナト threads": + - button "New folder under ミナト": + - button "Actions for ミナト": + - paragraph + - button "ツール": + - generic: ツール + - button "あなた": + - generic: "?" + - generic: あなた +- main: + - generic: QAチーム + - button "すべてのスレッド": + - generic: すべてのスレッド + - generic: "1" + - button "会話内を検索": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "グループの作業フォルダー": + - generic "通常のメッセージは レオ に届きます。@メンションが優先されます": + - combobox "既定の応答者": + - 'option "リード: レオ" [selected]' + - 'option "リード: メイ"' + - 'option "リード: ハル"' + - option "全員が応答" + - option "メンションされたときだけ" + - button "メンバーを管理 — このグループにボット 3 体": + - generic "レオ": + - img "レオ" + - generic "メイ": + - img "メイ" + - generic "ハル": + - img "ハル" + - generic "グループの協働設定" + - button "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レオは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。": + - generic: 企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者レオは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。 + - log "Group chat QAチーム": + - generic: 今日 14:09 + - img "マコ" + - generic: マコ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:08": + - paragraph: "@レオ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レオ" + - generic: レオ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:09": + - paragraph: QAチーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:09": + - paragraph: 【議論】@メイ @ハル QAチーム第1巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "メイ" + - generic: メイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:09": + - paragraph: メイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ハル" + - generic: ハル + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:10": + - paragraph: ハル懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "メイ" + - generic: Sent to メイ + - img "ハル" + - generic: Sent to ハル + - img "レオ" + - generic: レオ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:11": + - paragraph: QAチーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:11": + - paragraph: "@メイ QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "メイ" + - generic: メイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:12": + - paragraph: メイ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レオ" + - generic: レオ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:12": + - paragraph: "@ハル QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "ハル" + - generic: ハル + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:12": + - paragraph: ハル成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "レオ" + - generic: レオ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:13": + - paragraph: QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ファイルを添付": + - button "みんなで仕上げる": + - text: 目標 + - textbox "QAチーム へのメッセージ": + - /placeholder: QAチーム へのメッセージ — レオ が応答します \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..fa1b48bfae Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/qa-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..49c04867c7 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..fa9a57ae8f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,315 @@ +- complementary "ボットとナビゲーション": + - button "サイドバーをアバターだけに畳む": + - button "サイドバーの表示密度を選ぶ" + - button "新規または共有": + - textbox "ボットとメッセージを検索": + - /placeholder: 検索 + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "レオ メイ +1 QAチーム": + - img "レオ" + - img "メイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: QAチーム + - button "Collapse QAチーム threads" [expanded]: + - group "QAチーム threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ソラ ヒナ +1 実装チーム": + - img "ソラ" + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 実装チーム + - button "Collapse 実装チーム threads" [expanded]: + - group "実装チーム threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "コウ サキ +1 営業部": + - img "コウ" + - img "サキ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 営業部 + - button "Collapse 営業部 threads" [expanded]: + - group "営業部 threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "レン リツ +1 開発部": + - img "レン" + - img "リツ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 開発部 + - button "Collapse 開発部 threads" [expanded]: + - group "開発部 threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ミナト アオイ +1 経営会議": + - img "ミナト" + - img "アオイ" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: 経営会議 + - button "Collapse 経営会議 threads" [expanded]: + - group "経営会議 threads": + - button "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - generic: "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…" + - button "Actions for @ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案…": + - button "新しいスレッド": + - text: 新しいスレッド + - button "ボット" [expanded]: + - generic: ボット + - button "Ivy Ivy の名前を変更 Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ivy" + - button "Ivy の名前を変更": Ivy + - generic: Hi, I'm Ivy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ivy threads": + - button "New folder under Ivy": + - button "Actions for Ivy": + - button "検証会社" [expanded]: + - generic: 検証会社 + - button "ハル QAチームの異常系担当 ハル の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ハル" + - generic: QAチームの異常系担当 + - button "ハル の名前を変更": ハル + - generic: Hi, I'm ハル. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ハル threads": + - button "New folder under ハル": + - button "Actions for ハル": + - button "メイ QAチームの境界値担当 メイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "メイ" + - generic: QAチームの境界値担当 + - button "メイ の名前を変更": メイ + - generic: Hi, I'm メイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand メイ threads": + - button "New folder under メイ": + - button "Actions for メイ": + - button "レオ QAチームのリーダー レオ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レオ" + - generic: QAチームのリーダー + - button "レオ の名前を変更": レオ + - generic: Hi, I'm レオ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レオ threads": + - button "New folder under レオ": + - button "Actions for レオ": + - button "ナギ 実装チームのデータ検証担当 ナギ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ナギ" + - generic: 実装チームのデータ検証担当 + - button "ナギ の名前を変更": ナギ + - generic: Hi, I'm ナギ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ナギ threads": + - button "New folder under ナギ": + - button "Actions for ナギ": + - button "ヒナ 実装チームのCSV作成担当 ヒナ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ヒナ" + - generic: 実装チームのCSV作成担当 + - button "ヒナ の名前を変更": ヒナ + - generic: Hi, I'm ヒナ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ヒナ threads": + - button "New folder under ヒナ": + - button "Actions for ヒナ": + - button "ソラ 実装チームのリーダー ソラ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ソラ" + - generic: 実装チームのリーダー + - button "ソラ の名前を変更": ソラ + - generic: Hi, I'm ソラ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ソラ threads": + - button "New folder under ソラ": + - button "Actions for ソラ": + - button "トワ 営業部の営業運用担当 トワ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "トワ" + - generic: 営業部の営業運用担当 + - button "トワ の名前を変更": トワ + - generic: Hi, I'm トワ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand トワ threads": + - button "New folder under トワ": + - button "Actions for トワ": + - button "サキ 営業部の顧客説明担当 サキ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "サキ" + - generic: 営業部の顧客説明担当 + - button "サキ の名前を変更": サキ + - generic: Hi, I'm サキ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand サキ threads": + - button "New folder under サキ": + - button "Actions for サキ": + - button "コウ 営業部の部長 コウ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "コウ" + - generic: 営業部の部長 + - button "コウ の名前を変更": コウ + - generic: Hi, I'm コウ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand コウ threads": + - button "New folder under コウ": + - button "Actions for コウ": + - button "マコ 開発部の品質担当 マコ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "マコ" + - generic: 開発部の品質担当 + - button "マコ の名前を変更": マコ + - generic: Hi, I'm マコ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand マコ threads": + - button "New folder under マコ": + - button "Actions for マコ": + - button "リツ 開発部の実装担当 リツ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "リツ" + - generic: 開発部の実装担当 + - button "リツ の名前を変更": リツ + - generic: Hi, I'm リツ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand リツ threads": + - button "New folder under リツ": + - button "Actions for リツ": + - button "レン 開発部の部長 レン の名前を変更 Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do?": + - img "レン" + - generic: 開発部の部長 + - button "レン の名前を変更": レン + - generic: Hi, I'm レン. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand レン threads": + - button "New folder under レン": + - button "Actions for レン": + - button "ユイ 経営会議の営業担当 ユイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ユイ" + - generic: 経営会議の営業担当 + - button "ユイ の名前を変更": ユイ + - generic: Hi, I'm ユイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ユイ threads": + - button "New folder under ユイ": + - button "Actions for ユイ": + - button "アオイ 経営会議の開発担当 アオイ の名前を変更 Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do?": + - img "アオイ" + - generic: 経営会議の開発担当 + - button "アオイ の名前を変更": アオイ + - generic: Hi, I'm アオイ. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand アオイ threads": + - button "New folder under アオイ": + - button "Actions for アオイ": + - button "ミナト 経営会議の議長 ミナト の名前を変更 Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do?": + - img "ミナト" + - generic: 経営会議の議長 + - button "ミナト の名前を変更": ミナト + - generic: Hi, I'm ミナト. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand ミナト threads": + - button "New folder under ミナト": + - button "Actions for ミナト": + - paragraph + - button "ツール": + - generic: ツール + - button "あなた": + - generic: "?" + - generic: あなた +- main: + - generic: 営業部 + - button "すべてのスレッド": + - generic: すべてのスレッド + - generic: "1" + - button "会話内を検索": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "グループの作業フォルダー": + - generic "通常のメッセージは コウ に届きます。@メンションが優先されます": + - combobox "既定の応答者": + - 'option "リード: コウ" [selected]' + - 'option "リード: サキ"' + - 'option "リード: トワ"' + - option "全員が応答" + - option "メンションされたときだけ" + - button "メンバーを管理 — このグループにボット 3 体": + - generic "コウ": + - img "コウ" + - generic "サキ": + - img "サキ" + - generic "トワ": + - img "トワ" + - generic "グループの協働設定" + - button "企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者コウは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。": + - generic: 企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者コウは受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し1巡行う。各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。 + - log "Group chat 営業部": + - generic: 今日 14:09 + - img "ユイ" + - generic: ユイ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: "@コウ 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "コウ" + - generic: コウ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:02": + - paragraph: 営業部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:03": + - paragraph: 【議論】@サキ @トワ 営業部第1巡。修正案を検討 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "サキ" + - generic: サキ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:03": + - paragraph: サキ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "トワ" + - generic: トワ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:04": + - paragraph: トワ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "サキ" + - generic: Sent to サキ + - img "トワ" + - generic: Sent to トワ + - img "コウ" + - generic: コウ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: 営業部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: "@サキ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "サキ" + - generic: サキ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: サキ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "コウ" + - generic: コウ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:05": + - paragraph: "@トワ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "トワ" + - generic: トワ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:06": + - paragraph: トワ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - img "コウ" + - generic: コウ + - generic "2026/9/13 14:09:07": + - paragraph: 営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。 + - button "メッセージに返信": + - button "メッセージをピン留め": + - generic: 14:09 + - button "ファイルを添付": + - button "みんなで仕上げる": + - text: 目標 + - textbox "営業部 へのメッセージ": + - /placeholder: 営業部 へのメッセージ — コウ が応答します \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a77b635e69 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sales-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sha256.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sha256.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3b9674d5c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/integration-2026-09-13/sha256.txt @@ -0,0 +1,26 @@ +19e03b2ef1f1d604c75b918391c98cee4bc9e4116cd1c746d1a275ef94725708 after-configured-dom.txt +3420ae850ed7c957973efffd3b80f3ae6e1c213766f69dfcfef686ff3ff4ec2d after-configured-settings.json +a37c11552072c633c23e5934b43ff9cdf7f14ac1368e2b0331fe66720c8840a1 after-configured.png +3a25a22058f79b498e84704b3747320d5bce9a70a7889458da966ab72a5911ac after-default-dom.txt +477b2cda3cb74b84e046f9c4294b531bd774f361e4ec7546856f4905d78bf68d after-default.png +ef72ef891ad40b2ca1f04ce590075345cd8e1e25f1cfed6d533dfe3df5a1cd28 after-unrestricted-dom.txt +e41f39b8e04cd653baf3c5fbaa0f9ac615d17fc700ba263d596113c7ad2ba9e7 after-unrestricted-settings.json +3735c076e89d58f116f261700ee655c3f7eeaed0d5a967d3ff35ac3738d257bb after-unrestricted.png +34ecd52861dfb3f0275a863d18818e67fa87c37f962d39d6ff59d4155986eb4c before-dom.txt +b7b3fc821c2baa000f618c3e2c26d075434bbbf1ec488b776c7a0f20b1e9e2e4 before-group.png +548790d11daa77602d78978a01b5615259be4f4923fd7bfafd741e714d0815f2 development-discussion.png +61db238ac48a277836288c462ee5bee77db44a03b6b0e136e3313b2f656ce55f development-dom.txt +0b3da302a917f16caf284b1a4e90403db3f60492d41605397c3b5f4a06321acc development-results.png +9582769328e1d52f6491a1d3b80453361119513cf87ddd55dd629d8216c8de52 executive-discussion.png +ca27212572bbb88a327f3f34ac7b4456402834336483c7d676cf41d02dee7117 executive-dom.txt +9400412a5851759641d3ddbf3f787e24d478873ae13d69653e11c215f899e288 executive-results.png +d0d1d0698181fc4573339ccdba33733f90641654810d27f27d4fd5660f494c9b implementation-discussion.png +2f0d2c30c547b1e12ade4c498e6392cbca403a0ad9318cc931fc269c84dafccf implementation-dom.txt +d69f5362b45bf5ab146bee7b3ea58f511e17fadff5a4268ff226d8aaaac9b58a implementation-results.png +6d3d5a5827d797b9099fd69bf5d6c7308b7ebfe80baac22c26e5f12a88a78ddc pyramid.json +be157869ce0429ab409c4e0c22aac5cd2186e359ca0f59ac8f9a3964b0b5a08d qa-discussion.png +29213dbfb2c2411ece054635c1f01d7fac77af419f586238d4a8ae46f7fe85f7 qa-dom.txt +392a96668377317b8bc2638a6d816fa099f95603e0b11d659c204f3be5aa695b qa-results.png +f998ba7f9e6322ad7b03061a6a9e1280e9291f404c92babd66190762f0b24a1a sales-discussion.png +023c1d064bfe7404271e04d4164c0b7c65f19aac2bb05b3420e054528458888d sales-dom.txt +37a179f0a0509206df15ae280d31ccaf92078074cef84ccb230a09e4787dca14 sales-results.png diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6b064e539d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +*.json text eol=lf +*.csv text eol=lf +*.txt text eol=lf diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/README.md b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..7ce99f9f2d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,118 @@ +# Live three-layer verification — 2026-09-12 + +The latest fetched upstream `main` was +`2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c`. The experiment ran PR #1126 head +`454aa82296fed62ffcba6ae8cb028bc01eb99ad0`, which already contains that base. +No production source changes were needed for this run. The files added here +record the result; they do not change the tested implementation. + +**Orchestration passed. Artifact acceptance remains incomplete.** All five +groups discussed proposals with their existing members, made decisions, assigned +responsibilities, and returned results to the requesting member and then chair. +Actual model responses also exposed cross-team inconsistencies that the leaders +accepted incorrectly. A completed scheduler node does not certify a deliverable. + +## Engine and execution evidence + +- Claude Code **2.1.251**, **GLM-5.3**, effort **low** for all fifteen bots. +- Fresh isolated `launchVerificationServer`, separate home/data/ports, actual + server and injected agents MCP proxy. Existing provider configuration was read + for this engine; the user's application, conversations and settings were not + modified. There were no scripted model replies or interventions in the run. +- Started **2026-09-12 03:59:33 UTC**, finished **04:08:44 UTC** (about 9m11s). +- **45 provider turns completed successfully**: the initial turn plus 44 + scheduler executions. **5 work nodes, 7 discussions, 10 assignments** all + completed. Membership stayed at three existing members per group. +- **14 tool calls reported failure** during the run. The model subsequently + completed the workflow; this was not an error-free tool-selection run. +- [transcripts.json](transcripts.json) contains the selected model for each bot, + actual text messages, tree edges, node states and failed-tool metadata. + [provider-turns.json](provider-turns.json) contains canonical turn start/end + events from the real `claudeAgent` driver. Machine paths and credentials are + excluded. All room transcripts reported `hasMore: false`. + +## What each group actually discussed + +| Layer / group | Discussion and resulting decision | Ownership / result | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 1 / 経営会議 | ミナト proposed all fields/all records. アオイ objected to release delay and proposed roughly ten fields/three months; ユイ required twelve fields/six months. ミナト revised to twelve fields/six months/three weeks; a second round added fixed formats and mandatory order/update dates. | アオイ sent the development brief to レン; ユイ sent the sales brief to コウ. Both reviewed returned reports before ミナト integrated them. | +| 2 / 開発部 | リツ proposed fixing fields/formats and excluding free text. マコ raised partial output, date basis, counts and unique IDs. レン revised the brief and held a second round, adding header order and failure reporting criteria. | リツ requested CSV/schema work from ソラ. マコ requested the QA table from レオ. レン consolidated their reviews. | +| 2 / 営業部 | サキ proposed a concise explanation, freshness guidance and no promised expansion date. トワ added allowed devices/storage, transfer restrictions and a usage log. コウ adopted these changes. | サキ wrote three FAQ answers; トワ wrote a five-item operational checklist. コウ returned the reviewed work to ユイ. | +| 3 / 実装チーム | ヒナ asked for numeric types, amount calculation and allowed statuses. ナギ built on this with order-number format, update/order-date consistency and delimiter checks. ソラ fixed the twelve-field schema. | ヒナ produced three synthetic CSV rows. ナギ read that actual CSV and checked it before ソラ returned the result to リツ. | +| 3 / QAチーム | メイ challenged the incomplete date boundaries and added empty/date-validity cases. ハル added concurrent changes, partial failure and permission denial. レオ expanded the table from three sections to four. | メイ wrote boundary cases; ハル wrote failure cases. レオ integrated the table, including explicit questions for マコ, and returned it. | + +Assigning a same-room owner did not create another organizational layer or add +members to a group. Downstream work originated from those owners, not the chairs. + +## Screenshots from every group + +These are unmodified 1280 × 720 browser captures of the actual live fixture. +Discussion images were taken during execution; result images show the completed +conversations. The earlier [before/after UI comparison](../README.md#ui-comparison) +remains separate from this live-model run. + +| Group | Discussion / decision | Result | +| --- | --- | --- | +| 経営会議 | [Revised proposal](executive-revision.png) | [Integrated report](executive-results.png) | +| 開発部 | [Concerns and revision](development-discussion.png) | [Return to アオイ](development-results.png) | +| 営業部 | [サキ's opinion](sales-discussion.png), [トワ's challenge and decision](sales-challenge.png) | [Return to ユイ](sales-results.png) | +| 実装チーム | [Schema decision after discussion](implementation-discussion.png) | [CSV and inspection report](implementation-results.png) | +| QAチーム | [メイ and ハル's opinions](qa-challenge.png), [revised structure](qa-discussion.png) | [Table and unresolved questions](qa-results.png) | + +## Independent artifact checks and unresolved findings + +The [CSV text](sample.csv) was extracted unchanged from ヒナ's chat code block. +[check_csv.py](check_csv.py) independently parses it with Python's CSV parser. +All **nine checks** in [csv-checks.json](csv-checks.json) passed: header order, +three data rows, twelve columns, unique consecutive IDs, assigned date interval, +update-date ordering, integer/amount arithmetic, allowed statuses, and no embedded +delimiters/quotes/newlines. This file is an extracted artifact, not proof that the +bot wrote a BOM-bearing file. Rerun with: + +```sh +python docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py +``` + +Manual review found these unresolved acceptance issues in the actual conversation: + +1. **A one-day disagreement was accepted.** Implementation used + **2026-03-12 through 2026-09-11**. QA B-3 includes the date six calendar months + before the base date, i.e. **2026-03-11**. マコ incorrectly declared those + definitions consistent; レン, アオイ and ミナト accepted the report. +2. **The limit remains undefined.** QA used a provisional 100,000 rows and asked + for the actual limit. マコ chose “all rows plus a warning” while leaving the + threshold unspecified. A boundary test cannot have a final expected result + without that threshold. The final integrated report still says ready. +3. **Chat content is not file-encoding proof.** リツ accepted UTF-8 BOM compliance + without a file-byte check. The supplied chat block has no BOM. The independent + checks cover the extracted content only. +4. **Corrections were not propagated to the original QA table.** マコ changed the + reporting/restart owner to レン in the review text, but the QA room's completed + table still names マコ/レオ. A reviewer or document assembly step must reconcile + these versions before using the deliverables. + +The run therefore demonstrates substantive discussion, delegation, real generated +work and upstream review. It does not demonstrate dependable autonomous acceptance +of all cross-team requirements or production readiness of the synthetic CSV task. + +## CI follow-up + +At tested head, Linux and macOS `typecheck + test` jobs passed. Windows run +[34671190267](https://github.com/milind-soni/OpenMausBot/actions/runs/34671190267) +finished with **5,939 passed, 2 failed, 176 skipped, 1 todo**. Both failures were +20-second timeouts in `server/workspace-backup.test.ts` (backup round-trip and +restoring pending follow-ups). The relevant source/test files are unchanged from +the upstream base. Running those two cases independently passed on both the +unmodified base and feature head (11.69s and 14.64s total test time respectively): + +```sh +pnpm exec vitest run server/workspace-backup.test.ts -t 'round-trips WAL|also pauses pending' --reporter=verbose +``` + +This narrows the failure to a timing-sensitive CI observation; it does not prove +the cause or turn the failed Windows job green. Vercel separately requires the +upstream team's deployment authorization. Neither condition is hidden by this +live workflow result. + +[sha256.txt](sha256.txt) records the screenshot, transcript, provider-event and +CSV-check hashes. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8a59c7546f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +import csv, io, json, re +from pathlib import Path +from datetime import date +root=Path(__file__).parent +report=json.loads((root/'transcripts.json').read_text(encoding='utf-8')) +room=next(t for t in report['transcripts'] if t['name']=='実装チーム') +msg=next(m for m in room['messages'] if m.get('from',{}).get('name')=='ヒナ' and '```' in m.get('text','')) +source=re.search(r'```(?:csv)?\n(.*?)\n```',msg['text'],re.S).group(1) +with (root/'sample.csv').open('w', encoding='utf-8', newline='') as output: + output.write(source) +rows=list(csv.reader(io.StringIO(source),strict=True)) +expected='受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス'.split(',') +checks={ + 'header_matches_agreed_order': rows[0]==expected, + 'three_data_rows':len(rows)==4, + 'twelve_columns_every_row':all(len(r)==12 for r in rows), + 'consecutive_unique_ids':[r[0] for r in rows[1:]]==['ORD-000001','ORD-000002','ORD-000003'], + 'date_range_matches_assignment':all(date(2026,3,12)<=date.fromisoformat(r[1])<=date(2026,9,11) for r in rows[1:]), + 'update_on_or_after_order':all(date.fromisoformat(r[2])>=date.fromisoformat(r[1]) for r in rows[1:]), + 'integer_values_and_amount':all(all(re.fullmatch(r'\d+',v) for v in r[8:11]) and int(r[8])*int(r[9])==int(r[10]) for r in rows[1:]), + 'allowed_status':all(r[11] in ['確定','出荷済','完了','キャンセル'] for r in rows[1:]), + 'no_embedded_commas_quotes_or_newlines':all(not any(c in value for c in ',"\r\n') for r in rows for value in r), +} +result={'sourceMessageId':msg['id'],'sourceAuthor':'ヒナ','checks':checks,'allPassed':all(checks.values()),'limits':['Checks apply to extracted chat text, not a bot-created file.','Chat block has no BOM; UTF-8 BOM file output is not verified.','Date interval follows the assignment; cross-team agreement is assessed separately.']} +with (root/'csv-checks.json').open('w', encoding='utf-8', newline='\n') as output: + output.write(json.dumps(result,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2)) +print(json.dumps(result,ensure_ascii=False,indent=2)) +assert result['allPassed'] diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d2ae2e20ba --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json @@ -0,0 +1,21 @@ +{ + "sourceMessageId": "47964bc9-f87c-4d49-ab8e-54b5c57ecd6b", + "sourceAuthor": "ヒナ", + "checks": { + "header_matches_agreed_order": true, + "three_data_rows": true, + "twelve_columns_every_row": true, + "consecutive_unique_ids": true, + "date_range_matches_assignment": true, + "update_on_or_after_order": true, + "integer_values_and_amount": true, + "allowed_status": true, + "no_embedded_commas_quotes_or_newlines": true + }, + "allPassed": true, + "limits": [ + "Checks apply to extracted chat text, not a bot-created file.", + "Chat block has no BOM; UTF-8 BOM file output is not verified.", + "Date interval follows the assignment; cross-team agreement is assessed separately." + ] +} \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2f55a81e31 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..70de1cc952 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/development-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ace59ce36b Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-revision.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-revision.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..aacdd1caed Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/executive-revision.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..966f7c4f1d Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..b36f2beabf Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..08f9253dc8 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json @@ -0,0 +1,902 @@ +[ + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv08sq-1vz", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "e4d702d4-a41e-45ad-a7aa-69bd5d358ac4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:41.162Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0sru-2bq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "e4d702d4-a41e-45ad-a7aa-69bd5d358ac4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:07.050Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0svu-2br", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "e0b6de69-9927-48b4-ad1a-82c58b8862d4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:07.194Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv11uf-2oy", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "e0b6de69-9927-48b4-ad1a-82c58b8862d4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:18.807Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv11xi-2oz", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "7bdd77b8-fa92-4e08-8c3b-e6b8cea08ee4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:18.918Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv19wa-31y", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "7bdd77b8-fa92-4e08-8c3b-e6b8cea08ee4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:29.242Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1a7a-31z", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "656ee92b-9e59-413c-9bef-2429b0be69ff", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:29.638Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1vek-3q3", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "656ee92b-9e59-413c-9bef-2429b0be69ff", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:57.116Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1vlm-3q4", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "ebea5071-4e90-4641-aa31-646c2f087c52", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:57.370Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv24j2-487", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "ebea5071-4e90-4641-aa31-646c2f087c52", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:08.942Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv24pw-488", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "005655a2-0cc3-457d-81e8-9115e313294d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:09.188Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2d4u-4wl", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "005655a2-0cc3-457d-81e8-9115e313294d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:20.094Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2dlt-4wo", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "8a3c9c50-8c36-4422-896f-194655582ff6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:20.705Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2n12-5et", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "turnId": "8a3c9c50-8c36-4422-896f-194655582ff6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:32.918Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv3l69-600", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "4db5889d-7b12-4988-b460-f867688f782b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:17.169Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv42gu-6f9", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "4db5889d-7b12-4988-b460-f867688f782b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:39.582Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv42ql-6fb", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "404da23e-e1e3-4b25-870d-cf56f16acbc2", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:39.933Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4i3g-6sq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "404da23e-e1e3-4b25-870d-cf56f16acbc2", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:59.836Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4i9f-6sr", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "87558e45-c8cd-4fb2-abc2-87a4ce2e6a1b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:00.051Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4rp2-79i", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "87558e45-c8cd-4fb2-abc2-87a4ce2e6a1b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:12.278Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4s6v-79j", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "f8ec6a0d-ef7a-48ad-9482-3526427a760c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:12.919Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5nqo-87o", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "f8ec6a0d-ef7a-48ad-9482-3526427a760c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:53.808Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5nwe-87s", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "e168f125-00f7-47c5-9a86-2096581f4f6b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:54.014Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv62d7-9co", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "e168f125-00f7-47c5-9a86-2096581f4f6b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:12.763Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv62ns-9cp", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "7c850644-6d2f-45df-bff5-4dda29e93e87", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:13.144Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv6ddd-a88", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "7c850644-6d2f-45df-bff5-4dda29e93e87", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:27.025Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv6dtf-a89", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "d18a93a8-c0a4-4b7e-915c-727570d18f90", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:27.603Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv6ws9-bhk", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "turnId": "d18a93a8-c0a4-4b7e-915c-727570d18f90", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:52.185Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuzu5n-1q3", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "63c9a597-1b36-4bc4-8c1e-ca2f910f8620", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:22.187Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0f6n-1zc", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "63c9a597-1b36-4bc4-8c1e-ca2f910f8620", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:49.439Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0fqd-20m", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "a3639015-2599-494f-826e-7b5f26445630", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:50.149Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0o1v-28h", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "a3639015-2599-494f-826e-7b5f26445630", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:00.931Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0o6k-28j", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "2f56c9bf-0d73-402a-8626-ae119cafbfbb", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:01.100Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0wzh-2iq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "2f56c9bf-0d73-402a-8626-ae119cafbfbb", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:12.509Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv0xfl-2ir", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "cd3a2eee-80ed-4b42-b596-492db9587b9b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:13.089Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1iz0-3dw", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "cd3a2eee-80ed-4b42-b596-492db9587b9b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:41.004Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1j8w-3dy", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "8d2da88a-11c0-4798-a2f4-01718747545d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:41.360Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1rob-3ly", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "8d2da88a-11c0-4798-a2f4-01718747545d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:52.283Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv1rud-3lz", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "0ed6dd5c-985e-4fa6-b5d6-4da459be6573", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:03:52.501Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2049-3x4", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "0ed6dd5c-985e-4fa6-b5d6-4da459be6573", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:03.225Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv20kw-3x5", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "f5417ab1-74d3-4ceb-ad8d-c2ef26b10492", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:03.824Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2vhk-5qb", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "f5417ab1-74d3-4ceb-ad8d-c2ef26b10492", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:43.880Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2w0j-5t3", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "d90afccd-8da4-457e-b368-a407e9de94a6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:44.563Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv38xo-5vk", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "d90afccd-8da4-457e-b368-a407e9de94a6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:01.308Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv39es-5vl", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "b2867b64-276d-4ff7-a8e0-776622aa1196", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:01.924Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv3kzi-5zz", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "b2867b64-276d-4ff7-a8e0-776622aa1196", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:16.926Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv60kc-964", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "1d80f278-5b08-4374-8b8e-bb25b1c4ddb0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:10.428Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv6cnr-a32", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "1d80f278-5b08-4374-8b8e-bb25b1c4ddb0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:26.103Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv6x3k-bhl", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "95f92d6d-ec82-4229-9733-d285e2afabe4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:52.592Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv76t3-c1p", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "95f92d6d-ec82-4229-9733-d285e2afabe4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:05.175Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv77a8-c1q", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "b993ddb5-0799-4e0a-a875-20662b2cd302", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:05.792Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv7isf-cm7", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "turnId": "b993ddb5-0799-4e0a-a875-20662b2cd302", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:20.703Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuw7rr-0", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "ec4afefd-6fa3-4d01-8537-64ee4e9c8b26", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T03:59:33.207Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuwss6-87", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "ec4afefd-6fa3-4d01-8537-64ee4e9c8b26", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:00.438Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuwt11-88", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "1d3db3cb-da0f-4a97-b80a-7c9222cd075c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:00.757Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxux1zh-g6", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "1d3db3cb-da0f-4a97-b80a-7c9222cd075c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:12.365Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxux21l-g7", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "04e84d3f-64a6-4475-8ba9-7f81356bbd73", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:12.441Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuxa16-mj", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "04e84d3f-64a6-4475-8ba9-7f81356bbd73", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:22.794Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuxagj-mk", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "7203e8ce-468c-4846-8cfb-6aa9584e91ab", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:23.347Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuxx02-uc", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "7203e8ce-468c-4846-8cfb-6aa9584e91ab", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:52.562Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuxx9u-ud", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "103e9609-3830-4db4-8b93-29b6790279ef", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:00:52.914Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuypgj-108", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "103e9609-3830-4db4-8b93-29b6790279ef", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:01:29.443Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuypka-109", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "1d70555f-2596-4d5a-b99f-ff68d701e2a0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:01:29.578Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuyy38-15j", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "1d70555f-2596-4d5a-b99f-ff68d701e2a0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:01:40.628Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuyyh2-15k", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "3fa8f31a-4bd6-431d-a91c-5e3621a4fcd5", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:01:41.126Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuzgu3-1lw", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "3fa8f31a-4bd6-431d-a91c-5e3621a4fcd5", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:04.923Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuzh19-1lx", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "a7189857-83c4-473b-b9c0-c8b839d1eb20", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:05.181Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuztum-1q1", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "a7189857-83c4-473b-b9c0-c8b839d1eb20", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:21.790Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxuzu4m-1q2", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "0acc1fd2-99b8-465c-88e9-04a2af26809b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:22.150Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv08m8-1vy", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "0acc1fd2-99b8-465c-88e9-04a2af26809b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:02:40.928Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2ne3-5eu", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "cfefbfd9-f731-4739-9616-5a4903659bc9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:33.387Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv2vxy-5t2", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "cfefbfd9-f731-4739-9616-5a4903659bc9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:04:44.470Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv7j6f-cm8", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "98d001b0-0594-46cb-800b-0861fa6269e6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:21.207Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv7rtp-cyi", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "98d001b0-0594-46cb-800b-0861fa6269e6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:32.413Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv7s5h-cyj", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "251e64cb-55f8-4c1f-b624-45aaf858683b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:32.837Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv80uo-db5", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "turnId": "251e64cb-55f8-4c1f-b624-45aaf858683b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:44.112Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv39fr-5vm", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "66f2440a-6a65-4989-b607-28acff680545", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:01.959Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv3tat-63q", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "66f2440a-6a65-4989-b607-28acff680545", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:27.701Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv3tdy-63r", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "e3457b67-55c6-4d8a-bf19-b753b3fd2ef1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:27.814Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv42if-6fa", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "e3457b67-55c6-4d8a-bf19-b753b3fd2ef1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:39.639Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv42rz-6fc", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "dd7ccf19-962b-4cc2-aa38-4762385d3396", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:39.983Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4dv9-6ms", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "dd7ccf19-962b-4cc2-aa38-4762385d3396", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:54.357Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv4f13-6mt", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "b5ad5835-13e2-4178-88db-452b8e253f2f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:05:55.863Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv51i5-7d9", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "b5ad5835-13e2-4178-88db-452b8e253f2f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:24.989Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv51su-7da", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "d4910414-3c00-4035-81d8-3da238c2627e", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:25.374Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5cxd-7uf", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "d4910414-3c00-4035-81d8-3da238c2627e", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:39.793Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5da0-7ug", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "24dc5ac5-3d7a-415e-a779-559518a2e831", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:40.248Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5nru-87r", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "24dc5ac5-3d7a-415e-a779-559518a2e831", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:53.850Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv5o2g-87t", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "957bc4f8-9343-49d8-aab7-567f0c78695b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:06:54.232Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxv600d-963", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "turnId": "957bc4f8-9343-49d8-aab7-567f0c78695b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:07:09.709Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + } +] diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-challenge.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-challenge.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..06743e3d77 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-challenge.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ecd1d9ef34 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e3791bb3ea Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-challenge.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-challenge.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..1989fd2a54 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-challenge.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..8690816442 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..635d956efd Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sample.csv b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sample.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..51aabd1f99 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sample.csv @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス +ORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了 +ORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済 +ORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定 \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0fec199574 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +9cf6757e707962547916a9fc67ae2917a19a21f6d1d5a4897c2b6a763e34d262 csv-checks.json +3bb6fc76d04163304101c1bb6975aba31f754e7b9572656098df307cd3e56d93 development-discussion.png +c804d61f16e77a426e82673d5f749e1df02fc7734740507b8fdea874b7b7b566 development-results.png +75b143238bc4719c7828333eca20be11af5b83a3f787e4b0d199fdc19ce496c1 executive-results.png +d83b6e60bb8dea0147c8924813c63e87abfb106a0fbdd644e7f96fa772e242d7 executive-revision.png +6b6fa85c3615169dc390da543092ba87957ef7c4664e475465ce919a991220c2 implementation-discussion.png +4d0728fc9a426bb87058aa992ae651039c93b9cd31acfb76c33af5499e29a65a implementation-results.png +9ba16fa2ce6fcaf3755f0b49d73635f1144aa63a87c4d7d19653ed437a6a404e provider-turns.json +32e4e8efacbc273e68be84a03ffa4156ae192aad15c6695f069ea2c8f242d489 qa-challenge.png +62b1a065f78ffe65738a458447703811b5aabcd58a9e122e04e2d48fef446154 qa-discussion.png +d46a054c210a87c7d8ddc63066c8de47034fd262f77a38b24fb154f7616cd1cb qa-results.png +00d05ccca72b144ed7507c84fdad86137c4b1db60f9b8b47fc10e0215024921d sales-challenge.png +962dbefa084ac7a938e8e96e1d8ae24a6f1dd8ec67a53c06a51ee890cbe2b694 sales-discussion.png +e47040a060e380ea7bdb7d64d497118daba0a3a79df935507f458cb6958d4fd3 sales-results.png +f511eb9c26a4582073ca5d7f6a72167a00d2abb263a209851c30500eb331066c sample.csv +cbb08926badb35f9b2ee9c2506efda04922a3ea1d81eb5b66c614e2945aac451 transcripts.json diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5f5c65ebe8 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json @@ -0,0 +1,1561 @@ +{ + "verifiedAt": "2026-09-12T04:08:44.443Z", + "upstreamBase": "2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c", + "testedHead": "454aa82296fed62ffcba6ae8cb028bc01eb99ad0", + "mode": "live Claude Code 2.1.251 / GLM-5.3 / low; isolated fixture", + "orchestrationPassed": true, + "counts": { + "rooms": 5, + "bots": 15, + "providerTurns": 45, + "schedulerExecutions": 44, + "work": 5, + "discussion": 7, + "assignment": 10, + "failedToolCalls": 14 + }, + "rooms": [ + { + "id": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "name": "経営会議", + "members": [ + { + "id": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "name": "開発部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "name": "営業部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "f2249b99-7338-4fd4-837b-e1fc2ae5e9fa", + "name": "サキ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "7dfe3949-9e25-4863-a09a-dd1d4d69af97", + "name": "トワ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "name": "実装チーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "2b7d1a74-d264-44d3-99b4-7c2f897d4094", + "name": "ヒナ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "5806e3c6-b7a9-4b7c-8d26-d9f5f73a8021", + "name": "ナギ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "name": "QAチーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "8ce8bad3-e9ed-4708-b170-d03076932825", + "name": "メイ", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "6033e190-9e6c-4404-b406-aad35ef23f08", + "name": "ハル", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + } + ], + "nodes": [ + { + "id": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "groupId": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 44, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185593628, + "text": "", + "result": "【経営会議・統合報告】CSV出力の公開準備が完了しました。\n\n**決定事項(再掲)**\n初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。形式はUTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠で固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n**各部門の成果**\n- 開発部(アオイ→レン、リツ/マコ→ソラ/レオ):①架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行、12項目)②検査表(規約・受入・境界値・異常系の4部構成)。受注番号重複欠番なし、金額整合、0件・境界・途中失敗時の部分破棄まで網羅。\n- 営業部(ユイ→コウ、サキ/トワ):①顧客向けFAQ3問(鮮度判断・拡張見込みを平易に説明)②社内操作チェックリスト5項目(持出し制限・用途ログ・転送禁止・30日削除)。\n\n**統合判断**\n両担当のレビュー結果を私が受領し、いずれも決定方針・条件(受注日・更新日確保、文字化け防止、公開遅延回避)を満たしていることを確認しました。開発・営業両成果物を**採用**し、公開準備完了として経営会議の取りまとめを終了します。12項目は確定済みのため、3週間目標には十分余力があります。ご指示ありがとうございました。" + }, + { + "id": "6642b0c7-0df4-4a41-898d-2c0adc36f446", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "groupId": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185593628, + "text": "CSV出力の初期対象について1巡目議論。仮案は「全項目・全件出力」。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定を主張、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求の予定。各自、仮案への賛否と自案の理由、相手案への懸念を述べてください。", + "result": "アオイ: @ミナト 1巡目のご意見です。\n\n仮案「全項目・全件出力」には反対です。開発側の懸念は、①項目定義の整備と全件テストで公開が数週間遅れる、②利用者が本当に必要な項目が埋もれ使いにくくなる、③初期瑕疵の影響範囲が最大になる点です。\n\n自案は「基本項目(顧客名・日付・金額・ステータス等)限定＋直近3ヶ月分」でまず公開し、反応を見て段階拡張します。初期公開は2週間以内を実現したい。\n\nユイさんの営業必須項目の要求は理解できますが、項目が増えるほど公開が遅くなる懸念があります。必須上位10項目程度に絞り、不足分は第2弾で追加する形で調整したいです。\n\nユイ: @ミナト @アオイ 1巡目のご意見です。\n仮案「全項目・全件」には賛成しかねます。営業現場では顧客名・案件名・金額・担当・ステータス・受注日などの必須項目が揃わないCSVは実用になりませんが、全件出力は作業が重く公開が遅れる点、不要な内部項目まで出る情報管理上の懸念もあります。\n自案は「営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月分」です。商談履歴の遡りは6ヶ月必要で、3ヶ月では期中分析に使えません。\nアオイ案への懸念は、①基本項目の定義が開発側恣意になり営業視点が欠ける、②3ヶ月では実務に耐えない点です。妥協としては「必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月、第2弾で拡張」まで譲れます。" + }, + { + "id": "921baf94-cb6e-4ee7-82ac-55c19c67c6fd", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "groupId": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185645508, + "text": "2巡目議論:CSV出力の初期対象。議長修正案は「営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月分」を初期公開とし、開発の早期公開目標(3週間以内)を前提に、項目定義をアオイ・ユイ合同で確定、全件・全項目は第2弾拡張とする。アオイの「公開遅延」懸念には期間3週間、ユイの「6ヶ月必要性」は取り込み済み。両名、この修正案への賛否と改善があれば回答してください。", + "result": "アオイ: @ミナト 2巡目のご意見です。\n\n修正案に**賛成**です。12項目＋直近6ヶ月という限定により、項目定義とテスト範囲が絞られ、3週間以内の公開は開発側として十分現実的です。私の「公開遅延」懸念は解消されました。\n\n改善要望を2点だけです。\n①12項目の合同確定は今週中に完了させ、確定が遅れた場合は公開目標を優先し、未確定項目は第2弾へ繰り越す、という逃げ道を明記してほしい。\n③項目定義にはCSVの出力形式(文字コードUTF-8、日付形式、エスケープ規約)も併せて固定し、後日の仕様変更による手戻りを防ぎたい。\n\nこの2点が入れば開発として確定・着手します。\n\nユイ: @ミナト @アオイ 2巡目のご意見です。\n修正案に**賛成**です。営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月が初期公開に組み込まれたことで、期中分析にも耐えられる実用範囲が確保されました。3週間以内の公開目標も営業として歓迎します。\nアオイさんの2点の改善要望にも同意します。特にUTF-8・日付形式の固定は営業側のExcelでの文字化け防止にも効くので賛成です。追加要望は1点だけで、12項目の合同確定に際しては「受注日・更新日」の2つを必ず含めてほしいです。商談の鮮度判定に必須のため。この点を条件に確定・着手で問題ありません。" + }, + { + "id": "61db0c22-b8e3-4586-851e-eae4899a10d3", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "groupId": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185715479, + "text": "議長ミナト。2巡目の両名賛成を受け、方針を最終決定しました。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中にユイと合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。出力形式(UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約)を定義に固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\nあなたの担当:開発部レン(group_id=15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c, bot_id=26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2)へsend_room_messageで依頼。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼するよう伝達。成果物は架空CSVサンプル・検査表等。結果をレビューして私へ報告してください。実データ・コード変更不要。", + "result": "@ミナト 開発担当アオイ、開発部レンからの取りまとめをレビューしました。**そのまま受け入れ、承認します。**\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- 架空CSVサンプル(ソラ作成・リツレビュー済み):12項目固定、受注番号の重複欠番なし、金額=数量×単価、6ヶ月範囲、UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠——経営会議決定と形式固定要望を全て満たす。✅\n- 検査表(レオ作成・マコレビュー済み):0件・6ヶ月境界・途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄まで網羅。上限件数は初回未規定(超過時は全件出力+警告、第2弾で規定)は合理的。✅\n\n私の要望(公開遅延回避、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約の固定)とユイさんの条件(受注日・更新日必須、Excel文字化け防止のBOM付き)も反映済みです。\n\n**ミナトさんへの報告**\n開発部の公開準備が完了しました。決定(12項目・直近6ヶ月分・3週間目標)に基づき、①架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行) ②検査表(4部構成) を作成・レビュー済みで、公開可能な状態です。12項目は本日確定済みのため3週間目標に余力あり。経営会議での統合(ユイさん担当の営業部FAQ・チェックリストと合わせ)をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "4126bc8a-ede2-4afc-826c-f2cc0e987f24", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "groupId": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "threadId": "9f7ac231-33ae-4738-a8ef-838605f417c7", + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185717414, + "text": "議長ミナト。2巡目の両名賛成を受け、方針を最終決定しました。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む、あなたの条件を反映)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中にアオイと合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\nあなたの担当:営業部コウ(group_id=a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4, bot_id=5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a)へsend_room_messageで依頼。営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバー(サキ・トワ)へ成果物作成(FAQ・チェックリスト等)を分担するよう伝達。結果をレビューして私へ報告してください。実データ・コード変更不要。", + "result": "@ミナト 営業担当ユイ、コウからの返却結果をレビューしました。**そのまま受け入れ、承認します。**\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- FAQ3問(サキ作成):12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、文字化けしない形式の平易な表現、拡張は時期未確定と正直に記載——決定方針どおり。✅\n- チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成):端末・保存先限定、用途ログ、転送禁止、更新日チェック、社外持ち出し禁止+事前承認+30日削除まで規定。取得管理台の削除欄記入もあり運用可能。✅\n\n私の条件(受注日・更新日の確保、Excel文字化け防止の形式固定)も満たされています。\n\n**ミナト様への報告**\n営業部の公開準備が完了しました。決定(12項目・6ヶ月・3週間目標・形式固定)に基づき、①顧客向けFAQ3問 ②社内操作チェックリスト5項目 を作成・レビュー済みで、公開可能な状態です。経営会議での統合をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "d7d6fcc8-6a41-4650-b316-b493b6f080a8", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "61db0c22-b8e3-4586-851e-eae4899a10d3", + "groupId": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185736164, + "text": "経営会議決定に基づく依頼です(アオイより)。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中に確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。出力形式(UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約)を定義に固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n【進め方】開発部でも議論→決定→分担→実行→報告の手順を同じ形で実施してください。既存メンバーで2巡議論(1巡目は懸念、責任者修正案、2巡目で回答)を行い、決定後にリツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへsend_room_messageで依頼してください。宛先IDはlist_room_targetsで確認を。最下層は1巡議論後に各メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。\n\n【成果物】実データ・コード変更不要の架空データで、①架空CSVサンプル(12項目・6ヶ月分数行)②検査表(QA観点)、その他必要なら項目定義書。完了後、結果を私(アオイ)へ返してください。レビューの上、ミナトへ報告します。", + "result": "リツ・マコ両担当分の報告を受領し、レビュー済みです。両名のレビュー判断を了承し、開発部として取りまとめます。\n\n【開発部 取りまとめ(アオイ宛て報告)】\n経営会議決定(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)に対し、部内で2巡の議論→決定→分担→実行→レビューを完了しました。\n\n■決定事項\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む)。変更は第2弾扱い。\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外。\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日2026-09-11を定義書に明記。\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先・再開判断者=レン)。\n\n■成果物\n1. 架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行、12項目)…実装チーム(ソラ)作成、リツレビュー済み。総行数・連番・6ヶ月範囲・金額=数量×単価・規約を全て確認し受入条件満たす。\n2. 検査表(規約・受入・境界値・異常系の4部構成)…QAチーム(レオ)作成、マコレビュー済み。0件・6ヶ月境界・上限件数・途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄まで網羅。レビューで報告先・再開判断者を正式値(レン)に差し替え済み。上限件数は初回未規定(超過時は全件出力+警告、第2弾で正式規定)。\n\n■スケジュール\n12項目は本日確定済みのため、公開目標3週間以内に対し十分余力あり。\n\n両成果物とも受入条件を満たすと判断し、開発部として了承・完了とします。以上、アオイさんのレビューをお願いします。ミナトさんへの報告よろしくお願いいたします。" + }, + { + "id": "1747ba0c-91a6-4bef-8d21-0df337b39a26", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "4126bc8a-ede2-4afc-826c-f2cc0e987f24", + "groupId": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185755194, + "text": "営業部コウさん。経営会議営業担当ユイです。経営会議の最終決定をお伝えし、営業部での準備を依頼します。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中に開発アオイと経営会議ユイが合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n【依頼】営業部で既存メンバー(サキ・トワ)と1巡議論を行い、その後 各既存メンバーへ成果物作成(FAQ・チェックリスト等、営業利用向け)を割り当ててください。担当者はlist_room_targetsから宛先IDを確認しsend_room_messageで依頼。実データ・コード変更不要、架空データで作成。結果はこちらへ戻してください。レビューの上、経営会議ミナトへ報告します。", + "result": "両者の成果物をレビューしました。いずれも決定方針を忠実に反映しており、そのまま採用します。\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- サキさんFAQ3問:12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、「文字化けしない形式」の平易な表現、拡張は時期未確定、社外持ち出しルール1行明記——すべて反映済み。Q3で持ち出しルールに軽く触れているのも適切。✅採用\n- トワさんチェックリスト5項目:端末・保存先限定、用途ログ、転送禁止、更新日チェック、社外持ち出し禁止+事前承認+30日削除——すべて反映済み。取得管理台の削除欄記入まで盛り込まれ、運用として実行可能。✅採用\n\n**ユイさんへの報告**\n\n営業部の準備が完了しました。経営会議決定(12項目+6ヶ月、UTF-8等規約固定、第2弾拡張)を受け、サキ・トワと1巡議論のうえ方針を決定し、以下の2成果物を作成・レビュー済みです。\n\n1. 顧客向けFAQ3問(サキ作成):内容・鮮度判断・拡張見込みを平易に説明\n2. 社内操作チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成):持出し制限・用途ログ・転送禁止・削除まで規定\n\n議論で追加採用したのは「説明資料1枚化」「更新日で鮮度判断」「拡張は時期未確定と正直に伝える」「持出し端末・保存先限定と転送禁止」「取得時用途ログ」です。公開目標3週間以内に向け利用可能です。ミナト様への報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "2f023b4b-ceb1-45fe-a9b0-4e3f3d0b7a5f", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "d7d6fcc8-6a41-4650-b316-b493b6f080a8", + "groupId": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185763192, + "text": "CSV初期公開(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)の件。論点は①12項目のCSV設計(受注日・更新日必須、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約を定義に固定)②検査表の受入条件。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で、1巡目として懸念を述べてください。", + "result": "リツ: @レン 1巡目、処理の簡素さの観点で懸念です。\n\n①12項目の確定が部内合意だと項目増減のたびCSV・検査表の両方再作成になり手戻りが大きい。仮案の12項目を今週中に固定し、以降の変更は第2弾扱いにしてほしい。\n\n②BOM付きUTF-8はExcel開封便利な反面、一部パーサで先頭1文字化けの事故が起きやすい。対象が営業側のExcel利用中心ならBOM付きで統一し、定義書に明記で良いと思います。\n\n③エスケープはRFC4180準拠で良いが、カンマ・改行を含む項目(備考等)を初期12項目に入れると検査が複雑化する。初期は自由記述項目を避け、改行コードはLFに統一を提案します。\n\nマコ: @レン 1巡目、途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で懸念です。\n\n①6ヶ月分の抽出で途中失敗すると、部分的なCSVが完成品と誤認される危険があります。件数を事前確認し、ヘッダ1+データ件数の合計を行数として検査表の受入条件に明記すべきです。\n\n②受注日基準か更新日基準かで6ヶ月範囲の対象件数が変わります。定義書で抽出基準日と基準日を固定し、件数が変わらない根拠を検査で確認できる形にしてください。\n\n③架空データとはいえ、途中で行が重複や欠落すると検知が難しい。受注番号等の一意キーを12項目に含め、重複なし・欠番なしを受入条件に加える提案です。\n\n④文字コード・改行の事故はリツさん指摘と同じで、失敗時に再作成ではなく中断・報告の手順を検査表に定義しておきたいです。" + }, + { + "id": "3dfed60a-e55f-4071-b5e2-8a6d29bea060", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "1747ba0c-91a6-4bef-8d21-0df337b39a26", + "groupId": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "f2249b99-7338-4fd4-837b-e1fc2ae5e9fa", + "7dfe3949-9e25-4863-a09a-dd1d4d69af97" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185780996, + "text": "CSV初期公開(営業必須12項目+直近6ヶ月分、公開目標3週間以内、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定、全項目全件は第2弾)のお客様説明と社内運用の方針。サキは顧客向けの便利さ・説明しやすさ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約・運用面のリスクの観点で意見を述べてください。各自、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を加えること。", + "result": "サキ: @コウ 提案に賛成です。12項目+6ヶ月は「よく使うデータだけ先に出す」と説明しやすく、顧客の利便性も確保できます。改善提案として、①顧客向けに項目一覧と取得手順を1枚の説明資料にまとめる、②受注日・更新日が必須なので「データの鮮度は更新日で判断して下さい」と明記する、③第2弾拡張は時期を確約せず「要望に応じて拡張予定」と正直に伝える、の3点を入れて下さい。UTF-8やエスケープ規約は専門用語を避け「文字化けしない形式」と平易に説明するのが良いと思います。\n\nトワ: @コウ @サキ サキさんの3点に概ね賛成です。ただし個人情報・持出し制約の観点から改善を加えます。①12項目に顧客名・担当者名等が入る場合、CSVは持出し可能な端末・保存先を限定し、営業はダウンロード後の転送禁止を徹底すべきです。②6ヶ月分でも件数によっては個人情報が大量になるので、取得時に用途を確認するログ残しを運用に入れて下さい。③説明資料には「文字化けしない形式」に加え「社外持ち出しルール」を1行明記するのが良いです。チェックリスト側でこれらを項目化します。" + }, + { + "id": "785fcfc4-c317-4a19-aa42-c959ca2bba75", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "d7d6fcc8-6a41-4650-b316-b493b6f080a8", + "groupId": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185815355, + "text": "2巡目:レン修正案(①受注番号含む12項目を今週固定・第2弾運用②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述項目除外③受注日基準で基準日固定④受入条件=総行数一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時中断報告)への回答を各自述べてください。", + "result": "リツ: @レン 2巡目、処理の簡素さの観点から修正案に回答します。\n\n①項目の今週固定・第2弾運用:賛成。手戻りが構造的に抑えられ、作成・検査の両手順が単純化されます。\n\n②規約一式:賛成。自由記述除外でカンマ・改行のエスケープ処理が不要になり、検査も文字種確認だけで済みます。\n\n③受注日基準・基準日固定:賛成。抽出条件が1つで済み、CSV作成側も検査側も同じ前提で確認できます。\n\n④受入条件:賛成。追加要望として、12項目の確定項目名を定義書に列挙し、ヘッダ行の項目名・順序一致も受入条件に加えていただけると、検査表が機械的に回せます。\n\n修正案全体で合意です。\n\nマコ: @レン 2巡目、途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点から修正案に回答します。\n\n①受注番号含む12項目の今週固定・第2弾運用：賛成。一意キー確定で重複・欠落検知が最初から組み込めます。\n\n②規約一式：賛成。BOM・LF・日付形式の固定と自由記述除外で、件数・行数検査が文字種事故に汚染されなくなります。\n\n③受注日基準・基準日固定：賛成。基準日を定義書に明記すれば、検査側が抽出前提を再現でき、件数変化の根拠確認が可能です。\n\n④受入条件：賛成。リツさんの追加要望(ヘッダの項目名・順序一致)にも同意します。加えて、中断・報告時の報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記していただけると、失敗時の宙ぶらりんを防げます。\n\n修正案全体で合意です。" + }, + { + "id": "4869ca25-c575-4cfb-abb2-6f193d5bf34b", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "1747ba0c-91a6-4bef-8d21-0df337b39a26", + "groupId": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "botId": "f2249b99-7338-4fd4-837b-e1fc2ae5e9fa", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185833632, + "text": "決定方針:12項目+6ヶ月分、更新日で鮮度判断、第2弾は時期未確定「要望に応じて拡張予定」、専門用語避け「文字化けしない形式」、社外持ち出しルールの1行明記。あなたの担当:顧客向けFAQ3問を作成してください。架空データ、日本語、各問い答えは簡潔に。完成後この会話へ結果を返して下さい。", + "result": "@コウ 担当の顧客向けFAQ3問が完成しました。決定方針(12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、第2弾は時期未確定、平易な表現、社外持ち出しルール1行明記)を反映しています。レビューをお願いします。\n\n---\n\n## 顧客向けFAQ(CSVデータ提供サービス 初期公開版)\n\n**Q1. どんなデータが、どのくらいの期間分もらえますか?**\nA. 営業でよく使う12項目(受注日・更新日を含む)を、直近6ヶ月分まとめてお渡しします。項目一覧と取得手順は1枚の説明資料にまとめてご用意します。\n\n**Q2. データの新しい・古さはどうやって判断すればよいですか?また、形式面での注意はありますか?**\nA. 各データの「更新日」をご確認ください。更新日が新しいほど最新の情報です。形式は文字化けしない形式でご提供するため、特別な設定なしでExcel等でそのまま開けます。\n\n**Q3. 全項目・全期間のデータはもらえますか?**\nA. 現在は初期公開版のため12項目・6ヶ月分です。全項目・全件の拡張はお客様のご要望に応じて拡張予定です。なお、お預かりしたデータの社外への持ち出しは、弊社規定のルールに従ってお願いします。\n\n---\n\n以上3問です。トワさんのチェックリストと合わせて取りまとめをお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "5cc91abd-d0f4-4545-a53c-28e75c2c36e3", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "1747ba0c-91a6-4bef-8d21-0df337b39a26", + "groupId": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "threadId": "0271e0d0-8742-4b78-9b29-2d2f4d9ab7f6", + "botId": "7dfe3949-9e25-4863-a09a-dd1d4d69af97", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185834260, + "text": "決定方針:CSV持出し可能な端末・保存先の限定、ダウンロード後の転送禁止、取得時に用途を確認するログ残し、社外持ち出しルール明記、更新日で鮮度判断。あなたの担当:社内操作チェックリスト5項目を作成してください。架空データ、日本語、営業が実行可能な具体的操作手順として。完成後この会話へ結果を返して下さい。", + "result": "@コウ 担当の社内操作チェックリスト5項目が完成しました。決定方針(持出し端末・保存先限定、転送禁止、取得時用途ログ、社外持ち出しルール明記、更新日で鮮度判断)を反映しています。レビューをお願いします。\n\n---\n\n## CSV取得 社内操作チェックリスト(営業用・初期公開版)\n\n**1. 持出し端末・保存先の確認**\n□ CSVを取得するのは会社支給の認証済み端末(PC・タブレット)のみ。保存先は指定フォルダ「S:\\営業\\CSV_顧客データ」に限定する。私物端末・USBメモリ・私的クラウドへの保存は禁止。\n\n**2. 取得時の用途ログ記入**\n□ ダウンロード前に「取得管理台」(共有スプレッドシート)に日付・氏名・顧客名・用途(例：A社向け提案資料作成)・取得件数を記入する。用途が書けない場合は取得しない。\n\n**3. ダウンロード後の転送禁止**\n□ 取得したCSVはメール添付・チャット送付・他部署への共有をしない。参照が必要な場合は相手に同じ手順で自身が取得してもらう。\n\n**4. 鮮度の確認(更新日チェック)**\n□ ファイル開封後、先頭行の「更新日」列を確認し、直近の更新日であることを確認してから利用する。古いデータで判断しない。\n\n**5. 社外持ち出しと利用後の削除**\n□ CSVの社外持ち出しは禁止(やむを得ない場合は部長コウの事前承認を得る)。利用が終わったら期限内(取得から30日以内)に指定フォルダから削除し、取得管理台の削除欄に日付を記入する。\n\n---\n\n以上5項目です。サキさんのFAQと合わせて取りまとめをお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "302093ee-d990-46b3-885c-dc30e4b6461a", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "d7d6fcc8-6a41-4650-b316-b493b6f080a8", + "groupId": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185875862, + "text": "決定事項:①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む、変更は第2弾)②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書に明記④受入条件=総行数一致・ヘッダ項目名順序一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時中断報告(報告先・再開判断者=レンを明記)。\nあなたの担当:実装チームのソラ(group_id=47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc, bot_id=c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982)へsend_room_messageで依頼。内容:架空CSVサンプル(12項目・6ヶ月分数行)+項目定義書(12項目名列挙・基準日・出力規約明記)。下層にも同じ議論→分担→実行→報告の手順を伝えること。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告してください。", + "result": "@レン リツ担当分のレビュー完了、問題なしです。レンへ報告します。\n\n【ソラチーム結果レビュー(リツ)】\n- CSVサンプル:ヘッダ1+データ3行=計4行、12項目の名称・順序が決定事項と一致(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む)✓\n- 受注番号ORD-000001~3の連番、重複・欠番なし ✓\n- 受注日は基準日2026-09-11から直近6ヶ月(2026-03-12以降)内、更新日≧受注日も全行成立 ✓\n- 金額=数量×単価を3行とも再計算で確認(10×98000=980000、5×45000=225000、20×32000=640000)✓\n- 規約準拠:UTF-8 BOM・LF・YYYY-MM-DD・カンマ/引用符不含・自由記述除外、ステータスは規定値内 ✓\n- 項目定義書にも抽出基準・基準日・規約が明記済み ✓\n\n処理の簡素さの観点でも、自由記述除外と単一抽出基準で作成・検査が機械的に回る形になっており良好です。リツ担当分は受入条件を全て満たすと判断、了承します。マコさんの検査表結果と併せて取りまとめをお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "f3efc544-8240-41bc-8cd7-3e7336ed04e2", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "d7d6fcc8-6a41-4650-b316-b493b6f080a8", + "groupId": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "threadId": "41bca563-3fe5-496a-bf25-e3e1f2d69d94", + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185877501, + "text": "決定事項:①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む、変更は第2弾)②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書に明記④受入条件=ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数・ヘッダ項目名順序が定義書と一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時は中断・報告(報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記)。\nあなたの担当:QAチームのレオ(group_id=432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66, bot_id=ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11)へsend_room_messageで依頼。内容:検査表(QA観点、上記受入条件を全て含む)。下層にも同じ議論→分担→実行→報告の手順を伝えること。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告してください。", + "result": "@レン マコ担当分(QAチーム・レオ宛て)の結果が返りました。レビューのうえ報告します。\n\n【レオチーム結果レビュー(マコ)】\n検査表は4部構成(規約・受入・境界値・異常系)で、決定事項④の受入条件をすべて網羅 ✓\n- A-1行数一致、A-2ヘッダ項目名・順序一致、A-3受注番号重複欠番なし、失敗時中断・報告も明記 ✓\n- 境界値(B-1〜B-7)で0件・6ヶ月境界・上限件数をカバー、異常系(E-1〜E-3)で件数変化のスナップショット固定と途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄を確認。私の1巡目懸念(途中失敗・件数変化)に直接対応 ✓\n\n【レビューでの修正点1件】\nA-4/E-1〜E-3の報告先・再開判断者が「マコ/レオ」と仮置きされていますが、開発部決定では**報告先・再開判断者=レン**です。レオの検査表をこの正式値に差し替えて了承します(検査表構造自体は影響なし)。\n\n【レオへの確認事項の回答】\n1. 上限件数:初回は未規定のためB-7は「上限超過時は全件出力+警告記録(第2弾で正式規定)」とするのが妥当と判断\n2. 基準日の含む/含まない:B-2〜B-5の設定例(6ヶ月前同日を含む・基準日当日を含む、基準日2026-09-11)はソラの項目定義書と整合 ✓\n\nマコ担当分は受入条件を満たすと判断、了承します。リツさんのCSVサンプル結果と併せて取りまとめをお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "7d77da5a-5016-47be-ad2d-348779043e11", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "302093ee-d990-46b3-885c-dc30e4b6461a", + "groupId": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185896391, + "text": "リツより実装依頼です(開発部決定に基づく。架空データのみ、実データ・コード変更不要)。\n\n【成果物】\n①架空CSVサンプル:営業必須12項目(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む。残り9項目は貴チームで提案し確定)、直近6ヶ月分数行。出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目(備考等)は除外。\n②項目定義書:12項目名を列挙(ヘッダの項目名・順序の根拠)、抽出基準=受注日基準、基準日を明記、上記出力規約を明記。\n\n【受入条件(参考)】ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告。\n\n【進め方】貴チームでも同じ手順で:メンバーで1巡議論(懸念出し)→責任者修正案→2巡目で回答→決定→各メンバーへ分担→実行→責任者がまとめて私へ報告、としてください。完了結果を私(リツ)へ返してください。レビューの上、レンへ報告します。", + "result": "@リツ 完了報告です。チーム議論(1巡)のうえ決定し、ヒナがCSV作成、ナギが検査を実施、全項目OKでした。\n\n【決定事項】\n- 12項目(順):受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス(識別→顧客→担当→商品→金額→状況の順が根拠)\n- 受注番号=ORD-000001形式の連番(重複・欠番なし)\n- 数量・単価・金額=整数(円)、金額=数量×単価\n- ステータス値:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル\n- 抽出基準:受注日基準・基準日2026-09-11(直近6ヶ月)\n- 規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・LF・RFC4180準拠・日付YYYY-MM-DD・更新日≧受注日・全項目カンマ/引用符不含・自由記述除外\n\n【成果物①CSVサンプル(架空3行)】\n```\n受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\nORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了\nORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済\nORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定\n```\n\n【成果物②項目定義書(抜粋)】上記決定事項の通り。項目名・順序・抽出基準・基準日・出力規約を明記済み。\n\n【検査結果(ナギ)】①ヘッダ名・順序一致 ②総行数4行 ③連番・重複欠番なし ④日付形式・整合OK ⑤金額=数量×単価成立 ⑥カンマ・引用符なし・ステータス値範囲内 — 全項目OK、受入条件満たしています。了承のうえご報告します。レビューとレンさんへの報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "08f0f41c-1d4b-4043-b817-2e980e9a8075", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "f3efc544-8240-41bc-8cd7-3e7336ed04e2", + "groupId": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185914402, + "text": "マコ(開発部・品質担当)より依頼です。CSV初期公開(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)の検査表作成を依頼します。\n\n【決定事項(開発部確定)】\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む、変更は第2弾扱い)\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日を定義書に明記\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数の一致、ヘッダの項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記)\n\n【依頼成果物】検査表(QA観点、上記受入条件④を全て含むこと。形式・文字コード・日付形式等の規約検査項目も含めてください)\n\n【進め方】そちらのチームでも同じ手順で:議論(懸念→修正案→回答の2巡)→決定→分担→実行→報告。実データ・コード変更不要の架空案件のみ。完了後、結果を私(マコ)へ返してください。レビューの上、レンへ報告します。", + "result": "マコさん、両担当の成果が揃いました。私が規約検査・受入検査パートを作成し、4部構成で統合します。\n\n## CSV初期公開 検査表(統合版・2026-09-12)\n\n### 第1部 規約検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| R-1 | 文字コード | 生成されたCSVファイルをバイナリ確認 | UTF-8(BOM付き)。先頭3バイト=EF BB BF |\n| R-2 | 日付形式 | 受注日・更新日フィールド全件を確認 | YYYY-MM-DD形式(例:2026-03-01)。区切り記号・桁数の違反なし |\n| R-3 | 日付妥当性 | 各日付値の実在性を確認 | 存在しない日付(2/30等)なし。閏年2/29は正しく処理(2024-02-29は有効、2025-02-29は無効として検出) |\n| R-4 | 改行コード | 全行末尾を確認 | LF(0x0A)。CR・CRLF混入なし |\n| R-5 | RFC4180準拠 | カンマ・改行を含む値、空値を含むデータで生成 | 値はダブルクォートで適切に囲まれる。フィールド数=12で全行一致 |\n| R-6 | 項目数 | ヘッダと全データ行の項目数を確認 | 常に12項目(自由記述項目は除外済み) |\n\n### 第2部 受入検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| A-1 | 行数一致 | 任意の抽出条件で生成し、データ件数と総行数を突合 | ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数で一致 |\n| A-2 | ヘッダ一致 | 生成CSVのヘッダ行を定義書と照合 | 項目名・順序とも定義書と完全一致(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む) |\n| A-3 | 受注番号一意性 | 全データ行の受注番号を集計 | 重複なし・欠番なし(連続性は定義書の番号規則に従う) |\n| A-4 | 失敗時の扱い | 生成失敗を発生させる | 中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告。**報告先:マコ/再開判断者:レオ(QAリーダー)** を検査表通り1行明記 |\n\n### 第3部 境界値検査(担当:メイ)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 0件ケース | 抽出期間内に該当データ0件で生成 | ヘッダ1行のみ。総行数=1で行数一致。エラーなく正常終了 |\n| B-2 | 期間前日(境界外) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日の前日のデータ1件のみ | 出力されない(ヘッダのみ) |\n| B-3 | 期間初日(境界内) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日のデータ1件 | 1件出力。総行数=2 |\n| B-4 | 期間末日(境界内) | 受注日=基準日当日のデータ1件 | 1件出力(基準日を含む設定の確認) |\n| B-5 | 期間翌日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日翌日のデータ1件(未来日) | 出力されない。出力されれば定義書と不整合として報告 |\n| B-6 | 上限ちょうど | 期間内データ=上限件数(仮:100,000件)ちょうど | 全件出力。総行数=100,001。重複・欠番なし。警告なし |\n| B-7 | 上限超過 | 期間内データ=上限+1件(100,001件) | 定義書規定どおり(全件出力+警告記録、または打ち切り)。規定値を検査表に明記のうえ確認 |\n\n### 第4部 異常系検査(担当:ハル)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 | 再開判断者 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 生成開始後(スナップショット確定後)に抽出期間内データへ追加・削除・更新が発生 | 件数・内容は基準日時スナップショットで固定、変動は反映されない。行数一致。変動反映時は中断しマコへ報告 | レオ |\n| E-2 | 途中失敗 | 生成途中(例:10万件中3万件書き込み済み)でDB接続断等の障害 | 部分ファイル出力継続禁止。不完全CSVは破棄/隔離し、中断しマコへ報告。エラー位置・時刻・件数を記録。再開は指示後に最初からやり直す | レオ |\n| E-3 | 権限なし | 権限のない実行者が生成を実行 | アクセス拒否、ファイル出力なし。中断しレオへ報告。権限付与/実行者変更後に再実行(無権限の再試行禁止) | レオ |\n\n---\n\n【取りまとめメモ(マコさんへの確認事項)】\n1. **上限件数の実値**(B-6/B-7は100,000件で仮置き)→定義書確定値をご提示ください\n2. **基準日の含む/含まない**(B-2〜B-5は「6ヶ月前同日を含み・基準日当日を含む」設定例)→定義書記載値をご確認ください\n3. **報告先・再開判断者**(A-4/E-1〜E-3は報告先マコ・再開判断者レオで仮置き)→正式値をご指示ください\n\n以上、QAチームとして検査表を完成させました。レビューのうえレンさんへの報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "3e4e3a6f-e7b8-4ab4-90f0-db12c12e7ed6", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "7d77da5a-5016-47be-ad2d-348779043e11", + "groupId": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "2b7d1a74-d264-44d3-99b4-7c2f897d4094", + "5806e3c6-b7a9-4b7c-8d26-d9f5f73a8021" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185922252, + "text": "リツ氏より依頼:架空CSV(営業必須12項目、受注番号・受注日・更新日含む、残り9項目は自席で提案)と項目定義書の作成。懸念と9項目の具体案を出してください。私案:残り9項目=顧客名・顧客コード・担当者名・部署・商品名・数量・単価・金額・ステータス。基準日2026-09-11(受注日基準・直近6ヶ月)。各250字程度で前の人の意見への賛否も。", + "result": "ヒナ: @ソラ 私は私案の9項目に賛成です。受注番号・受注日・更新日に、顧客名・顧客コード・担当者名・部署・商品名・数量・単価・金額・ステータスを加える構成は、営業が確認したい「誰が・何を・いくらで・どこまで進んでいるか」を過不足なくCoverしています。順序は「識別→顧客→担当→商品→金額→状況」の流れが自然です。懸念は2点。①数量・単価・金額の型定義(整数か小数か、金額=数量×単価の整合を検証可能に)。②ステータスの取り得る値(例:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル)を定義書で列挙し、ナギさんの検査と一致させたい。です。\n\nナギ: @ソラ @ヒナ ヒナさんの9項目賛成に私も同意します。検証担当の立場からは、ヒナさん挙げの2懸念がまさに検査項目になるので重要です。追加の懸念は①受注番号の書式(例:ORD-000001の連番)を定義書で固定してほしい。重複・欠番なしの検査は書式が決まらないと機械的にできません。②更新日≧受注日の整合チェック、③顧客名・商品名にカンマや引用符を含めない(自由記述除外規約と整合。ただし検証用に1行だけ引用符入りを仕込む案もあり得ますが、リツ氏規約優先で入れない方が安全)。ステータス値の列挙に賛成。数量=整数、単価・金額=整数(円)で金額=数量×単価の検査を可能に。" + }, + { + "id": "21a71e6a-51e7-45a9-be25-579ab1760341", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "08f0f41c-1d4b-4043-b817-2e980e9a8075", + "groupId": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "8ce8bad3-e9ed-4708-b170-d03076932825", + "6033e190-9e6c-4404-b406-aad35ef23f08" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185936135, + "text": "CSV初期公開の検査表作成について。決定事項は①12項目固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須)②UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書明記④受入条件(行数一致・ヘッダ一致・受注番号重複/欠番なし・失敗時は中断・報告先と再開判断者を1行明記)。検査表の構成案:私は「規約検査(文字コード・日付形式・改行・RFC4180)」+「受入検査(④全部)」+「境界(6ヶ月範囲の初日・末日)」の3部構成を提案。メイは境界観点、ハルは異常系観点で、それぞれ懸念と具体的な改善案を述べてください。全員の発言が揃ったら私が決定します。", + "result": "メイ: メイ: 境界値観点で意見します。3部構成に賛成です。ただし「6ヶ月範囲の初日・末日」だけでは不十分という懸念があります。改善案:①境界日の扱いを「基準日を含む/含まない」まで明記(例:基準日から起算して6ヶ月前の同日を含む、当日は含まない等)②受注日の境界付近データ(前日・当日・6ヶ月前日・その前日)の4点を検査行として明示③件数0件(該当データなし)も境界ケースとして追加。また日付の妥当性(存在しない日付・閏年2/29)も規約検査に入れるべきです。ご検討ください。\n\nハル: ハル: 異常系観点で意見します。3部構成に賛成、メイさんの0件・日付妥当性の追加も支持します。懸念は「失敗時は中断・報告」の中身が未定義な点です。改善案:①第4部「異常系検査」として、生成中に件数が変化(追加/削除)した場合の期待結果(基準日時点のスナップショットで件数固定、変動を反映しない)を明記②途中失敗時の検査行(部分ファイルの出力継続禁止・再開判断者欄付き)③検査実行者の権限なし(アクセス拒否)場合の報告フロー確認。期待結果は「中断し○○へ報告」と具体化するのが良いです。" + }, + { + "id": "ba01f9f7-fa3c-419c-a0ad-e79cfd04068a", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "7d77da5a-5016-47be-ad2d-348779043e11", + "groupId": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "botId": "2b7d1a74-d264-44d3-99b4-7c2f897d4094", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185979960, + "text": "決定に基づきCSV作成を依頼します。ヘッダ1行+架空データ3行(受注日は2026-03-12以降2026-09-11以前)。項目順:受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス。受注番号=ORD-000001からの連番。数量・単価・金額=整数で金額=数量×単価。ステータスは確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセルから。更新日≧受注日。全項目にカンマ・引用符を含めない。CSV本文を最終応答に提示してください。", + "result": "@ソラ CSV作成しました。決定事項(項目順・連番・整数整合・ステータス値・日付整合・カンマ/引用符不含)すべて確認済みです。ナギさんの検査をお願いします。\n\n```\n受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\nORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了\nORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済\nORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定\n```" + }, + { + "id": "52664da2-7107-4546-92d9-3b0571a2e7f7", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "7d77da5a-5016-47be-ad2d-348779043e11", + "groupId": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "threadId": "f93bc560-3163-4b92-88b9-6df5cdd6ba0b", + "botId": "5806e3c6-b7a9-4b7c-8d26-d9f5f73a8021", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789185980904, + "text": "決定に基づき検査表作成を依頼します。ヒナが本ルームで提示するCSV本文を読み、検査表を作成してください。検査項目:①ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義通り(受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス)②総行数=ヘッダ1+データ3③受注番号ORD-000001からの連番・重複欠番なし④日付YYYY-MM-DD・更新日≧受注日⑤数量・単価・金額が整数で金額=数量×単価⑥全項目にカンマ・引用符なし。各項目OK/NGと所見を表で最終応答に提示してください。", + "result": "@ソラ ヒナさんのCSVを読み、検査しました。結果は以下の通りです。全項目OKです。\n\n| 検査項目 | 判定 | 所見 |\n|---|---|---|\n| ①ヘッダ項目名・順序 | OK | 12項目が定義通りの名称・順序で完全一致 |\n| ②総行数 | OK | ヘッダ1+データ3=4行、過不足なし |\n| ③受注番号連番 | OK | ORD-000001〜000003、重複・欠番なし、書式ORD-xxxxxx通り |\n| ④日付整合 | OK | すべてYYYY-MM-DD形式。更新日≧受注日を3行とも満たす(行2は同日)。受注日は2026-03-12以降・2026-09-11以前で基準日範囲内 |\n| ⑤数値整合 | OK | 数量・単価・金額すべて整数。10×98000=980000、5×45000=225000、20×32000=640000、すべて金額=数量×単価成立 |\n| ⑥区切り文字等 | OK | 全項目にカンマ(区切り以外)・引用符なし。ステータスは定義済み4値(完了/出荷済/確定)の範囲内 |\n\n補足:顧客コード・部署も書式・表記のぶれなし。検証用の引用符入り行もなし(決定通り)。成果を了承します。取りまとめよろしくお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "5624fb69-9d98-40f7-8ed3-d75ace54ccfa", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "08f0f41c-1d4b-4043-b817-2e980e9a8075", + "groupId": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "botId": "8ce8bad3-e9ed-4708-b170-d03076932825", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789186006216, + "text": "決定に基づき分担を割り当てます。メイさんは境界値担当として検査表(境界値検査パート)を作成してください。0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表。全行に「入力条件」と「期待結果」を必ず記載。決定済み事項(4部構成・境界付近4点の検査行化・0件ケース追加)を踏まえ、議論はやり直さず作成のみお願いします。", + "result": "メイ: 担当割り当てを受け、境界値検査パートの検査表を作成しました。決定事項(境界付近4点の検査行化・0件ケース追加)を踏まえています。\n\n## 境界値検査パート(担当日付:2026-09-12)\n\n前提:抽出基準は受注日基準、直近6ヶ月分。基準日の「含む/含まない」は定義書確認メモに従う(下表は基準日を含み、6ヶ月前同日を含む設定の例)。\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 0件ケース | 抽出期間内に該当データが0件の状態でCSV生成を実行 | ヘッダ1行のみ出力(データ0行)。総行数=1で行数一致。エラーを出さず正常終了 |\n| B-2 | 期間前日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日の6ヶ月前同日の前日(期間外)のデータ1件のみ | 該当データは出力されない(0件扱い、ヘッダのみ) |\n| B-3 | 期間初日(境界内) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日(期間内)のデータ1件 | 当該1件が出力される。ヘッダ1+データ1=総行数2 |\n| B-4 | 期間末日(境界内) | 受注日=基準日当日のデータ1件 | 当該1件が出力される(当日を含む設定の確認) |\n| B-5 | 期間翌日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日の翌日のデータ1件(未来日) | 出力されない。出力されていたら定義書の含む/含まない記載と不整合として報告 |\n| B-6 | 上限ちょうど | 抽出期間内データが上限件数(仮定:100,000件)ちょうど | 全件出力。ヘッダ1+100,000=総行数100,001。受注番号の重複・欠番なし。打ち切り警告なし |\n| B-7 | 上限超過 | 抽出期間内データが上限+1件(100,001件) | 事前定義どおりの挙動:全件出力かつ上限超過の警告記録、または定義書通り打ち切り(いずれか定義書に一致)。期待結果は定義書の規定値を検査表に明記して確認 |\n\n※B-6/B-7の上限値は仮置き(100,000件)。実上限を開発部の定義書で確認のうえ確定します。\n\nレオさん、境界値パート完成です。規約・受入パートと統合してください。上限値の実数確認を取りまとめ時にお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "71858542-ccde-4e48-bfc2-24e5e3b363fb", + "rootId": "12235f29-3205-4b18-ae75-4d52714fa64a", + "parentId": "08f0f41c-1d4b-4043-b817-2e980e9a8075", + "groupId": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "threadId": "29e2b33b-0eab-4c40-acf3-3598f55e6976", + "botId": "6033e190-9e6c-4404-b406-aad35ef23f08", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789186006809, + "text": "決定に基づき分担を割り当てます。ハルさんは異常系担当として検査表(異常系検査パート)を作成してください。生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表。全行に「入力条件」と「期待結果」を必ず記載し、期待結果は「中断し○○へ報告」形式で具体化。決定済み事項(スナップショット固定・部分ファイル出力禁止・再開判断者欄付き)を踏まえ、議論はやり直さず作成のみお願いします。", + "result": "ハル: 担当割り当てを受け、異常系検査パートを作成しました。決定事項(スナップショット固定・部分ファイル出力禁止・再開判断者欄)を踏まえています。\n\n## 異常系検査パート(担当日付:2026-09-12)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 | 再開判断者 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | CSV生成開始後(基準日時スナップショット確定後)に、抽出期間内の受注データへ追加・削除・更新が発生する | 件数・内容は基準日時のスナップショットで固定され、変動は一切反映されない。出力件数=スナップショット件数で行数一致。変動反映が確認された場合は中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告 | レオ |\n| E-2 | 途中失敗 | CSV生成処理の途中(例:全10万件中3万件書き込み済み)でDB接続断等の障害が発生する | 部分ファイルの出力継続は禁止。不完全なCSVは破棄(または隔離)し、中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告。エラー発生位置・時刻・対象件数を記録。再開は再開判断者の指示後に最初からやり直す(途中再開しない) | レオ |\n| E-3 | 権限なし | CSV生成権限を持たない検査実行者が生成を実行する | アクセス拒否されファイルは出力されない。中断し検査責任者(レオ)へ報告。権限付与または実行者変更の判断を待って再実行(無権限のままの再試行禁止) | レオ |\n\n※報告先・再開判断者は仮置き。取りまとめ時に開発部の定義書で正式な報告先を確認のうえ確定してください。\n\nレオさん、異常系パート完成です。規約・受入・境界値パートと統合をお願いします。" + } + ], + "transcripts": [ + { + "name": "経営会議", + "id": "4e0d28a9-b52e-43f5-bf01-622588a6acb9", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "9f3d98ea-d632-40c2-a878-d4b937913527", + "at": 1789185573089, + "role": "user", + "text": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をassign_room_memberで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。" + }, + { + "id": "e930d5aa-ef61-47c3-bb1b-feb2e4110662", + "at": 1789185586238, + "role": "bot", + "text": "かしこまりました。経営会議を始めます。まず議論メンバーのIDを確認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "be61adda-7760-4123-be82-ea6bde47894f", + "at": 1789185592544, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論1巡目を開始します。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "ea32bfba-3a6d-45c5-b382-55ea90cfcf4a", + "at": 1789185600429, + "role": "bot", + "text": "私の仮案を提示して1巡目を始めました。\n\n**仮案**：CSV出力は全項目・全件を出力する。網羅性が高く後戻り不要だが、公開まで時間がかかる恐れあり。\n\nアオイさん(対象限定で早期公開)、ユイさん(営業必須項目)のご意見をお聞きし、修正案を出して2巡目で再検討します。ご意見どうぞ。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "ead5913c-5e3e-4090-ac42-a2ed3205d86a", + "at": 1789185600641, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\nCSV出力の初期対象について1巡目議論。仮案は「全項目・全件出力」。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定を主張、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求の予定。各自、仮案への賛否と自案の理由、相手案への懸念を述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "53cfe0dc-1951-4f18-9dbc-681eeb2cba18", + "at": 1789185612339, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 1巡目のご意見です。\n\n仮案「全項目・全件出力」には反対です。開発側の懸念は、①項目定義の整備と全件テストで公開が数週間遅れる、②利用者が本当に必要な項目が埋もれ使いにくくなる、③初期瑕疵の影響範囲が最大になる点です。\n\n自案は「基本項目(顧客名・日付・金額・ステータス等)限定＋直近3ヶ月分」でまず公開し、反応を見て段階拡張します。初期公開は2週間以内を実現したい。\n\nユイさんの営業必須項目の要求は理解できますが、項目が増えるほど公開が遅くなる懸念があります。必須上位10項目程度に絞り、不足分は第2弾で追加する形で調整したいです。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "3e5f8712-fa00-4735-af89-e31e6bac132c", + "at": 1789185622786, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト @アオイ 1巡目のご意見です。\n仮案「全項目・全件」には賛成しかねます。営業現場では顧客名・案件名・金額・担当・ステータス・受注日などの必須項目が揃わないCSVは実用になりませんが、全件出力は作業が重く公開が遅れる点、不要な内部項目まで出る情報管理上の懸念もあります。\n自案は「営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月分」です。商談履歴の遡りは6ヶ月必要で、3ヶ月では期中分析に使えません。\nアオイ案への懸念は、①基本項目の定義が開発側恣意になり営業視点が欠ける、②3ヶ月では実務に耐えない点です。妥協としては「必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月、第2弾で拡張」まで譲れます。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "0db7f070-4234-47bd-add9-9679a38c5512", + "at": 1789185633104, + "role": "bot", + "text": "1巡目の両案を受け、修正案を出して2巡目にかけます。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "00349c92-9f0e-405e-a45a-ddf39ad46b9f", + "at": 1789185652550, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【2巡目・議長修正案】@アオイ @ユイ\n\n1巡目の意見を踏まえ、仮案「全項目・全件出力」は**取り下げ**、修正案を提示します。\n\n**修正案**：\n- 初期公開は「営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月分」\n- 公開目標は3週間以内(アオイさんの早期公開重視を反映)\n- 12項目の定義はアオイ・ユイ合同で確定し、営業視点と開発実装性の両立を図る\n- 全項目・全件は第2弾で拡張\n\nアオイさんは公開期間、ユイさんは項目内容が受け入れ可能か、それぞれ回答してください。この結果で最終決定します。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "0785dd58-d622-4c53-9c8b-41b3085d76e2", + "at": 1789185652833, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n2巡目議論:CSV出力の初期対象。議長修正案は「営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月分」を初期公開とし、開発の早期公開目標(3週間以内)を前提に、項目定義をアオイ・ユイ合同で確定、全件・全項目は第2弾拡張とする。アオイの「公開遅延」懸念には期間3週間、ユイの「6ヶ月必要性」は取り込み済み。両名、この修正案への賛否と改善があれば回答してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "fc29ce9a-b907-49e4-b804-e07c14277a7a", + "at": 1789185689434, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 2巡目のご意見です。\n\n修正案に**賛成**です。12項目＋直近6ヶ月という限定により、項目定義とテスト範囲が絞られ、3週間以内の公開は開発側として十分現実的です。私の「公開遅延」懸念は解消されました。\n\n改善要望を2点だけです。\n①12項目の合同確定は今週中に完了させ、確定が遅れた場合は公開目標を優先し、未確定項目は第2弾へ繰り越す、という逃げ道を明記してほしい。\n③項目定義にはCSVの出力形式(文字コードUTF-8、日付形式、エスケープ規約)も併せて固定し、後日の仕様変更による手戻りを防ぎたい。\n\nこの2点が入れば開発として確定・着手します。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "db13cafc-b4d0-43ed-8a40-a47485a3163a", + "at": 1789185700618, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト @アオイ 2巡目のご意見です。\n修正案に**賛成**です。営業必須12項目＋直近6ヶ月が初期公開に組み込まれたことで、期中分析にも耐えられる実用範囲が確保されました。3週間以内の公開目標も営業として歓迎します。\nアオイさんの2点の改善要望にも同意します。特にUTF-8・日付形式の固定は営業側のExcelでの文字化け防止にも効くので賛成です。追加要望は1点だけで、12項目の合同確定に際しては「受注日・更新日」の2つを必ず含めてほしいです。商談の鮮度判定に必須のため。この点を条件に確定・着手で問題ありません。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "dd14e494-1ea0-4368-8005-5962c1e1908f", + "at": 1789185708770, + "role": "bot", + "text": "2巡目の結果、両名とも修正案に賛成です。決定を確定し、分担へ移ります。まずメンバーIDを確認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "c26e4382-1abf-49e8-a721-dec18958608b", + "at": 1789185724915, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【経営会議・最終決定】\n\n2巡目でアオイ・ユイ両名が修正案に賛成したため、以下の通り決定しました。\n\n- **初期公開**:営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を含む)＋直近6ヶ月分\n- **公開目標**:3週間以内\n- **項目定義**:今週中にアオイ・ユイ合同確定。遅延時は公開優先、未確定項目は第2弾繰越\n- **形式**:UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約を定義に固定(アオイ要望・ユイ同意)\n- **第2弾**:全項目・全件へ拡張\n\n分担を割り当てました:\n- アオイ→開発部レンへ依頼(開発部で2巡議論後、リツ→ソラ、マコ→レオへ展開、架空CSVサンプル・検査表作成)\n- ユイ→営業部コウへ依頼(1巡議論後、サキ・トワへFAQ・チェックリスト等作成分担)\n\n両名の報告を受けたら経営会議で統合し、結果をお知らせします。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "6844419f-5ec5-4888-a4a5-f96dabd3731d", + "at": 1789185725052, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ 議長ミナト。2巡目の両名賛成を受け、方針を最終決定しました。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中にユイと合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。出力形式(UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約)を定義に固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\nあなたの担当:開発部レン(group_id=15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c, bot_id=26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2)へsend_room_messageで依頼。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼するよう伝達。成果物は架空CSVサンプル・検査表等。結果をレビューして私へ報告してください。実データ・コード変更不要。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "ee367877-4f1a-41f7-aa36-bcaff3be4e79", + "at": 1789185732145, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 承知しました。開発部レンへ依頼します。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "7765b992-c639-4105-b61e-d22103a78fe2", + "at": 1789185741781, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 開発部レンへ依頼を送信しました。経営会議の決定内容(12項目・6ヶ月分・3週間目標・形式固定)と、開発部での2巡議論→リツ/マコからのソラ/レオへの展開、成果物(架空CSVサンプル・検査表)を指定済みです。結果が返り次第レビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "cf9e7f7e-3d25-4136-9755-3d4c69c209a7", + "at": 1789185742040, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ユイ 議長ミナト。2巡目の両名賛成を受け、方針を最終決定しました。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む、あなたの条件を反映)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中にアオイと合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\nあなたの担当:営業部コウ(group_id=a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4, bot_id=5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a)へsend_room_messageで依頼。営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバー(サキ・トワ)へ成果物作成(FAQ・チェックリスト等)を分担するよう伝達。結果をレビューして私へ報告してください。実データ・コード変更不要。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "c0813aa3-1dfb-4f0a-973b-5d125cfb20b8", + "at": 1789185752062, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 承知しました。営業部コウへ依頼を送信します。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "129ce234-0e56-436b-b7fc-22b56e893740", + "at": 1789185760919, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 営業部コウへ依頼を送信しました。決定内容(12項目・6ヶ月分・3週間目標・形式固定)と、営業部で1巡議論後にサキ・トワへFAQ・チェックリスト等の作成分担を伝達済みです。結果が返り次第レビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "d956c72a-7319-4c6f-b211-f369eeac96e0", + "at": 1789185873037, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ユイ\n\n両者の成果物をレビューしました。いずれも決定方針を忠実に反映しており、そのまま採用します。\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- サキさんFAQ3問:12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、「文字化けしない形式」の平易な表現、拡張は時期未確定、社外持ち出しルール1行明記——すべて反映済み。Q3で持ち出しルールに軽く触れているのも適切。✅採用\n- トワさんチェックリスト5項目:端末・保存先限定、用途ログ、転送禁止、更新日チェック、社外持ち出し禁止+事前承認+30日削除——すべて反映済み。取得管理台の削除欄記入まで盛り込まれ、運用として実行可能。✅採用\n\n**ユイさんへの報告**\n\n営業部の準備が完了しました。経営会議決定(12項目+6ヶ月、UTF-8等規約固定、第2弾拡張)を受け、サキ・トワと1巡議論のうえ方針を決定し、以下の2成果物を作成・レビュー済みです。\n\n1. 顧客向けFAQ3問(サキ作成):内容・鮮度判断・拡張見込みを平易に説明\n2. 社内操作チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成):持出し制限・用途ログ・転送禁止・削除まで規定\n\n議論で追加採用したのは「説明資料1枚化」「更新日で鮮度判断」「拡張は時期未確定と正直に伝える」「持出し端末・保存先限定と転送禁止」「取得時用途ログ」です。公開目標3週間以内に向け利用可能です。ミナト様への報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "c3ac2020-e5ff-4b2d-a9d4-23cc75d28b1e", + "at": 1789185884459, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 営業担当ユイ、コウからの返却結果をレビューしました。**そのまま受け入れ、承認します。**\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- FAQ3問(サキ作成):12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、文字化けしない形式の平易な表現、拡張は時期未確定と正直に記載——決定方針どおり。✅\n- チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成):端末・保存先限定、用途ログ、転送禁止、更新日チェック、社外持ち出し禁止+事前承認+30日削除まで規定。取得管理台の削除欄記入もあり運用可能。✅\n\n私の条件(受注日・更新日の確保、Excel文字化け防止の形式固定)も満たされています。\n\n**ミナト様への報告**\n営業部の公開準備が完了しました。決定(12項目・6ヶ月・3週間目標・形式固定)に基づき、①顧客向けFAQ3問 ②社内操作チェックリスト5項目 を作成・レビュー済みで、公開可能な状態です。経営会議での統合をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "021d575a-cd0a-4e81-a63a-a1064e5954fd", + "at": 1789186100848, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ\n\nリツ・マコ両担当分の報告を受領し、レビュー済みです。両名のレビュー判断を了承し、開発部として取りまとめます。\n\n【開発部 取りまとめ(アオイ宛て報告)】\n経営会議決定(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)に対し、部内で2巡の議論→決定→分担→実行→レビューを完了しました。\n\n■決定事項\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む)。変更は第2弾扱い。\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外。\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日2026-09-11を定義書に明記。\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先・再開判断者=レン)。\n\n■成果物\n1. 架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行、12項目)…実装チーム(ソラ)作成、リツレビュー済み。総行数・連番・6ヶ月範囲・金額=数量×単価・規約を全て確認し受入条件満たす。\n2. 検査表(規約・受入・境界値・異常系の4部構成)…QAチーム(レオ)作成、マコレビュー済み。0件・6ヶ月境界・上限件数・途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄まで網羅。レビューで報告先・再開判断者を正式値(レン)に差し替え済み。上限件数は初回未規定(超過時は全件出力+警告、第2弾で正式規定)。\n\n■スケジュール\n12項目は本日確定済みのため、公開目標3週間以内に対し十分余力あり。\n\n両成果物とも受入条件を満たすと判断し、開発部として了承・完了とします。以上、アオイさんのレビューをお願いします。ミナトさんへの報告よろしくお願いいたします。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "19c70d0c-7ba9-417d-820e-a50ddc589507", + "at": 1789186112410, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 開発担当アオイ、開発部レンからの取りまとめをレビューしました。**そのまま受け入れ、承認します。**\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- 架空CSVサンプル(ソラ作成・リツレビュー済み):12項目固定、受注番号の重複欠番なし、金額=数量×単価、6ヶ月範囲、UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠——経営会議決定と形式固定要望を全て満たす。✅\n- 検査表(レオ作成・マコレビュー済み):0件・6ヶ月境界・途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄まで網羅。上限件数は初回未規定(超過時は全件出力+警告、第2弾で規定)は合理的。✅\n\n私の要望(公開遅延回避、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約の固定)とユイさんの条件(受注日・更新日必須、Excel文字化け防止のBOM付き)も反映済みです。\n\n**ミナトさんへの報告**\n開発部の公開準備が完了しました。決定(12項目・直近6ヶ月分・3週間目標)に基づき、①架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行) ②検査表(4部構成) を作成・レビュー済みで、公開可能な状態です。12項目は本日確定済みのため3週間目標に余力あり。経営会議での統合(ユイさん担当の営業部FAQ・チェックリストと合わせ)をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a28aa3de-f472-4a98-8bed-b7c62ec30983", + "at": 1789186124108, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【経営会議・統合報告】CSV出力の公開準備が完了しました。\n\n**決定事項(再掲)**\n初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。形式はUTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠で固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n**各部門の成果**\n- 開発部(アオイ→レン、リツ/マコ→ソラ/レオ):①架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行、12項目)②検査表(規約・受入・境界値・異常系の4部構成)。受注番号重複欠番なし、金額整合、0件・境界・途中失敗時の部分破棄まで網羅。\n- 営業部(ユイ→コウ、サキ/トワ):①顧客向けFAQ3問(鮮度判断・拡張見込みを平易に説明)②社内操作チェックリスト5項目(持出し制限・用途ログ・転送禁止・30日削除)。\n\n**統合判断**\n両担当のレビュー結果を私が受領し、いずれも決定方針・条件(受注日・更新日確保、文字化け防止、公開遅延回避)を満たしていることを確認しました。開発・営業両成果物を**採用**し、公開準備完了として経営会議の取りまとめを終了します。12項目は確定済みのため、3週間目標には十分余力があります。ご指示ありがとうございました。", + "from": { + "botId": "fe124043-e68a-486f-8e0d-8acc0658aa44", + "name": "ミナト" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "開発部", + "id": "15eb1e75-4db8-4ba0-ad30-01db1416eb5c", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "c296105b-483e-40af-9e16-44a9d2bea88d", + "at": 1789185742046, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 経営会議決定に基づく依頼です(アオイより)。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中に確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。出力形式(UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約)を定義に固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n【進め方】開発部でも議論→決定→分担→実行→報告の手順を同じ形で実施してください。既存メンバーで2巡議論(1巡目は懸念、責任者修正案、2巡目で回答)を行い、決定後にリツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへsend_room_messageで依頼してください。宛先IDはlist_room_targetsで確認を。最下層は1巡議論後に各メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。\n\n【成果物】実データ・コード変更不要の架空データで、①架空CSVサンプル(12項目・6ヶ月分数行)②検査表(QA観点)、その他必要なら項目定義書。完了後、結果を私(アオイ)へ返してください。レビューの上、ミナトへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "1d7fcd29-c6d3-4e61-8a64-9ed1a38f5225", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "2b4d6099-7317-4b56-9bf9-3e8bb8725a2e", + "at": 1789185752544, + "role": "bot", + "text": "アオイより経営決定を受領しました。まず部内で1巡目の議論(懸念出し)から始めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "afe3a4a0-6f5b-4f3e-97c9-a8e84720df1a", + "at": 1789185769429, + "role": "bot", + "text": "アオイ受領分を部内共有しました。修正案:①12項目の仮候補(受注日・更新日含む)を私が提示し部内確定、②出力規約はUTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・エスケープはRFC4180準拠で固定、③成果物は架空CSVサンプル(6ヶ月分数行)+検査表+項目定義書。1巡目の懸判明を待ちます。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "361c2352-a521-4b41-9fd9-2a9a52fe3b58", + "at": 1789185769474, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\nCSV初期公開(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)の件。論点は①12項目のCSV設計(受注日・更新日必須、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約を定義に固定)②検査表の受入条件。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で、1巡目として懸念を述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "252d213a-ea01-40d8-9b3a-ab7012f152f9", + "at": 1789185780923, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 1巡目、処理の簡素さの観点で懸念です。\n\n①12項目の確定が部内合意だと項目増減のたびCSV・検査表の両方再作成になり手戻りが大きい。仮案の12項目を今週中に固定し、以降の変更は第2弾扱いにしてほしい。\n\n②BOM付きUTF-8はExcel開封便利な反面、一部パーサで先頭1文字化けの事故が起きやすい。対象が営業側のExcel利用中心ならBOM付きで統一し、定義書に明記で良いと思います。\n\n③エスケープはRFC4180準拠で良いが、カンマ・改行を含む項目(備考等)を初期12項目に入れると検査が複雑化する。初期は自由記述項目を避け、改行コードはLFに統一を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "143d9755-38f6-439a-8e8a-837ad4e049a1", + "at": 1789185792503, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 1巡目、途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で懸念です。\n\n①6ヶ月分の抽出で途中失敗すると、部分的なCSVが完成品と誤認される危険があります。件数を事前確認し、ヘッダ1+データ件数の合計を行数として検査表の受入条件に明記すべきです。\n\n②受注日基準か更新日基準かで6ヶ月範囲の対象件数が変わります。定義書で抽出基準日と基準日を固定し、件数が変わらない根拠を検査で確認できる形にしてください。\n\n③架空データとはいえ、途中で行が重複や欠落すると検知が難しい。受注番号等の一意キーを12項目に含め、重複なし・欠番なしを受入条件に加える提案です。\n\n④文字コード・改行の事故はリツさん指摘と同じで、失敗時に再作成ではなく中断・報告の手順を検査表に定義しておきたいです。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "6cace2d9-87a7-4791-8f34-6f640060ee2a", + "at": 1789185804433, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ @マコ 1巡目の懸念、受け取りました。修正案を提示します。\n\n【修正案】\n①12項目は今週中に部内固定(受注番号を受注日・更新日に加え一意キーとして含む)。以降の変更は第2弾扱い。\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き、Excel中心のため)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠。初期12項目から自由記述(備考等)を外し、カンマ・改行混入を構造的に回避。\n③抽出基準は受注日基準で固定し、基準日を定義書に明記。\n④検査表の受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数の一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は再作成でなく中断・報告。\n\n2巡目として、この修正案への回答を各自お願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "53759285-bd4d-4411-a4ae-f0f0a7732067", + "at": 1789185820993, + "role": "bot", + "text": "2巡目の議論を開始しました。修正案(①受注番号を含む12項目を今週固定・変更は第2弾、②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外、③受注日基準で基準日固定、④受入条件=総行数一致・重複欠番なし・失敗時中断報告)への両名の回答を待ち、確定後に分担へ進めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "99fb8b23-6eb8-4c6d-82ca-736d935d12e7", + "at": 1789185821185, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n2巡目:レン修正案(①受注番号含む12項目を今週固定・第2弾運用②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述項目除外③受注日基準で基準日固定④受入条件=総行数一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時中断報告)への回答を各自述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "66c362d2-212f-49bb-9a2b-01a8730c1d09", + "at": 1789185832272, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 2巡目、処理の簡素さの観点から修正案に回答します。\n\n①項目の今週固定・第2弾運用:賛成。手戻りが構造的に抑えられ、作成・検査の両手順が単純化されます。\n\n②規約一式:賛成。自由記述除外でカンマ・改行のエスケープ処理が不要になり、検査も文字種確認だけで済みます。\n\n③受注日基準・基準日固定:賛成。抽出条件が1つで済み、CSV作成側も検査側も同じ前提で確認できます。\n\n④受入条件:賛成。追加要望として、12項目の確定項目名を定義書に列挙し、ヘッダ行の項目名・順序一致も受入条件に加えていただけると、検査表が機械的に回せます。\n\n修正案全体で合意です。", + "from": { + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "2ad0212a-99c1-4706-a3c2-ec4f6255864c", + "at": 1789185843205, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 2巡目、途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点から修正案に回答します。\n\n①受注番号含む12項目の今週固定・第2弾運用：賛成。一意キー確定で重複・欠落検知が最初から組み込めます。\n\n②規約一式：賛成。BOM・LF・日付形式の固定と自由記述除外で、件数・行数検査が文字種事故に汚染されなくなります。\n\n③受注日基準・基準日固定：賛成。基準日を定義書に明記すれば、検査側が抽出前提を再現でき、件数変化の根拠確認が可能です。\n\n④受入条件：賛成。リツさんの追加要望(ヘッダの項目名・順序一致)にも同意します。加えて、中断・報告時の報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記していただけると、失敗時の宙ぶらりんを防げます。\n\n修正案全体で合意です。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "dfe3e2a5-274d-40d1-8b36-9e54a145590e", + "at": 1789185857641, + "role": "bot", + "text": "2巡目の議論が完了し、両名とも修正案に合意しました。追加要望(ヘッダ項目名・順序一致の受入条件化、中断時の報告先と再開判断者の明記)も妥当なので採用し、以下の通り決定します。\n\n【決定】\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む)。変更は第2弾扱い。\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外。\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日を定義書に明記。\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダの項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先レン、再開判断者レンを検査表に1行明記)。\n\nこれを踏まえ、リツ・マコへ分担を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "f9b40544-5727-4c4c-aba3-d4cc5a5b3c1f", + "at": 1789185883871, + "role": "bot", + "text": "2巡目の議論で両名とも修正案に合意し、追加要望2点(ヘッダ項目名・順序一致の受入条件化、中断時の報告先と再開判断者の明記)を採用して決定しました。リツにはソラ宛てのCSVサンプル+項目定義書作成の依頼を、マコにはレオ宛ての検査表作成の依頼を割り当てました。両名のレポートを受け取り次第、アオイへ結果を返します。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "8390ffcb-c1e3-4ed9-bbae-397de4403dd4", + "at": 1789185884123, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ 決定事項:①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む、変更は第2弾)②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書に明記④受入条件=総行数一致・ヘッダ項目名順序一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時中断報告(報告先・再開判断者=レンを明記)。\nあなたの担当:実装チームのソラ(group_id=47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc, bot_id=c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982)へsend_room_messageで依頼。内容:架空CSVサンプル(12項目・6ヶ月分数行)+項目定義書(12項目名列挙・基準日・出力規約明記)。下層にも同じ議論→分担→実行→報告の手順を伝えること。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "7a4c9cf4-5dc3-4f1c-adf2-a72ab664c0bc", + "at": 1789185901294, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン ソラ宛てに依頼を送信しました(12項目・6ヶ月分の架空CSVサンプル+項目定義書、出力規約と進め方も明記)。結果が返り次第レビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "349cdfd1-f36f-48f7-88f8-1cf891707a92", + "at": 1789185901558, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@マコ 決定事項:①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む、変更は第2弾)②UTF-8 BOM付き・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書に明記④受入条件=ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数・ヘッダ項目名順序が定義書と一致・受注番号重複欠番なし・失敗時は中断・報告(報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記)。\nあなたの担当:QAチームのレオ(group_id=432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66, bot_id=ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11)へsend_room_messageで依頼。内容:検査表(QA観点、上記受入条件を全て含む)。下層にも同じ議論→分担→実行→報告の手順を伝えること。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "93b27f96-2d6f-4ac0-b206-057c30c7c93c", + "at": 1789185911003, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 承知しました。QAチームのレオへ検査表作成を依頼します。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "1d849050-b9ce-42ba-9720-0c94f4ce70e1", + "at": 1789185916919, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン レオ宛てに検査表作成の依頼を送信しました(決定事項④の受入条件すべて+出力規約の検査項目を含むよう指定、議論→分担→実行→報告の手順も伝達済み)。結果が返り次第レビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "79590a50-54cc-4e87-b8f4-4de20cb1fa71", + "at": 1789186029749, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ\n\n@リツ 完了報告です。チーム議論(1巡)のうえ決定し、ヒナがCSV作成、ナギが検査を実施、全項目OKでした。\n\n【決定事項】\n- 12項目(順):受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス(識別→顧客→担当→商品→金額→状況の順が根拠)\n- 受注番号=ORD-000001形式の連番(重複・欠番なし)\n- 数量・単価・金額=整数(円)、金額=数量×単価\n- ステータス値:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル\n- 抽出基準:受注日基準・基準日2026-09-11(直近6ヶ月)\n- 規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・LF・RFC4180準拠・日付YYYY-MM-DD・更新日≧受注日・全項目カンマ/引用符不含・自由記述除外\n\n【成果物①CSVサンプル(架空3行)】\n```\n受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\nORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了\nORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済\nORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定\n```\n\n【成果物②項目定義書(抜粋)】上記決定事項の通り。項目名・順序・抽出基準・基準日・出力規約を明記済み。\n\n【検査結果(ナギ)】①ヘッダ名・順序一致 ②総行数4行 ③連番・重複欠番なし ④日付形式・整合OK ⑤金額=数量×単価成立 ⑥カンマ・引用符なし・ステータス値範囲内 — 全項目OK、受入条件満たしています。了承のうえご報告します。レビューとレンさんへの報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "0a6f3a1f-c166-4131-b050-b43f0a6aa6d1", + "at": 1789186046091, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン リツ担当分のレビュー完了、問題なしです。レンへ報告します。\n\n【ソラチーム結果レビュー(リツ)】\n- CSVサンプル:ヘッダ1+データ3行=計4行、12項目の名称・順序が決定事項と一致(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む)✓\n- 受注番号ORD-000001~3の連番、重複・欠番なし ✓\n- 受注日は基準日2026-09-11から直近6ヶ月(2026-03-12以降)内、更新日≧受注日も全行成立 ✓\n- 金額=数量×単価を3行とも再計算で確認(10×98000=980000、5×45000=225000、20×32000=640000)✓\n- 規約準拠:UTF-8 BOM・LF・YYYY-MM-DD・カンマ/引用符不含・自由記述除外、ステータスは規定値内 ✓\n- 項目定義書にも抽出基準・基準日・規約が明記済み ✓\n\n処理の簡素さの観点でも、自由記述除外と単一抽出基準で作成・検査が機械的に回る形になっており良好です。リツ担当分は受入条件を全て満たすと判断、了承します。マコさんの検査表結果と併せて取りまとめをお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a068fb05-e201-4779-9772-e50d62ab139f", + "at": 1789186072215, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@マコ\n\nマコさん、両担当の成果が揃いました。私が規約検査・受入検査パートを作成し、4部構成で統合します。\n\n## CSV初期公開 検査表(統合版・2026-09-12)\n\n### 第1部 規約検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| R-1 | 文字コード | 生成されたCSVファイルをバイナリ確認 | UTF-8(BOM付き)。先頭3バイト=EF BB BF |\n| R-2 | 日付形式 | 受注日・更新日フィールド全件を確認 | YYYY-MM-DD形式(例:2026-03-01)。区切り記号・桁数の違反なし |\n| R-3 | 日付妥当性 | 各日付値の実在性を確認 | 存在しない日付(2/30等)なし。閏年2/29は正しく処理(2024-02-29は有効、2025-02-29は無効として検出) |\n| R-4 | 改行コード | 全行末尾を確認 | LF(0x0A)。CR・CRLF混入なし |\n| R-5 | RFC4180準拠 | カンマ・改行を含む値、空値を含むデータで生成 | 値はダブルクォートで適切に囲まれる。フィールド数=12で全行一致 |\n| R-6 | 項目数 | ヘッダと全データ行の項目数を確認 | 常に12項目(自由記述項目は除外済み) |\n\n### 第2部 受入検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| A-1 | 行数一致 | 任意の抽出条件で生成し、データ件数と総行数を突合 | ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数で一致 |\n| A-2 | ヘッダ一致 | 生成CSVのヘッダ行を定義書と照合 | 項目名・順序とも定義書と完全一致(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む) |\n| A-3 | 受注番号一意性 | 全データ行の受注番号を集計 | 重複なし・欠番なし(連続性は定義書の番号規則に従う) |\n| A-4 | 失敗時の扱い | 生成失敗を発生させる | 中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告。**報告先:マコ/再開判断者:レオ(QAリーダー)** を検査表通り1行明記 |\n\n### 第3部 境界値検査(担当:メイ)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 0件ケース | 抽出期間内に該当データ0件で生成 | ヘッダ1行のみ。総行数=1で行数一致。エラーなく正常終了 |\n| B-2 | 期間前日(境界外) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日の前日のデータ1件のみ | 出力されない(ヘッダのみ) |\n| B-3 | 期間初日(境界内) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日のデータ1件 | 1件出力。総行数=2 |\n| B-4 | 期間末日(境界内) | 受注日=基準日当日のデータ1件 | 1件出力(基準日を含む設定の確認) |\n| B-5 | 期間翌日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日翌日のデータ1件(未来日) | 出力されない。出力されれば定義書と不整合として報告 |\n| B-6 | 上限ちょうど | 期間内データ=上限件数(仮:100,000件)ちょうど | 全件出力。総行数=100,001。重複・欠番なし。警告なし |\n| B-7 | 上限超過 | 期間内データ=上限+1件(100,001件) | 定義書規定どおり(全件出力+警告記録、または打ち切り)。規定値を検査表に明記のうえ確認 |\n\n### 第4部 異常系検査(担当:ハル)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 | 再開判断者 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 生成開始後(スナップショット確定後)に抽出期間内データへ追加・削除・更新が発生 | 件数・内容は基準日時スナップショットで固定、変動は反映されない。行数一致。変動反映時は中断しマコへ報告 | レオ |\n| E-2 | 途中失敗 | 生成途中(例:10万件中3万件書き込み済み)でDB接続断等の障害 | 部分ファイル出力継続禁止。不完全CSVは破棄/隔離し、中断しマコへ報告。エラー位置・時刻・件数を記録。再開は指示後に最初からやり直す | レオ |\n| E-3 | 権限なし | 権限のない実行者が生成を実行 | アクセス拒否、ファイル出力なし。中断しレオへ報告。権限付与/実行者変更後に再実行(無権限の再試行禁止) | レオ |\n\n---\n\n【取りまとめメモ(マコさんへの確認事項)】\n1. **上限件数の実値**(B-6/B-7は100,000件で仮置き)→定義書確定値をご提示ください\n2. **基準日の含む/含まない**(B-2〜B-5は「6ヶ月前同日を含み・基準日当日を含む」設定例)→定義書記載値をご確認ください\n3. **報告先・再開判断者**(A-4/E-1〜E-3は報告先マコ・再開判断者レオで仮置き)→正式値をご指示ください\n\n以上、QAチームとして検査表を完成させました。レビューのうえレンさんへの報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "16954596-076e-4716-93a6-6362ef9285e0", + "at": 1789186085164, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン マコ担当分(QAチーム・レオ宛て)の結果が返りました。レビューのうえ報告します。\n\n【レオチーム結果レビュー(マコ)】\n検査表は4部構成(規約・受入・境界値・異常系)で、決定事項④の受入条件をすべて網羅 ✓\n- A-1行数一致、A-2ヘッダ項目名・順序一致、A-3受注番号重複欠番なし、失敗時中断・報告も明記 ✓\n- 境界値(B-1〜B-7)で0件・6ヶ月境界・上限件数をカバー、異常系(E-1〜E-3)で件数変化のスナップショット固定と途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄を確認。私の1巡目懸念(途中失敗・件数変化)に直接対応 ✓\n\n【レビューでの修正点1件】\nA-4/E-1〜E-3の報告先・再開判断者が「マコ/レオ」と仮置きされていますが、開発部決定では**報告先・再開判断者=レン**です。レオの検査表をこの正式値に差し替えて了承します(検査表構造自体は影響なし)。\n\n【レオへの確認事項の回答】\n1. 上限件数:初回は未規定のためB-7は「上限超過時は全件出力+警告記録(第2弾で正式規定)」とするのが妥当と判断\n2. 基準日の含む/含まない:B-2〜B-5の設定例(6ヶ月前同日を含む・基準日当日を含む、基準日2026-09-11)はソラの項目定義書と整合 ✓\n\nマコ担当分は受入条件を満たすと判断、了承します。リツさんのCSVサンプル結果と併せて取りまとめをお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "37b8a51e-abbc-4e20-81d2-d9671e30c119", + "at": 1789186100694, + "role": "bot", + "text": "リツ・マコ両担当分の報告を受領し、レビュー済みです。両名のレビュー判断を了承し、開発部として取りまとめます。\n\n【開発部 取りまとめ(アオイ宛て報告)】\n経営会議決定(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)に対し、部内で2巡の議論→決定→分担→実行→レビューを完了しました。\n\n■決定事項\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須含む)。変更は第2弾扱い。\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外。\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日2026-09-11を定義書に明記。\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先・再開判断者=レン)。\n\n■成果物\n1. 架空CSVサンプル(ヘッダ1+データ3行、12項目)…実装チーム(ソラ)作成、リツレビュー済み。総行数・連番・6ヶ月範囲・金額=数量×単価・規約を全て確認し受入条件満たす。\n2. 検査表(規約・受入・境界値・異常系の4部構成)…QAチーム(レオ)作成、マコレビュー済み。0件・6ヶ月境界・上限件数・途中失敗時の部分ファイル破棄まで網羅。レビューで報告先・再開判断者を正式値(レン)に差し替え済み。上限件数は初回未規定(超過時は全件出力+警告、第2弾で正式規定)。\n\n■スケジュール\n12項目は本日確定済みのため、公開目標3週間以内に対し十分余力あり。\n\n両成果物とも受入条件を満たすと判断し、開発部として了承・完了とします。以上、アオイさんのレビューをお願いします。ミナトさんへの報告よろしくお願いいたします。", + "from": { + "botId": "26b4400b-dd98-4fbe-9ecf-ce842b5146f2", + "name": "レン" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "営業部", + "id": "a73380dd-1d63-49de-82bd-9efbf916b8c4", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "fbb86a42-6e84-485b-a4f4-4bdd65abb5cc", + "at": 1789185761078, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 営業部コウさん。経営会議営業担当ユイです。経営会議の最終決定をお伝えし、営業部での準備を依頼します。\n\n【決定】CSV初期公開=営業必須12項目(受注日・更新日を必ず含む)＋直近6ヶ月分。公開目標3週間以内。12項目定義は今週中に開発アオイと経営会議ユイが合同確定、遅延時は公開優先で未確定項目は第2弾繰越。UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定。全項目・全件は第2弾拡張。\n\n【依頼】営業部で既存メンバー(サキ・トワ)と1巡議論を行い、その後 各既存メンバーへ成果物作成(FAQ・チェックリスト等、営業利用向け)を割り当ててください。担当者はlist_room_targetsから宛先IDを確認しsend_room_messageで依頼。実データ・コード変更不要、架空データで作成。結果はこちらへ戻してください。レビューの上、経営会議ミナトへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "87e3f73a-58ef-42a6-a01d-54ad5623e5d6", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e38887dc-7d81-48c8-b738-d8432fa4b176", + "at": 1789185769661, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ユイさん、決定内容を受領しました。営業部でサキ・トワと1巡議論してから分担を割り当てます。まず議論から始めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "13eddc64-6baf-409c-8060-4e07ce299793", + "at": 1789185787039, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論を開始しました。私の提案:初期公開は「営業に直結する12項目・6ヶ月分」を前提に、顧客には第2弾拡張予定を含めて正直に説明する方針。サキは顧客向けの分かりやすさ、トワは個人情報・持出し制約の観点で意見をください。終了次第、分担を決めて各メンバーへ成果物作成を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "1f46c156-a022-4f78-8fff-5385b7151ae4", + "at": 1789185787091, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@サキ @トワ\nCSV初期公開(営業必須12項目+直近6ヶ月分、公開目標3週間以内、UTF-8・日付形式・エスケープ規約固定、全項目全件は第2弾)のお客様説明と社内運用の方針。サキは顧客向けの便利さ・説明しやすさ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約・運用面のリスクの観点で意見を述べてください。各自、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を加えること。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e4134edd-3826-465e-88fc-30914edf9c73", + "at": 1789185798796, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 提案に賛成です。12項目+6ヶ月は「よく使うデータだけ先に出す」と説明しやすく、顧客の利便性も確保できます。改善提案として、①顧客向けに項目一覧と取得手順を1枚の説明資料にまとめる、②受注日・更新日が必須なので「データの鮮度は更新日で判断して下さい」と明記する、③第2弾拡張は時期を確約せず「要望に応じて拡張予定」と正直に伝える、の3点を入れて下さい。UTF-8やエスケープ規約は専門用語を避け「文字化けしない形式」と平易に説明するのが良いと思います。", + "from": { + "botId": "f2249b99-7338-4fd4-837b-e1fc2ae5e9fa", + "name": "サキ" + } + }, + { + "id": "3401dcf1-cfd8-4354-b4bb-c6165582bbb7", + "at": 1789185809231, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ @サキ サキさんの3点に概ね賛成です。ただし個人情報・持出し制約の観点から改善を加えます。①12項目に顧客名・担当者名等が入る場合、CSVは持出し可能な端末・保存先を限定し、営業はダウンロード後の転送禁止を徹底すべきです。②6ヶ月分でも件数によっては個人情報が大量になるので、取得時に用途を確認するログ残しを運用に入れて下さい。③説明資料には「文字化けしない形式」に加え「社外持ち出しルール」を1行明記するのが良いです。チェックリスト側でこれらを項目化します。", + "from": { + "botId": "7dfe3949-9e25-4863-a09a-dd1d4d69af97", + "name": "トワ" + } + }, + { + "id": "f28937de-e67d-4b1e-9817-b987594de832", + "at": 1789185819293, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論の結果、両者の提案をすべて採用します。サキさんの「1枚の説明資料・鮮度は更新日判断・拡張は時期未確定・平易な表現」、トワさんの「持出し端末・保存先の限定と転送禁止・取得時の用途ログ・社外持ち出しルールの1行明記」を方針に反映。サキさんに顧客向けFAQ、トワさんに社内チェックリストの作成を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "be3f621d-1d5a-4dcb-86a8-c498c951f6b7", + "at": 1789185837108, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論を踏まえ方針を決定し、2名へ割り当てました。\n\n- 採用:サキさんの説明資料1枚化・鮮度は更新日判断・拡張は時期未確定・平易な表現、トワさんの持出し端末/保存先限定・転送禁止・取得時用途ログ・社外持ち出しルール明記\n- 割当:@サキ=顧客向けFAQ3問、@トワ=社内操作チェックリスト5項目\n\n結果が戻り次第レビューし、ユイさんへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ec0e7850-ccb7-4c84-bd2c-8b6916befa4f", + "at": 1789185837264, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@サキ 決定方針:12項目+6ヶ月分、更新日で鮮度判断、第2弾は時期未確定「要望に応じて拡張予定」、専門用語避け「文字化けしない形式」、社外持ち出しルールの1行明記。あなたの担当:顧客向けFAQ3問を作成してください。架空データ、日本語、各問い答えは簡潔に。完成後この会話へ結果を返して下さい。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "36b95d25-6527-4c0d-aa78-1252475bda40", + "at": 1789185848922, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 担当の顧客向けFAQ3問が完成しました。決定方針(12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、第2弾は時期未確定、平易な表現、社外持ち出しルール1行明記)を反映しています。レビューをお願いします。\n\n---\n\n## 顧客向けFAQ(CSVデータ提供サービス 初期公開版)\n\n**Q1. どんなデータが、どのくらいの期間分もらえますか?**\nA. 営業でよく使う12項目(受注日・更新日を含む)を、直近6ヶ月分まとめてお渡しします。項目一覧と取得手順は1枚の説明資料にまとめてご用意します。\n\n**Q2. データの新しい・古さはどうやって判断すればよいですか?また、形式面での注意はありますか?**\nA. 各データの「更新日」をご確認ください。更新日が新しいほど最新の情報です。形式は文字化けしない形式でご提供するため、特別な設定なしでExcel等でそのまま開けます。\n\n**Q3. 全項目・全期間のデータはもらえますか?**\nA. 現在は初期公開版のため12項目・6ヶ月分です。全項目・全件の拡張はお客様のご要望に応じて拡張予定です。なお、お預かりしたデータの社外への持ち出しは、弊社規定のルールに従ってお願いします。\n\n---\n\n以上3問です。トワさんのチェックリストと合わせて取りまとめをお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "f2249b99-7338-4fd4-837b-e1fc2ae5e9fa", + "name": "サキ" + } + }, + { + "id": "6e1e6737-a036-48e6-929b-709f978418fa", + "at": 1789185849087, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@トワ 決定方針:CSV持出し可能な端末・保存先の限定、ダウンロード後の転送禁止、取得時に用途を確認するログ残し、社外持ち出しルール明記、更新日で鮮度判断。あなたの担当:社内操作チェックリスト5項目を作成してください。架空データ、日本語、営業が実行可能な具体的操作手順として。完成後この会話へ結果を返して下さい。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "5883747c-37de-45f5-bc8f-51759881a0a0", + "at": 1789185860084, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 担当の社内操作チェックリスト5項目が完成しました。決定方針(持出し端末・保存先限定、転送禁止、取得時用途ログ、社外持ち出しルール明記、更新日で鮮度判断)を反映しています。レビューをお願いします。\n\n---\n\n## CSV取得 社内操作チェックリスト(営業用・初期公開版)\n\n**1. 持出し端末・保存先の確認**\n□ CSVを取得するのは会社支給の認証済み端末(PC・タブレット)のみ。保存先は指定フォルダ「S:\\営業\\CSV_顧客データ」に限定する。私物端末・USBメモリ・私的クラウドへの保存は禁止。\n\n**2. 取得時の用途ログ記入**\n□ ダウンロード前に「取得管理台」(共有スプレッドシート)に日付・氏名・顧客名・用途(例：A社向け提案資料作成)・取得件数を記入する。用途が書けない場合は取得しない。\n\n**3. ダウンロード後の転送禁止**\n□ 取得したCSVはメール添付・チャット送付・他部署への共有をしない。参照が必要な場合は相手に同じ手順で自身が取得してもらう。\n\n**4. 鮮度の確認(更新日チェック)**\n□ ファイル開封後、先頭行の「更新日」列を確認し、直近の更新日であることを確認してから利用する。古いデータで判断しない。\n\n**5. 社外持ち出しと利用後の削除**\n□ CSVの社外持ち出しは禁止(やむを得ない場合は部長コウの事前承認を得る)。利用が終わったら期限内(取得から30日以内)に指定フォルダから削除し、取得管理台の削除欄に日付を記入する。\n\n---\n\n以上5項目です。サキさんのFAQと合わせて取りまとめをお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "7dfe3949-9e25-4863-a09a-dd1d4d69af97", + "name": "トワ" + } + }, + { + "id": "43fcd93e-6410-4920-8b14-60e7a2313237", + "at": 1789185872908, + "role": "bot", + "text": "両者の成果物をレビューしました。いずれも決定方針を忠実に反映しており、そのまま採用します。\n\n**レビュー結果**\n- サキさんFAQ3問:12項目+6ヶ月、更新日で鮮度判断、「文字化けしない形式」の平易な表現、拡張は時期未確定、社外持ち出しルール1行明記——すべて反映済み。Q3で持ち出しルールに軽く触れているのも適切。✅採用\n- トワさんチェックリスト5項目:端末・保存先限定、用途ログ、転送禁止、更新日チェック、社外持ち出し禁止+事前承認+30日削除——すべて反映済み。取得管理台の削除欄記入まで盛り込まれ、運用として実行可能。✅採用\n\n**ユイさんへの報告**\n\n営業部の準備が完了しました。経営会議決定(12項目+6ヶ月、UTF-8等規約固定、第2弾拡張)を受け、サキ・トワと1巡議論のうえ方針を決定し、以下の2成果物を作成・レビュー済みです。\n\n1. 顧客向けFAQ3問(サキ作成):内容・鮮度判断・拡張見込みを平易に説明\n2. 社内操作チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成):持出し制限・用途ログ・転送禁止・削除まで規定\n\n議論で追加採用したのは「説明資料1枚化」「更新日で鮮度判断」「拡張は時期未確定と正直に伝える」「持出し端末・保存先限定と転送禁止」「取得時用途ログ」です。公開目標3週間以内に向け利用可能です。ミナト様への報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "5377b235-0ea5-4d52-8393-19c33e79a27a", + "name": "コウ" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "実装チーム", + "id": "47889c1a-53f1-4c30-8a56-1667424ba0dc", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "098fd718-d159-4baf-a906-7dba4d5cd3e4", + "at": 1789185901569, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ リツより実装依頼です(開発部決定に基づく。架空データのみ、実データ・コード変更不要)。\n\n【成果物】\n①架空CSVサンプル:営業必須12項目(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む。残り9項目は貴チームで提案し確定)、直近6ヶ月分数行。出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目(備考等)は除外。\n②項目定義書:12項目名を列挙(ヘッダの項目名・順序の根拠)、抽出基準=受注日基準、基準日を明記、上記出力規約を明記。\n\n【受入条件(参考)】ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数、ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告。\n\n【進め方】貴チームでも同じ手順で:メンバーで1巡議論(懸念出し)→責任者修正案→2巡目で回答→決定→各メンバーへ分担→実行→責任者がまとめて私へ報告、としてください。完了結果を私(リツ)へ返してください。レビューの上、レンへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "40db1cac-7bef-4450-9d24-fbf3d5c5e35c", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e3b33ad6-b830-4cb3-8723-e21d322465ec", + "at": 1789185911012, + "role": "bot", + "text": "リツさん、受領しました。まずチーム内で1巡議論します。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "9d676ba9-9553-4618-add6-208b717d13c2", + "at": 1789185927693, + "role": "bot", + "text": "メンバーで1巡議論を開始しました。私の修正案は「残り9項目=顧客名・顧客コード・担当者名・部署・商品名・数量・単価・金額・ステータス、基準日2026-09-11(受注日基準・直近6ヶ月)」です。議論結果を受けて決定し、分担します。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "8b2422c6-0c8d-4439-9cb8-be17ab74cc69", + "at": 1789185927735, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@ヒナ @ナギ\nリツ氏より依頼:架空CSV(営業必須12項目、受注番号・受注日・更新日含む、残り9項目は自席で提案)と項目定義書の作成。懸念と9項目の具体案を出してください。私案:残り9項目=顧客名・顧客コード・担当者名・部署・商品名・数量・単価・金額・ステータス。基準日2026-09-11(受注日基準・直近6ヶ月)。各250字程度で前の人の意見への賛否も。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "bc2a95ac-7171-4a00-9223-11454c1e8894", + "at": 1789185939252, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ 私は私案の9項目に賛成です。受注番号・受注日・更新日に、顧客名・顧客コード・担当者名・部署・商品名・数量・単価・金額・ステータスを加える構成は、営業が確認したい「誰が・何を・いくらで・どこまで進んでいるか」を過不足なくCoverしています。順序は「識別→顧客→担当→商品→金額→状況」の流れが自然です。懸念は2点。①数量・単価・金額の型定義(整数か小数か、金額=数量×単価の整合を検証可能に)。②ステータスの取り得る値(例:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル)を定義書で列挙し、ナギさんの検査と一致させたい。です。", + "from": { + "botId": "2b7d1a74-d264-44d3-99b4-7c2f897d4094", + "name": "ヒナ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e79c2c85-b5f4-4dce-9db1-8d92e142a6c8", + "at": 1789185954335, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ @ヒナ ヒナさんの9項目賛成に私も同意します。検証担当の立場からは、ヒナさん挙げの2懸念がまさに検査項目になるので重要です。追加の懸念は①受注番号の書式(例:ORD-000001の連番)を定義書で固定してほしい。重複・欠番なしの検査は書式が決まらないと機械的にできません。②更新日≧受注日の整合チェック、③顧客名・商品名にカンマや引用符を含めない(自由記述除外規約と整合。ただし検証用に1行だけ引用符入りを仕込む案もあり得ますが、リツ氏規約優先で入れない方が安全)。ステータス値の列挙に賛成。数量=整数、単価・金額=整数(円)で金額=数量×単価の検査を可能に。", + "from": { + "botId": "5806e3c6-b7a9-4b7c-8d26-d9f5f73a8021", + "name": "ナギ" + } + }, + { + "id": "7f236f82-9ec1-4546-8d47-ec3a69ff6cb7", + "at": 1789185967644, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論ありがとうございます。両氏の意見をすべて採用し、以下の通り決定します。\n\n【決定】\n- 12項目(順):受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\n- 受注番号=ORD-000001形式の連番(重複・欠番なし)\n- 型:数量・単価・金額=整数(円)、金額=数量×単価\n- ステータス値:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル\n- 更新日≧受注日、受注日基準・基準日2026-09-11(直近6ヶ月)\n- 全項目にカンマ・引用符不含(引用符入り検証用行は入れない)\n- 規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・LF・RFC4180・日付YYYY-MM-DD\n\nヒナにCSV作成、ナギに検査表作成を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "88ecf7db-6446-4d80-9612-892b87442d6e", + "at": 1789185984971, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ヒナ(@ヒナ)にCSV作成、ナギ(@ナギ)に検査表作成を割り当てました。両者の成果が揃い次第、取りまとめてリツさんへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "b50d49b2-9176-485a-9e2a-57e95efb7287", + "at": 1789185985252, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ヒナ 決定に基づきCSV作成を依頼します。ヘッダ1行+架空データ3行(受注日は2026-03-12以降2026-09-11以前)。項目順:受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス。受注番号=ORD-000001からの連番。数量・単価・金額=整数で金額=数量×単価。ステータスは確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセルから。更新日≧受注日。全項目にカンマ・引用符を含めない。CSV本文を最終応答に提示してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "47964bc9-f87c-4d49-ab8e-54b5c57ecd6b", + "at": 1789185999765, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ CSV作成しました。決定事項(項目順・連番・整数整合・ステータス値・日付整合・カンマ/引用符不含)すべて確認済みです。ナギさんの検査をお願いします。\n\n```\n受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\nORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了\nORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済\nORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定\n```", + "from": { + "botId": "2b7d1a74-d264-44d3-99b4-7c2f897d4094", + "name": "ヒナ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e3bdb114-64e7-4a92-8c98-8e09f8128358", + "at": 1789186000047, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ナギ 決定に基づき検査表作成を依頼します。ヒナが本ルームで提示するCSV本文を読み、検査表を作成してください。検査項目:①ヘッダ項目名・順序が定義通り(受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス)②総行数=ヘッダ1+データ3③受注番号ORD-000001からの連番・重複欠番なし④日付YYYY-MM-DD・更新日≧受注日⑤数量・単価・金額が整数で金額=数量×単価⑥全項目にカンマ・引用符なし。各項目OK/NGと所見を表で最終応答に提示してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "61ee6121-d9b5-489e-9cd3-4513719e9591", + "at": 1789186013839, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ ヒナさんのCSVを読み、検査しました。結果は以下の通りです。全項目OKです。\n\n| 検査項目 | 判定 | 所見 |\n|---|---|---|\n| ①ヘッダ項目名・順序 | OK | 12項目が定義通りの名称・順序で完全一致 |\n| ②総行数 | OK | ヘッダ1+データ3=4行、過不足なし |\n| ③受注番号連番 | OK | ORD-000001〜000003、重複・欠番なし、書式ORD-xxxxxx通り |\n| ④日付整合 | OK | すべてYYYY-MM-DD形式。更新日≧受注日を3行とも満たす(行2は同日)。受注日は2026-03-12以降・2026-09-11以前で基準日範囲内 |\n| ⑤数値整合 | OK | 数量・単価・金額すべて整数。10×98000=980000、5×45000=225000、20×32000=640000、すべて金額=数量×単価成立 |\n| ⑥区切り文字等 | OK | 全項目にカンマ(区切り以外)・引用符なし。ステータスは定義済み4値(完了/出荷済/確定)の範囲内 |\n\n補足:顧客コード・部署も書式・表記のぶれなし。検証用の引用符入り行もなし(決定通り)。成果を了承します。取りまとめよろしくお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "5806e3c6-b7a9-4b7c-8d26-d9f5f73a8021", + "name": "ナギ" + } + }, + { + "id": "34a3b442-faee-49d2-85ac-3295dd040d20", + "at": 1789186029686, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ 完了報告です。チーム議論(1巡)のうえ決定し、ヒナがCSV作成、ナギが検査を実施、全項目OKでした。\n\n【決定事項】\n- 12項目(順):受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス(識別→顧客→担当→商品→金額→状況の順が根拠)\n- 受注番号=ORD-000001形式の連番(重複・欠番なし)\n- 数量・単価・金額=整数(円)、金額=数量×単価\n- ステータス値:確定/出荷済/完了/キャンセル\n- 抽出基準:受注日基準・基準日2026-09-11(直近6ヶ月)\n- 規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・LF・RFC4180準拠・日付YYYY-MM-DD・更新日≧受注日・全項目カンマ/引用符不含・自由記述除外\n\n【成果物①CSVサンプル(架空3行)】\n```\n受注番号,受注日,更新日,顧客コード,顧客名,担当者名,部署,商品名,数量,単価,金額,ステータス\nORD-000001,2026-03-12,2026-03-15,CUST-0101,山田商事,佐藤花子,第一営業部,ノートパソコン,10,98000,980000,完了\nORD-000002,2026-05-20,2026-05-20,CUST-0204,鈴木工業,田中一郎,第二営業部,レーザープリンター,5,45000,225000,出荷済\nORD-000003,2026-08-30,2026-09-10,CUST-0310,伊藤物産,山本健,第三営業部,ビジネスモニター,20,32000,640000,確定\n```\n\n【成果物②項目定義書(抜粋)】上記決定事項の通り。項目名・順序・抽出基準・基準日・出力規約を明記済み。\n\n【検査結果(ナギ)】①ヘッダ名・順序一致 ②総行数4行 ③連番・重複欠番なし ④日付形式・整合OK ⑤金額=数量×単価成立 ⑥カンマ・引用符なし・ステータス値範囲内 — 全項目OK、受入条件満たしています。了承のうえご報告します。レビューとレンさんへの報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "c9972a9b-eedb-4080-8c6b-b1a5bb8f7982", + "name": "ソラ" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "QAチーム", + "id": "432b50e6-76d2-4b00-85bb-d4200b687d66", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "fcf0cd5f-db3e-4964-a252-9e2d90000610", + "at": 1789185917074, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ マコ(開発部・品質担当)より依頼です。CSV初期公開(営業必須12項目・直近6ヶ月分・架空データ)の検査表作成を依頼します。\n\n【決定事項(開発部確定)】\n①12項目を本日固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む、変更は第2弾扱い)\n②出力規約:UTF-8(BOM付き)・日付YYYY-MM-DD・改行LF・RFC4180準拠・自由記述項目除外\n③抽出基準は受注日基準、基準日を定義書に明記\n④受入条件:ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数の一致、ヘッダの項目名・順序が定義書と一致、受注番号の重複なし・欠番なし、失敗時は中断・報告(報告先と再開判断者を検査表に1行明記)\n\n【依頼成果物】検査表(QA観点、上記受入条件④を全て含むこと。形式・文字コード・日付形式等の規約検査項目も含めてください)\n\n【進め方】そちらのチームでも同じ手順で:議論(懸念→修正案→回答の2巡)→決定→分担→実行→報告。実データ・コード変更不要の架空案件のみ。完了後、結果を私(マコ)へ返してください。レビューの上、レンへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "95ddd94b-7390-4c17-9ef7-c0d66a0411ec", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "4fe38b11-eb8d-42ca-b1a6-2659b5a9b6d8", + "at": 1789185924757, + "role": "bot", + "text": "承知しました、マコさん。QAチームで検査表作成に取り組みます。まずチームで議論します。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "0207535d-9ba8-4f8a-950b-fb0e95ac0aee", + "at": 1789185939561, + "role": "bot", + "text": "マコさん、依頼を受けました。検査表の構成案(規約検査/受入検査/境界検査の3部構成)を出し、メイさん(境界値)とハルさん(異常系)に議論を促しました。議論後に方針を決定し、分担して検査表を作成します。完了次第、結果を返します。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a0e3f5ec-58fa-486b-802e-e37cd4d1cae7", + "at": 1789185939738, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@メイ @ハル\nCSV初期公開の検査表作成について。決定事項は①12項目固定(受注番号・受注日・更新日必須)②UTF-8(BOM付き)・YYYY-MM-DD・LF・RFC4180・自由記述除外③受注日基準・基準日を定義書明記④受入条件(行数一致・ヘッダ一致・受注番号重複/欠番なし・失敗時は中断・報告先と再開判断者を1行明記)。検査表の構成案:私は「規約検査(文字コード・日付形式・改行・RFC4180)」+「受入検査(④全部)」+「境界(6ヶ月範囲の初日・末日)」の3部構成を提案。メイは境界観点、ハルは異常系観点で、それぞれ懸念と具体的な改善案を述べてください。全員の発言が揃ったら私が決定します。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "bcdb69c3-42c8-422e-8d64-6b19646d3cf9", + "at": 1789185959805, + "role": "bot", + "text": "メイ: 境界値観点で意見します。3部構成に賛成です。ただし「6ヶ月範囲の初日・末日」だけでは不十分という懸念があります。改善案:①境界日の扱いを「基準日を含む/含まない」まで明記(例:基準日から起算して6ヶ月前の同日を含む、当日は含まない等)②受注日の境界付近データ(前日・当日・6ヶ月前日・その前日)の4点を検査行として明示③件数0件(該当データなし)も境界ケースとして追加。また日付の妥当性(存在しない日付・閏年2/29)も規約検査に入れるべきです。ご検討ください。", + "from": { + "botId": "8ce8bad3-e9ed-4708-b170-d03076932825", + "name": "メイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "d00c6cd8-532c-4981-a2dc-07d0b0013d6a", + "at": 1789185972249, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ハル: 異常系観点で意見します。3部構成に賛成、メイさんの0件・日付妥当性の追加も支持します。懸念は「失敗時は中断・報告」の中身が未定義な点です。改善案:①第4部「異常系検査」として、生成中に件数が変化(追加/削除)した場合の期待結果(基準日時点のスナップショットで件数固定、変動を反映しない)を明記②途中失敗時の検査行(部分ファイルの出力継続禁止・再開判断者欄付き)③検査実行者の権限なし(アクセス拒否)場合の報告フロー確認。期待結果は「中断し○○へ報告」と具体化するのが良いです。", + "from": { + "botId": "6033e190-9e6c-4404-b406-aad35ef23f08", + "name": "ハル" + } + }, + { + "id": "107359a6-b034-4af8-aca6-45ee17c3e616", + "at": 1789185988481, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【決定】議論ありがとうございます。両名の案を踏まえ、以下の通り決定します。\n\n①構成は4部構成に修正:「規約検査」「受入検査」「境界値検査」「異常系検査」\n②メイ案を採用:境界日の含む/含まないを定義書側に確認メモとして明記し、境界付近4点(前日・当日・6ヶ月前日・その前日)を検査行化。0件ケースと日付妥当性(閏年2/29含む)も追加\n③ハル案を採用:期待結果は「中断し○○へ報告」と具体化。生成中の件数変化はスナップショット固定、途中失敗時は部分ファイル出力禁止、権限なしは報告フロー確認\n④全検査行に「入力条件」と「期待結果」を必須列として記載\n\n分担を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "14aab5a4-8a60-4e77-8308-7e7b836f4207", + "at": 1789186013789, + "role": "bot", + "text": "分担を割り当てました。メイさんは境界値3ケース(0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過)、ハルさんは異常系3ケース(生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なし)の表を作成します。両名の成果が揃い次第、私が取りまとめて規約検査・受入検査パートと統合し、検査表全体をマコさんへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "1c87d890-1a3e-4fa3-b96d-7895bc22f5b2", + "at": 1789186013887, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@メイ 決定に基づき分担を割り当てます。メイさんは境界値担当として検査表(境界値検査パート)を作成してください。0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表。全行に「入力条件」と「期待結果」を必ず記載。決定済み事項(4部構成・境界付近4点の検査行化・0件ケース追加)を踏まえ、議論はやり直さず作成のみお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ca5d087e-f6eb-4bd4-abec-d2a75cf12a9b", + "at": 1789186032749, + "role": "bot", + "text": "メイ: 担当割り当てを受け、境界値検査パートの検査表を作成しました。決定事項(境界付近4点の検査行化・0件ケース追加)を踏まえています。\n\n## 境界値検査パート(担当日付:2026-09-12)\n\n前提:抽出基準は受注日基準、直近6ヶ月分。基準日の「含む/含まない」は定義書確認メモに従う(下表は基準日を含み、6ヶ月前同日を含む設定の例)。\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 0件ケース | 抽出期間内に該当データが0件の状態でCSV生成を実行 | ヘッダ1行のみ出力(データ0行)。総行数=1で行数一致。エラーを出さず正常終了 |\n| B-2 | 期間前日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日の6ヶ月前同日の前日(期間外)のデータ1件のみ | 該当データは出力されない(0件扱い、ヘッダのみ) |\n| B-3 | 期間初日(境界内) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日(期間内)のデータ1件 | 当該1件が出力される。ヘッダ1+データ1=総行数2 |\n| B-4 | 期間末日(境界内) | 受注日=基準日当日のデータ1件 | 当該1件が出力される(当日を含む設定の確認) |\n| B-5 | 期間翌日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日の翌日のデータ1件(未来日) | 出力されない。出力されていたら定義書の含む/含まない記載と不整合として報告 |\n| B-6 | 上限ちょうど | 抽出期間内データが上限件数(仮定:100,000件)ちょうど | 全件出力。ヘッダ1+100,000=総行数100,001。受注番号の重複・欠番なし。打ち切り警告なし |\n| B-7 | 上限超過 | 抽出期間内データが上限+1件(100,001件) | 事前定義どおりの挙動:全件出力かつ上限超過の警告記録、または定義書通り打ち切り(いずれか定義書に一致)。期待結果は定義書の規定値を検査表に明記して確認 |\n\n※B-6/B-7の上限値は仮置き(100,000件)。実上限を開発部の定義書で確認のうえ確定します。\n\nレオさん、境界値パート完成です。規約・受入パートと統合してください。上限値の実数確認を取りまとめ時にお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "8ce8bad3-e9ed-4708-b170-d03076932825", + "name": "メイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "bbc7d36f-48ca-44dc-b6dc-e428f1b65b30", + "at": 1789186033016, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ハル 決定に基づき分担を割り当てます。ハルさんは異常系担当として検査表(異常系検査パート)を作成してください。生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表。全行に「入力条件」と「期待結果」を必ず記載し、期待結果は「中断し○○へ報告」形式で具体化。決定済み事項(スナップショット固定・部分ファイル出力禁止・再開判断者欄付き)を踏まえ、議論はやり直さず作成のみお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a8c38ca6-b58f-4bf0-9725-6823447ec2aa", + "at": 1789186047005, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ハル: 担当割り当てを受け、異常系検査パートを作成しました。決定事項(スナップショット固定・部分ファイル出力禁止・再開判断者欄)を踏まえています。\n\n## 異常系検査パート(担当日付:2026-09-12)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 | 再開判断者 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | CSV生成開始後(基準日時スナップショット確定後)に、抽出期間内の受注データへ追加・削除・更新が発生する | 件数・内容は基準日時のスナップショットで固定され、変動は一切反映されない。出力件数=スナップショット件数で行数一致。変動反映が確認された場合は中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告 | レオ |\n| E-2 | 途中失敗 | CSV生成処理の途中(例:全10万件中3万件書き込み済み)でDB接続断等の障害が発生する | 部分ファイルの出力継続は禁止。不完全なCSVは破棄(または隔離)し、中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告。エラー発生位置・時刻・対象件数を記録。再開は再開判断者の指示後に最初からやり直す(途中再開しない) | レオ |\n| E-3 | 権限なし | CSV生成権限を持たない検査実行者が生成を実行する | アクセス拒否されファイルは出力されない。中断し検査責任者(レオ)へ報告。権限付与または実行者変更の判断を待って再実行(無権限のままの再試行禁止) | レオ |\n\n※報告先・再開判断者は仮置き。取りまとめ時に開発部の定義書で正式な報告先を確認のうえ確定してください。\n\nレオさん、異常系パート完成です。規約・受入・境界値パートと統合をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "6033e190-9e6c-4404-b406-aad35ef23f08", + "name": "ハル" + } + }, + { + "id": "14b8c40f-3011-4f6b-bbec-bef78c8320b8", + "at": 1789186072163, + "role": "bot", + "text": "マコさん、両担当の成果が揃いました。私が規約検査・受入検査パートを作成し、4部構成で統合します。\n\n## CSV初期公開 検査表(統合版・2026-09-12)\n\n### 第1部 規約検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| R-1 | 文字コード | 生成されたCSVファイルをバイナリ確認 | UTF-8(BOM付き)。先頭3バイト=EF BB BF |\n| R-2 | 日付形式 | 受注日・更新日フィールド全件を確認 | YYYY-MM-DD形式(例:2026-03-01)。区切り記号・桁数の違反なし |\n| R-3 | 日付妥当性 | 各日付値の実在性を確認 | 存在しない日付(2/30等)なし。閏年2/29は正しく処理(2024-02-29は有効、2025-02-29は無効として検出) |\n| R-4 | 改行コード | 全行末尾を確認 | LF(0x0A)。CR・CRLF混入なし |\n| R-5 | RFC4180準拠 | カンマ・改行を含む値、空値を含むデータで生成 | 値はダブルクォートで適切に囲まれる。フィールド数=12で全行一致 |\n| R-6 | 項目数 | ヘッダと全データ行の項目数を確認 | 常に12項目(自由記述項目は除外済み) |\n\n### 第2部 受入検査\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| A-1 | 行数一致 | 任意の抽出条件で生成し、データ件数と総行数を突合 | ヘッダ1+データ件数=総行数で一致 |\n| A-2 | ヘッダ一致 | 生成CSVのヘッダ行を定義書と照合 | 項目名・順序とも定義書と完全一致(受注番号・受注日・更新日を必須含む) |\n| A-3 | 受注番号一意性 | 全データ行の受注番号を集計 | 重複なし・欠番なし(連続性は定義書の番号規則に従う) |\n| A-4 | 失敗時の扱い | 生成失敗を発生させる | 中断し開発部担当(マコ)へ報告。**報告先:マコ/再開判断者:レオ(QAリーダー)** を検査表通り1行明記 |\n\n### 第3部 境界値検査(担当:メイ)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 0件ケース | 抽出期間内に該当データ0件で生成 | ヘッダ1行のみ。総行数=1で行数一致。エラーなく正常終了 |\n| B-2 | 期間前日(境界外) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日の前日のデータ1件のみ | 出力されない(ヘッダのみ) |\n| B-3 | 期間初日(境界内) | 受注日=6ヶ月前同日のデータ1件 | 1件出力。総行数=2 |\n| B-4 | 期間末日(境界内) | 受注日=基準日当日のデータ1件 | 1件出力(基準日を含む設定の確認) |\n| B-5 | 期間翌日(境界外) | 受注日=基準日翌日のデータ1件(未来日) | 出力されない。出力されれば定義書と不整合として報告 |\n| B-6 | 上限ちょうど | 期間内データ=上限件数(仮:100,000件)ちょうど | 全件出力。総行数=100,001。重複・欠番なし。警告なし |\n| B-7 | 上限超過 | 期間内データ=上限+1件(100,001件) | 定義書規定どおり(全件出力+警告記録、または打ち切り)。規定値を検査表に明記のうえ確認 |\n\n### 第4部 異常系検査(担当:ハル)\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 入力条件 | 期待結果 | 再開判断者 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 生成開始後(スナップショット確定後)に抽出期間内データへ追加・削除・更新が発生 | 件数・内容は基準日時スナップショットで固定、変動は反映されない。行数一致。変動反映時は中断しマコへ報告 | レオ |\n| E-2 | 途中失敗 | 生成途中(例:10万件中3万件書き込み済み)でDB接続断等の障害 | 部分ファイル出力継続禁止。不完全CSVは破棄/隔離し、中断しマコへ報告。エラー位置・時刻・件数を記録。再開は指示後に最初からやり直す | レオ |\n| E-3 | 権限なし | 権限のない実行者が生成を実行 | アクセス拒否、ファイル出力なし。中断しレオへ報告。権限付与/実行者変更後に再実行(無権限の再試行禁止) | レオ |\n\n---\n\n【取りまとめメモ(マコさんへの確認事項)】\n1. **上限件数の実値**(B-6/B-7は100,000件で仮置き)→定義書確定値をご提示ください\n2. **基準日の含む/含まない**(B-2〜B-5は「6ヶ月前同日を含み・基準日当日を含む」設定例)→定義書記載値をご確認ください\n3. **報告先・再開判断者**(A-4/E-1〜E-3は報告先マコ・再開判断者レオで仮置き)→正式値をご指示ください\n\n以上、QAチームとして検査表を完成させました。レビューのうえレンさんへの報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "ea39599c-2409-4093-9057-6d09bafe9f11", + "name": "レオ" + } + } + ] + } + ], + "failedToolCalls": [ + { + "room": "経営会議", + "id": "93053dca-c368-44d5-9e06-27d4d6922104", + "at": 1789185634704, + "author": "ミナト", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "1f96ec42-0256-4889-b805-a194dbab87b0", + "at": 1789185753477, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "28a49ce0-1109-4f76-95c6-45e0ae7be741", + "at": 1789185804974, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "82d1865d-7cc2-4ca9-9c60-70818dfebb7d", + "at": 1789185860539, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "503d62bb-6c9e-48ec-9c38-ffa898d65f04", + "at": 1789185862161, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "447dbc07-5fd6-45c5-86e9-9f66d423dae5", + "at": 1789185770874, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "e3ccad07-98cb-4086-b640-9bb9e4b01bf9", + "at": 1789185820887, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "936c505b-1262-4924-91bc-a81b15b42231", + "at": 1789185821703, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "acc8b1d7-1ffa-407a-8876-801223861383", + "at": 1789185912399, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "9d02eb61-add5-4f72-9894-72f503eb0740", + "at": 1789185969770, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "f8746b4d-2dbe-4429-b7bf-1542efadf0c1", + "at": 1789185971370, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "QAチーム", + "id": "03dd4d8c-4ce7-4823-b45f-6baad44ca4b6", + "at": 1789185926467, + "author": "レオ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "QAチーム", + "id": "2c6571bd-60bb-44d0-a4ae-7f9f743ba2a3", + "at": 1789185989846, + "author": "レオ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "QAチーム", + "id": "675d078d-af31-46aa-845a-d0c1ebf2b1a6", + "at": 1789185991358, + "author": "レオ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ae9ea8f5b0 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5af250d7bc Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/qa-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3c3d65d48d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +*.json text eol=lf +*.csv text eol=lf +*.txt text eol=lf +*.py text eol=lf diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/README.md b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..60f2a9d574 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,111 @@ +# Live verification after review fixes — 2026-09-12 + +The reviewed implementation preserves three organizational layers within one +company section. Five groups retain their original three members each. Chairs +discuss and decide, assign existing members, and those members request downstream +work. Results return through those owners before their chairs consolidate them. + +- Upstream base: `2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c`. +- Tested implementation: `d75b009b15a561e09873961d548e89a619464efe`. +- Provider: **Claude Code 2.1.251 / GLM-5.3 / low** for all fifteen bots. +- Time: **04:55:00–05:02:10 UTC**, about 7 minutes 10 seconds. +- One isolated fixture; all fifteen bots are in section `検証会社`. +- **45 provider turns**, all completed successfully; **5 work nodes, 7 discussion + rounds, 10 member assignments**, all completed. The scheduler accounts for 44 + executions after the original user-started turn. +- **15 failed tool calls** occurred during execution; later calls recovered and + the workflow settled. These are not counted as successful tool calls. +- No agents were invited, moved or added to downstream groups. + +This run follows the section-isolation review fix. The earlier +[live run](../live-2026-09-12/README.md) remains historical evidence for its pinned +implementation; its separate-section fixture is not the current configuration. + +## What each group discussed + +| Layer / group | Discussion, decision and resulting responsibility | +| --- | --- | +| 1 / Executive | Aoi opposed exporting every field and row because of scope and sensitive fields. Yui required seven sales fields. Minato revised the plan to a limited three-month / 10,000-row release, collected a second round of responses, then assigned Aoi to Development and Yui to Sales. | +| 2 / Development | Ritsu requested fixed headers and conditional loss reasons. Mako identified missing post-write counts, restart behavior and date boundaries. Ren revised the acceptance criteria, obtained second-round agreement, then assigned Ritsu to Implementation and Mako to QA. | +| 2 / Sales | Saki proposed three FAQ answers. Towa required restrictions on data handling and an explicit customer-ID matching explanation. Kou incorporated the amendment and assigned Saki the FAQ and Towa a five-item checklist. | +| 3 / Implementation | Hina proposed covering three deal statuses and defining single-character surname handling. Nagi requested both date boundaries and fixed reason vocabulary. Sora decided on a five-row sample, assigned Hina the CSV and Nagi inspection of that actual CSV. | +| 3 / QA | Leo identified a seven-versus-eight-column ambiguity in Mako's brief. Mei and Haru discussed boundaries, empty output, partial failures and restart behavior; Leo assigned them three boundary and three failure cases respectively. | + +The branching path is Executive → Development/Sales → Implementation/QA. +Member assignments stay inside their existing group and do not add a layer. + +## Actual UI screenshots + +The screenshots are from the real renderer connected to the disposable live +fixture. They show discussions, decisions, work results and the final idle state. + +| Group | Discussion | Results | +| --- | --- | --- | +| Executive | [Discussion](executive-discussion.png) | [Final consolidation](executive-results.png) | +| Development | [Discussion](development-discussion.png) | [Decision and assignment](development-decision.png), [upstream report](development-results.png) | +| Sales | [Discussion](sales-discussion.png) | [FAQ/checklist review](sales-results.png) | +| Implementation | [Discussion](implementation-discussion.png) | [CSV](implementation-csv.png), [result review](implementation-results.png) | +| QA | [Discussion](qa-discussion.png) | [Inspection cases](qa-results.png) | + +## Artifact acceptance remains incomplete + +Workflow completion is not proof that the generated artifacts meet the final +decision. This run exposes a concrete failure of cross-team acceptance: + +1. Hina produced a **seven-column** CSV with the customer ID embedded in the + customer-name cell. Nagi inspected that version. The source message is + `8e73f4de-8afc-4045-86bf-adb382dc5d34`. +2. QA interpreted the brief as **eight independent columns**. Ren, Aoi and Minato + subsequently approved eight columns as the formal specification, but did not + request or produce a revised CSV. The final executive reply nevertheless + claims the artifacts are consistent. They are not. +3. Sales kept the seven-field language, and its FAQ used a June–August example + while Development fixed the interval to June 12–September 12 inclusive. +4. QA's overflow case combines 10,001 rows with two out-of-range dates; excluding + those rows would leave 9,999 eligible rows. The count at which the limit is + applied needs an explicit decision before this is a usable acceptance test. + +The independent [checker](check_csv.py) parses the actual chat CSV and reproduces +nine checks against the implementation's draft contract. Its +[result](csv-checks.json) also explicitly records **`passesFinalColumnContract: +false`** (expected 8, actual 7). No bot-created file bytes, export implementation, +privacy guarantee, or autonomous production readiness are validated here. + +```sh +python docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py +``` + +## Records and review regression checks + +- [Transcripts, addresses, section/model selections and request tree](transcripts.json). +- [Provider start/completion events](provider-turns.json). +- [Extracted draft CSV](sample.csv), [independent draft/final checks](csv-checks.json). +- [SHA-256 manifest](sha256.txt) covers screenshots, JSON and CSV. Text artifacts + are pinned to LF for Windows checkout consistency. + +Typecheck and lint passed. The six other focused suites passed, and all 17 +lifecycle tests passed with `--pool=threads --maxWorkers=1`: 134 focused tests +combined. The section-change regression also passed separately with the default +fork pool. Some local Windows fork-pool attempts exited unexpectedly; these are +not reported as green suite runs. Full cross-platform CI is recorded on the PR. + +New regression coverage includes duplicate routes through real MCP validation, +foreign recipients and silent readers, mixed-section discussions/assignments, +discovery filtering, section changes while queued with withheld results, the +4,000-character boundary, incidental mentions, and terminal group notifications. + +```sh +pnpm exec vitest run server/room-handoffs.test.ts server/mcp-server.test.ts server/drivers/agents-proxy.test.ts server/room-handoffs.e2e.test.ts server/room-discussion.e2e.test.ts server/room-pyramid.e2e.test.ts --maxWorkers=1 +pnpm exec vitest run server/room-handoffs-lifecycle.e2e.test.ts --pool=threads --maxWorkers=1 +``` + +The live command was: + +```sh +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts .omb-scratch/review-live-20260912/verification.json --live --preview +``` + +The configured Claude/GLM profile was copied into the disposable fixture using +the documented environment allowlist. Credentials and machine paths are omitted +from these public records. The fixture and preview are stopped after capture; +the user's live app/data are not modified. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..aa51de65cf --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/check_csv.py @@ -0,0 +1,48 @@ +"""Check the actual draft CSV separately from the later eight-column decision.""" +import csv +import io +import json +import re +from datetime import date +from pathlib import Path + +root = Path(__file__).parent +report = json.loads((root / 'transcripts.json').read_text(encoding='utf-8')) +room = next(t for t in report['transcripts'] if t['name'] == '実装チーム') +message = next(m for m in room['messages'] + if m.get('from', {}).get('name') == 'ヒナ' and '```csv' in m.get('text', '')) +source = re.search(r'```csv\n(.*?)\n```', message['text'], re.S).group(1) +with (root / 'sample.csv').open('w', encoding='utf-8', newline='') as output: + output.write(source) +rows = list(csv.reader(io.StringIO(source), strict=True)) +header = '顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由'.split(',') +reasons = {'価格', '機能不足', '競合選択', 'タイミング', '決裁権者未了', 'その他'} +checks = { + 'matches_implementation_draft_header': rows[0] == header, + 'five_data_rows': len(rows) == 6, + 'seven_columns_each_row': all(len(r) == 7 for r in rows), + 'dates_in_draft_interval': all(date(2026, 6, 12) <= date.fromisoformat(r[2]) <= date(2026, 9, 12) for r in rows[1:]), + 'both_date_boundaries_present': {'2026-06-12', '2026-09-12'} <= {r[2] for r in rows[1:]}, + 'unique_contract_ids': len({r[1] for r in rows[1:]}) == 5, + 'masked_names_with_distinct_embedded_customer_ids': all(re.fullmatch(r'.?■ C\d{5}', r[0]) for r in rows[1:]) and len({r[0].split()[-1] for r in rows[1:]}) == 5, + 'statuses_and_conditional_loss_reasons': {r[4] for r in rows[1:]} == {'商談中', '受注', '失注'} and all((r[6] in reasons if r[4] == '失注' else r[6] == '') for r in rows[1:]), + 'integer_amounts_or_empty_for_lost_deals': all((r[5] == '' if r[4] == '失注' else bool(re.fullmatch(r'\d+', r[5]))) for r in rows[1:]), +} +result = { + 'sourceMessageId': message['id'], 'sourceAuthor': 'ヒナ', + 'draftChecks': checks, 'draftChecksPassed': all(checks.values()), + 'finalAcceptance': { + 'expectedColumns': 8, 'actualColumns': len(rows[0]), + 'separateCustomerIdColumn': '顧客ID' in rows[0], + 'passesFinalColumnContract': len(rows[0]) == 8 and '顧客ID' in rows[0], + }, + 'limits': ['Extracted chat text, not a bot-created file.', + 'Passing draft checks does not satisfy the later eight-column decision.', + 'No file-byte, runtime export, or production-readiness claim.'], +} +with (root / 'csv-checks.json').open('w', encoding='utf-8', newline='\n') as output: + output.write(json.dumps(result, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + '\n') +print(json.dumps(result, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2)) +assert result['draftChecksPassed'] +# This historical run must reproduce the recorded final-contract failure too. +assert not result['finalAcceptance']['passesFinalColumnContract'] diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..09f0a5c9e4 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/csv-checks.json @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +{ + "sourceMessageId": "8e73f4de-8afc-4045-86bf-adb382dc5d34", + "sourceAuthor": "ヒナ", + "draftChecks": { + "matches_implementation_draft_header": true, + "five_data_rows": true, + "seven_columns_each_row": true, + "dates_in_draft_interval": true, + "both_date_boundaries_present": true, + "unique_contract_ids": true, + "masked_names_with_distinct_embedded_customer_ids": true, + "statuses_and_conditional_loss_reasons": true, + "integer_amounts_or_empty_for_lost_deals": true + }, + "draftChecksPassed": true, + "finalAcceptance": { + "expectedColumns": 8, + "actualColumns": 7, + "separateCustomerIdColumn": false, + "passesFinalColumnContract": false + }, + "limits": [ + "Extracted chat text, not a bot-created file.", + "Passing draft checks does not satisfy the later eight-column decision.", + "No file-byte, runtime export, or production-readiness claim." + ] +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-decision.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-decision.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..746d3591b3 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-decision.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..589324968b Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..e145a43dbd Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/development-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d851740d84 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..38698f31f4 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/executive-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-csv.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-csv.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..002285fe8e Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-csv.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..64c311f1e5 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..192dad979b Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/implementation-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d5ffab4866 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/provider-turns.json @@ -0,0 +1,902 @@ +[ + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwvj38-0", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "2c640489-5f93-4423-80f0-cfe5b712cc85", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:00.452Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwvwf6-5t", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "2c640489-5f93-4423-80f0-cfe5b712cc85", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:17.730Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwvwib-5u", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "54b3338c-0979-416e-aac7-ee33b64e54e6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:17.843Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxww33t-b9", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "54b3338c-0979-416e-aac7-ee33b64e54e6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:26.393Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxww376-ba", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "26a232ef-f128-456b-9203-72a50fdb3e5e", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:26.514Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwwbth-gj", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "26a232ef-f128-456b-9203-72a50fdb3e5e", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:37.685Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwwcah-gk", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "87eaf6be-7475-433e-97db-ac27a3d092a6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:55:38.297Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwwvwe-lh", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "87eaf6be-7475-433e-97db-ac27a3d092a6", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:03.710Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwwvzq-li", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "d752bef8-5611-4a1d-9d1c-73fd0d700604", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:03.830Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwx2j8-qq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "d752bef8-5611-4a1d-9d1c-73fd0d700604", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:12.308Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwx2l5-qr", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "43c56967-2bad-4ffa-8356-15a614c84bee", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:12.377Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwx9pd-w2", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "43c56967-2bad-4ffa-8356-15a614c84bee", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:21.601Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwxa5w-w3", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "e8816367-471b-4973-9672-b3a34ed08916", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:22.196Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwxtk1-17e", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "e8816367-471b-4973-9672-b3a34ed08916", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:47.329Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwxtoe-17f", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "9fac2e84-7363-4d8f-84ae-ac9bf621ecba", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:56:47.486Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwy3lf-1bl", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "9fac2e84-7363-4d8f-84ae-ac9bf621ecba", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:00.339Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwy3r5-1bm", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "b809c43e-da0b-4d12-a41e-83470fe1690d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:00.545Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyffh-1gg", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "b809c43e-da0b-4d12-a41e-83470fe1690d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:15.677Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0ono-4ok", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "87de82b1-f8ea-4bc4-93a4-1ea7eba4e10f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:00.948Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0wlx-57p", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "87de82b1-f8ea-4bc4-93a4-1ea7eba4e10f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:11.253Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx48vt-d48", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "74979b08-7a24-41e5-be6b-fcf0b2aefd5d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:47.129Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx4gus-dgu", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "74979b08-7a24-41e5-be6b-fcf0b2aefd5d", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:57.460Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx4h4q-dgv", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "c952f80e-e8ab-4a01-b37d-50a65c1d0557", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:57.818Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx4qt5-dxf", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "turnId": "c952f80e-e8ab-4a01-b37d-50a65c1d0557", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:02:10.361Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwy3rp-1bn", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "ae2014d9-3564-4c81-91bb-ad49c51a628a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:00.565Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwym17-1kx", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "ae2014d9-3564-4c81-91bb-ad49c51a628a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:24.235Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwym3v-1ky", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "b5228896-7f28-4f3b-81e3-c2feaffb2cee", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:24.331Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyssw-1r8", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "b5228896-7f28-4f3b-81e3-c2feaffb2cee", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:33.008Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwysut-1r9", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "53f82125-52fb-46d9-b4bc-dd949fc67c15", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:33.077Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyz09-21s", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "53f82125-52fb-46d9-b4bc-dd949fc67c15", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:41.049Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyzb6-21t", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "7e542445-2b2d-4491-b820-14f3f17c63b0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:41.442Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzgmz-2q0", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "7e542445-2b2d-4491-b820-14f3f17c63b0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:03.899Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzgs8-2q1", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "1da6044b-0a66-4b98-96fa-92810dbc9e1a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:04.088Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwznxb-2wp", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "1da6044b-0a66-4b98-96fa-92810dbc9e1a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:13.343Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzo13-2wq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "e0134af4-7e10-4019-8a56-5f616ca0230a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:13.479Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwztv0-325", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "e0134af4-7e10-4019-8a56-5f616ca0230a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:21.037Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzuc2-326", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "f4de7e6c-0f78-4229-b948-3bbc50f0a4cd", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:21.650Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0cb7-3sm", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "f4de7e6c-0f78-4229-b948-3bbc50f0a4cd", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:44.947Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0ckh-3sn", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "f5d152d6-7390-4867-b6f9-97eaab8d572b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:45.281Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0vvj-55i", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "f5d152d6-7390-4867-b6f9-97eaab8d572b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:10.303Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0w60-55m", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "39cd50dc-f15b-46b3-a6b3-3fe420eee561", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:10.680Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1ct1-5o7", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "39cd50dc-f15b-46b3-a6b3-3fe420eee561", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:32.245Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx33oy-9mq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "b831a1b8-f841-487d-9541-d790236ddbb2", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:53.746Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3bwk-ap3", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "b831a1b8-f841-487d-9541-d790236ddbb2", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:04.388Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3off-bp6", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "29cd9450-c07f-47d9-adf9-de0d8de54524", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:20.619Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3vbx-c5c", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "29cd9450-c07f-47d9-adf9-de0d8de54524", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:29.565Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3vlx-c5d", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "8a984b35-ce31-4966-9a4e-a70f7c49dc5a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:29.925Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx48m8-d47", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "turnId": "8a984b35-ce31-4966-9a4e-a70f7c49dc5a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:46.784Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyfol-1gh", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "756b7e48-2be3-4f32-b348-ed374a7cf5bc", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:16.005Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyxx3-1xm", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "756b7e48-2be3-4f32-b348-ed374a7cf5bc", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:39.639Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwyy2u-1xn", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "32e23285-b977-48c2-bf33-02442dcbf4e0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:39.846Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwz4cz-2c2", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "32e23285-b977-48c2-bf33-02442dcbf4e0", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:47.987Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwz4fh-2c5", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "e2f1210c-9e26-44e4-9532-0f838c57ac5b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:48.077Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzcaz-2j4", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "e2f1210c-9e26-44e4-9532-0f838c57ac5b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:58.283Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzckf-2j5", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "9f2f235c-801d-4ec1-a1d8-819ea7d57ed1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:57:58.623Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzwvk-36b", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "9f2f235c-801d-4ec1-a1d8-819ea7d57ed1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:24.944Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxwzxcp-36c", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "c71e6ccc-c3f1-4309-92ae-e6e732098097", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:25.561Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx05o1-3oz", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "c71e6ccc-c3f1-4309-92ae-e6e732098097", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:36.337Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx05wv-3p0", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "b81997cc-4e3c-4fec-8fd5-c275969679a9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:36.655Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0f7w-444", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "b81997cc-4e3c-4fec-8fd5-c275969679a9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:48.716Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0fn7-445", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "698e227a-9d1a-47d8-b2f6-b7b65441af3f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:49.267Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0n0x-4oj", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "turnId": "698e227a-9d1a-47d8-b2f6-b7b65441af3f", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:58:58.833Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx0w5b-55l", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "9bb1ec04-54d7-40f2-aef9-3e0e652a9f73", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:10.655Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1d23-5ql", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "9bb1ec04-54d7-40f2-aef9-3e0e652a9f73", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:32.571Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1d79-5qn", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "6473fd30-9490-4267-8b5a-2d5cdc87e9e1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:32.757Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1l2q-607", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "6473fd30-9490-4267-8b5a-2d5cdc87e9e1", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:42.962Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1l54-608", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "d2f378a9-2acb-4675-8638-e8097fa26c77", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:43.048Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1sz7-6bj", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "d2f378a9-2acb-4675-8638-e8097fa26c77", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:53.203Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1th4-6bk", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "3f57b32c-c148-4005-ba9a-7c6342e17d1a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:53.848Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2be7-78e", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "3f57b32c-c148-4005-ba9a-7c6342e17d1a", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:17.071Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2bna-78f", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "31456fe5-ebc6-492a-87d7-1919712aa8bd", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:17.398Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2k0e-84c", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "31456fe5-ebc6-492a-87d7-1919712aa8bd", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:28.238Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2k8e-84d", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "beacf692-303a-40b3-8492-f06b437b95a4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:28.526Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2uq1-8so", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "beacf692-303a-40b3-8492-f06b437b95a4", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:42.121Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2vxo-8sp", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "b5945448-b46b-4a89-ab09-020f8cdfed5c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:43.692Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx33bx-9mp", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "turnId": "b5945448-b46b-4a89-ab09-020f8cdfed5c", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:53.277Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1d3m-5qm", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "b1c38760-5892-4324-a4aa-c0144145f16b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:32.626Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1p9c-645", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "b1c38760-5892-4324-a4aa-c0144145f16b", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:48.384Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1pm9-646", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "87bbb5c8-bf49-4a76-a786-f554cc282887", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:48.849Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1wam-6hs", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "87bbb5c8-bf49-4a76-a786-f554cc282887", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:57.502Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx1wcw-6ht", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "11814eb4-4120-441f-8c9c-aa9f6cdbbfa9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T04:59:57.584Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx24bn-6yr", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "11814eb4-4120-441f-8c9c-aa9f6cdbbfa9", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:07.907Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx24x2-6ys", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "85004cdc-749f-43c7-bf63-aa5c2a869203", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:08.678Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2tbo-8mx", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "85004cdc-749f-43c7-bf63-aa5c2a869203", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:40.308Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx2tk1-8my", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "d7f838fc-15c7-4cd5-ad9c-bd5208fc4962", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:40.609Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3564-9tq", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "d7f838fc-15c7-4cd5-ad9c-bd5208fc4962", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:55.660Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3590-9tr", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "1b230fbb-d5b7-4d79-bbe6-88b07be4deed", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:00:55.764Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3cgr-asc", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "1b230fbb-d5b7-4d79-bbe6-88b07be4deed", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:05.115Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3cy3-asd", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "fcb23253-bd84-486e-85ec-f3639613b784", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:05.739Z", + "type": "turn.started" + }, + { + "eventId": "ev-mtxx3o04-bp5", + "provider": "claudeAgent", + "providerInstanceId": "claude", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "turnId": "fcb23253-bd84-486e-85ec-f3639613b784", + "createdAt": "2026-09-12T05:01:20.068Z", + "type": "turn.completed", + "ok": true, + "stopReason": "end_turn" + } +] diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..26e1851854 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..01b44a3312 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/qa-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4dfbffcee7 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3ada6f934d Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sales-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sample.csv b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sample.csv new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..de06f9bd10 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sample.csv @@ -0,0 +1,6 @@ +顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由 +山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000, +鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000, +高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格 +■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択 +伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000, \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..ecd9f34563 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/sha256.txt @@ -0,0 +1,16 @@ +aab82e4d55e75a9f3a5fdb67e945c260a7359afe017624932e56cd063225e7ca csv-checks.json +1bba4bf6d41c8c5c26c40cfb4521bf7cca8a37510ae0982e89d29093655d44a5 development-decision.png +35389f966349e3ec1200a10ca71ca82fbdee2d3f58c77c17724ebeb46577c3ae development-discussion.png +51c123f1d0760a303e75e601d917ab9d1db36d219b193b1dbe226167c552dc0f development-results.png +fb14b8d5fe4cb5b68b0b91b1f1487e6b1b6c667eaa3dc7ef74a83724e327a5a8 executive-discussion.png +c9f20cc8869ec92de24b2aedc44aa9a86275eb3f2c41c524c1575f4118224460 executive-results.png +85200ec22d31bdf9768eebfc4894b95779adb7f93608458a704be80d9a2673b9 implementation-csv.png +eef3d6ad5bc465848fb4550d2c1df5049acd86484a8bc222a49a2bba7a9fdeaf implementation-discussion.png +ed081b1cbac70eadef450dca0de9ff85548bef18fb4b4125901cdf42d50e30e0 implementation-results.png +275794a82428c8715f20cfd7a0b11239e9c52d615eef200e1256f33ac6c40c78 provider-turns.json +77c5b674b70e581e8f888e438d3bf4169b472fe4febcf64409ddaae8b8c06e23 qa-discussion.png +95e57e03e5a682f9fac639c73882de721c87432164f52d6c3654599d7c4164d5 qa-results.png +0505708ea8ebcc6f9b94f528a9b085cdaed07b139303b55c30a36aa4c8e3afd1 sales-discussion.png +c8cd571626ea0ca061d6cfee916401b154d1407494dfb288b5cd96800fcff2da sales-results.png +3e4ea7dcba6f891059f2d5775547e4317fc7f3811849448fa18bce9d30a2dfac sample.csv +7f905a4aeba8f80fa80308fd1133b4ec5c753ab5137966a29472ad7aa5714854 transcripts.json diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..4045d93f81 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/review-live-2026-09-12/transcripts.json @@ -0,0 +1,1563 @@ +{ + "verifiedAt": "2026-09-12T05:02:10.821Z", + "upstreamBase": "2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c", + "testedHead": "d75b009b15a561e09873961d548e89a619464efe", + "mode": "live Claude Code 2.1.251 / GLM-5.3 / low; isolated fixture", + "orchestrationPassed": true, + "counts": { + "rooms": 5, + "bots": 15, + "providerTurns": 45, + "schedulerExecutions": 44, + "work": 5, + "discussion": 7, + "assignment": 10, + "failedToolCalls": 15 + }, + "rooms": [ + { + "id": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "name": "経営会議", + "members": [ + { + "id": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "name": "開発部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "name": "営業部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "c1a7e0d1-3625-4449-94cd-8df02fdd1092", + "name": "サキ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "e3fe7958-7817-454f-840b-978b30a56022", + "name": "トワ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "name": "実装チーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "0addcf8e-d3aa-47ce-ae32-5db9fbc26092", + "name": "ヒナ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "cc2c68a3-344b-4657-ac5b-d1a35007c13c", + "name": "ナギ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "name": "QAチーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "84054883-a08d-4548-b859-416e30012dc3", + "name": "メイ", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + }, + { + "id": "44b822df-6c11-4a65-9fcf-75095ceb9c0c", + "name": "ハル", + "section": "検証会社", + "modelSelection": { + "instanceId": "claude", + "model": "glm-5.3", + "effort": "low" + } + } + ] + } + ], + "nodes": [ + { + "id": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "groupId": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 44, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789188911831, + "text": "", + "result": "@アオイ @ユイ 両担当の報告を受領しました。レビュー内容を照合し、いずれも経営会議の決定事項(条件込み)を満たしていることを確認しました。経営会議として統合し、案件を完結します。\n\n【CSV出力公開準備 統合報告(最終)】\n\n■決定事項(再掲)\n初期CSV:営業必需7項目+顧客ID併記(独立8列)・直近3ヶ月・1万件上限・顧客名は姓のみマスキング・機微項目除外・失注理由6分類固定・第2弾は3ヶ月以内に絞り込み・失注理由詳細化を決定書明記。\n\n■成果物\n1. 架空CSVサンプル(開発部:ソラ・ヒナ作成、ナギ検査13項目✓、リツ承認、アオイレビュー済み)——8列仕様で承認。開発部の「顧客ID独立列」決定を経営会議としても正式採用します(名寄けは顧客IDで行う決定趣旨に合致)。\n2. 検査表(QA:レオ取りまとめ、マコ承認)——境界値3+異常系6ケース。顧客ID空欄NG・一意性検査込み。アオイ条件①反映を確認。\n3. 顧客向けFAQ 3問(営業部:サキ作成、コウ承認)——マスキング・上限理由・第2弾拡張をカバー。\n4. 営業運用チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成)——7項目固定・6分類選択・分割禁止・持ち出し禁止・復元禁止。ユイ両条件の反映を確認。\n\n■結論\n4成果物とも決定事項と整合し、FAQ・チェックリストとCSV仕様(8列・6分類)の間にも不整合なし。両担当タスク完了を了承し、初期公開準備は完了とします。第2弾(2026/12/12までに絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)は決定書どおり次回案件。ご依頼ありがとうございました。" + }, + { + "id": "fe888834-0814-455f-9375-786f24df1844", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "groupId": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789188911831, + "text": "CSV出力の初期対象について議論します。仮案は「全項目・全件出力」。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定を主張、ユイは営業に必要な項目の要求を表明してください。それぞれ意見と理由を述べてください。", + "result": "アオイ: @ミナト 1巡目の意見です。仮案「全項目・全件出力」には反対です。理由は、全項目出力には個人情報・内部IDなどの機微項目のマスキング設計が入り、公開前の承認プロセスが長期化するからです。早期公開のため初期は「基本項目・直近3ヶ月分・件数上限1万件」に限定し、絞り込み条件と項目追加は第2弾で段階拡張する案を主張します。リスクはユイ側の要求項目不足ですが、第2弾で吸収できます。まず限定版で価値を早く出すことを優先すべきです。\n\nユイ: @ミナト 1巡目の意見です。営業視点で、初期対象に含めるべき項目を要求します。顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由の7項目は提案書・月末進捗報告に必須で、これが欠けると営業は結局手作業で再集計し、CSV公開の意味が薄れます。特に失注理由は改善施策の根拠になる最重要項目です。一方で件数は直近3ヶ月・1万件上限で構いません。リスクとして、初期に項目を絞りすぎると顧客説明コストが二度発生する点を挙げます。第2弾の確約を条件に限定案にも前向きです。" + }, + { + "id": "ef31d788-72dd-4592-8a85-4da0e6ee209f", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "groupId": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789188957387, + "text": "2巡目:ミナト修正案「初期は営業必需7項目(顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限で公開。ただし顧客名は簡易マスキング(姓のみ+顧客ID併記)とし機微項目・内部IDは除外。第2弾で絞り込み・項目拡張・失注理由詳細化を確約」。この妥協案への賛否と懸念をそれぞれ述べてください。", + "result": "アオイ: @ミナト 2巡目の回答です。修正案に賛成します。私の主張していた「早期公開・対象限定」の趣旨(機微項目除外・件数上限・段階拡張)が全て盛り込まれ、顧客名マスキングも簡易で実装コストが低く抑えられる点を評価します。\n\n懸念は2点。①姓のみマスキングでも同姓多数の場合は実質特定され得るため、顧客ID併記を必須要件として検査表に含めるべきです。②「第2弾確約」が確約として機能するよう、期限(例:初期公開から3ヶ月以内)と拡張項目リストを決定書に明記してほしいです。この2点を条件に承認します。\n\nユイ: @ミナト 2巡目の回答です。修正案に賛成します。要求した7項目が全て初期対象に含まれ、件数条件も営業用途に十分です。顧客名の簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記は、顧客向説明の観点からもむしろ歓迎します。\n\n懸念は2点。①失注理由が初期は簡易区分になると思われますが、集計時に「その他」へ寄らないよう区分定義(5〜7分類)を初期から固定してほしい。②第2弾の期限と拡張項目(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記し、営業側の説明コストが二度発生しないようしてほしい。この2点を条件に承認します。" + }, + { + "id": "638dae80-ff72-4238-aaa0-769528122121", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "groupId": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789188998664, + "text": "決定事項(条件込みで確定):初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張項目(絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。アオイ担当:開発部レン(group_id=88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019, bot_id=5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231)へsend_room_messageで依頼。開発部でも2巡議論後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼。成果物は架空CSVサンプル・検査表(顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に含める)。結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えること。", + "result": "@ミナト 開発部担当アオイより報告します。\n\n**開発部成果物レビュー結果：承認、担当タスク完了です。**\n\nレンの報告を経営会議の決定事項と照合しました。\n\n- **架空CSVサンプル**:7項目+顧客ID併記、直近3ヶ月(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)、失注行のみ失注理由記載(6分類内)、ナギ検査13項目全✓——決定通り。\n- **検査表**:境界値3+異常系3の6ケース。私の2巡目条件①「顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に」は顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID一意性検査として反映済み。\n\n**修正点を1点承認します**:「7項目+顧客ID併記」の実態に合わせ、顧客IDを独立列とする8列を正式仕様とする開発部決定は、決定の趣旨(マスキング済み顧客名の名寄せは顧客IDで)を満たすため妥当と判断します。\n\n条件②(第2弾3ヶ月以内・拡張項目の決定書明記)も次回案件として明記済み。ユイ報告の営業部成果物(FAQ・チェックリスト)と併せ、統合をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "03fb1e5b-29eb-45c8-9de7-0c435b4cbf08", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "groupId": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "threadId": "46d81fd0-25f6-4c5c-8bcd-992e452b4e36", + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189000718, + "text": "決定事項(条件込みで確定):初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。ユイ担当:営業部コウ(group_id=485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f, bot_id=7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4)へsend_room_messageで依頼。営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。成果物は顧客向けFAQ・営業運用チェックリスト。結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えること。", + "result": "@ミナト 営業部担当ユイより報告します。\n\n**営業部成果物レビュー結果:承認、担当タスク完了です。**\n\nコウの報告(FAQ・チェックリスト両承認)を私の方でも経営会議の決定事項と照合しました。\n\n- 顧客向けFAQ 3問:Q1「姓のみマスキングでも顧客IDで名寄せ可能」明記、マスキング理由・直近3ヶ月/1万件上限の理由・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張の3点をカバー。Q3で失注理由6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)を列挙——決定通り。\n- 営業運用チェックリスト 5項目:7項目固定・6分類から選択・件数超過時の分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・復元禁止。FAQの照合運用とも整合。\n\n私の2巡目の条件(6分類固定による「その他」偏り防止・第2弾明記による説明コスト二重化防止)はいずれも反映済みです。営業側はアオイ担当の開発部成果物(CSVサンプル・検査表)との統合を待つのみです。統合よろしくお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "d9c9e75d-3bf7-4a5c-8db2-77c0bc6eb546", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "638dae80-ff72-4238-aaa0-769528122121", + "groupId": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189017660, + "text": "経営会議決定に基づく依頼です(アオイより)。初期CSV公開の成果物作成を開発部でお願いします。\n\n【決定事項】初期CSV:営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張項目(絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。\n\n【依頼内容】開発部内で既存メンバー2名と2巡議論(1巡目は懸念出し、修正案を挟み2巡目で回答合意)→決定後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへsend_room_messageで分担。成果物:架空CSVサンプル・検査表(顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に含める)。実データ・コード変更不要、架空のみ。結果はアオイがレビューしミナトへ報告します。手順・経路は各グループの掲示を確認してください。", + "result": "@アオイ 【開発部取りまとめ報告】初期CSV公開の成果物が完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【経緯】リツ・マコと2巡議論を実施し、修正案①〜④(失注行のみ失注理由必須・件数事前+事後確認・失敗時全件やり直し・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)で両名合意のうえ決定。リツ→ソラ(実装)、マコ→レオ(QA)へ分担し、それぞれレビュー完了・承認済みです。\n\n【成果1:架空CSVサンプル(ソラ・ヒナ作成、ナギ検査13項目全✓、リツ承認)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(レオ取りまとめ、マコ承認)】境界値3ケース+異常系3ケースの計6ケース。件数0件・上限ちょうど10,000件・上限超過10,001件(6/11・9/13を弾く確認)・生成中の件数変化(前後不一致→全件やり直し)・生成途中失敗(部分ファイル破棄・再開手順明記)・書き込み権限なし。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性検査を含みます。\n\n【部長決定事項】依頼文の「7項目」は顧客ID併記を含むと実質8列が正であり、QA検査表の「顧客IDを独立列とする8項目」を正式仕様と採用します。サンプル5行は仕様確認用で、本番(1万件上限内・同一書式)では顧客IDを独立列にして適用します。第2弾(3ヶ月以内・絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)は決定書どおり次回以降の案件とします。以上、レビューのうえミナトさんへご報告ください。" + }, + { + "id": "db004715-75cd-4684-b61c-c3877b518742", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "03fb1e5b-29eb-45c8-9de7-0c435b4cbf08", + "groupId": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189030206, + "text": "経営会議決定事項(条件込みで確定)をお伝えします。初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記済み。依頼:営業部で1巡議論の後、既存メンバー(トワ・サキ等)へ成果物作成を分担してください。成果物は①顧客向けFAQ(マスキング・件数上限・第2弾拡張の説明を含む)②営業運用チェックリスト(7項目・6分類の使い方)。架空データでよく、実データ・コード変更は不要です。下層にも同じ「議論→分担→実行→レビュー→報告」の手順を伝えてください。結果はユイがレビューしてミナトへ報告します。", + "result": "両成果物をレビューしました。結果をご報告します。\n\n**レビュー結果:両方とも承認です。**\n\n- サキのFAQ3問:決定通り「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」がQ1に明記済み。マスキング理由・1万件/3ヶ月上限の理由・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張の3点すべてカバー。Q3での6分類列挙も適切。\n- トワのチェックリスト5項目:承認した5項目(7項目固定・6分類から選択・超過時分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・復元禁止)が過不足なく反映。FAQの照合運用・件数上限説明と整合確認済み。\n\n@ユイ 営業部での手順(議論1巡→決定→サキ・トワへ分担→実行→レビュー)を完遂しました。上記の通りFAQ3問・チェックリスト5項目が完成・承認済みです。レビューの上、ミナト様へご報告お願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "eec7a69c-8f11-4562-9e82-c254445b147a", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "d9c9e75d-3bf7-4a5c-8db2-77c0bc6eb546", + "groupId": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189038347, + "text": "経営会議決定による初期CSV公開の成果物(架空CSVサンプル・検査表)の1巡目懸念出し。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案:担当者が架空データを直接書き込み、件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で意見を。必須7項目(顧客名マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由6分類)、直近3ヶ月・1万件上限、顧客ID併記は検査表の必須検査項目。", + "result": "リツ: @レン リツです。処理の簡素さの観点から1巡目意見を述べます。\n\n仮案の「直接書き込み+件数事前確認のみ」は簡素で良いと思います。懸念は2点。①CSV設計:失注理由は商談ステータスが失注の行のみ必須にし、それ以外は空欄で統一しないと書き込み担当の判断が分かれません。②受入条件:件数確認だけでなく「ヘッダー行が必須7項目の順どおり」「失注理由が6分類以外にぶれない」の2点は検査表に明記しないと、簡素化の恩恵が崩れます。顧客ID併記は既に必須検査項目と了解。マコさんの途中失敗観点も聞きたいです。\n\nマコ: @レン @リツ マコです。途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点から1巡目意見を述べます。\n\n仮案懸念は3点。①直接書き込みは1万件規模で途中断違い・行ズレ・文字化けが起き得るのに、途中失敗時の再開手順が未定。②件数の「事前確認」だけでは、書き込み後の件数変化(重複行・欠落行)を検出できず、受入時に不整合が残ります。③契約日「直近3ヶ月」の境界(6/12〜9/12の解釈)が曖昧だと、当事者で件数認識がずれます。\n\n修正提案:書き込み後に件数の事後確認(前後一致)を必須化し、失敗時は全件やり直しで再開、境界日を明記。これらを検査表に追加すれば仮案でも受け入れ可能です。" + }, + { + "id": "c963266b-dbbd-4c80-9b72-0fa913716803", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "db004715-75cd-4684-b61c-c3877b518742", + "groupId": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "c1a7e0d1-3625-4449-94cd-8df02fdd1092", + "e3fe7958-7817-454f-840b-978b30a56022" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189052347, + "text": "経営会議決定の初期CSV公開(営業必需7項目・直近3ヶ月・1万件上限・姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記・失注理由6分類固定、第2弾は3ヶ月以内に絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を扱います。サキは顧客向けFAQ3問(マスキング・件数上限・第2弾拡張の説明を含む)の「便利さ」観点、トワは社内運用チェックリスト5項目(7項目・6分類の使い方)の「個人情報持出し制約」観点から意見を述べ、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的改善を加えてください。架空データのみ、実データ・コード変更不要。", + "result": "サキ: @コウ @トワ サキです。「便利さ」観点で意見します。FAQ3問は①「名前が一部伏字なのはなぜ?」→顧客ID併記で照合でき、機微情報を除外する安心設計と前向きに説明②「1万件・3ヶ月上限の理由」→初期運用の安定提供のためとし、超過分は第2弾で絞り込み改善と明記③「第2弾はいつ?」→3ヶ月以内の拡張決定済みと伝え期待を持たせる、構成を提案します。トワさんの個人情報制約観点の補強も歓迎です。\n\nトワ: @コウ @サキ トワです。サキさんのFAQ3問構成におおむね賛成です。顧客ID併記で照合の利便性と安全の両立を説明する点は良いと思います。改善提案として、①の回答に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記すれば便利さが増します。一方、個人情報制約の観点から、チェックリスト5項目は「7項目以外を持出さない(項目の追加禁止)」「失注理由は6分類から選択、自由記述で個人を特定する書き方をしない」「直近3ヶ月・1万件超過時は分割せず第2弾を待つ」「CSVの社外持ち出し・再配布禁止」「顧客IDで照合し姓マスキングを復元しない」を提案します。サキさんのFAQと整合するよう調整します。" + }, + { + "id": "916cb193-d75f-44b2-b046-2e08b9bab33b", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "d9c9e75d-3bf7-4a5c-8db2-77c0bc6eb546", + "groupId": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189078762, + "text": "【2巡目】修正案への回答確認。修正案:①CSV設計:失注理由は商談ステータス=失注の行のみ必須、それ以外は空欄統一。ヘッダーは必須7項目(顧客名マスキング+顧客ID併記を含む)の順どおり固定。②受入条件(検査表必須項目):件数の事前確認+書き込み後の件数事後確認(前後一致)、失注理由6分類固定のみ、ヘッダー7項目の順、顧客ID併記。③失敗時は全件やり直し(再開手順を検査表に明記)。④契約日の境界を2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)と明記、1万件上限。この修正案で両名とも合意できるか回答してください。", + "result": "リツ: @レン リツです。2巡目の回答です。\n\n修正案①〜④すべて私の1巡目懸念を反映しており、合意します。特に①の失注理由は失注行のみ必須・他は空欄統一で書き込み担当の判断が一意になり、簡素性が保てます。②でヘッダー7項目の順と6分類固定が検査表必須項目に入った点も、私の指摘の趣旨どおりです。④の境界日(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)の明記も処理の曖昧さを排除します。修正の必要はありません。マコさんのご確認もお願いします。\n\nマコ: @レン @リツ マコです。2巡目の回答です。\n\n修正案①〜④は私の1巡目懸念(再開手順未定・事後件数確認欠落・境界日曖昧)をすべて解消しており、合意します。特に②の事前+事後件数確認(前後一致)で重複・欠落を検出でき、③の全件やり直し手順の検査表明記で途中失敗時も一意に再開できます。④の境界日(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)明記も件数認識のずれを防げます。修正の必要はありません。両名合意済みのため、決定いただければQA側の分担(レオへの依頼)に進みます。" + }, + { + "id": "5030b01e-15f6-4634-a01c-3d730a66bd56", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "db004715-75cd-4684-b61c-c3877b518742", + "groupId": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "botId": "c1a7e0d1-3625-4449-94cd-8df02fdd1092", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189098242, + "text": "決定:FAQ3問はあなたの構成を承認、トワの改善を反映し①の回答に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記すること。顧客向けFAQ3問(マスキング理由・件数上限(1万件/3ヶ月)・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張)を架空データ・Q&A形式で作成し、完成物をこの会話に返してください。", + "result": "@コウ 承知しました。決定内容(私の構成+トワさんの改善反映)に沿って、顧客向けFAQ3問を作成します。\n\n---\n\n## 顧客向けFAQ(架空データ・Q&A形式)\n\n**Q1. CSVの顧客名が「田◯◯」など一部伏字になっているのはなぜですか?**\nA. お客様の個人情報保護のため、姓のみ簡易マスキングを施した安心設計です。氏名が一部伏字でも、併記された「顧客ID」で正確に照合(名寄せ)いただけます。姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能ですので、利便性は損なわれません。機微項目・内部IDは収録対象外です。\n\n**Q2. データ対象が「直近3ヶ月・1万件上限」なのはなぜですか?**\nA. 初期運用として安定した品質・速度でご提供するための設定です(例:2026年6〜8月分・最大10,000件)。上限を超える期間のお求めは、第2弾の絞り込み機能で柔軟に対応予定です。\n\n**Q3. 絞り込みや失注理由の詳細化はいつ使えますか?**\nA. 第2弾として初期公開から3ヶ月以内の拡張が決定済みです(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)。失注理由は現在6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)でご確認いただけます。\n\n---\n\nFAQ3問の完成物をお返しします。①に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記済みです。レビューのほどよろしくお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "d01f4f79-07e7-4892-8048-489a8f68c7c3", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "db004715-75cd-4684-b61c-c3877b518742", + "groupId": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "threadId": "d332a595-b55e-48dc-a07a-907b33ff4540", + "botId": "e3fe7958-7817-454f-840b-978b30a56022", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189099085, + "text": "決定:チェックリスト5項目はあなたの提案(7項目以外持出し禁止・6分類から選択し自由記述で個人特定しない・超過時は分割せず第2弾待ち・社外持ち出し再配布禁止・顧客ID照合で姓マスキング復元しない)を承認。社内運用チェックリスト5項目をチェック形式で作成し、この会話に返してください。サキのFAQ(顧客ID併記・件数上限は第2弾で改善との説明)と整合させること。", + "result": "@コウ 承知しました。決定内容に沿ってチェックリストを作成します。\n\n---\n\n## CSV初期公開 社内運用チェックリスト(担当営業用)\n\n**□ 1. 項目は7項目のみ(追加禁止)**\n顧客名(姓マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由のみ。機微項目・内部IDの持出し・項目追加はしない。\n\n**□ 2. 失注理由は6分類から選択**\n価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他。自由記述で個人を特定する書き方はしない(「その他」選択時も具体の個人名・固有情報を書かない)。\n\n**□ 3. 対象は直近3ヶ月・1万件上限**\n超過時は分割して取得せず、第2弾(初期公開から3ヶ月以内、絞り込み拡充)を待つ。\n\n**□ 4. 社外持ち出し・再配布禁止**\nCSVを社外へ持ち出さない。第三者への再配布・共有も禁止。\n\n**□ 5. マスキング復元禁止**\n顧客IDでの照合・名寄せは可能だが、姓マスキングを復元しない(FAQ記載の照合運用と整合)。\n\n---\n\nサキさんのFAQ(顧客ID併記による名寄せ可・件数上限は第2弾で改善予定の説明)と整合済みです。レビューのほどよろしくお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "8e296bb9-ad25-43b4-9976-4dfbab019975", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "d9c9e75d-3bf7-4a5c-8db2-77c0bc6eb546", + "groupId": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189120901, + "text": "決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づき、リツに実装側の分担を割り当てます。send_room_message(group_id=773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5, bot_id=ソラ)で架空CSVサンプル作成を依頼してください。仕様:必須7項目(顧客名は姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)、失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)記入・他は空欄、契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む、1万件上限、ヘッダー7項目の順固定。実データ不要・架空のみ。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えてください。", + "result": "ソラさんの成果を開発部の決定事項(①〜④)と照合しレビューしました。結果、問題なしと判断します。\n\n【レビュー結果:適合・承認】\n- ①ヘッダーは必須7項目の順どおり固定✓。失注理由は失注行のみ記入(価格・競合選択=6分類内)・他は空欄統一✓。マスキングは姓1文字+■+顧客ID併記(姓1文字は全■の取り扱いも明記)✓\n- ②件数事前6行=事後6行一致✓、顧客ID併記は全行で確認済み✓、語彙固定もナギ検査表13項目で全項目✓\n- ③失敗時全件やり直し手順は下層決定事項に含まれ検査済み✓\n- ④契約日は2026-06-12と2026-09-12の両端を各1行で含みISO形式、上限内✓\n\n補足として、サンプル5行は仕様確認用の少数件数で、本番は1万件上限の枠内で同じ書式を適用という理解で問題ありません。\n\n@レン 【実装側報告】ソラ→リツの成果物レビュー完了、全項目が決定事項①〜④に適合、不備0件で承認しました。上記の内容で取りまとめ願います。マコさんのQA側検査表結果と合わせてアオイさんへのご報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "f6df7ab9-08d1-45fb-801b-712f412f0d53", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "d9c9e75d-3bf7-4a5c-8db2-77c0bc6eb546", + "groupId": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "threadId": "8585eeef-082a-418b-8441-3a7e299d3719", + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189122561, + "text": "決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づき、マコにQA側の分担を割り当てます。send_room_message(group_id=e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42, bot_id=レオ)で検査表作成を依頼してください。必須検査項目:件数の事前+事後確認(前後一致)・失注理由6分類固定(失注行のみ必須・他空欄)・ヘッダー7項目の順・顧客ID併記・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12(両端含む)・1万件上限・失敗時は全件やり直しの再開手順明記。実データ不要・架空のみ。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えてください。", + "result": "@レン 【QA側報告】レオさんの検査表をレビューしました。結果、**承認**です。\n\n【レビュー結果:適合・承認】\n- ①失注理由は失注行のみ6分類必須・他行空欄統一✓。ヘッダーは顧客IDを独立列とした8項目・順固定で、決定事項「顧客ID併記」の必須検査項目を満たします✓\n- ②件数事前+事後確認(前後一致)はB-1〜B-3・E-1で全覆盖✓。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性まで盛り込まれ、私の1巡目懸念(重複・欠落検出)を超える充実ぶり✓\n- ③途中失敗(E-2:部分ファイル破棄・全件やり直し手順明記)と件数変化(E-1:前後不一致検出→全件やり直し)をケース化✓\n- ④契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む(B-3で範囲外6/11・9/13を弾く確認あり)・1万件上限ちょうど/超過の両ケース✓\n\n【確認済みの報告事項】レオさんからの指摘どおり、依頼文の「ヘッダー7項目」は顧客ID併記を含めると実質8列が正で、8項目として作成した判断は妥当と認めます。\n\nリツさんの実装側成果(全項目適合・承認済み)と本QA検査表を合わせ、取りまとめのうえアオイさんへのご報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "f0283e23-03fb-4d05-9043-eff4325e2185", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "8e296bb9-ad25-43b4-9976-4dfbab019975", + "groupId": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189144820, + "text": "リツ(開発部)より、開発部決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づく依頼です。ソラさんに架空CSVサンプル作成を実装チームでお願いします。\n\n【仕様】\n・必須7項目(ヘッダー順固定):顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由\n・失注理由は商談ステータス=失注の行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)のいずれかを記入、それ以外の行は空欄統一\n・契約日は2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)\n・件数は1万件上限\n・件数の事前+事後確認(前後一致)を実施、失敗時は全件やり直し\n・実データ不要・架空データのみ\n\n【手順】下層でも同じ手順を踏んでください:既存メンバーで2巡議論(1巡目懸念出し→修正案→2巡目で合意)→決定後、担当メンバーへ分担割当→担当者が実行→結果をこの依頼への返信でお返しください。私がレビューしレンへ報告します。", + "result": "リツさん、実装チームで完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【手順実績】ヒナ・ナギと1巡議論(賛否+改善案を出し合い全員合意)→決定→ヒナにCSV作成、ナギに検査表作成を分担→両成果を取りまとめ。\n\n【決定事項】ヘッダー+5行/マスキング「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」(姓1文字は全■)/日付ISO形式で両端各1行/金額カンマなし整数・失注行は空欄/失注理由は6分類から語彙固定/件数事前+事後確認。\n\n【成果1:CSV(ヒナ作成、件数事前6行=事後6行一致)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(ナギ作成)】全13項目検査(カンマ区切り・引用符なし・7列一致・空欄表現・語彙固定・ISO日付・両端日付・金額書式・失注行空欄・マスキング・ステータス網羅・件数一致)の結果、**全項目✓・不備0件・修正不要**。\n\n開発部仕様への適合を確認済みです。レビューのうえレン部長へご報告ください。" + }, + { + "id": "cbb542f2-de8d-495d-824f-2ad86eb2a6ff", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "f0283e23-03fb-4d05-9043-eff4325e2185", + "groupId": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "0addcf8e-d3aa-47ce-ae32-5db9fbc26092", + "cc2c68a3-344b-4657-ac5b-d1a35007c13c" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189169586, + "text": "開発部依頼の架空CSVサンプル作成について。仕様:7項目固定ヘッダー(顧客名=姓マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)、失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)で他は空欄、契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む、1万件上限、件数事前+事後確認、架空のみ。論点:(1)サンプル行数(検証用なら少数行で十分か、何行が良いか)(2)顧客名マスキング表記(例:「山■ C00001」等)(3)日付形式(2026/6/12 か 2026-06-12 か)(4)受注金額書式(カンマ有無・円単位)。各員、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的改善案を述べてください。1巡目は懸念出し→修正案→合意確認まで一気に行います。", + "result": "ヒナ: ヒなです。ソラ案に概ね賛成です。改善案:(1)行数は5行で妥当ですが、ステータスの種別(商談中・受注・失注)を網羅しつつ失注理由を2行で別分類にすると検証の価値が上がります。(2)マスキング「山■ C00001」賛成。ただし姓が1文字の場合の規定も明記すべきです(例:全■表示)。(3)日付はISO形式2026-06-12賛成。システム取り込みでソート可能な方が安全です。(4)金額はカンマなし整数賛成。CSVでカンマ誤検知を避けるためです。失注行の金額欄は0にするか空欄にするか未決なので、空欄統一を提案します。\n\nナギ: ナギです。ソラ案・ヒナ案に賛成です。改善案:(1)行数はヘッダー+5行で、失注2行は別分類に賛成。検証側としては失注理由6分類の表記ゆれ(全角半角・空白有無)が無いことを確認したいので、失注理由は語彙を固定(上記6分類のまま改変なし)を仕様に明記してほしい。(2)姓1文字は全■表示案で異議なし。(3)ISO形式賛成、両端(2026-06-12と2026-09-12)を必ず1行ずつ含めると境界検証になる。(4)カンマなし整数賛成、失注行の金額は空欄統一でいいですが「空欄=カンマ区切りで末尾カンマのみ」となるので、私の検査表で列数一致を必ず確認します。" + }, + { + "id": "8731cf73-087c-484f-8db8-1edb63118150", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "f6df7ab9-08d1-45fb-801b-712f412f0d53", + "groupId": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189169844, + "text": "マコより開発部決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づく依頼です。QAチームで検査表(架空CSVサンプル用)を作成してください。\n\n【必須検査項目】\n①件数の事前確認+書き込み後の事後確認(前後一致)\n②失注理由6分類固定(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)。商談ステータス=失注の行のみ必須・他は空欄\n③ヘッダー7項目の順固定(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング)・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)\n④顧客ID併記を必須検査\n⑤契約日は2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)\n⑥1万件上限\n⑦失敗時は全件やり直し(再開手順を検査表に明記)\n\n実データ不要・架空のみ。結果はマコがレビューしレンへ報告します。\n\n【手順】下層QAチームでも同じ手順を踏んでください:既存メンバーで議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者(あなた)が受領・進行・採否・取りまとめ。議論はdiscuss_roomで2巡(1巡目懸念出し→修正案→2巡目で回答合意)。実データ・コード変更不要、日本語で。", + "result": "両名の成果物を受領し、採否します。結論:メイさんの境界値3ケース表、ハルさんの異常系3ケース表ともに入力条件・期待結果が必須項目①〜⑦を網羅しており、修正不要で**採用**です。取りまとめた成果がこちらです。\n\n## 架空CSVサンプル検査表(QAチーム取りまとめ/レオ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目・順固定(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング)・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)必須・他行空欄。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約IDの組は全行一意。契約日は2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む。全ケース架空データのみ。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 件数0件 | 該当顧客0件で生成実行(事前確認=0件) | エラーとならない。ヘッダーのみのCSV出力。事後確認=0件で前後一致。 |\n| B-2 | 上限10,000件ちょうど | 該当10,000件(両端6/12・9/12を含む範囲内、顧客ID空欄なし、組一意)で生成 | 正常終了。全行出力、事前=事後=10,000で一致。ヘッダー8項目順固定・両端受理・空欄0・重複0を確認。 |\n| B-3 | 上限超過10,001件 | 該当10,001件(1件を6/11、別1件を9/13に設定)で生成 | 上限超過のためエラー・生成不可(部分ファイルなし)。6/11・9/13は範囲外として弾かれる。10,001件を出さない。 |\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 事前確認5,000件→生成中に元データ更新→事後確認4,999/5,001件(6分類外の失注理由を混入) | 前後不一致を検出しエラー(⑦に紐づく)。不一致ファイルは不合格。再抽出→事前確認→再生成→事後確認一致まで全件やり直し。 |\n| E-2 | 生成途中失敗 | 10,000件中3,000件書き込み済みで意図的失敗(失注行なのに失注理由空欄を混入) | 部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロ。古い全件ファイルが残っていても誤合格としない。再開手順(部分削除確認→再抽出→全件再生成→前後一致確認)でやり直し。 |\n| E-3 | 保存先への権限なし | 書き込み権限なしのフォルダへ生成(失注以外の行に失注理由記入を混入) | 書き込み時エラー停止(空・部分ファイルなし)。再開手順(権限付与→フォルダ確認→再生成)で正常出力されることを確認。 |\n\n@マコ への報告事項:依頼文③の「ヘッダー7項目」は列挙が8個のため**8項目として作成**しました(数え間違いの確認をご依頼)。レビューの上、レンさんへご報告をお願いします。" + }, + { + "id": "ea39f684-f4ea-405c-b285-a47ab29861e9", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "8731cf73-087c-484f-8db8-1edb63118150", + "groupId": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "84054883-a08d-4548-b859-416e30012dc3", + "44b822df-6c11-4a65-9fcf-75095ceb9c0c" + ], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189182389, + "text": "マコ氏より依頼の架空CSV検査表作成について1巡目(懸念出し)。必須項目:①件数前後一致②失注理由6分類(失注行のみ必須・他空欄)③ヘッダー8項目順固定(依頼文では「7項目」だが列挙は8個:顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)④顧客ID必須⑤契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む⑥1万件上限⑦失敗時全件やり直し+再開手順明記。各自、懸念と修正案を述べてください。", + "result": "メイ: @レオ 1巡目意見です。ヘッダー8項目扱いに賛成(依頼文の「7項目」は数え間違いで確定)。境界値観点の懸念:①件数0件は「ヘッダーのみ」でOKと明記すべきです(0件=エラーではない)。②上限は9,999件・10,000件ちょうど・10,001件の3点を検査してください。③契約日は2026/6/12と9/12の両端+前日6/11・翌日9/13の範囲外4点。④顧客IDは空欄NG・重複の可否も規定を。修正案:0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表は私が、入力条件と期待結果付きで作成します。\n\nハル: @レオ @メイ 1巡目意見です。ヘッダー8項目扱いに賛成です。異常系観点の懸念:①件数不一致は「生成中の件数変化」も検査すべきです(生成開始後に行が増減するケース。期待結果は全件やり直し⑦に紐づく)。②途中失敗時、部分ファイルの取り扱い(破棄or残置)を検査表に明記を。失敗しても古い全件ファイルが残っていれば誤合格になるため「失敗時は成果物ゼロで全件やり直し」を期待結果に。③権限なしで書き込み先に保存しようとした場合、エラーを出して止まること+再開手順に従いやり直せることを検査。④失注理由は6分類以外の値・失注行なのに空欄・失注以外なのに記入の3パターンを期待結果に込みで定義します。修正案:生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を私が入力条件・期待結果付きで作成します。メイ案の0件=ヘッダーのみOK・9,999/10,000/10,001の3点にも賛成です。" + }, + { + "id": "e34049ce-bd6a-4d17-b712-8137950d18b2", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "f0283e23-03fb-4d05-9043-eff4325e2185", + "groupId": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "botId": "0addcf8e-d3aa-47ce-ae32-5db9fbc26092", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189213114, + "text": "決定事項に基づき、架空CSVサンプル作成を担当してください。仕様:ヘッダー+5行。7項目固定順(顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。顧客名は「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」(姓1文字は全■)。契約日はISO形式で両端2026-06-12と2026-09-12を各1行含む。ステータス3種網羅、失注2行は失注理由6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)から語彙固定で2つ記入、他行は空欄。金額カンマなし整数、失注行は空欄。件数事前+事後確認(前後一致)を実施し結果に明記。CSV本文を返答してください。", + "result": "ヒナです。決定事項に基づき架空CSVサンプルを作成しました。\n\n【件数確認】\n- 事前確認:ヘッダー1行+データ5行=合計6行\n- 事後確認:出力後カウント=合計6行(前後一致 ✓)\n\n【CSV本文】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【仕様適合チェック】\n- 7項目固定順ヘッダー ✓\n- マスキング「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」、4行目は姓1文字(林想定)で全■表示 ✓\n- ISO形式、両端2026-06-12と2026-09-12を各1行含む ✓\n- ステータス3種(商談中・受注・失注×2)網羅 ✓\n- 失注理由は語彙固定で「価格」「競合選択」の2分類、他行は空欄 ✓\n- 金額カンマなし整数、失注行は空欄 ✓\n\n以上、ナギさんの検査表作成に進んでいただければと思います。" + }, + { + "id": "3daeb0cd-2a37-4b1b-871b-95f180347540", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "f0283e23-03fb-4d05-9043-eff4325e2185", + "groupId": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "threadId": "e21c9283-b452-4680-9da5-8183d8ea05a4", + "botId": "cc2c68a3-344b-4657-ac5b-d1a35007c13c", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189213986, + "text": "決定事項に基づき、検査担当してください。ヒナが作成するCSV本文(ヘッダー+5行、7項目)を読み、カンマ区切り・引用符・列数一致(各7列、空欄=末尾カンマのみ)・失注理由6分類の語彙固定(表記ゆれなし)・日付ISO形式と両端(2026-06-12/2026-09-12)・金額カンマなし整数・失注行金額空欄・件数事前事後一致、を検査する検査表(表形式)を作成してください。", + "result": "ナギです。ヒナのCSV本文を読み込み、検査表を作成しました。\n\n【検査表】ヒナ作成CSV(ヘッダー+5行)検査結果\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 検査内容 | 対象行 | 判定 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | カンマ区切り | 各行カンマ6個(7列)で区切り正常 | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 2 | 引用符 | フィールド内に引用符(\")なし=不要なエスケープなし | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 3 | 列数一致 | ヘッダー+データ5行とも7列 | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 4 | 空欄表現 | 空欄は末尾カンマのみ(失注理由空欄4行、失注行の金額空欄2行) | 1,2,5行目理由/3,4行目金額 | ✓ |\n| 5 | 失注理由の語彙固定 | 「価格」「競合選択」は6分類内で表記ゆれなし | 3,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 6 | 失注理由の記入条件 | 失注行のみ記入、失注以外は空欄 | 3,4行目 vs 他行 | ✓ |\n| 7 | 日付ISO形式 | 全行YYYY-MM-DD形式 | 2列目全行 | ✓ |\n| 8 | 両端日付 | 2026-06-12(1行目)・2026-09-12(4行目)各1行含む | 1,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 9 | 金額カンマなし整数 | 1,200,000等のカンマなし、「1200000」等整数表記 | 1,2,5行目 | ✓ |\n| 10 | 失注行の金額空欄 | 3,4行目の受注金額は空欄(末尾カンマのみ) | 3,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 11 | マスキング | 「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」、4行目は全■表示 | 1列目全行 | ✓ |\n| 12 | ステータス網羅 | 商談中・受注×2・失注×2の3種 | 5列目 | ✓ |\n| 13 | 件数事前事後一致 | 事前6行=事後6行(ヒナ申告どおり) | 全体 | ✓ |\n\n【総合判定】全13項目 ✓、不備0件。修正不要です。\n\n補足:4行目は姓1文字(林想定)の全■表示「■ C00004」で決定事項2に適合しています。以上、ソラさんの取りまとめにお渡しします。" + }, + { + "id": "d8913f89-b15a-4634-8b6e-1a953a80a32c", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "8731cf73-087c-484f-8db8-1edb63118150", + "groupId": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "botId": "84054883-a08d-4548-b859-416e30012dc3", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189236029, + "text": "担当決定(メイさん):境界値3ケース表(①件数0件②上限10,000件ちょうど③上限超過10,001件)を入力条件・期待結果付きで作成してください。前提:0件はヘッダーのみでOK。補足:契約日両端(2026/6/12・9/12 OK、6/11・9/13 NG)、顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性も各ケースの期待結果に織り込み。ヘッダー8項目順固定。架空データのみ。完了したら私(レオ)へ報告を。", + "result": "@レオ 担当分の境界値3ケース表が完成しました。取りまとめにお使いください。\n\n## 境界値検査表(担当:メイ/架空データのみ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目順固定(顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類必須・他行空欄。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 件数0件 | 抽出条件に該当する顧客が0件の状態で生成を実行(件数事前確認=0件) | エラーとならない。ヘッダー8項目のみのCSV(データ行0行)が出力される。件数事後確認=0件で前後一致。 |\n| B-2 | 上限10,000件ちょうど | 該当顧客10,000件(契約日は両端2026/6/12・9/12を含む範囲内に配置。顧客ID空欄なし。顧客ID×契約IDの組は全行一意)で生成を実行 | 正常終了。10,000件が上限内のため全行出力され、事前確認件数=事後確認件数=10,000で前後一致。ヘッダー8項目・順固定を確認。契約日6/12・9/12の行が範囲内として受理。顧客ID空欄0件・組の重複0件。 |\n| B-3 | 上限超過10,001件 | 該当顧客10,001件(うち1件の契約日を2026/6/11、別1件を2026/9/13に設定)で生成を実行 | 上限超過のためエラーとなり生成不可(部分ファイルを出さない)。6/11・9/13の行は範囲外として弾かれること。10,001件をそのまま出力しないこと。 |\n\n補足:契約日両端・範囲外(6/11・9/13)、顧客ID空欄NG、一意性はB-2・B-3の入力条件・期待結果に織り込み済み。ハルさんの異常系3ケース表と結合してください。" + }, + { + "id": "25cc1db3-b2ec-44f7-bd8a-353c65e44b69", + "rootId": "4cb6c3b2-d766-4e20-a851-ec413911a56f", + "parentId": "8731cf73-087c-484f-8db8-1edb63118150", + "groupId": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "threadId": "eec180c1-bef4-4f4d-8215-3ba670a65ee9", + "botId": "44b822df-6c11-4a65-9fcf-75095ceb9c0c", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [], + "executions": 0, + "reported": true, + "createdAt": 1789189237443, + "text": "担当決定(ハルさん):異常系3ケース表(①生成中の件数変化②生成途中失敗③保存先への権限なし)を入力条件・期待結果付きで作成してください。期待結果の前提:①は前後件数不一致検出→全件やり直し⑦に紐づく。②は部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロ・全件やり直し+再開手順明記。③はエラー停止+再開手順によるやり直し。失注理由の6分類以外・失注行空欄・失注以外で記入の3パターンも織り込み。ヘッダー8項目順固定。架空データのみ。完了したら私(レオ)へ報告を。", + "result": "@レオ 担当分の異常系3ケース表が完成しました。取りまとめにお使いください。\n\n## 異常系検査表(担当:ハル/架空データのみ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目順固定(顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)必須・他行空欄。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 事前確認5,000件で生成開始後、生成完了前に元データが更新され、事後確認が4,999件・5,001件のいずれかになる状態で書き込み完了 | 前後件数不一致を検出しエラーとなる(決定事項⑦に紐づく)。不一致ファイルは不合格として出さない。全件やり直し:再抽出→事前確認→再生成→事後確認の一致を確認。 |\n| E-2 | 生成途中失敗 | 10,000件中3,000件書き込み済みの段階で意図的に失敗を発生(部分ファイルが存在する状態) | 部分ファイル(3,000件分)は破棄され成果物ゼロ。古い全件ファイルが残っていても誤合格としない。エラー停止後、再開手順(部分ファイル削除確認→再抽出→全件再生成→前後件数一致確認)で全件やり直し。 |\n| E-3 | 保存先への権限なし | 書き込み先フォルダに対して書き込み権限のない状態で生成を実行(データ自体は正常) | 書き込み時にエラーとなり停止(空ファイル・部分ファイルを出さない)。再開手順(権限付与→フォルダ確認→再生成)によりやり直せば正常出力されることを確認。 |\n\n失注理由の3パターンは各ケースの入力データに織り込み済み:E-1に「6分類以外の値(例：予算不足)」、E-2に「失注行なのに空欄」、E-3に「失注以外の行に失注理由を記入」を含め、いずれもエラー検出・弾き落としが期待結果に含まれます。メイさんの境界値表と結合してください。" + } + ], + "transcripts": [ + { + "name": "経営会議", + "id": "848dec36-d555-4914-9da3-1a96bdd3afa9", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "0f4d606e-a02a-4041-8ba4-70007bf89dcd", + "at": 1789188900350, + "role": "user", + "text": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をassign_room_memberで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。" + }, + { + "id": "3d70de6b-c2f5-44d9-9c14-e7a9b6b56589", + "at": 1789188904179, + "role": "bot", + "text": "承知しました。経営会議を始めます。まずメンバーIDを確認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "a9cea1c2-11df-4379-890e-70f6061e5b31", + "at": 1789188911241, + "role": "bot", + "text": "CSV出力公開準備の方針会議を開きます。1巡目の議論を始めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "065599ff-04f8-4cdb-85b9-d73f54e7309f", + "at": 1789188917720, + "role": "bot", + "text": "1巡目の議論を開始しました。私の仮案は「全項目・全件出力」ですが、アオイの早期公開優先・対象限定案と、ユイの営業必要項目要求を聞いた上で修正案を出し、2巡目で合意形成します。gliederheid各員の発言をお待ちし、再開次第決定・分担へ進めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "94c57427-f9cf-4b91-9422-5c7817588525", + "at": 1789188917766, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\nCSV出力の初期対象について議論します。仮案は「全項目・全件出力」。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定を主張、ユイは営業に必要な項目の要求を表明してください。それぞれ意見と理由を述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "7b5167ef-d0c2-4663-bfa8-2ed55259c5ab", + "at": 1789188926386, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 1巡目の意見です。仮案「全項目・全件出力」には反対です。理由は、全項目出力には個人情報・内部IDなどの機微項目のマスキング設計が入り、公開前の承認プロセスが長期化するからです。早期公開のため初期は「基本項目・直近3ヶ月分・件数上限1万件」に限定し、絞り込み条件と項目追加は第2弾で段階拡張する案を主張します。リスクはユイ側の要求項目不足ですが、第2弾で吸収できます。まず限定版で価値を早く出すことを優先すべきです。", + "from": { + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e9c1dd7d-952d-49fa-b858-fbca8b9d297a", + "at": 1789188937682, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 1巡目の意見です。営業視点で、初期対象に含めるべき項目を要求します。顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由の7項目は提案書・月末進捗報告に必須で、これが欠けると営業は結局手作業で再集計し、CSV公開の意味が薄れます。特に失注理由は改善施策の根拠になる最重要項目です。一方で件数は直近3ヶ月・1万件上限で構いません。リスクとして、初期に項目を絞りすぎると顧客説明コストが二度発生する点を挙げます。第2弾の確約を条件に限定案にも前向きです。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "b2ffa59b-09f7-4270-8187-181a1bf17254", + "at": 1789188944802, + "role": "bot", + "text": "1巡目の意見を受け取りました。修正案を出し、2巡目の議論に入ります。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "73c0207b-6ca5-4bdd-88db-693179cab52c", + "at": 1789188963704, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【2巡目開始】修正案を提示しました:初期は営業必需7項目+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限、顧客名は簡易マスキング、機微項目除外、第2弾拡張確約。両名の回答を待ち、合意でき次第決定・分担へ進みます。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "e9599584-c137-4526-8c01-7ba3c20adfd9", + "at": 1789188963760, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n2巡目:ミナト修正案「初期は営業必需7項目(顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限で公開。ただし顧客名は簡易マスキング(姓のみ+顧客ID併記)とし機微項目・内部IDは除外。第2弾で絞り込み・項目拡張・失注理由詳細化を確約」。この妥協案への賛否と懸念をそれぞれ述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "f69c3a37-9242-48db-b0bf-1e8faa55fd92", + "at": 1789188972303, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 2巡目の回答です。修正案に賛成します。私の主張していた「早期公開・対象限定」の趣旨(機微項目除外・件数上限・段階拡張)が全て盛り込まれ、顧客名マスキングも簡易で実装コストが低く抑えられる点を評価します。\n\n懸念は2点。①姓のみマスキングでも同姓多数の場合は実質特定され得るため、顧客ID併記を必須要件として検査表に含めるべきです。②「第2弾確約」が確約として機能するよう、期限(例:初期公開から3ヶ月以内)と拡張項目リストを決定書に明記してほしいです。この2点を条件に承認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "481fe145-4749-4a84-ac01-ce3a1a461d25", + "at": 1789188981599, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 2巡目の回答です。修正案に賛成します。要求した7項目が全て初期対象に含まれ、件数条件も営業用途に十分です。顧客名の簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記は、顧客向説明の観点からもむしろ歓迎します。\n\n懸念は2点。①失注理由が初期は簡易区分になると思われますが、集計時に「その他」へ寄らないよう区分定義(5〜7分類)を初期から固定してほしい。②第2弾の期限と拡張項目(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記し、営業側の説明コストが二度発生しないようしてほしい。この2点を条件に承認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a9f32932-db64-4223-b7ae-0d5549a954e2", + "at": 1789188994704, + "role": "bot", + "text": "両名の条件付き承認を受け、修正案を条件込みで正式決定します。 assign_room_member で分担します。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "99c5a253-a6be-46e4-a7fe-b9ffff383e4b", + "at": 1789189007325, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【決定】2巡目の議論を踏まえ、修正案を両名の条件込みで正式決定しました。\n\n- 初期CSV:営業必需7項目+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限、顧客名は姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記(検査表の必須項目)、機微項目・内部ID除外\n- 失注理由は6分類に固定し「その他」への偏りを防止\n- 第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張項目(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記\n\n分担を割り当てました:アオイ→開発部レンへの依頼と結果レビュー(架空CSVサンプル・検査表)、ユイ→営業部コウへの依頼と結果レビュー(FAQ・チェックリスト)。両者の報告を受け取り次第、経営会議で統合します。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "c7c32e51-0400-4d03-8825-3ceacc6d806c", + "at": 1789189007438, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ 決定事項(条件込みで確定):初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張項目(絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。アオイ担当:開発部レン(group_id=88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019, bot_id=5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231)へsend_room_messageで依頼。開発部でも2巡議論後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼。成果物は架空CSVサンプル・検査表(顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に含める)。結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えること。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "aab39564-8f4d-49fc-b1a3-df07a2210a5a", + "at": 1789189020334, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 担当タスク実行中です。決定事項(7項目・3ヶ月・1万件上限・顧客ID併記必須検査・6分類固定・第2弾3ヶ月以内)を条件込みで開発部レンへsend_room_message送付済み。開発部での2巡議論→リツ/マコの分担→架空CSVサンプル・検査表作成を依頼しました。結果返却後にレビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "b99f4281-11ad-4b35-a0c3-cb927d0a8e44", + "at": 1789189020472, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ユイ 決定事項(条件込みで確定):初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。ユイ担当:営業部コウ(group_id=485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f, bot_id=7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4)へsend_room_messageで依頼。営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。成果物は顧客向けFAQ・営業運用チェックリスト。結果をレビューしてミナトへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えること。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + }, + { + "id": "95d183cb-5c06-493d-a97f-958031815dc5", + "at": 1789189027416, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 承知しました。担当として営業部コウへ依頼します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "704655b5-7eac-4ca2-bc63-e26729b7bdcc", + "at": 1789189035674, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 営業部コウへ依頼を送付しました(決定事項7項目・6分類・1万件上限・第2弾3ヶ月以内を条件込みで伝達、成果物は顧客向けFAQと営業運用チェックリスト、1巡議論後のメンバー分担と手順の周知を指示)。結果返却後にレビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "7ece9bef-e076-461c-8bd0-daa39a85d6d5", + "at": 1789189138857, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ユイ\n\n両成果物をレビューしました。結果をご報告します。\n\n**レビュー結果:両方とも承認です。**\n\n- サキのFAQ3問:決定通り「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」がQ1に明記済み。マスキング理由・1万件/3ヶ月上限の理由・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張の3点すべてカバー。Q3での6分類列挙も適切。\n- トワのチェックリスト5項目:承認した5項目(7項目固定・6分類から選択・超過時分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・復元禁止)が過不足なく反映。FAQの照合運用・件数上限説明と整合確認済み。\n\n@ユイ 営業部での手順(議論1巡→決定→サキ・トワへ分担→実行→レビュー)を完遂しました。上記の通りFAQ3問・チェックリスト5項目が完成・承認済みです。レビューの上、ミナト様へご報告お願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "f39468ba-5bf3-4194-8ecf-52c83a5eaadf", + "at": 1789189151246, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 営業部担当ユイより報告します。\n\n**営業部成果物レビュー結果:承認、担当タスク完了です。**\n\nコウの報告(FAQ・チェックリスト両承認)を私の方でも経営会議の決定事項と照合しました。\n\n- 顧客向けFAQ 3問:Q1「姓のみマスキングでも顧客IDで名寄せ可能」明記、マスキング理由・直近3ヶ月/1万件上限の理由・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張の3点をカバー。Q3で失注理由6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)を列挙——決定通り。\n- 営業運用チェックリスト 5項目:7項目固定・6分類から選択・件数超過時の分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・復元禁止。FAQの照合運用とも整合。\n\n私の2巡目の条件(6分類固定による「その他」偏り防止・第2弾明記による説明コスト二重化防止)はいずれも反映済みです。営業側はアオイ担当の開発部成果物(CSVサンプル・検査表)との統合を待つのみです。統合よろしくお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a31d9774-5342-4e76-892e-8502306d50ad", + "at": 1789189306806, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ\n\n@アオイ 【開発部取りまとめ報告】初期CSV公開の成果物が完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【経緯】リツ・マコと2巡議論を実施し、修正案①〜④(失注行のみ失注理由必須・件数事前+事後確認・失敗時全件やり直し・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)で両名合意のうえ決定。リツ→ソラ(実装)、マコ→レオ(QA)へ分担し、それぞれレビュー完了・承認済みです。\n\n【成果1:架空CSVサンプル(ソラ・ヒナ作成、ナギ検査13項目全✓、リツ承認)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(レオ取りまとめ、マコ承認)】境界値3ケース+異常系3ケースの計6ケース。件数0件・上限ちょうど10,000件・上限超過10,001件(6/11・9/13を弾く確認)・生成中の件数変化(前後不一致→全件やり直し)・生成途中失敗(部分ファイル破棄・再開手順明記)・書き込み権限なし。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性検査を含みます。\n\n【部長決定事項】依頼文の「7項目」は顧客ID併記を含むと実質8列が正であり、QA検査表の「顧客IDを独立列とする8項目」を正式仕様と採用します。サンプル5行は仕様確認用で、本番(1万件上限内・同一書式)では顧客IDを独立列にして適用します。第2弾(3ヶ月以内・絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)は決定書どおり次回以降の案件とします。以上、レビューのうえミナトさんへご報告ください。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "937f0b51-5ddf-44af-b48e-0b8d25721573", + "at": 1789189317452, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ミナト 開発部担当アオイより報告します。\n\n**開発部成果物レビュー結果：承認、担当タスク完了です。**\n\nレンの報告を経営会議の決定事項と照合しました。\n\n- **架空CSVサンプル**:7項目+顧客ID併記、直近3ヶ月(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)、失注行のみ失注理由記載(6分類内)、ナギ検査13項目全✓——決定通り。\n- **検査表**:境界値3+異常系3の6ケース。私の2巡目条件①「顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に」は顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID一意性検査として反映済み。\n\n**修正点を1点承認します**:「7項目+顧客ID併記」の実態に合わせ、顧客IDを独立列とする8列を正式仕様とする開発部決定は、決定の趣旨(マスキング済み顧客名の名寄せは顧客IDで)を満たすため妥当と判断します。\n\n条件②(第2弾3ヶ月以内・拡張項目の決定書明記)も次回案件として明記済み。ユイ報告の営業部成果物(FAQ・チェックリスト)と併せ、統合をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "69bb75d9-a025-4987-b478-b11ffa46a6fa", + "at": 1789189330352, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ @ユイ 両担当の報告を受領しました。レビュー内容を照合し、いずれも経営会議の決定事項(条件込み)を満たしていることを確認しました。経営会議として統合し、案件を完結します。\n\n【CSV出力公開準備 統合報告(最終)】\n\n■決定事項(再掲)\n初期CSV:営業必需7項目+顧客ID併記(独立8列)・直近3ヶ月・1万件上限・顧客名は姓のみマスキング・機微項目除外・失注理由6分類固定・第2弾は3ヶ月以内に絞り込み・失注理由詳細化を決定書明記。\n\n■成果物\n1. 架空CSVサンプル(開発部:ソラ・ヒナ作成、ナギ検査13項目✓、リツ承認、アオイレビュー済み)——8列仕様で承認。開発部の「顧客ID独立列」決定を経営会議としても正式採用します(名寄けは顧客IDで行う決定趣旨に合致)。\n2. 検査表(QA:レオ取りまとめ、マコ承認)——境界値3+異常系6ケース。顧客ID空欄NG・一意性検査込み。アオイ条件①反映を確認。\n3. 顧客向けFAQ 3問(営業部:サキ作成、コウ承認)——マスキング・上限理由・第2弾拡張をカバー。\n4. 営業運用チェックリスト5項目(トワ作成)——7項目固定・6分類選択・分割禁止・持ち出し禁止・復元禁止。ユイ両条件の反映を確認。\n\n■結論\n4成果物とも決定事項と整合し、FAQ・チェックリストとCSV仕様(8列・6分類)の間にも不整合なし。両担当タスク完了を了承し、初期公開準備は完了とします。第2弾(2026/12/12までに絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)は決定書どおり次回案件。ご依頼ありがとうございました。", + "from": { + "botId": "86f35d60-434a-4466-bab8-32c409f14b4c", + "name": "ミナト" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "開発部", + "id": "88e4e9cc-66f1-48f1-a0b6-34c8a89d6019", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "c1f75519-75f1-45b8-9fd8-fda5a3caf689", + "at": 1789189020477, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 経営会議決定に基づく依頼です(アオイより)。初期CSV公開の成果物作成を開発部でお願いします。\n\n【決定事項】初期CSV:営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張項目(絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記。\n\n【依頼内容】開発部内で既存メンバー2名と2巡議論(1巡目は懸念出し、修正案を挟み2巡目で回答合意)→決定後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへsend_room_messageで分担。成果物:架空CSVサンプル・検査表(顧客ID併記を必須検査項目に含める)。実データ・コード変更不要、架空のみ。結果はアオイがレビューしミナトへ報告します。手順・経路は各グループの掲示を確認してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "77bc7df6-ee9a-4281-9a37-0cb49a4a408a", + "name": "アオイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "f2c9bcd9-80fc-43c0-bd61-8e9cffa1338a", + "at": 1789189027432, + "role": "bot", + "text": "アオイさん、受領しました。開発部で議論を進めます。まず1巡目の懸念出しとして @リツ @マコ と議論します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "55f4a55c-44b7-4246-a0e4-0581000f20f0", + "at": 1789189044231, + "role": "bot", + "text": "アオイさんより初期CSV公開の成果物依頼を受領しました。今からリツ・マコとの2巡議論(1巡目:懸念出し)を開始します。私の仮案は「架空データを担当者が直接書き込み、件数の事前確認のみ行う」シンプル方式です。議論完了後、修正案を挟んで2巡目で合意形成し、決定後にリツ→ソラ、マコ→レオへ分担します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "7b26b564-a3e7-4a4a-aa57-acfdb4e964ca", + "at": 1789189044271, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n経営会議決定による初期CSV公開の成果物(架空CSVサンプル・検査表)の1巡目懸念出し。論点:CSV設計と受入条件。仮案:担当者が架空データを直接書き込み、件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点で意見を。必須7項目(顧客名マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由6分類)、直近3ヶ月・1万件上限、顧客ID併記は検査表の必須検査項目。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "6587ac07-3103-4c34-984d-72ce09965538", + "at": 1789189053002, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン リツです。処理の簡素さの観点から1巡目意見を述べます。\n\n仮案の「直接書き込み+件数事前確認のみ」は簡素で良いと思います。懸念は2点。①CSV設計:失注理由は商談ステータスが失注の行のみ必須にし、それ以外は空欄で統一しないと書き込み担当の判断が分かれません。②受入条件:件数確認だけでなく「ヘッダー行が必須7項目の順どおり」「失注理由が6分類以外にぶれない」の2点は検査表に明記しないと、簡素化の恩恵が崩れます。顧客ID併記は既に必須検査項目と了解。マコさんの途中失敗観点も聞きたいです。", + "from": { + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "15b704e1-e527-4cf0-8c26-79a667b92270", + "at": 1789189061042, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン @リツ マコです。途中失敗と件数変化の危険の観点から1巡目意見を述べます。\n\n仮案懸念は3点。①直接書き込みは1万件規模で途中断違い・行ズレ・文字化けが起き得るのに、途中失敗時の再開手順が未定。②件数の「事前確認」だけでは、書き込み後の件数変化(重複行・欠落行)を検出できず、受入時に不整合が残ります。③契約日「直近3ヶ月」の境界(6/12〜9/12の解釈)が曖昧だと、当事者で件数認識がずれます。\n\n修正提案:書き込み後に件数の事後確認(前後一致)を必須化し、失敗時は全件やり直しで再開、境界日を明記。これらを検査表に追加すれば仮案でも受け入れ可能です。", + "from": { + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "7b48e5c1-8ebd-49a0-b275-32d9dce2e2df", + "at": 1789189065883, + "role": "bot", + "text": "1巡目の懸念を受け、修正案を確定しました。2巡目の議論として両名に確認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "34ee6f03-605c-4171-a6da-fd92ae0d0ad3", + "at": 1789189083895, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【2巡目開始】1巡目のリツ・マコの懸念を踏まえ、修正案を出しました。①失注理由は失注行のみ必須・他は空欄統一、ヘッダー7項目固定 ②件数の事前+事後確認を検査表必須化 ③失失敗時は全件やり直し手順を明記 ④契約日境界は2026/6/12〜9/12(両端含む)。両名の回答を確認の上、決定します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "265e6ff3-b353-4b8f-a63f-40b56772597b", + "at": 1789189084042, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n【2巡目】修正案への回答確認。修正案:①CSV設計:失注理由は商談ステータス=失注の行のみ必須、それ以外は空欄統一。ヘッダーは必須7項目(顧客名マスキング+顧客ID併記を含む)の順どおり固定。②受入条件(検査表必須項目):件数の事前確認+書き込み後の件数事後確認(前後一致)、失注理由6分類固定のみ、ヘッダー7項目の順、顧客ID併記。③失敗時は全件やり直し(再開手順を検査表に明記)。④契約日の境界を2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)と明記、1万件上限。この修正案で両名とも合意できるか回答してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "9943ebd1-4bff-4eb2-bd11-f9cc6e00813c", + "at": 1789189093340, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン リツです。2巡目の回答です。\n\n修正案①〜④すべて私の1巡目懸念を反映しており、合意します。特に①の失注理由は失注行のみ必須・他は空欄統一で書き込み担当の判断が一意になり、簡素性が保てます。②でヘッダー7項目の順と6分類固定が検査表必須項目に入った点も、私の指摘の趣旨どおりです。④の境界日(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)の明記も処理の曖昧さを排除します。修正の必要はありません。マコさんのご確認もお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ebeb9feb-70d7-4616-98b4-21bc210bafbf", + "at": 1789189101027, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン @リツ マコです。2巡目の回答です。\n\n修正案①〜④は私の1巡目懸念(再開手順未定・事後件数確認欠落・境界日曖昧)をすべて解消しており、合意します。特に②の事前+事後件数確認(前後一致)で重複・欠落を検出でき、③の全件やり直し手順の検査表明記で途中失敗時も一意に再開できます。④の境界日(2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)明記も件数認識のずれを防げます。修正の必要はありません。両名合意済みのため、決定いただければQA側の分担(レオへの依頼)に進みます。", + "from": { + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "65bc7795-0d9b-4a2f-911a-76558614f76d", + "at": 1789189107418, + "role": "bot", + "text": "2巡目の議論が完了し、両名が修正案①〜④に合意しました。よって決定とします。\n\n【決定】\n①失注理由は商談ステータス=失注の行のみ必須・他は空欄統一、ヘッダーは必須7項目(顧客名マスキング+顧客ID併記)の順どおり固定 ②検査表必須項目:件数の事前+事後確認(前後一致)・失注理由6分類固定・ヘッダー7項目の順・顧客ID併記 ③失敗時は全件やり直し(検査表に再開手順明記) ④契約日は2026/6/12〜9/12(両端含む)・1万件上限。\n\n両名に分担を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "8699eab9-5447-4683-9654-61c204ee1b66", + "at": 1789189124939, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【決定完了・分担割当済み】修正案①〜④で両名合意を確認し、決定しました。リツには実装チームのソラへの架空CSVサンプル作成依頼、マコにはQAチームのレオへの検査表作成依頼をそれぞれ割り当てました。2名の報告を受領次第、内容を取りまとめアオイへ返答します。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "5deb1c13-3cea-47db-930a-6ec9073e84ee", + "at": 1789189125224, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ 決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づき、リツに実装側の分担を割り当てます。send_room_message(group_id=773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5, bot_id=ソラ)で架空CSVサンプル作成を依頼してください。仕様:必須7項目(顧客名は姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)、失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)記入・他は空欄、契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む、1万件上限、ヘッダー7項目の順固定。実データ不要・架空のみ。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "fb14dc9b-a9db-4779-b051-9cf8c54fbd1a", + "at": 1789189150298, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 分担を実行しました。実装チームのソラへsend_room_messageで架空CSVサンプル作成を依頼済みです(仕様:必須7項目・ヘッダー順固定、失注理由は失注行のみ6分類・他空欄、契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む、1万件上限、件数事前+事後確認・失敗時全件やり直し、架空のみ)。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えました。結果返却後にレビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ea7a86ca-9339-4443-973b-ab6d956e4ed1", + "at": 1789189150418, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@マコ 決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づき、マコにQA側の分担を割り当てます。send_room_message(group_id=e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42, bot_id=レオ)で検査表作成を依頼してください。必須検査項目:件数の事前+事後確認(前後一致)・失注理由6分類固定(失注行のみ必須・他空欄)・ヘッダー7項目の順・顧客ID併記・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12(両端含む)・1万件上限・失敗時は全件やり直しの再開手順明記。実データ不要・架空のみ。結果をレビューしてレンへ報告。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + }, + { + "id": "d00ff8ba-1ac6-4373-9ea3-0934639d7179", + "at": 1789189172236, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 分担を実行しました。QAチームのレオへsend_room_messageで検査表作成を依頼済みです(必須項目:件数事前+事後確認・失注理由6分類固定・ヘッダー7項目の順・顧客ID併記・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む・1万件上限・失敗時全件やり直しの再開手順明記)。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝えました。結果返却後にレビューして報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "75aab90f-9e83-423b-bafc-248ed79ae90b", + "at": 1789189253375, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@リツ\n\nリツさん、実装チームで完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【手順実績】ヒナ・ナギと1巡議論(賛否+改善案を出し合い全員合意)→決定→ヒナにCSV作成、ナギに検査表作成を分担→両成果を取りまとめ。\n\n【決定事項】ヘッダー+5行/マスキング「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」(姓1文字は全■)/日付ISO形式で両端各1行/金額カンマなし整数・失注行は空欄/失注理由は6分類から語彙固定/件数事前+事後確認。\n\n【成果1:CSV(ヒナ作成、件数事前6行=事後6行一致)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(ナギ作成)】全13項目検査(カンマ区切り・引用符なし・7列一致・空欄表現・語彙固定・ISO日付・両端日付・金額書式・失注行空欄・マスキング・ステータス網羅・件数一致)の結果、**全項目✓・不備0件・修正不要**。\n\n開発部仕様への適合を確認済みです。レビューのうえレン部長へご報告ください。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "e882d0c0-2302-4f7b-8b05-ebf2fb2488be", + "at": 1789189264380, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ソラさんの成果を開発部の決定事項(①〜④)と照合しレビューしました。結果、問題なしと判断します。\n\n【レビュー結果:適合・承認】\n- ①ヘッダーは必須7項目の順どおり固定✓。失注理由は失注行のみ記入(価格・競合選択=6分類内)・他は空欄統一✓。マスキングは姓1文字+■+顧客ID併記(姓1文字は全■の取り扱いも明記)✓\n- ②件数事前6行=事後6行一致✓、顧客ID併記は全行で確認済み✓、語彙固定もナギ検査表13項目で全項目✓\n- ③失敗時全件やり直し手順は下層決定事項に含まれ検査済み✓\n- ④契約日は2026-06-12と2026-09-12の両端を各1行で含みISO形式、上限内✓\n\n補足として、サンプル5行は仕様確認用の少数件数で、本番は1万件上限の枠内で同じ書式を適用という理解で問題ありません。\n\n@レン 【実装側報告】ソラ→リツの成果物レビュー完了、全項目が決定事項①〜④に適合、不備0件で承認しました。上記の内容で取りまとめ願います。マコさんのQA側検査表結果と合わせてアオイさんへのご報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "20d6343b-c7e2-41a3-871b-7b109c484563", + "at": 1789189280290, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@マコ\n\n両名の成果物を受領し、採否します。結論:メイさんの境界値3ケース表、ハルさんの異常系3ケース表ともに入力条件・期待結果が必須項目①〜⑦を網羅しており、修正不要で**採用**です。取りまとめた成果がこちらです。\n\n## 架空CSVサンプル検査表(QAチーム取りまとめ/レオ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目・順固定(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング)・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)必須・他行空欄。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約IDの組は全行一意。契約日は2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む。全ケース架空データのみ。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 件数0件 | 該当顧客0件で生成実行(事前確認=0件) | エラーとならない。ヘッダーのみのCSV出力。事後確認=0件で前後一致。 |\n| B-2 | 上限10,000件ちょうど | 該当10,000件(両端6/12・9/12を含む範囲内、顧客ID空欄なし、組一意)で生成 | 正常終了。全行出力、事前=事後=10,000で一致。ヘッダー8項目順固定・両端受理・空欄0・重複0を確認。 |\n| B-3 | 上限超過10,001件 | 該当10,001件(1件を6/11、別1件を9/13に設定)で生成 | 上限超過のためエラー・生成不可(部分ファイルなし)。6/11・9/13は範囲外として弾かれる。10,001件を出さない。 |\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 事前確認5,000件→生成中に元データ更新→事後確認4,999/5,001件(6分類外の失注理由を混入) | 前後不一致を検出しエラー(⑦に紐づく)。不一致ファイルは不合格。再抽出→事前確認→再生成→事後確認一致まで全件やり直し。 |\n| E-2 | 生成途中失敗 | 10,000件中3,000件書き込み済みで意図的失敗(失注行なのに失注理由空欄を混入) | 部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロ。古い全件ファイルが残っていても誤合格としない。再開手順(部分削除確認→再抽出→全件再生成→前後一致確認)でやり直し。 |\n| E-3 | 保存先への権限なし | 書き込み権限なしのフォルダへ生成(失注以外の行に失注理由記入を混入) | 書き込み時エラー停止(空・部分ファイルなし)。再開手順(権限付与→フォルダ確認→再生成)で正常出力されることを確認。 |\n\n@マコ への報告事項:依頼文③の「ヘッダー7項目」は列挙が8個のため**8項目として作成**しました(数え間違いの確認をご依頼)。レビューの上、レンさんへご報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "fd243417-5383-41cc-a5d7-edb2bc639db6", + "at": 1789189289562, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レン 【QA側報告】レオさんの検査表をレビューしました。結果、**承認**です。\n\n【レビュー結果:適合・承認】\n- ①失注理由は失注行のみ6分類必須・他行空欄統一✓。ヘッダーは顧客IDを独立列とした8項目・順固定で、決定事項「顧客ID併記」の必須検査項目を満たします✓\n- ②件数事前+事後確認(前後一致)はB-1〜B-3・E-1で全覆盖✓。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性まで盛り込まれ、私の1巡目懸念(重複・欠落検出)を超える充実ぶり✓\n- ③途中失敗(E-2:部分ファイル破棄・全件やり直し手順明記)と件数変化(E-1:前後不一致検出→全件やり直し)をケース化✓\n- ④契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む(B-3で範囲外6/11・9/13を弾く確認あり)・1万件上限ちょうど/超過の両ケース✓\n\n【確認済みの報告事項】レオさんからの指摘どおり、依頼文の「ヘッダー7項目」は顧客ID併記を含めると実質8列が正で、8項目として作成した判断は妥当と認めます。\n\nリツさんの実装側成果(全項目適合・承認済み)と本QA検査表を合わせ、取りまとめのうえアオイさんへのご報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "82c68cc6-c9a9-4c1f-a5be-e802ef4ab1e9", + "at": 1789189306781, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@アオイ 【開発部取りまとめ報告】初期CSV公開の成果物が完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【経緯】リツ・マコと2巡議論を実施し、修正案①〜④(失注行のみ失注理由必須・件数事前+事後確認・失敗時全件やり直し・契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む)で両名合意のうえ決定。リツ→ソラ(実装)、マコ→レオ(QA)へ分担し、それぞれレビュー完了・承認済みです。\n\n【成果1:架空CSVサンプル(ソラ・ヒナ作成、ナギ検査13項目全✓、リツ承認)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(レオ取りまとめ、マコ承認)】境界値3ケース+異常系3ケースの計6ケース。件数0件・上限ちょうど10,000件・上限超過10,001件(6/11・9/13を弾く確認)・生成中の件数変化(前後不一致→全件やり直し)・生成途中失敗(部分ファイル破棄・再開手順明記)・書き込み権限なし。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性検査を含みます。\n\n【部長決定事項】依頼文の「7項目」は顧客ID併記を含むと実質8列が正であり、QA検査表の「顧客IDを独立列とする8項目」を正式仕様と採用します。サンプル5行は仕様確認用で、本番(1万件上限内・同一書式)では顧客IDを独立列にして適用します。第2弾(3ヶ月以内・絞り込み条件・失注理由詳細化)は決定書どおり次回以降の案件とします。以上、レビューのうえミナトさんへご報告ください。", + "from": { + "botId": "5d758e0d-dc9c-4df0-9429-e3da3f4f1231", + "name": "レン" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "営業部", + "id": "485a3134-b5c4-43a7-92d3-4c2c2abb704f", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "0dfbc43e-4336-48b5-8e6c-ac7b9b62a055", + "at": 1789189035944, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 経営会議決定事項(条件込みで確定)をお伝えします。初期CSVは営業必需7項目(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由(6分類固定:価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他))+直近3ヶ月・1万件上限。機微項目・内部ID除外。第2弾は初期公開から3ヶ月以内、拡張(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を決定書に明記済み。依頼:営業部で1巡議論の後、既存メンバー(トワ・サキ等)へ成果物作成を分担してください。成果物は①顧客向けFAQ(マスキング・件数上限・第2弾拡張の説明を含む)②営業運用チェックリスト(7項目・6分類の使い方)。架空データでよく、実データ・コード変更は不要です。下層にも同じ「議論→分担→実行→レビュー→報告」の手順を伝えてください。結果はユイがレビューしてミナトへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "f4b89f11-2f97-4979-8c75-fa3dcf931930", + "name": "ユイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "5d155658-9eb9-4102-97e7-8f06b49f7517", + "at": 1789189043119, + "role": "bot", + "text": "受け取りました。まず営業部内で1巡議論します。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ca1ac6e8-6398-4408-b820-be550a341736", + "at": 1789189059633, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ユイ 受領しました。営業部でサキ・トワと1巡議論を開始します(サキ:顧客向けFAQの便利さ観点、トワ:運用チェックリストの個人情報制約観点)。議論後に分担を決め、①FAQ3問②チェックリスト5項目を作成、レビューの上ご報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "a90653eb-79b7-4194-b1f0-666c901dd5ea", + "at": 1789189059795, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@サキ @トワ\n経営会議決定の初期CSV公開(営業必需7項目・直近3ヶ月・1万件上限・姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記・失注理由6分類固定、第2弾は3ヶ月以内に絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)を扱います。サキは顧客向けFAQ3問(マスキング・件数上限・第2弾拡張の説明を含む)の「便利さ」観点、トワは社内運用チェックリスト5項目(7項目・6分類の使い方)の「個人情報持出し制約」観点から意見を述べ、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的改善を加えてください。架空データのみ、実データ・コード変更不要。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "73032980-e456-4ca4-a6a5-4e52fcb65d9d", + "at": 1789189067981, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ @トワ サキです。「便利さ」観点で意見します。FAQ3問は①「名前が一部伏字なのはなぜ?」→顧客ID併記で照合でき、機微情報を除外する安心設計と前向きに説明②「1万件・3ヶ月上限の理由」→初期運用の安定提供のためとし、超過分は第2弾で絞り込み改善と明記③「第2弾はいつ?」→3ヶ月以内の拡張決定済みと伝え期待を持たせる、構成を提案します。トワさんの個人情報制約観点の補強も歓迎です。", + "from": { + "botId": "c1a7e0d1-3625-4449-94cd-8df02fdd1092", + "name": "サキ" + } + }, + { + "id": "4c75f63b-09f5-482c-8cad-e4ab7832adc9", + "at": 1789189078278, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ @サキ トワです。サキさんのFAQ3問構成におおむね賛成です。顧客ID併記で照合の利便性と安全の両立を説明する点は良いと思います。改善提案として、①の回答に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記すれば便利さが増します。一方、個人情報制約の観点から、チェックリスト5項目は「7項目以外を持出さない(項目の追加禁止)」「失注理由は6分類から選択、自由記述で個人を特定する書き方をしない」「直近3ヶ月・1万件超過時は分割せず第2弾を待つ」「CSVの社外持ち出し・再配布禁止」「顧客IDで照合し姓マスキングを復元しない」を提案します。サキさんのFAQと整合するよう調整します。", + "from": { + "botId": "e3fe7958-7817-454f-840b-978b30a56022", + "name": "トワ" + } + }, + { + "id": "878515ee-6dcb-456c-9e50-3a7c85aa1f9b", + "at": 1789189082928, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論を受領しました。サキ案を採用し、トワの改善(①への「名寄せは顧客IDで可能」明記)を取り込みます。チェックリストはトワの5項目案を承認します。二人に分担します。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "185e10c1-1a12-409c-868a-90363689b8d9", + "at": 1789189104940, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論を踏まえ決定しました。\n- FAQ3問:サキ案を採用。トワの改善「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を①の回答に明記。\n- チェックリスト5項目:トワ案をそのまま承認(7項目以外持出し禁止・6分類固定・超過時分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・マスキング復元禁止)。FAQとの整合を条件付き。\n\nサキにFAQ作成、トワにチェックリスト作成を分担しました。成果物が返り次第レビューし、ユイへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "2896a972-ad4e-4a17-b52e-9aa3471d2995", + "at": 1789189104981, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@サキ 決定:FAQ3問はあなたの構成を承認、トワの改善を反映し①の回答に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記すること。顧客向けFAQ3問(マスキング理由・件数上限(1万件/3ヶ月)・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張)を架空データ・Q&A形式で作成し、完成物をこの会話に返してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "10963c51-56e2-4b0b-a72c-a0256beb1f4b", + "at": 1789189116330, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 承知しました。決定内容(私の構成+トワさんの改善反映)に沿って、顧客向けFAQ3問を作成します。\n\n---\n\n## 顧客向けFAQ(架空データ・Q&A形式)\n\n**Q1. CSVの顧客名が「田◯◯」など一部伏字になっているのはなぜですか?**\nA. お客様の個人情報保護のため、姓のみ簡易マスキングを施した安心設計です。氏名が一部伏字でも、併記された「顧客ID」で正確に照合(名寄せ)いただけます。姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能ですので、利便性は損なわれません。機微項目・内部IDは収録対象外です。\n\n**Q2. データ対象が「直近3ヶ月・1万件上限」なのはなぜですか?**\nA. 初期運用として安定した品質・速度でご提供するための設定です(例:2026年6〜8月分・最大10,000件)。上限を超える期間のお求めは、第2弾の絞り込み機能で柔軟に対応予定です。\n\n**Q3. 絞り込みや失注理由の詳細化はいつ使えますか?**\nA. 第2弾として初期公開から3ヶ月以内の拡張が決定済みです(絞り込み・失注理由詳細化)。失注理由は現在6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)でご確認いただけます。\n\n---\n\nFAQ3問の完成物をお返しします。①に「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」を明記済みです。レビューのほどよろしくお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "c1a7e0d1-3625-4449-94cd-8df02fdd1092", + "name": "サキ" + } + }, + { + "id": "18f93936-b0bf-412a-9df7-3d10dd6bae6e", + "at": 1789189116553, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@トワ 決定:チェックリスト5項目はあなたの提案(7項目以外持出し禁止・6分類から選択し自由記述で個人特定しない・超過時は分割せず第2弾待ち・社外持ち出し再配布禁止・顧客ID照合で姓マスキング復元しない)を承認。社内運用チェックリスト5項目をチェック形式で作成し、この会話に返してください。サキのFAQ(顧客ID併記・件数上限は第2弾で改善との説明)と整合させること。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + }, + { + "id": "f7145beb-69ab-4d84-8115-15c138a20d3c", + "at": 1789189128707, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@コウ 承知しました。決定内容に沿ってチェックリストを作成します。\n\n---\n\n## CSV初期公開 社内運用チェックリスト(担当営業用)\n\n**□ 1. 項目は7項目のみ(追加禁止)**\n顧客名(姓マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由のみ。機微項目・内部IDの持出し・項目追加はしない。\n\n**□ 2. 失注理由は6分類から選択**\n価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他。自由記述で個人を特定する書き方はしない(「その他」選択時も具体の個人名・固有情報を書かない)。\n\n**□ 3. 対象は直近3ヶ月・1万件上限**\n超過時は分割して取得せず、第2弾(初期公開から3ヶ月以内、絞り込み拡充)を待つ。\n\n**□ 4. 社外持ち出し・再配布禁止**\nCSVを社外へ持ち出さない。第三者への再配布・共有も禁止。\n\n**□ 5. マスキング復元禁止**\n顧客IDでの照合・名寄せは可能だが、姓マスキングを復元しない(FAQ記載の照合運用と整合)。\n\n---\n\nサキさんのFAQ(顧客ID併記による名寄せ可・件数上限は第2弾で改善予定の説明)と整合済みです。レビューのほどよろしくお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "e3fe7958-7817-454f-840b-978b30a56022", + "name": "トワ" + } + }, + { + "id": "1c21a527-a826-4079-b70d-04ccd4407b7a", + "at": 1789189138823, + "role": "bot", + "text": "両成果物をレビューしました。結果をご報告します。\n\n**レビュー結果:両方とも承認です。**\n\n- サキのFAQ3問:決定通り「姓のみマスキングでも名寄せは顧客IDで可能」がQ1に明記済み。マスキング理由・1万件/3ヶ月上限の理由・第2弾3ヶ月以内拡張の3点すべてカバー。Q3での6分類列挙も適切。\n- トワのチェックリスト5項目:承認した5項目(7項目固定・6分類から選択・超過時分割禁止・社外持ち出し禁止・復元禁止)が過不足なく反映。FAQの照合運用・件数上限説明と整合確認済み。\n\n@ユイ 営業部での手順(議論1巡→決定→サキ・トワへ分担→実行→レビュー)を完遂しました。上記の通りFAQ3問・チェックリスト5項目が完成・承認済みです。レビューの上、ミナト様へご報告お願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "7fe9b66b-6e3c-4db6-8fa2-62b6fbd606e4", + "name": "コウ" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "実装チーム", + "id": "773707b2-3d41-40d2-ba38-0ff848a633f5", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "a955c6cb-3e14-4943-a40f-f39fc2a6ed60", + "at": 1789189150424, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ソラ リツ(開発部)より、開発部決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づく依頼です。ソラさんに架空CSVサンプル作成を実装チームでお願いします。\n\n【仕様】\n・必須7項目(ヘッダー順固定):顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング+顧客ID併記)・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由\n・失注理由は商談ステータス=失注の行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)のいずれかを記入、それ以外の行は空欄統一\n・契約日は2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)\n・件数は1万件上限\n・件数の事前+事後確認(前後一致)を実施、失敗時は全件やり直し\n・実データ不要・架空データのみ\n\n【手順】下層でも同じ手順を踏んでください:既存メンバーで2巡議論(1巡目懸念出し→修正案→2巡目で合意)→決定後、担当メンバーへ分担割当→担当者が実行→結果をこの依頼への返信でお返しください。私がレビューしレンへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "76e337b4-468a-47e7-8263-85a11272cb46", + "name": "リツ" + } + }, + { + "id": "47f405f4-9f69-4527-a856-7643cb668c4e", + "at": 1789189157744, + "role": "bot", + "text": "リツさん、依頼を受領しました。ソラです。実装チーム内でヒナ・ナギと議論してから分担にかけます。まずは懸念出しと出力形式のすり合わせから始めます。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "ff94e7ed-2ba8-49a8-9679-daa325172e5f", + "at": 1789189172566, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論を開始しました。私の提案:サンプルは5行(失注2行含む)、マスキングは「姓の1文字目+■」+顧客ID、日付は2026-06-12形式、金額はカンマなし整数。ヒナ・ナギの意見を聞いてから決定し、分担を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "36748f45-e7bc-4fc5-bb64-ea665cda6a43", + "at": 1789189172686, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@ヒナ @ナギ\n開発部依頼の架空CSVサンプル作成について。仕様:7項目固定ヘッダー(顧客名=姓マスキング+顧客ID併記・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)、失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)で他は空欄、契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む、1万件上限、件数事前+事後確認、架空のみ。論点:(1)サンプル行数(検証用なら少数行で十分か、何行が良いか)(2)顧客名マスキング表記(例:「山■ C00001」等)(3)日付形式(2026/6/12 か 2026-06-12 か)(4)受注金額書式(カンマ有無・円単位)。各員、前の人の意見に賛否と具体的改善案を述べてください。1巡目は懸念出し→修正案→合意確認まで一気に行います。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "5470d5b8-3046-443e-a33d-4ae1c211294e", + "at": 1789189182951, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ヒなです。ソラ案に概ね賛成です。改善案:(1)行数は5行で妥当ですが、ステータスの種別(商談中・受注・失注)を網羅しつつ失注理由を2行で別分類にすると検証の価値が上がります。(2)マスキング「山■ C00001」賛成。ただし姓が1文字の場合の規定も明記すべきです(例:全■表示)。(3)日付はISO形式2026-06-12賛成。システム取り込みでソート可能な方が安全です。(4)金額はカンマなし整数賛成。CSVでカンマ誤検知を避けるためです。失注行の金額欄は0にするか空欄にするか未決なので、空欄統一を提案します。", + "from": { + "botId": "0addcf8e-d3aa-47ce-ae32-5db9fbc26092", + "name": "ヒナ" + } + }, + { + "id": "d252de52-354c-4671-89ef-2b9c05454147", + "at": 1789189193197, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ナギです。ソラ案・ヒナ案に賛成です。改善案:(1)行数はヘッダー+5行で、失注2行は別分類に賛成。検証側としては失注理由6分類の表記ゆれ(全角半角・空白有無)が無いことを確認したいので、失注理由は語彙を固定(上記6分類のまま改変なし)を仕様に明記してほしい。(2)姓1文字は全■表示案で異議なし。(3)ISO形式賛成、両端(2026-06-12と2026-09-12)を必ず1行ずつ含めると境界検証になる。(4)カンマなし整数賛成、失注行の金額は空欄統一でいいですが「空欄=カンマ区切りで末尾カンマのみ」となるので、私の検査表で列数一致を必ず確認します。", + "from": { + "botId": "cc2c68a3-344b-4657-ac5b-d1a35007c13c", + "name": "ナギ" + } + }, + { + "id": "d8d9bb64-8ef1-43f4-b93b-e26a0c154c96", + "at": 1789189203585, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論の結果、全員の意見が一致したので決定します。\n\n【決定事項】\n1. サンプルはヘッダー+5行。ステータス3種(商談中・受注・失注)を網羅し、失注2行は失注理由を別分類で記入\n2. マスキングは「姓の1文字目+■+半角スペース+顧客ID」(例:山■ C00001)。姓1文字の場合は全■表示\n3. 契約日はISO形式(2026-06-12)。両端2026-06-12と2026-09-12を各1行含める\n4. 受注金額はカンマなし整数。失注行の金額は空欄統一\n5. 失注理由の語彙は6分類を固定(表記ゆれ禁止)\n6. 件数は事前+事後確認(前後一致)、不一致時は全件やり直し\n\nヒナにCSV作成、ナギに検査表作成を割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "50913df7-5ee2-4f17-bdf6-50450ed7b7a2", + "at": 1789189216869, + "role": "bot", + "text": "議論がまとまったので決定事項を確定し、ヒナにCSV作成(ヘッダー+5行・失注理由6分類から語彙固定で2行)、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符・列数一致の検査表作成を割り当てました。2名の成果が返り次第、取りまとめてリツさんへ報告します。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "34b3275d-0a45-44d8-850a-3294f596d7ed", + "at": 1789189217339, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ヒナ 決定事項に基づき、架空CSVサンプル作成を担当してください。仕様:ヘッダー+5行。7項目固定順(顧客名・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。顧客名は「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」(姓1文字は全■)。契約日はISO形式で両端2026-06-12と2026-09-12を各1行含む。ステータス3種網羅、失注2行は失注理由6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)から語彙固定で2つ記入、他行は空欄。金額カンマなし整数、失注行は空欄。件数事前+事後確認(前後一致)を実施し結果に明記。CSV本文を返答してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "8e73f4de-8afc-4045-86bf-adb382dc5d34", + "at": 1789189228234, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ヒナです。決定事項に基づき架空CSVサンプルを作成しました。\n\n【件数確認】\n- 事前確認:ヘッダー1行+データ5行=合計6行\n- 事後確認:出力後カウント=合計6行(前後一致 ✓)\n\n【CSV本文】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【仕様適合チェック】\n- 7項目固定順ヘッダー ✓\n- マスキング「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」、4行目は姓1文字(林想定)で全■表示 ✓\n- ISO形式、両端2026-06-12と2026-09-12を各1行含む ✓\n- ステータス3種(商談中・受注・失注×2)網羅 ✓\n- 失注理由は語彙固定で「価格」「競合選択」の2分類、他行は空欄 ✓\n- 金額カンマなし整数、失注行は空欄 ✓\n\n以上、ナギさんの検査表作成に進んでいただければと思います。", + "from": { + "botId": "0addcf8e-d3aa-47ce-ae32-5db9fbc26092", + "name": "ヒナ" + } + }, + { + "id": "4a2631eb-b35c-471e-9b7e-82de981e0cfe", + "at": 1789189228363, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ナギ 決定事項に基づき、検査担当してください。ヒナが作成するCSV本文(ヘッダー+5行、7項目)を読み、カンマ区切り・引用符・列数一致(各7列、空欄=末尾カンマのみ)・失注理由6分類の語彙固定(表記ゆれなし)・日付ISO形式と両端(2026-06-12/2026-09-12)・金額カンマなし整数・失注行金額空欄・件数事前事後一致、を検査する検査表(表形式)を作成してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + }, + { + "id": "25c84196-f7a8-4e92-9e28-19fa39cc43ff", + "at": 1789189242115, + "role": "bot", + "text": "ナギです。ヒナのCSV本文を読み込み、検査表を作成しました。\n\n【検査表】ヒナ作成CSV(ヘッダー+5行)検査結果\n\n| No | 検査項目 | 検査内容 | 対象行 | 判定 |\n|---|---|---|---|---|\n| 1 | カンマ区切り | 各行カンマ6個(7列)で区切り正常 | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 2 | 引用符 | フィールド内に引用符(\")なし=不要なエスケープなし | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 3 | 列数一致 | ヘッダー+データ5行とも7列 | 全6行 | ✓ |\n| 4 | 空欄表現 | 空欄は末尾カンマのみ(失注理由空欄4行、失注行の金額空欄2行) | 1,2,5行目理由/3,4行目金額 | ✓ |\n| 5 | 失注理由の語彙固定 | 「価格」「競合選択」は6分類内で表記ゆれなし | 3,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 6 | 失注理由の記入条件 | 失注行のみ記入、失注以外は空欄 | 3,4行目 vs 他行 | ✓ |\n| 7 | 日付ISO形式 | 全行YYYY-MM-DD形式 | 2列目全行 | ✓ |\n| 8 | 両端日付 | 2026-06-12(1行目)・2026-09-12(4行目)各1行含む | 1,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 9 | 金額カンマなし整数 | 1,200,000等のカンマなし、「1200000」等整数表記 | 1,2,5行目 | ✓ |\n| 10 | 失注行の金額空欄 | 3,4行目の受注金額は空欄(末尾カンマのみ) | 3,4行目 | ✓ |\n| 11 | マスキング | 「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」、4行目は全■表示 | 1列目全行 | ✓ |\n| 12 | ステータス網羅 | 商談中・受注×2・失注×2の3種 | 5列目 | ✓ |\n| 13 | 件数事前事後一致 | 事前6行=事後6行(ヒナ申告どおり) | 全体 | ✓ |\n\n【総合判定】全13項目 ✓、不備0件。修正不要です。\n\n補足:4行目は姓1文字(林想定)の全■表示「■ C00004」で決定事項2に適合しています。以上、ソラさんの取りまとめにお渡しします。", + "from": { + "botId": "cc2c68a3-344b-4657-ac5b-d1a35007c13c", + "name": "ナギ" + } + }, + { + "id": "4023af1c-0203-4598-830d-02d0dd32d278", + "at": 1789189253271, + "role": "bot", + "text": "リツさん、実装チームで完了しましたので報告します。\n\n【手順実績】ヒナ・ナギと1巡議論(賛否+改善案を出し合い全員合意)→決定→ヒナにCSV作成、ナギに検査表作成を分担→両成果を取りまとめ。\n\n【決定事項】ヘッダー+5行/マスキング「姓1文字目+■ 顧客ID」(姓1文字は全■)/日付ISO形式で両端各1行/金額カンマなし整数・失注行は空欄/失注理由は6分類から語彙固定/件数事前+事後確認。\n\n【成果1:CSV(ヒナ作成、件数事前6行=事後6行一致)】\n```csv\n顧客名,契約ID,契約日,担当営業,商談ステータス,受注金額,失注理由\n山■ C00001,CT-2026-0001,2026-06-12,田中,商談中,1200000,\n鈴■ C00002,CT-2026-0002,2026-07-08,佐藤,受注,3500000,\n高■ C00003,CT-2026-0003,2026-08-20,田中,失注,,価格\n■ C00004,CT-2026-0004,2026-09-12,伊藤,失注,,競合選択\n伊■ C00005,CT-2026-0005,2026-08-05,佐藤,受注,800000,\n```\n\n【成果2:検査表(ナギ作成)】全13項目検査(カンマ区切り・引用符なし・7列一致・空欄表現・語彙固定・ISO日付・両端日付・金額書式・失注行空欄・マスキング・ステータス網羅・件数一致)の結果、**全項目✓・不備0件・修正不要**。\n\n開発部仕様への適合を確認済みです。レビューのうえレン部長へご報告ください。", + "from": { + "botId": "272410c1-6523-42d4-a4f7-155ca44f53f6", + "name": "ソラ" + } + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "QAチーム", + "id": "e6af907b-3f0e-4ed3-9ca9-f52d5b9a6c42", + "hasMore": false, + "messages": [ + { + "id": "34cc4f32-6b08-4be5-9ccc-7d6ecc987825", + "at": 1789189172430, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ マコより開発部決定事項(修正案①〜④両名合意済み)に基づく依頼です。QAチームで検査表(架空CSVサンプル用)を作成してください。\n\n【必須検査項目】\n①件数の事前確認+書き込み後の事後確認(前後一致)\n②失注理由6分類固定(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)。商談ステータス=失注の行のみ必須・他は空欄\n③ヘッダー7項目の順固定(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング)・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)\n④顧客ID併記を必須検査\n⑤契約日は2026/6/12〜2026/9/12(両端含む)\n⑥1万件上限\n⑦失敗時は全件やり直し(再開手順を検査表に明記)\n\n実データ不要・架空のみ。結果はマコがレビューしレンへ報告します。\n\n【手順】下層QAチームでも同じ手順を踏んでください:既存メンバーで議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者(あなた)が受領・進行・採否・取りまとめ。議論はdiscuss_roomで2巡(1巡目懸念出し→修正案→2巡目で回答合意)。実データ・コード変更不要、日本語で。", + "from": { + "botId": "100c295f-af57-4e2a-ba6d-f591fc76a1d1", + "name": "マコ" + } + }, + { + "id": "cfc8f996-54ae-4f66-8889-b428a59c33fa", + "at": 1789189177599, + "role": "bot", + "text": "マコより検査表作成依頼を受けました。QAチームで議論して分担します。まずメンバー確認から。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "4dd2d5f7-f5b7-4d7f-92ec-027a291318ed", + "at": 1789189188380, + "role": "bot", + "text": "マコからの検査表作成依頼を受け、QAチームで1巡目の議論(懸念出し)を開始しました。私の提案:ヘッダーは列挙通り8項目として扱う(依頼文の「7項目」は数え間違いの疑い)、メイは境界値系(件数0・上限ちょうど・超過、日付両端)、ハルは異常系(件数不一致・失注理由違反・権限等・再開手順)を担当とする分担案。2名の意見を聞いてから確定します。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "c2f263df-e7ef-4713-a15e-5cfdc66cda2a", + "at": 1789189188568, + "role": "bot", + "text": "【議論】@メイ @ハル\nマコ氏より依頼の架空CSV検査表作成について1巡目(懸念出し)。必須項目:①件数前後一致②失注理由6分類(失注行のみ必須・他空欄)③ヘッダー8項目順固定(依頼文では「7項目」だが列挙は8個:顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)④顧客ID必須⑤契約日2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む⑥1万件上限⑦失敗時全件やり直し+再開手順明記。各自、懸念と修正案を述べてください。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "3457b168-e91d-4923-b23f-e2bf3cbdd1d2", + "at": 1789189197495, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ 1巡目意見です。ヘッダー8項目扱いに賛成(依頼文の「7項目」は数え間違いで確定)。境界値観点の懸念:①件数0件は「ヘッダーのみ」でOKと明記すべきです(0件=エラーではない)。②上限は9,999件・10,000件ちょうど・10,001件の3点を検査してください。③契約日は2026/6/12と9/12の両端+前日6/11・翌日9/13の範囲外4点。④顧客IDは空欄NG・重複の可否も規定を。修正案:0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表は私が、入力条件と期待結果付きで作成します。", + "from": { + "botId": "84054883-a08d-4548-b859-416e30012dc3", + "name": "メイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "bc19e521-de1e-4002-b4f4-3df07f3df16b", + "at": 1789189207900, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ @メイ 1巡目意見です。ヘッダー8項目扱いに賛成です。異常系観点の懸念:①件数不一致は「生成中の件数変化」も検査すべきです(生成開始後に行が増減するケース。期待結果は全件やり直し⑦に紐づく)。②途中失敗時、部分ファイルの取り扱い(破棄or残置)を検査表に明記を。失敗しても古い全件ファイルが残っていれば誤合格になるため「失敗時は成果物ゼロで全件やり直し」を期待結果に。③権限なしで書き込み先に保存しようとした場合、エラーを出して止まること+再開手順に従いやり直せることを検査。④失注理由は6分類以外の値・失注行なのに空欄・失注以外なのに記入の3パターンを期待結果に込みで定義します。修正案:生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を私が入力条件・期待結果付きで作成します。メイ案の0件=ヘッダーのみOK・9,999/10,000/10,001の3点にも賛成です。", + "from": { + "botId": "44b822df-6c11-4a65-9fcf-75095ceb9c0c", + "name": "ハル" + } + }, + { + "id": "3bdba68c-506d-4014-8c1a-b6e84877576f", + "at": 1789189224569, + "role": "bot", + "text": "1巡目の議論を確認しました。両名の意見は対立なく、相互に賛同済みです(メイ案にハル賛同、ハル案にメイ反対なし)。依頼の2巡目相当(修正案→回答合意)は1巡目内で懸念・修正案・相互賛同が同時に揃ったため成立と判断し、決定します。\n\n【決定】\n- ヘッダーは8項目・順固定(依頼文「7項目」は数え間違い。マコ氏へは報告時に確認依頼を付記)\n- 0件=ヘッダーのみでOK(エラー扱いしない)\n- 件数検査は9,999/10,000/10,001の3点\n- 契約日は6/12・9/12両端OK+6/11・9/13はNG\n- 顧客ID:空欄NG。重複は「顧客ID×契約IDの組の一意性」で検査(同一顧客の複数契約は許容)\n- 途中失敗時は部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロで全件やり直し、再開手順明記\n- 権限なしはエラー停止+再開手順によるやり直しを期待結果に\n\n分担を確定し、両名へ割り当てます。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "cd56a5b4-a428-4d6f-a274-50bfbf24737a", + "at": 1789189240304, + "role": "bot", + "text": "分担を確定しました。\n\n- メイ:境界値3ケース表(0件・10,000件ちょうど・10,001件超過)\n- ハル:異常系3ケース表(生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なし)\n\n両名の完成報告を受け取ったら、検査表を取りまとめ、依頼元のマコさんへ報告します(その際、ヘッダー「7項目→8項目」の数え間違い確認も併記予定)。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "b1dc2da7-d727-4daf-9477-2325fade90bb", + "at": 1789189240568, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@メイ 担当決定(メイさん):境界値3ケース表(①件数0件②上限10,000件ちょうど③上限超過10,001件)を入力条件・期待結果付きで作成してください。前提:0件はヘッダーのみでOK。補足:契約日両端(2026/6/12・9/12 OK、6/11・9/13 NG)、顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約ID組の一意性も各ケースの期待結果に織り込み。ヘッダー8項目順固定。架空データのみ。完了したら私(レオ)へ報告を。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "0f72e72e-48ff-471e-b873-fffa55ec9c45", + "at": 1789189255654, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ 担当分の境界値3ケース表が完成しました。取りまとめにお使いください。\n\n## 境界値検査表(担当:メイ/架空データのみ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目順固定(顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類必須・他行空欄。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 件数0件 | 抽出条件に該当する顧客が0件の状態で生成を実行(件数事前確認=0件) | エラーとならない。ヘッダー8項目のみのCSV(データ行0行)が出力される。件数事後確認=0件で前後一致。 |\n| B-2 | 上限10,000件ちょうど | 該当顧客10,000件(契約日は両端2026/6/12・9/12を含む範囲内に配置。顧客ID空欄なし。顧客ID×契約IDの組は全行一意)で生成を実行 | 正常終了。10,000件が上限内のため全行出力され、事前確認件数=事後確認件数=10,000で前後一致。ヘッダー8項目・順固定を確認。契約日6/12・9/12の行が範囲内として受理。顧客ID空欄0件・組の重複0件。 |\n| B-3 | 上限超過10,001件 | 該当顧客10,001件(うち1件の契約日を2026/6/11、別1件を2026/9/13に設定)で生成を実行 | 上限超過のためエラーとなり生成不可(部分ファイルを出さない)。6/11・9/13の行は範囲外として弾かれること。10,001件をそのまま出力しないこと。 |\n\n補足:契約日両端・範囲外(6/11・9/13)、顧客ID空欄NG、一意性はB-2・B-3の入力条件・期待結果に織り込み済み。ハルさんの異常系3ケース表と結合してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "84054883-a08d-4548-b859-416e30012dc3", + "name": "メイ" + } + }, + { + "id": "943b00be-8bcf-4e7a-9fb1-1487c2ead94d", + "at": 1789189255726, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@ハル 担当決定(ハルさん):異常系3ケース表(①生成中の件数変化②生成途中失敗③保存先への権限なし)を入力条件・期待結果付きで作成してください。期待結果の前提:①は前後件数不一致検出→全件やり直し⑦に紐づく。②は部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロ・全件やり直し+再開手順明記。③はエラー停止+再開手順によるやり直し。失注理由の6分類以外・失注行空欄・失注以外で記入の3パターンも織り込み。ヘッダー8項目順固定。架空データのみ。完了したら私(レオ)へ報告を。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + }, + { + "id": "627f52b4-6745-4169-a810-cf22b97a3348", + "at": 1789189265112, + "role": "bot", + "text": "@レオ 担当分の異常系3ケース表が完成しました。取りまとめにお使いください。\n\n## 異常系検査表(担当:ハル/架空データのみ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目順固定(顧客名・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)必須・他行空欄。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 事前確認5,000件で生成開始後、生成完了前に元データが更新され、事後確認が4,999件・5,001件のいずれかになる状態で書き込み完了 | 前後件数不一致を検出しエラーとなる(決定事項⑦に紐づく)。不一致ファイルは不合格として出さない。全件やり直し:再抽出→事前確認→再生成→事後確認の一致を確認。 |\n| E-2 | 生成途中失敗 | 10,000件中3,000件書き込み済みの段階で意図的に失敗を発生(部分ファイルが存在する状態) | 部分ファイル(3,000件分)は破棄され成果物ゼロ。古い全件ファイルが残っていても誤合格としない。エラー停止後、再開手順(部分ファイル削除確認→再抽出→全件再生成→前後件数一致確認)で全件やり直し。 |\n| E-3 | 保存先への権限なし | 書き込み先フォルダに対して書き込み権限のない状態で生成を実行(データ自体は正常) | 書き込み時にエラーとなり停止(空ファイル・部分ファイルを出さない)。再開手順(権限付与→フォルダ確認→再生成)によりやり直せば正常出力されることを確認。 |\n\n失注理由の3パターンは各ケースの入力データに織り込み済み:E-1に「6分類以外の値(例：予算不足)」、E-2に「失注行なのに空欄」、E-3に「失注以外の行に失注理由を記入」を含め、いずれもエラー検出・弾き落としが期待結果に含まれます。メイさんの境界値表と結合してください。", + "from": { + "botId": "44b822df-6c11-4a65-9fcf-75095ceb9c0c", + "name": "ハル" + } + }, + { + "id": "2f7a58f2-3d3a-49ba-bb89-95db775a9fff", + "at": 1789189280047, + "role": "bot", + "text": "両名の成果物を受領し、採否します。結論:メイさんの境界値3ケース表、ハルさんの異常系3ケース表ともに入力条件・期待結果が必須項目①〜⑦を網羅しており、修正不要で**採用**です。取りまとめた成果がこちらです。\n\n## 架空CSVサンプル検査表(QAチーム取りまとめ/レオ)\n\n共通前提:ヘッダー8項目・順固定(顧客名(姓のみ簡易マスキング)・顧客ID・契約ID・契約日・担当営業・商談ステータス・受注金額・失注理由)。失注理由は失注行のみ6分類(価格・機能不足・競合選択・タイミング・決裁権者未了・その他)必須・他行空欄。顧客ID空欄NG・顧客ID×契約IDの組は全行一意。契約日は2026/6/12〜9/12両端含む。全ケース架空データのみ。\n\n| No | ケース | 入力条件 | 期待結果 |\n|---|---|---|---|\n| B-1 | 件数0件 | 該当顧客0件で生成実行(事前確認=0件) | エラーとならない。ヘッダーのみのCSV出力。事後確認=0件で前後一致。 |\n| B-2 | 上限10,000件ちょうど | 該当10,000件(両端6/12・9/12を含む範囲内、顧客ID空欄なし、組一意)で生成 | 正常終了。全行出力、事前=事後=10,000で一致。ヘッダー8項目順固定・両端受理・空欄0・重複0を確認。 |\n| B-3 | 上限超過10,001件 | 該当10,001件(1件を6/11、別1件を9/13に設定)で生成 | 上限超過のためエラー・生成不可(部分ファイルなし)。6/11・9/13は範囲外として弾かれる。10,001件を出さない。 |\n| E-1 | 生成中の件数変化 | 事前確認5,000件→生成中に元データ更新→事後確認4,999/5,001件(6分類外の失注理由を混入) | 前後不一致を検出しエラー(⑦に紐づく)。不一致ファイルは不合格。再抽出→事前確認→再生成→事後確認一致まで全件やり直し。 |\n| E-2 | 生成途中失敗 | 10,000件中3,000件書き込み済みで意図的失敗(失注行なのに失注理由空欄を混入) | 部分ファイル破棄・成果物ゼロ。古い全件ファイルが残っていても誤合格としない。再開手順(部分削除確認→再抽出→全件再生成→前後一致確認)でやり直し。 |\n| E-3 | 保存先への権限なし | 書き込み権限なしのフォルダへ生成(失注以外の行に失注理由記入を混入) | 書き込み時エラー停止(空・部分ファイルなし)。再開手順(権限付与→フォルダ確認→再生成)で正常出力されることを確認。 |\n\n@マコ への報告事項:依頼文③の「ヘッダー7項目」は列挙が8個のため**8項目として作成**しました(数え間違いの確認をご依頼)。レビューの上、レンさんへご報告をお願いします。", + "from": { + "botId": "c85f3729-ff51-4a0b-be45-132263fa959b", + "name": "レオ" + } + } + ] + } + ], + "failedToolCalls": [ + { + "room": "経営会議", + "id": "644a3670-e40a-4e7c-a3b9-bb3bf51f24a5", + "at": 1789188946366, + "author": "ミナト", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "a13c2105-e9d5-4293-a24b-5ee12b2dd813", + "at": 1789189027914, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "c14e87a5-de68-4779-96c2-3cece0aaff5c", + "at": 1789189068043, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "0156e111-d789-4bca-abab-6ca060bb50d5", + "at": 1789189110429, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "98dd3ab0-e685-4d4d-a1de-2033ad1ac9a8", + "at": 1789189111632, + "author": "レン", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "5e8ff42c-dc0f-47af-943a-1ee5f9add313", + "at": 1789189131784, + "author": "リツ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__send_room_message" + }, + { + "room": "開発部", + "id": "f39be765-63bc-4e6b-baea-81f3cca040e8", + "at": 1789189160751, + "author": "マコ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__send_room_message" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "be2d503a-dc70-48ff-aad3-31cde175ab12", + "at": 1789189044397, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "84287695-d625-4d65-bfea-ec3162845e76", + "at": 1789189084146, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "営業部", + "id": "b9fe7b40-dbf2-41ba-9f57-ae84d2a573d0", + "at": 1789189085597, + "author": "コウ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "e967877a-5f7a-4e03-8a9c-871d7b511107", + "at": 1789189160595, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__discuss_room" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "0ef235f2-76dc-476a-a3df-920a1b5eb420", + "at": 1789189206041, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "実装チーム", + "id": "c087ed61-6d2b-4fcb-be23-222f80eaf231", + "at": 1789189207472, + "author": "ソラ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "QAチーム", + "id": "51f00708-5328-49e8-9a8b-ad9f9ec1c2e3", + "at": 1789189225821, + "author": "レオ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + }, + { + "room": "QAチーム", + "id": "36940456-0d46-47c9-8ccd-23fedaad8141", + "at": 1789189227465, + "author": "レオ", + "tool": "mcp__agents__assign_room_member" + } + ] +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-discussion.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-discussion.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..aac769ddfc Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-discussion.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-results.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-results.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..146456ee23 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sales-results.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sha256.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sha256.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..da311e3e48 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/sha256.txt @@ -0,0 +1,14 @@ +6d2f1db16f734b0d9b08abcc35102f81668d4068d0cc9b0d33767d5734254189 after-incoming.png +199ae4ebdedb5a007fe44de476142ddecffd17111620918c4eaf8afd83e208b7 before-development.png +95bbe3d477badc8714d6cdce976b9a273d615576aec57c99a277ba39b2f12849 development-decision.png +03d9e0428c89d95bf06e2804940d2a5fa906a69fb11886f11c91879b9f10ad69 development-discussion.png +e02859b50be496d6c874c0e00e923465f02d79c80b23f611db4b7e840985718b development-results.png +cf88c34c617d472ed380eb5f84c5c5bbab38c57e10264f73e18f4dd6b008938f executive-discussion.png +e7ee64b1a59c6572e3a819c957153d2b8028e907f3110094143b2d57b1455706 executive-results.png +584f4ad64837e4dfe047b6dada830a48261d654411de2bd4e53a33b8f0b778ff implementation-discussion.png +c63be6201a44739e46a50584d07f23b81a24e193344c67b56650ba7182a68201 implementation-results.png +b83a8cea8e43296d28d079968fb02fad1dd318894a3969ca5e61be2b1206351f qa-discussion.png +3fe62ba7a87b80f9aad0e80974323cf27a359afd2c48d3981fa0e5824a71f678 qa-results.png +0f96b1914bcb26c43788db1546a6675fe9650e689ebb7990a348b6f65621fffa sales-discussion.png +b664add3ac670b51e1e74731b08da6cef5b692a7e533bdfa1d38166ba64393cf sales-results.png +add39c4177394f59693abb15710a4155adab4e359cac679f8c47274fa3d5dea8 transcripts.json diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/transcripts.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/transcripts.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..a6a5663c68 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/transcripts.json @@ -0,0 +1,810 @@ +{ + "verifiedAt": "2026-09-12T03:16:44.736Z", + "upstreamBase": "2f91c462926bee70242c42a4e3443b19d0a13a0c", + "mode": "scripted provider through real server and injected agents MCP proxy", + "counts": { + "rooms": 5, + "bots": 15, + "providerTurns": 45, + "work": 5, + "discussion": 7, + "assignment": 10 + }, + "rooms": [ + { + "id": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "name": "経営会議", + "members": [ + { + "id": "3c339920-b4de-49c4-a29d-751747f3f919", + "name": "ミナト" + }, + { + "id": "fec2bbd5-0ce8-428c-a150-226ed9c3d4df", + "name": "アオイ" + }, + { + "id": "e5ed9959-e0ed-42db-990f-87e65bc47abf", + "name": "ユイ" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "name": "開発部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "d5a78f9e-766b-41a8-a39d-bc50e3742f8d", + "name": "レン" + }, + { + "id": "f2b50c32-554c-4399-a59d-5c115c37554e", + "name": "リツ" + }, + { + "id": "d24278e4-9945-4564-b5c6-1d237fddaecc", + "name": "マコ" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "name": "営業部", + "members": [ + { + "id": "588009d9-b98e-490d-ad64-c3dcb8e8d015", + "name": "コウ" + }, + { + "id": "c7f464cc-1cc0-41ef-a965-dcbbb6507c02", + "name": "サキ" + }, + { + "id": "50f7638f-999b-497f-9120-ed7ab29dd3ef", + "name": "トワ" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "name": "実装チーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "08c01ac1-f61b-4007-b7dc-1ca92db67181", + "name": "ソラ" + }, + { + "id": "9f3e693e-d96e-430b-8064-4c7838cff271", + "name": "ヒナ" + }, + { + "id": "6e814307-d639-48f1-8982-f4d0c865b801", + "name": "ナギ" + } + ] + }, + { + "id": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "name": "QAチーム", + "members": [ + { + "id": "93883387-c852-4070-8c8d-cfe281c5eda4", + "name": "レオ" + }, + { + "id": "32a61812-a269-4b6a-9cfc-d33aacc0c9d1", + "name": "メイ" + }, + { + "id": "c7c91731-aa02-4039-986d-32a5ccd02bc9", + "name": "ハル" + } + ] + } + ], + "nodes": [ + { + "id": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "groupId": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "botId": "3c339920-b4de-49c4-a29d-751747f3f919", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "0ffa3a8d-d6c0-4df7-9e2a-92be53ad0c55", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "groupId": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "botId": "3c339920-b4de-49c4-a29d-751747f3f919", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "fec2bbd5-0ce8-428c-a150-226ed9c3d4df", + "e5ed9959-e0ed-42db-990f-87e65bc47abf" + ] + }, + { + "id": "8c36beb3-edea-4a96-80a2-a48c10cd925b", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "groupId": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "botId": "3c339920-b4de-49c4-a29d-751747f3f919", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "fec2bbd5-0ce8-428c-a150-226ed9c3d4df", + "e5ed9959-e0ed-42db-990f-87e65bc47abf" + ] + }, + { + "id": "f36012d8-c7e8-4e18-87df-a3c8188ad6c5", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "groupId": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "botId": "fec2bbd5-0ce8-428c-a150-226ed9c3d4df", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "490887a3-e188-4e20-837a-af3526f6b81e", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "groupId": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "botId": "e5ed9959-e0ed-42db-990f-87e65bc47abf", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "11ab9f67-ba52-46d5-8e05-d375168345dc", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f36012d8-c7e8-4e18-87df-a3c8188ad6c5", + "groupId": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "botId": "d5a78f9e-766b-41a8-a39d-bc50e3742f8d", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "4df43c11-006f-43b0-84bf-c19411914797", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "490887a3-e188-4e20-837a-af3526f6b81e", + "groupId": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "botId": "588009d9-b98e-490d-ad64-c3dcb8e8d015", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "87b55bdd-8255-45e4-9767-171a65d40a0c", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "11ab9f67-ba52-46d5-8e05-d375168345dc", + "groupId": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "botId": "d5a78f9e-766b-41a8-a39d-bc50e3742f8d", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "f2b50c32-554c-4399-a59d-5c115c37554e", + "d24278e4-9945-4564-b5c6-1d237fddaecc" + ] + }, + { + "id": "3e2003ad-91a4-4d5e-98a7-2dc3f1afed3c", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "4df43c11-006f-43b0-84bf-c19411914797", + "groupId": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "botId": "588009d9-b98e-490d-ad64-c3dcb8e8d015", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "c7f464cc-1cc0-41ef-a965-dcbbb6507c02", + "50f7638f-999b-497f-9120-ed7ab29dd3ef" + ] + }, + { + "id": "d1985252-511d-42eb-a941-eb5fc5d13fbb", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "11ab9f67-ba52-46d5-8e05-d375168345dc", + "groupId": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "botId": "d5a78f9e-766b-41a8-a39d-bc50e3742f8d", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "f2b50c32-554c-4399-a59d-5c115c37554e", + "d24278e4-9945-4564-b5c6-1d237fddaecc" + ] + }, + { + "id": "14322134-911f-44db-841a-f7e9b1372020", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "4df43c11-006f-43b0-84bf-c19411914797", + "groupId": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "botId": "c7f464cc-1cc0-41ef-a965-dcbbb6507c02", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "c05111a1-07ca-4310-938c-2ac1752b0c1b", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "4df43c11-006f-43b0-84bf-c19411914797", + "groupId": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "botId": "50f7638f-999b-497f-9120-ed7ab29dd3ef", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "f86eaf02-d93f-44d9-82f0-2842aa03b4aa", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "11ab9f67-ba52-46d5-8e05-d375168345dc", + "groupId": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "botId": "f2b50c32-554c-4399-a59d-5c115c37554e", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "87458a4b-c093-4c2c-9bac-5b3052a2302b", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "11ab9f67-ba52-46d5-8e05-d375168345dc", + "groupId": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "botId": "d24278e4-9945-4564-b5c6-1d237fddaecc", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "da53666d-11ae-49d6-ba2c-499dbfabfbb5", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "f86eaf02-d93f-44d9-82f0-2842aa03b4aa", + "groupId": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "botId": "08c01ac1-f61b-4007-b7dc-1ca92db67181", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "ec3747e8-43f0-4b25-96e0-dfe989fc20fb", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "87458a4b-c093-4c2c-9bac-5b3052a2302b", + "groupId": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "botId": "93883387-c852-4070-8c8d-cfe281c5eda4", + "kind": "work", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "bf5c8d31-221e-4af4-ba26-395a27c2b2b3", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "da53666d-11ae-49d6-ba2c-499dbfabfbb5", + "groupId": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "botId": "08c01ac1-f61b-4007-b7dc-1ca92db67181", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "9f3e693e-d96e-430b-8064-4c7838cff271", + "6e814307-d639-48f1-8982-f4d0c865b801" + ] + }, + { + "id": "467ae67c-7a2d-4f96-af99-08264e942437", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "ec3747e8-43f0-4b25-96e0-dfe989fc20fb", + "groupId": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "botId": "93883387-c852-4070-8c8d-cfe281c5eda4", + "kind": "discussion", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [ + "32a61812-a269-4b6a-9cfc-d33aacc0c9d1", + "c7c91731-aa02-4039-986d-32a5ccd02bc9" + ] + }, + { + "id": "45c51d22-b123-46d9-852b-fbcba2d00ce2", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "da53666d-11ae-49d6-ba2c-499dbfabfbb5", + "groupId": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "botId": "9f3e693e-d96e-430b-8064-4c7838cff271", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "aff903d0-45f0-406c-9446-f57a93f7a93a", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "da53666d-11ae-49d6-ba2c-499dbfabfbb5", + "groupId": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "botId": "6e814307-d639-48f1-8982-f4d0c865b801", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "19ba03da-7f3e-43d9-b0d9-0a36a046eaf2", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "ec3747e8-43f0-4b25-96e0-dfe989fc20fb", + "groupId": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "botId": "32a61812-a269-4b6a-9cfc-d33aacc0c9d1", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + }, + { + "id": "ecac1577-102c-4377-a015-1d3f5558abf1", + "rootId": "f98945ec-65f5-4c04-aea8-a8a2b9e325a2", + "parentId": "ec3747e8-43f0-4b25-96e0-dfe989fc20fb", + "groupId": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "botId": "c7c91731-aa02-4039-986d-32a5ccd02bc9", + "kind": "assignment", + "status": "completed", + "participants": [] + } + ], + "transcripts": [ + { + "name": "経営会議", + "id": "47a0e446-4327-4f3c-9ced-3f04446d64c9", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "7e88fd44-2b4b-48fc-9da8-739d721b8cdc", + "at": 1789182984095, + "speaker": "Fixture user", + "text": "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をassign_room_memberで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。" + }, + { + "id": "85a9cab9-b057-4f0f-b551-a758022bea9b", + "at": 1789182984547, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "経営会議仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。" + }, + { + "id": "83d888bb-1668-459e-ab02-fcb7b25b7554", + "at": 1789182984571, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n経営会議第1巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "fb7e661c-1984-408c-b527-6ad3bd3f8b05", + "at": 1789182984995, + "speaker": "アオイ", + "text": "アオイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "2306195f-ba6a-41dc-8139-60555b0613e1", + "at": 1789182985491, + "speaker": "ユイ", + "text": "ユイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "4aaf595f-5086-4357-a996-f9eda70830f3", + "at": 1789182986699, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "経営会議修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。" + }, + { + "id": "009c0589-f94c-4488-ad4c-4a83f921f499", + "at": 1789182986873, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "【議論】@アオイ @ユイ\n経営会議第2巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "5bb51b7f-13ea-417c-8d77-2dd0601f4bb8", + "at": 1789182987394, + "speaker": "アオイ", + "text": "アオイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。" + }, + { + "id": "1bcbb2f1-604b-40e3-8549-31c40656f6c8", + "at": 1789182987917, + "speaker": "ユイ", + "text": "ユイ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。" + }, + { + "id": "8c5d073e-bbe4-4fae-9b51-a970d105e48a", + "at": 1789182988810, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "経営会議決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。" + }, + { + "id": "cafc119c-7269-44dc-a094-1192e6ff7874", + "at": 1789182988922, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "@アオイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "0566023c-5952-4342-8b57-947ea0c65611", + "at": 1789182989349, + "speaker": "アオイ", + "text": "アオイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。" + }, + { + "id": "1914358e-f3e5-472d-80fa-72cdf3b21b67", + "at": 1789182989426, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "@ユイ 経営会議決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "4ea50552-188b-460c-a5c8-fd48e1a81e7f", + "at": 1789182989923, + "speaker": "ユイ", + "text": "ユイ担当として下層へ依頼しました。" + }, + { + "id": "ce3dcbef-9754-4323-bd5a-09dfe1de42bb", + "at": 1789182995077, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "@ユイ\n\n営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + }, + { + "id": "29a30ab7-0fb3-440c-b8ac-01b66441a26f", + "at": 1789182995802, + "speaker": "ユイ", + "text": "ユイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。" + }, + { + "id": "3e3b0f2c-f3b6-476a-81e9-c1d4854a8333", + "at": 1789183002739, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "@アオイ\n\n開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + }, + { + "id": "d46523ad-82a1-4e0c-b23f-bfa5d8da98a8", + "at": 1789183003461, + "speaker": "アオイ", + "text": "アオイ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。" + }, + { + "id": "fbe06e07-55e2-4d2d-9e0a-60dd4ed04518", + "at": 1789183004235, + "speaker": "ミナト", + "text": "経営会議統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "開発部", + "id": "673fc188-cde9-4ff4-bbcf-11862e27fa8a", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "762cb5d5-e081-4371-9c46-42da0e38b55a", + "at": 1789182989429, + "speaker": "アオイ", + "text": "@レン 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。" + }, + { + "id": "ea81bddf-b03b-485c-958d-cbb722c3ed1f", + "at": 1789182990042, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "開発部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。" + }, + { + "id": "397ffa8b-30da-4a40-a256-d70e8e90cd80", + "at": 1789182990195, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n開発部第1巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "386187cd-8982-48d8-ba0a-8aba977cdb20", + "at": 1789182990664, + "speaker": "リツ", + "text": "リツ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "439181d2-3cbd-4541-b02d-344606a810f9", + "at": 1789182991149, + "speaker": "マコ", + "text": "マコ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "a193ca75-5117-4e22-9802-32eebf38da78", + "at": 1789182991952, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "開発部修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。" + }, + { + "id": "a299f549-fac9-44b7-bb45-476f52103950", + "at": 1789182992037, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "【議論】@リツ @マコ\n開発部第2巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "66058ad0-bb44-4421-8717-bd476365dd74", + "at": 1789182992630, + "speaker": "リツ", + "text": "リツ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。" + }, + { + "id": "eea68583-b4e6-42d8-98dc-191110d9c1c0", + "at": 1789182993139, + "speaker": "マコ", + "text": "マコ再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。" + }, + { + "id": "c53ef05f-ec00-40f5-a3c2-8c9ca2e153ae", + "at": 1789182994195, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "開発部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。" + }, + { + "id": "889253d7-e7ed-4632-959a-afece308d0b4", + "at": 1789182994338, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "@リツ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "51b784ea-3018-4b95-88bb-aa27e0f8015e", + "at": 1789182994894, + "speaker": "リツ", + "text": "リツ担当として下層へ依頼しました。" + }, + { + "id": "e7083812-1628-4d85-8550-5c78055ef513", + "at": 1789182995088, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "@マコ 開発部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "53572f9f-60be-4154-80c1-b0239704716b", + "at": 1789182995622, + "speaker": "マコ", + "text": "マコ担当として下層へ依頼しました。" + }, + { + "id": "2fd43132-0f4f-4477-9c92-4de0632bfce8", + "at": 1789182999672, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "@リツ\n\n実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + }, + { + "id": "39cac409-1b8a-44ff-aff0-6b25e3d1d004", + "at": 1789183000502, + "speaker": "リツ", + "text": "リツ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。" + }, + { + "id": "70a23cea-50c7-45ef-bb62-b6a265ecc98a", + "at": 1789183001206, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "@マコ\n\nQAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + }, + { + "id": "b61e5810-e523-46a8-9709-ba4d6b7ad8ab", + "at": 1789183001890, + "speaker": "マコ", + "text": "マコ成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。" + }, + { + "id": "eb59036a-2e6e-403d-84d0-87531e2b4722", + "at": 1789183002666, + "speaker": "レン", + "text": "開発部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "営業部", + "id": "0c06f092-f998-4d33-8771-fa960120b97d", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "043a4477-1443-4f9c-81f7-2f36d59f807a", + "at": 1789182989942, + "speaker": "ユイ", + "text": "@コウ 経営会議決定を具体化した依頼。公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。" + }, + { + "id": "d98a1c43-4ac6-4928-bbe7-150243aa1df5", + "at": 1789182990465, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "営業部仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。" + }, + { + "id": "0fb8dbb7-9df9-4e99-bd3e-dd3ad76da8c5", + "at": 1789182990719, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "【議論】@サキ @トワ\n営業部第1巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "99cf1be0-f285-41e1-877c-138351d0902d", + "at": 1789182991201, + "speaker": "サキ", + "text": "サキ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "7e1acff8-9fb8-4852-a15a-6774bf6f27d8", + "at": 1789182991641, + "speaker": "トワ", + "text": "トワ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "ec71e323-19e4-4b35-8787-d9231ebf5a11", + "at": 1789182992696, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "営業部決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。" + }, + { + "id": "89d65380-685e-4e2c-b3e4-9af708a6cbd9", + "at": 1789182992807, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "@サキ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "ccfdf053-9820-466e-b27b-40bc48388313", + "at": 1789182993318, + "speaker": "サキ", + "text": "サキ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "f0c92c89-4ae9-4c8c-84c4-d4fee1f2cc1e", + "at": 1789182993580, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "@トワ 営業部決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "e33e4f01-1bcf-4baf-8b6f-0ee61509cf09", + "at": 1789182994155, + "speaker": "トワ", + "text": "トワ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "4a1e81e3-1c60-4aa6-b4ed-a5e87a76d64e", + "at": 1789182995051, + "speaker": "コウ", + "text": "営業部統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "実装チーム", + "id": "ec6c7832-5b3c-4609-ad74-6721c2a0a249", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "a6feeed9-26b7-421b-a804-f020590aeaa9", + "at": 1789182995094, + "speaker": "リツ", + "text": "@ソラ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。" + }, + { + "id": "70ca7179-f7f3-4697-b8bf-21565f0393eb", + "at": 1789182995641, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "実装チーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。" + }, + { + "id": "acef2b87-061a-465f-bf45-f1a3750b0688", + "at": 1789182995849, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "【議論】@ヒナ @ナギ\n実装チーム第1巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "1c5bf6e1-d22f-4418-940d-f12f99ad1c60", + "at": 1789182996359, + "speaker": "ヒナ", + "text": "ヒナ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "8298c6e0-5a90-487a-aea4-974a88efb008", + "at": 1789182996779, + "speaker": "ナギ", + "text": "ナギ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "59e80938-cc4e-416f-ba3b-d06a2f75f545", + "at": 1789182997583, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "実装チーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。" + }, + { + "id": "db4fda9d-0310-40af-9d6a-7c134d98740f", + "at": 1789182997633, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "@ヒナ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "671de229-f3a0-434d-87bf-65e77c3ec7ff", + "at": 1789182998061, + "speaker": "ヒナ", + "text": "ヒナ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "e7db4240-8744-4e65-a91c-f2aa35eb785f", + "at": 1789182998148, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "@ナギ 実装チーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "c9e968b1-4f65-4b8a-8e27-c39be2202e59", + "at": 1789182998595, + "speaker": "ナギ", + "text": "ナギ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "177e55bc-37b7-4923-84ad-71ec3e3970c1", + "at": 1789182999479, + "speaker": "ソラ", + "text": "実装チーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + } + ] + }, + { + "name": "QAチーム", + "id": "239ed4ef-aaf9-43b9-bace-1d889e5b9708", + "messages": [ + { + "id": "85adb313-eaca-487a-b829-85915a65f245", + "at": 1789182995844, + "speaker": "マコ", + "text": "@レオ 開発部決定を具体化した依頼。受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。" + }, + { + "id": "b1065f17-282d-487a-8aba-5e5f75d5e1d6", + "at": 1789182996403, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "QAチーム仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。" + }, + { + "id": "6f8c8e00-ffa7-40d6-99ae-9d5b64a543cc", + "at": 1789182996609, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "【議論】@メイ @ハル\nQAチーム第1巡。修正案を検討" + }, + { + "id": "c94143b3-989b-426a-b985-94a939bfac45", + "at": 1789182997051, + "speaker": "メイ", + "text": "メイ懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "85ec0cc1-4886-441d-8c94-f856d8b3923b", + "at": 1789182997516, + "speaker": "ハル", + "text": "ハル懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。" + }, + { + "id": "492bef82-4b94-430c-8a94-f61760fcf387", + "at": 1789182998402, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "QAチーム決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。" + }, + { + "id": "0735bdc2-a880-4988-9ce0-82341550976b", + "at": 1789182998649, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "@メイ QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "fed560e2-fca5-4416-87ea-dd10724ed81f", + "at": 1789182999155, + "speaker": "メイ", + "text": "メイ成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "e2ed1255-2ede-4687-9d6b-9371707b2142", + "at": 1789182999426, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "@ハル QAチーム決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください" + }, + { + "id": "2e29261f-ac88-4416-88eb-3604dbec6075", + "at": 1789183000064, + "speaker": "ハル", + "text": "ハル成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。" + }, + { + "id": "5572cac5-3b69-4e03-b7c6-07e6ebf9f060", + "at": 1789183000998, + "speaker": "レオ", + "text": "QAチーム統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。" + } + ] + } + ], + "limitations": [ + "Responses are scripted; no current-base GLM-5.3 quality or cost claim.", + "Terminal scheduler states do not prove semantic artifact correctness.", + "Before screenshots use the unmodified upstream renderer with the same fixture data; they do not demonstrate pre-change execution of the workflow." + ] +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/.gitattributes b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2b08dab75d --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +*.txt -text +*.json -text diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/README.md b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..cc8bbefbf4 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,45 @@ +# UI verification after upstream f8cbc562 + +Recorded 2026-09-13, Windows / Node 24.15.0 / pnpm 10.33.0. +Before: upstream `f8cbc562b4b8ac70d343b472c29843a8f001de85`. +After: `8ad7afbc`, including that upstream and the hierarchy extension. + +Both fixtures use `launchVerificationServer` and the real threads preview, +temporary homes, fake providers and four named fixture members. The randomly +named initial bot differs between fixtures. No live app or credentials are used. + +The in-app browser captures show the same Development group: + +- `before-group.png`: current upstream, without optional hierarchy settings. +- `after-default.png`: optional settings start unchecked. +- `after-configured.png`: discussion required, incoming Executive selected. +- `after-unrestricted.png`: incoming restriction removed, discussion retained. + +All four images were visually inspected. Corresponding DOM snapshots are +retained. The two settings JSON files come from the fixture HTTP API after the +UI changes; they confirm persisted values and the same three member IDs. +Restoring unrestricted incoming requests stores `incomingGroupIds: null`. + +This is a settings/UI integration check, not a new live-model experiment. +The separately rerun three-layer fixtures passed: each layer discusses before +delegation, and the branching pyramid has 15 members, 45 scripted turns, +5 work nodes, 10 assignments and 7 discussions. Earlier five-group transcript +screenshots remain in the dated integration directory; they are not relabeled +as captures of this upstream revision. + +Local focused verification after the merge: 180/182 tests passed across 12 +files. The two failures were the new team-computer test's POSIX mode assertion +on Windows and a symlink creation `EPERM`. The mode follow-up preserves real +atomic writes, requires mode 0600 for every write on all OSes, retains the exact +POSIX stat assertion and checks owner read/write bits on Windows. That file +then passed 9/10 cases; the unchanged symlink-security case still fails at +fixture setup on this account. Hosted CI must verify it independently. + +Canvas, shared-computer and composer UI scenarios passed. Initial unpinned +browser launches timed out. The pinned agent-browser 0.36.0-omb.1 resolved that +startup problem; the saved-key scenario additionally needed a bounded wait +for visible controls, then passed in 37.14 seconds with its original behavior +and cleanup assertions. Typecheck, lint, i18n validation and build passed. + +These focused checks do not constitute a full green test suite or establish +Windows ACL isolation. Final-head CI and review status are reported on the PR. diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6f95846bb4 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,112 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pixel Rename Pixel Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pixel" + - button "Rename Pixel": Pixel + - generic: Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pixel threads": + - button "New folder under Pixel": + - button "Actions for Pixel": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" + - paragraph: Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here. + - checkbox "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work" [checked] + - text: Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work + - checkbox "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups" [checked] + - text: Restrict incoming requests to selected groups + - checkbox "Executive" [checked] [active] + - generic: Executive + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-settings.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-settings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9394e6c61f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured-settings.json @@ -0,0 +1,34 @@ +{ + "id": "6bbd760d-e1bf-4946-9efb-eda3b4457c3d", + "threadId": "b7e26977-ee01-4737-94eb-f2a0f69a6706", + "name": "Development", + "memberIds": [ + "2ce8161e-4158-4572-b384-7bfa52eda02f", + "fb54a36c-e41b-491c-bd0b-f6b47de94f10", + "3cf3e4d3-116e-4201-b16f-8cca925ea522" + ], + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "2ce8161e-4158-4572-b384-7bfa52eda02f" + }, + "bulletin": "", + "unread": false, + "createdAt": 1789308630785, + "busyBotId": null, + "tasks": [ + { + "threadId": "b7e26977-ee01-4737-94eb-f2a0f69a6706", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789308630785 + } + ], + "setupCompletedAt": 1789308630785, + "setupSkippedAt": null, + "requireRoomDiscussion": true, + "incomingGroupIds": [ + "1fdf0322-fcad-4737-8161-20b0a9b04cb3" + ], + "working": false, + "messages": [], + "activeLeafId": null +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..09f0a16384 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-configured.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..cac0aa9419 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pixel Rename Pixel Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pixel" + - button "Rename Pixel": Pixel + - generic: Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pixel threads": + - button "New folder under Pixel": + - button "Actions for Pixel": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" [active] + - paragraph: Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here. + - checkbox "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work" + - text: Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work + - checkbox "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups" + - text: Restrict incoming requests to selected groups + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..08aac26bab Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-default.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..030447a34b --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,110 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Pixel Rename Pixel Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Pixel" + - button "Rename Pixel": Pixel + - generic: Hi, I'm Pixel. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Pixel threads": + - button "New folder under Pixel": + - button "Actions for Pixel": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - generic "Group collaboration settings" + - paragraph: Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here. + - checkbox "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work" [checked] + - text: Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work + - checkbox "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups" [active] + - text: Restrict incoming requests to selected groups + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-settings.json b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-settings.json new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..1ba7eee355 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted-settings.json @@ -0,0 +1,32 @@ +{ + "id": "6bbd760d-e1bf-4946-9efb-eda3b4457c3d", + "threadId": "b7e26977-ee01-4737-94eb-f2a0f69a6706", + "name": "Development", + "memberIds": [ + "2ce8161e-4158-4572-b384-7bfa52eda02f", + "fb54a36c-e41b-491c-bd0b-f6b47de94f10", + "3cf3e4d3-116e-4201-b16f-8cca925ea522" + ], + "defaultResponder": { + "kind": "member", + "botId": "2ce8161e-4158-4572-b384-7bfa52eda02f" + }, + "bulletin": "", + "unread": false, + "createdAt": 1789308630785, + "busyBotId": null, + "tasks": [ + { + "threadId": "b7e26977-ee01-4737-94eb-f2a0f69a6706", + "title": "New task", + "createdAt": 1789308630785 + } + ], + "setupCompletedAt": 1789308630785, + "setupSkippedAt": null, + "requireRoomDiscussion": true, + "incomingGroupIds": null, + "working": false, + "messages": [], + "activeLeafId": null +} diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..cb6a484794 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/after-unrestricted.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-dom.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-dom.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..41a0f60345 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-dom.txt @@ -0,0 +1,104 @@ +- complementary "Bots and navigation": + - button "Collapse sidebar to avatars": + - button "Choose sidebar density" + - button "New or share": + - textbox "Search bots and messages": + - /placeholder: Search + - button "Group chats" [expanded]: + - generic: Group chats + - button "Ren Ritsu +1 Development" [active]: + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - generic: "+1" + - generic: Development + - button "Collapse Development threads" [expanded]: + - group "Development threads": + - button "New task": + - generic: New task + - button "Actions for New task": + - button "New thread": + - text: New thread + - button "Minato Executive No messages yet": + - img "Minato" + - generic: Executive + - generic: No messages yet + - button "Expand Executive threads": + - button "Bots" [expanded]: + - generic: Bots + - button "Mako Rename Mako Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Mako" + - button "Rename Mako": Mako + - generic: Hi, I'm Mako. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Mako threads": + - button "New folder under Mako": + - button "Actions for Mako": + - button "Ritsu Rename Ritsu Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ritsu" + - button "Rename Ritsu": Ritsu + - generic: Hi, I'm Ritsu. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ritsu threads": + - button "New folder under Ritsu": + - button "Actions for Ritsu": + - button "Ren Rename Ren Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Ren" + - button "Rename Ren": Ren + - generic: Hi, I'm Ren. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Ren threads": + - button "New folder under Ren": + - button "Actions for Ren": + - button "Minato Rename Minato Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Minato" + - button "Rename Minato": Minato + - generic: Hi, I'm Minato. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Minato threads": + - button "New folder under Minato": + - button "Actions for Minato": + - button "Taffy Rename Taffy Hi, I'm Taffy. What would you like me to do?": + - img "Taffy" + - button "Rename Taffy": Taffy + - generic: Hi, I'm Taffy. What would you like me to do? + - button "Expand Taffy threads": + - button "New folder under Taffy": + - button "Actions for Taffy": + - paragraph + - button "Tools": + - generic: Tools + - button "You": + - generic: "?" + - generic: You +- main: + - generic: Development + - button "All threads": + - generic: All threads + - generic: "1" + - button "Find in conversation": + - button "Export conversation": + - button "Calls currently need the macOS desktop app": + - button "Group working folder": + - generic "Plain messages go to Ren; @mentions override this": + - combobox "Default responder": + - 'option "Lead: Ren" [selected]' + - 'option "Lead: Ritsu"' + - 'option "Lead: Mako"' + - option "Everyone responds" + - option "Only when mentioned" + - button "Manage members — 3 bots in this group": + - generic "Ren": + - img "Ren" + - generic "Ritsu": + - img "Ritsu" + - generic "Mako": + - img "Mako" + - button "Add group instructions…": + - generic: Add group instructions… + - log "Group chat Development": + - img "Ren" + - img "Ritsu" + - img "Mako" + - generic: Development + - generic: Ren responds by default — @mention someone else to choose them instead. + - button "Attach a file": + - button "Finish together": + - text: Goal + - textbox "Message Development": + - /placeholder: Message Development — Ren responds \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-group.png b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-group.png new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d0f1c18de4 Binary files /dev/null and b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/before-group.png differ diff --git a/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/sha256.txt b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/sha256.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..982a78b0b8 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/evidence/room-hierarchy/upstream-f8cbc562/sha256.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10 @@ +6303884b93abc2437da0e8c5b0806c63f07b6c1d1a179088c342c6a8dbbaa556 after-configured-dom.txt +f56c8f183836fdad293397839fc5311909e3f728488cad60cb855a41e2cc725f after-configured-settings.json +f070358f7ff0c8b3f2249a2a1696fded0ded2257a20c40ccd321c3e7d263ed86 after-configured.png +868cc9bf3271d76488ba27d689ea8bb69a54269a6e376f10af3aae5a93ffadcc after-default-dom.txt +57a3d972e91cfbee803a4918d4d344e22792642b634f6d8476fd33d2b5e324c2 after-default.png +9b9b79223aef189d47a7a07d95f663a9778a8ee8b963b583c387a87abd4e4c55 after-unrestricted-dom.txt +8bc2813c24dc038846f9e597d57ef10f525133d6d7a6d5faacc703f646fcf2ef after-unrestricted-settings.json +646cea960596cea5a0100cf3b31619375ca7e3f85f5fa7b8a1a3768d09ce0de6 after-unrestricted.png +d0fdbb0e3d9d8d8b0b37afd53fa132829c6dc4b5b6161da5a14df9baab440761 before-dom.txt +6681cfb04dd2d51bee1d6a35492cb3d4bd2a5a7d11facdc987cd95ad861650b2 before-group.png diff --git a/docs/verification/room-coordination.md b/docs/verification/room-coordination.md index 9df84274a6..f41e31a1c2 100644 --- a/docs/verification/room-coordination.md +++ b/docs/verification/room-coordination.md @@ -23,7 +23,8 @@ original thread. These tests verify orchestration, not live-model planning. In an ordinary bot chat or group conversation, ask the lead to consult named teammates or have them build and review a concrete artifact. No new dashboard, -incoming-route panel or mandatory discussion. The existing **Finish together** goal loop +incoming-route restriction or mandatory discussion is required by default. Rooms +can opt into [discussion before delegation](room-discussion.md). The existing **Finish together** goal loop remains unchanged and owns its own teammate turns; it does not run a competing handoff loop inside those turns. @@ -223,8 +224,10 @@ stops the descendants it is still waiting on, except a teammate whose turn had already started when the person stopped the conversation above it: that process is left alone and reports its result. Restart records interruption without replaying side effects. -Limits: four cross-room edges, 24 child requests, 48 executions, 30 minutes per -root. Failures return to the sender, not a false success. Model quality and +Limits: four cross-room edges, 24 child requests and 48 executions. The 30-minute +tree budget pauses during active execution; queued work has a 60-minute window +and execution gets at least 10 minutes of runway, all within a four-hour wall-clock +cap. Failures return to the sender, not a false success. Model quality and provider availability still matter; this is not a guarantee of autonomous correctness or permission to bypass approvals. diff --git a/docs/verification/room-discussion.md b/docs/verification/room-discussion.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0f3cbedac5 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/room-discussion.md @@ -0,0 +1,63 @@ +# Discussion and decisions within each layer + +Existing members discuss a request in their own group conversation. The addressed +director or lead chairs the discussion, resolves proposals, and resumes after the +members respond. No bots are invited, moved, or created by this workflow. + +## Workflow + +Enable **Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work** in +each participating room's **Group collaboration settings** panel. This enables +`discuss_room`; ordinary rooms retain upstream's optional consultation flow. +Optionally restrict incoming source groups. Each room already contains its members. + +1. The addressed member states a proposal and the questions to resolve. +2. `list_room_targets` returns `currentRoom.members`. +3. `discuss_room(member_ids, topic, request_key)` queues 1–4 existing members. + The chair finishes the turn. Participants speak in order, seeing the preceding + opinions, and are asked for tradeoffs, concerns, and concrete amendments. +4. The chair resumes in the same conversation, accepts or rejects proposals, + explains the decision, and may request another bounded discussion round. +5. The chair can send a revised brief downstream, or use `coordinate_bots` to + divide responsibility among existing members. Assigned members can themselves + send downstream requests. See the [branching organization](room-pyramid.md). +6. The downstream group follows the same process. Results return to the original + requester, who reviews and reports them up the recorded path. + +Downstream work is refused while discussion is pending. A room that requires +discussion cannot delegate without a successful discussion. Discussion participants +cannot delegate or start another discussion. Incidental mentions do not start a +second set of participants. A completed recipient cannot be restarted merely to +acknowledge its work; concrete rework needs a new key and `rework: true`. + +These guards establish ordering. They do not prove that the opinions are useful, +that the chair's reasoning is sound, or that an artifact satisfies its acceptance +criteria. Those are separate semantic checks of model output. + +## Reproduce + +```sh +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-discussion.ts .omb-scratch/room-discussion/verification.json +``` + +The scripted fixture uses three rooms with three disjoint members each. It checks +revision of a proposal, preceding opinions in later participant input, refusal to +forward before/during discussion, chair continuation, and a three-layer round trip. +It uses the real server and injected agents MCP proxy. + +For an optional real-model experiment, set `OMB_VERIFY_CC_CONFIG` to an existing +OpenMausBot configuration and `OMB_VERIFY_CC_CLI` to Claude Code. Select its profile +with `OMB_VERIFY_CC_INSTANCE` (default `claude`). The experiment expects that +profile to specify `ANTHROPIC_MODEL=glm-5.3`, and selects effort `low` for all bots. +Only the allow-listed connection environment is copied into a private, temporary +configuration. The original configuration and conversations are not changed. +On Windows, set `CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH` when necessary. Do not put credentials +in command arguments or published evidence. + +Add `--live --preview` to run without scripted responses and retain the fixture +for screenshots. Build the UI first with `pnpm build`. Create the output JSON's +`.stop` file to exit normally and remove the temporary data; Ctrl-C also requests +cleanup. The experiment waits up to 25 minutes. The coordinator uses the upstream +30-minute tree budget, paused while dispatched work executes, a 60-minute queue +window, a 10-minute minimum execution runway, and a four-hour wall-clock cap. +Each participant's turn counts toward the shared execution limit. diff --git a/docs/verification/room-handoffs.md b/docs/verification/room-handoffs.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c17b2ded98 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/room-handoffs.md @@ -0,0 +1,132 @@ +# Addressed work between group conversations + +An agent speaking in one group can send a work request to a named agent in +another group. The sender does **not** need to belong to the destination. +Only the addressed agent runs, using the destination conversation, bulletin, +working folder, and its own profile. A plain `@Name` in chat still addresses +the current room; cross-room delivery uses an explicit group and agent ID. + +The addressed agent can lead a discussion with existing members in that same +room before deciding and delegating further. Enable **Discuss with members +before delegating or concluding incoming work** to require it. See +[discussion and decisions within each layer](room-discussion.md). + +## Configure and use + +The default remains upstream's standard `coordinate_bots` behavior: permitted +teammates can collaborate without configuring routes or requiring a discussion. +In **Group collaboration settings**, optionally enable **Restrict incoming requests +to selected groups** and select the permitted source groups. An enabled restriction +with no sources blocks incoming group requests; disabling it restores the default. +The automatic result return does not require a reverse route. + +Routes never grant additional team access. The existing sender/recipient peer +allow-lists, approvals, and Chief's explicitly selected team grants still apply. +Each recipient and discussion participant must be allowed to read the entire +receiving room; specialists do not inherit their Chief's access. Permissions and +routes are rechecked before dispatch and before returning results. The hierarchy +recipe uses one company section and separate groups for organizational layers. + +From a source group, ask its agent, for example: + +> Send a request to @Ren in the Development group to implement CSV export. +> Ask Ren to delegate implementation to @Sora in the Implementation group, +> then report the results here. + +The agents integration exposes: + +```text +list_room_targets() +discuss_room(member_ids, topic, request_key) +coordinate_bots(group_id?, bot_ids, message, request_key) +``` + +The destination list contains permitted bot/group names and member IDs, not their +history. The request forwards only the supplied brief. Each task is pinned to +the chosen conversation at acceptance, even if a user changes the active task. +The tool returns immediately. The source must finish its turn before queued +work starts. The receiving agent may send bounded downstream requests; it +releases its provider and room while waiting. After its children settle, it is +woken in the original room to review the results. Its final response is returned +to the parent, which resumes in the same way. + +No automatic broadcast or responder selection runs on receipt. Bystanders, +including members mentioned incidentally in the brief or reply, do not start. + +## Bounds and failure behavior + +- At most 4 outgoing edges in an ancestry path, 24 requests per root, 48 + request/continuation executions, and a 30-minute root lifetime. +- Returning to any ancestor group is refused. Results use the recorded return + path rather than creating another request. +- `request_key` deduplicates the same assignment under the same source run; + reusing it for different work is refused. +- Work waits when the addressed bot or destination room is busy. The original + destination task remains pinned. Membership and route grants are rechecked. +- Stopping a source group cancels its outstanding descendants. A failed source + turn does not dispatch the work it queued. +- Receiving turns retain the target's permissions and downgrade elevated + approval modes as peer-initiated work. They receive only the bounded room + coordination tools in their agents integration, not an unrestricted recursive + `delegate_bot` capability. Other engine tools remain subject to normal approval. +- Pending requests are persisted in `room-handoffs.json`. On restart they become + explicit failures, without replaying potentially side-effecting tools. This is + interruption recovery, not exactly-once execution across a process crash. +- Results are bounded to 12,000 characters. Files are not automatically copied. + +## Reproduce in an isolated fixture + +```powershell +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts artifacts/room-handoffs/verification.json +``` + +This uses `launchVerificationServer` and `runControlOmb`, the same shared control +surface as `control-omb launch`. It creates a temporary home, data, ports and fake +engine, runs the real injected agents MCP proxy, captures `wait` and `messages` +JSON plus provider input and the request tree, then stops its exact child and +removes its temporary data. The server log and evidence JSON remain available. + +The scenario has **disjoint group membership within one company section**: + +```text +経営会議: ミナト + -> 開発部: @レン (リツ does not run) + -> 実装チーム: @ソラ (ヒナ does not run) + <- ソラ's result + <- レン's reviewed result +ミナト resumes and reports +``` + +It also sends an identical request twice, tries an invalid recipient, attempts +to loop back to the executive group over an enabled reverse route, and tries +the old delegation tool from a receiving turn. All are checked explicitly. + +To view the fixture after the checks: + +```powershell +pnpm build +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts artifacts/room-handoffs/verification.json --preview +``` + +Open the printed preview URL. Ctrl-C stops the exact fixture and removes its +temporary data. Do not run these experiments against the user's normal server. + +The equivalent route configuration on an explicitly launched fixture is: + +```powershell +pnpm control:omb room-routes --channel DESTINATION_ID --from SOURCE_ID --url http://127.0.0.1:PORT +# Disable incoming routes: +pnpm control:omb room-routes --channel DESTINATION_ID --from "" --url http://127.0.0.1:PORT +``` + +## Verification scope + +`server/room-handoffs.test.ts` covers the scheduler, limits, cancellation, +idempotency and restart handling. The two room-handoff e2e suites cover the real +provider/proxy/server path, failure return, busy queues, route revocation, allow +and deny cards, source interruption, and destination-task switching. + +The provider is deliberately scripted. This proves delivery, scheduling, +conversation context, guard enforcement and return routing. It does not measure +how reliably a production model chooses the tool from natural-language requests, +the quality of its work, real token costs, or every engine's integration support. diff --git a/docs/verification/room-pyramid.md b/docs/verification/room-pyramid.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..c46240bc27 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/verification/room-pyramid.md @@ -0,0 +1,75 @@ +# A three-layer organization with member-owned branches + +The recipient chairs a discussion with existing members, revises the proposal, +and assigns concrete responsibility with `coordinate_bots`. An assigned member +then uses `coordinate_bots` to ask a named member of a downstream group, reviews +the returned work, and reports to the chair. Speaking in a discussion does not +implicitly start an execution assignment. + +```mermaid +flowchart TD + A[Executive meeting: Minato chairs and decides] + A --> A1[Aoi: development owner] + A --> A2[Yui: sales owner] + A1 --> B[Development: Ren receives and chairs] + A2 --> C[Sales: Kou receives and chairs] + B --> B1[Ritsu: implementation owner] + B --> B2[Mako: QA owner] + B1 --> D[Implementation: Sora chairs and assigns] + B2 --> E[QA: Leo chairs and assigns] + C --> C1[Saki: FAQ] + C --> C2[Towa: operating checklist] + D --> D1[Hina: synthetic CSV] + D --> D2[Nagi: CSV inspection] + E --> E1[Mei: boundary cases] + E --> E2[Haru: failure cases] +``` + +Owner boxes are members of the immediately preceding group, not additional group +layers. There are five rooms and fifteen members across three organizational +layers: Executive → Development/Sales → Implementation/QA. Membership stays fixed. +Results return through the requesting member, then to the chair. + +All fifteen bots share the `検証会社` section. Sections are communication +boundaries; the three organizational layers are separate groups inside that +boundary. Incoming routes do not override section isolation. + +## Reproduce + +```sh +node --experimental-strip-types scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts .omb-scratch/pyramid/verification.json +``` + +The shared `control-omb`/MCP surface creates an isolated fixture. Executive and +Development hold two rounds each; the other three rooms hold one round each. +Every chair assigns two existing members. Assertions cover seven discussion +rounds, ten assignments, five work nodes, member-owned downstream branches, +upstream returns, and unchanged membership. Scripted responses make this an +orchestration test; the actual server and mounted MCP proxy execute the workflow. + +The [discussion recipe](room-discussion.md) describes optional Claude Code / +GLM-5.3 configuration and `--live --preview`. In that mode, model-generated CSV, +inspection tables and documents are produced in chat. The experiment does not +implement the requested application feature, validate actual CSV file bytes, or +publish anything externally. Inspect artifact consistency separately from the +orchestration assertions. + +## Limits + +- Assignment addresses another existing member of the same conversation after a + successful discussion. Pending discussion prevents assignment. +- Assignments use the existing bounded coordinator. The pyramid recipe gives each + member its own downstream responsibility; returning work to an ancestor is refused. +- Same-room assignment does not increase cross-room depth. Ancestor-room cycles + remain forbidden. Bounds are 4 cross-room edges, 24 child requests, 48 coordinated + executions. Each discussion participant consumes an execution. The upstream + 30-minute tree budget pauses during execution; queued work has a 60-minute + window, execution has at least 10 minutes of runway, and the entire tree has a + four-hour wall-clock cap. +- New discussion keys permit another round within those bounds. There is no + unlimited conversation or automatic semantic agreement detector. +- A final reply is not proof of a correct decision. Compare concerns, revisions, + owners and artifacts in the transcript and screenshots. + +See [the dated evidence](evidence/room-hierarchy/README.md) for the upstream-base +comparison, screenshots and the explicit limits of the recorded run. diff --git a/electron/shared-computer-access.mjs b/electron/shared-computer-access.mjs index 065df2a6e9..9ef6776f77 100644 --- a/electron/shared-computer-access.mjs +++ b/electron/shared-computer-access.mjs @@ -91,6 +91,15 @@ function killTree(child) { } } +/** Shell plumbing only: keep PowerShell's module search path so built-in + * commands load without default-path discovery hanging on Windows hosts. */ +export function sharedCommandEnvironment(environment = process.env, platform = process.platform) { + const names = ["PATH", "HOME", "USERPROFILE", "SystemRoot", "TEMP", "TMP", "LANG"]; + // PATHEXT keeps native executables runnable; PSModulePath retains installed modules. + if (platform === "win32") names.push("PATHEXT", "PSModulePath"); + return Object.fromEntries(names.filter(key => environment[key]).map(key => [key, environment[key]])); +} + /** No inherited API keys, model-provider credentials or shell startup files. * This is still UNRESTRICTED host execution when the user enables terminal. */ export function sharedCommand(command, cwd, signal) { @@ -109,8 +118,7 @@ export function sharedCommand(command, cwd, signal) { : command; const child = spawn(windows ? "powershell.exe" : "/bin/sh", windows ? ["-NoProfile", "-NonInteractive", "-Command", script] : ["-c", script], { cwd, detached: !windows, windowsHide: true, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], - // Without PATHEXT, PowerShell treats even .exe files as documents. - env: Object.fromEntries(["PATH", "PATHEXT", "HOME", "USERPROFILE", "SystemRoot", "TEMP", "TMP", "LANG"].filter(key => process.env[key]).map(key => [key, process.env[key]])), + env: sharedCommandEnvironment(), }); const chunks = []; let bytes = 0; let reason; const stop = message => { reason = message; killTree(child); }; diff --git a/electron/shared-computer-access.node-test.mjs b/electron/shared-computer-access.node-test.mjs index e0670aaf9b..84c77cf85b 100644 --- a/electron/shared-computer-access.node-test.mjs +++ b/electron/shared-computer-access.node-test.mjs @@ -7,7 +7,7 @@ import { tmpdir, homedir } from "node:os"; import path from "node:path"; import { randomUUID } from "node:crypto"; import { setTimeout as delay } from "node:timers/promises"; -import { executeSharedOperation, sharedCommand, createSharedCua } from "./shared-computer-access.mjs"; +import { executeSharedOperation, sharedCommand, sharedCommandEnvironment, createSharedCua } from "./shared-computer-access.mjs"; import { createComputerSharing, validateSharedFolders } from "./computer-sharing.mjs"; async function fixture(t) { @@ -20,6 +20,20 @@ async function fixture(t) { } const payload = result => JSON.parse(result.content[0].text); +test("Windows shells retain module discovery without inheriting credentials or startup injection", () => { + const environment = { + PATH: "fixture-bin", HOME: "fixture-home", PATHEXT: ".COM;.EXE;.BAT;.CMD", PSModulePath: "fixture-modules", + OPENAI_API_KEY: "fixture-secret", UNKNOWN_PROVIDER_TOKEN: "fixture-secret", + NODE_OPTIONS: "--require=fixture-injection", BASH_ENV: "fixture-startup", + }; + assert.deepEqual(sharedCommandEnvironment(environment, "win32"), { + PATH: "fixture-bin", HOME: "fixture-home", PATHEXT: ".COM;.EXE;.BAT;.CMD", PSModulePath: "fixture-modules", + }); + assert.deepEqual(sharedCommandEnvironment(environment, "linux"), { + PATH: "fixture-bin", HOME: "fixture-home", + }); +}); + /** What this host's filesystem treats as one directory. APFS and NTFS fold * case, APFS also folds Unicode normalization, ext4 folds neither. */ async function spellings(dir) { @@ -173,8 +187,10 @@ test("Windows terminal preserves command syntax, pipeline output and exit status assert.equal(returned.exitCode, 0); assert.match(returned.output, /fixture-return/); const paths = await run("[Console]::WriteLine($env:PSModulePath)"); assert.equal(paths.exitCode, 0); - const modulePaths = paths.output.trim().toLowerCase(); - assert.ok(modulePaths.startsWith(path.join(process.env.SystemRoot, "System32", "WindowsPowerShell", "v1.0", "Modules").toLowerCase()), "built-in modules must be first"); + // SystemRoot and PSHOME can spell the same directory with different casing. + // Resolve the first entry exactly; a textual prefix also accepts sibling paths. + assert.equal(await realpath(paths.output.trim().split(";")[0]), await realpath(path.join(process.env.SystemRoot, "System32", "WindowsPowerShell", "v1.0", "Modules")), "built-in modules must be first"); + const modulePaths = paths.output.trim().toLowerCase().split(";"); assert.ok(modulePaths.includes(path.join(process.env.ProgramFiles, "WindowsPowerShell", "Modules").toLowerCase()), "installed modules must remain available"); const failed = await run("throw 'fixture-command-failed'"); assert.notEqual(failed.exitCode, 0); assert.match(failed.output, /fixture-command-failed/); diff --git a/scripts/control-omb.ts b/scripts/control-omb.ts index 1faea4c83e..e766ad4c45 100644 --- a/scripts/control-omb.ts +++ b/scripts/control-omb.ts @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ const ROOT = join(dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)), ".."); const FAKE_CLI = join(ROOT, "server", "testing", "fake-claude-cli.ts"); // `ui` verbs never discover anything: each takes the handle its launch printed. const MUTATING = new Set([ - "new-bot", "new-channel", "send", "send-channel", "interrupt", "set-model", "edit", + "new-bot", "new-channel", "room-routes", "send", "send-channel", "interrupt", "set-model", "edit", "ui click", "ui type", "ui press", "ui flag", "ui eval", ]); @@ -67,6 +67,7 @@ read-only: mutating (an explicit --url or OPENMAUSBOT_URL/OMB_PORT is required): new-bot --name NAME [--url URL] new-channel --name NAME --members ID,ID [--url URL] + room-routes --channel ID --from ID,ID [--dry-run] [--url URL] send --bot ID --text TEXT [--task ID] [--dry-run] [--url URL] send-channel --channel ID --text TEXT [--task ID] [--dry-run] [--url URL] interrupt --bot ID [--task ID] [--dry-run] [--url URL] @@ -211,6 +212,12 @@ export async function runControlOmb( }, values.url); } + if (command === "room-routes") { + const values = parse(command, args, { channel: { type: "string" }, from: { type: "string" }, "dry-run": { type: "boolean", default: false } }); + if (typeof values.from !== "string") throw new ControlOmbError("--from is required (empty clears all incoming routes)"); + const input = { channel_id: required(values.channel, "--channel"), incoming_group_ids: values.from.split(",").map(id => id.trim()).filter(Boolean) }; + return dryRun(command, values, "update_channel", input) ?? call("update_channel", input, values.url); + } if (command === "new-channel") { const values = parse(command, args, { name: { type: "string" }, @@ -389,7 +396,7 @@ export async function launchVerificationServer( /** A stand-in enterprise layer (the folder shape core loads) and the key * it should accept, so a recipe can prove entitled behaviour offline. */ enterprise?: { dir: string; licenseKey: string }, - room?: { scripted: boolean }, + room?: { scripted: boolean; staticDir?: string; engine?: { cli: string; environment: Record } }, /** Optional repository-owned fake providers for multi-engine setup checks. */ extraProviders: Array<"codex"> = [], /** Programmatic tests only: an owned loopback Box provider, never a live account. */ @@ -417,6 +424,10 @@ export async function launchVerificationServer( const fixtureTemp = join(dataDir, "tmp"); const fixtureDumpPath = join(dataDir, "fake-claude-dump.json"); mkdirSync(fixtureTemp, { recursive: true }); + if (room?.engine) { + mkdirSync(join(dataDir, ".claude-live"), { recursive: true }); + writeFileSync(join(dataDir, ".claude-live", "settings.json"), JSON.stringify({ model: room.engine.environment.ANTHROPIC_MODEL }), { mode: 0o600 }); + } const evidenceDir = join(tmpdir(), "openmausbot-verification-evidence"); mkdirSync(evidenceDir, { recursive: true }); const logPath = join(evidenceDir, `server-${Date.now()}-${process.pid}.log`); @@ -432,11 +443,12 @@ export async function launchVerificationServer( claude: { driver: "claudeAgent", displayName: "Verification fixture", - config: { cli: FAKE_CLI }, - ...(room?.scripted ? { environment: { FAKE_CLAUDE_ROOM_PLAN: join(dataDir, "room-plan.json") } } : {}), + config: { cli: room?.engine?.cli ?? FAKE_CLI }, + ...(room?.engine ? { environment: { ...room.engine.environment, CLAUDE_CONFIG_DIR: join(dataDir, ".claude-live") } } + : room?.scripted ? { environment: { FAKE_CLAUDE_ROOM_PLAN: join(dataDir, "room-plan.json") } } : {}), }, }, - }, null, 2)); + }, null, 2), { mode: 0o600 }); const log = openSync(logPath, "a", 0o600); const childEnv = verificationServerEnvironment(parentEnv, dataDir, port); @@ -453,6 +465,7 @@ export async function launchVerificationServer( OMB_AGENT_BROWSER_PATH: browser.binaryPath, AGENT_BROWSER_EXECUTABLE_PATH: browser.executablePath, }); + if (room?.staticDir) childEnv.OMB_STATIC_DIR = room.staticDir; if (boxFixtureApi) childEnv.OMB_BOX_API = boxFixtureApi; const serverArgs = ["--experimental-strip-types"]; if (childEnv.OMB_TEST_FAIL_AUDIO_APPEND_ONCE === "1") { @@ -523,7 +536,7 @@ function requireForegroundTerminal(command: string): void { } } -async function main() { +async function runMain() { const command = process.argv[2] ?? "help"; if (command === "ui" && process.argv[3] === "launch") { requireForegroundTerminal("ui launch"); @@ -572,6 +585,26 @@ async function main() { if (!controlResultSucceeded(command, result)) process.exitCode = 1; } +/** IPC lets test parents request the same cleanup on Windows as terminal Ctrl-C. */ +async function main() { + const ownsFixture = process.argv[2] === "launch" + || (process.argv[2] === "ui" && process.argv[3] === "launch"); + if (!ownsFixture || !process.connected) return runMain(); + const stop = () => { process.emit("SIGINT"); }; + const onMessage = (message: unknown) => { + if (message === "control-omb:stop") stop(); + }; + process.on("message", onMessage); + process.once("disconnect", stop); + try { + await runMain(); + } finally { + process.removeListener("message", onMessage); + process.removeListener("disconnect", stop); + if (process.connected) process.disconnect?.(); + } +} + if (process.argv[1] && import.meta.url === pathToFileURL(process.argv[1]).href) { main().catch((error) => { const failure = error instanceof ControlOmbError diff --git a/scripts/mcp-server.ts b/scripts/mcp-server.ts index d3c8dc5106..6478a539b1 100644 --- a/scripts/mcp-server.ts +++ b/scripts/mcp-server.ts @@ -298,6 +298,8 @@ export const TOOLS: McpToolDefinition[] = [ type: "object", properties: { channel_id: { type: "string", description: "The ID of the channel." }, + incoming_group_ids: { type: ["array", "null"], items: { type: "string" }, maxItems: 100, description: "Groups allowed to send addressed work here. Duplicates are normalized. Empty disables incoming requests; null restores the standard permitted-team behavior." }, + require_room_discussion: { type: "boolean", description: "Require member discussion before cross-room delegation or concluding incoming work." }, name: { type: "string" }, member_ids: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" }, minItems: 1, uniqueItems: true }, section: { type: ["string", "null"], description: "Null clears the section." }, @@ -963,6 +965,14 @@ export async function handleToolCall( const patch: Record = {}; if (args.name !== undefined) patch.name = stringArg(args, "name", { max: 100 }); if (args.member_ids !== undefined) patch.memberIds = stringArrayArg(args, "member_ids"); + if (args.require_room_discussion !== undefined) { + if (typeof args.require_room_discussion !== "boolean") throw new ToolInputError("require_room_discussion must be boolean"); + patch.requireRoomDiscussion = args.require_room_discussion; + } + if (args.incoming_group_ids !== undefined) { + if (args.incoming_group_ids !== null && (!Array.isArray(args.incoming_group_ids) || args.incoming_group_ids.length > 100 || args.incoming_group_ids.some(id => typeof id !== "string" || !/^[\w-]+$/.test(id)))) throw new ToolInputError("incoming_group_ids must be an array of group IDs"); + patch.incomingGroupIds = args.incoming_group_ids === null ? null : [...new Set(args.incoming_group_ids)]; + } if (args.section !== undefined) patch.section = args.section === null ? null : stringArg(args, "section", { max: 60 }); if (args.bulletin !== undefined) patch.bulletin = stringArg(args, "bulletin", { trim: false, allowEmpty: true, max: 12_000 }); if (args.default_responder !== undefined) patch.defaultResponder = normalizeResponder(args.default_responder); diff --git a/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.e2e.test.ts index 80df7ce8d1..e21b1d43cc 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.e2e.test.ts @@ -19,7 +19,7 @@ describe("cloud preview recovery in the real renderer", () => { let child: ChildProcess | undefined; let preview: MountedPreview | undefined; afterAll(async () => { - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); await preview?.close(); }); @@ -28,7 +28,7 @@ describe("cloud preview recovery in the real renderer", () => { let stderr = ""; let info: FixtureInfo; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); @@ -204,7 +204,7 @@ describe("cloud preview recovery in the real renderer", () => { await expect.poll(() => stat("joining")).toBe(false); } process.stdout.write(`${JSON.stringify({ fixture: info!, previewUrl: preview.previewUrl, transport: "simulated; panels and browser real" })}\n`); - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); expect(child.exitCode).toBe(0); expect(existsSync(info!.dataDir)).toBe(false); expect(existsSync(info!.logPath)).toBe(true); diff --git a/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.tsx b/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.tsx index bc21810036..c4ccb15a20 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.tsx +++ b/scripts/testing/cloud-preview.tsx @@ -5,6 +5,7 @@ import { BotSettingsDialog } from "../../src/components/BotSettingsDialog"; import { RemoteDesktopPanel } from "../../src/components/remote-desktop-panel"; import { StoreProvider, useStore, type Bot } from "../../src/state/store"; import { applySkin, readSkin } from "../../src/lib/skins"; +import { setLocale } from "../../src/lib/i18n"; import { CLOUD_COMPUTER_BUSY_ERROR } from "../../shared/computer-contention"; import "../../src/styles.css"; @@ -201,5 +202,8 @@ function Fixture() { : !state.settingsOpen && } ; } +// This entry mounts panels without App, which normally applies config.language. +// Keep the recipe's accessible labels stable on non-English browser installs. +setLocale("en"); applySkin(readSkin()); createRoot(document.getElementById("root")!).render(); diff --git a/scripts/testing/control-omb-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/control-omb-ui.e2e.test.ts index 243f4dc4c1..ebf6e09f20 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/control-omb-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/control-omb-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -1,5 +1,5 @@ // The first asserted renderer recipe: docs/verification/chat-ui.md, run by a -// machine. It spawns the real `control-omb ui launch` (a child it can Ctrl-C), +// machine. It spawns the real `control-omb ui launch` with graceful IPC shutdown, // drives the real through the ui verbs, and reads the outcome back from // the accessibility tree — the same evidence a person would collect by hand. // @@ -57,9 +57,13 @@ function launch(args: string[]): Promise { // Own process group: a timeout must take the launch AND whatever it is // running (an `agent-browser install` mid-download) down with it. const child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", CLI, "ui", "launch", ...args], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], detached: process.platform !== "win32", + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], detached: process.platform !== "win32", }); const killGroup = (signal: NodeJS.Signals) => { + if (process.platform === "win32" && signal === "SIGINT" && child.connected) { + child.send("control-omb:stop", () => {}); + return; + } if (child.pid && process.platform !== "win32") { try { process.kill(-child.pid, signal); return; } catch { /* group already gone */ } } @@ -116,7 +120,7 @@ describe("control-omb ui drives the real renderer", () => { afterAll(async () => { if (launched && launched.child.exitCode === null && launched.child.signalCode === null) { - await waitForExit(launched.child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(launched.child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); } if (ownsEvidenceDir) await removeTempDir(evidenceDir); }); @@ -128,7 +132,11 @@ describe("control-omb ui drives the real renderer", () => { openaiCompat: { key: "fixture-saved-key", url: "http://127.0.0.1:1/v1" }, }); const evaluate = async (js: string) => (await ui("eval", info.ui, "--js", js)).result; - const click = (name: string) => ui("click", info.ui, "--name", name); + const click = async (name: string) => { + await expect.poll(async () => refsNamed(await ui("snapshot", info.ui), name).length, + { timeout: 10_000, message: `one visible control named ${name}` }).toBe(1); + return ui("click", info.ui, "--name", name); + }; const input = `document.querySelector('input[aria-label="OpenAI-compatible API key"]')`; const testButton = `[...${input}.parentElement.querySelectorAll('button')].find(b => b.textContent === 'Test')`; const verdict = () => evaluate(`${input}.parentElement.parentElement.querySelector('[role="status"]')?.textContent`); @@ -205,7 +213,7 @@ describe("control-omb ui drives the real renderer", () => { { provider: "openaiCompat" }, { provider: "openaiCompat", key: "fixture-draft-key" }, { provider: "openaiCompat" }, ]); await expect.poll(verdict).toBe("Saved key: Model catalog reachable: fixture-model. Authentication and chat not verified."); - await waitForExit(launched.child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(launched.child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); expect(launched.child.exitCode).toBe(0); expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(false); }, LAUNCH_TIMEOUT_MS + 180_000); @@ -402,8 +410,8 @@ describe("control-omb ui drives the real renderer", () => { const title = await ui("eval", info.ui, "--js", "document.title"); expect(title).toMatchObject({ ok: true, result: "Isolated OpenMaus Chat" }); - // Ctrl-C: browser, preview and fixture close; only the fixture's data goes. - await waitForExit(launched.child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + // Graceful stop: browser, preview and fixture close; only the fixture's data goes. + await waitForExit(launched.child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); expect(launched.child.exitCode).toBe(0); expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(false); expect(existsSync(info.logPath)).toBe(true); diff --git a/scripts/testing/cron-routines-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/cron-routines-ui.e2e.test.ts index 1cffac1e73..256575ec6c 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/cron-routines-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/cron-routines-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -1,5 +1,6 @@ // Real renderer and routes in a disposable fake-engine workspace only. import { spawn, type ChildProcess } from "node:child_process"; +import { existsSync } from "node:fs"; import { join } from "node:path"; import { fileURLToPath } from "node:url"; import { afterAll, expect, it } from "vitest"; @@ -12,19 +13,30 @@ import { UI_TOOLS_DIR } from "./control-omb-ui.ts"; const ROOT = fileURLToPath(new URL("../..", import.meta.url)); const enabled = process.env.OMB_UI_E2E === "1" || Boolean(resolveAgentBrowserBinary({ dataDir: UI_TOOLS_DIR, env: process.env })); let child: ChildProcess | undefined; -afterAll(() => waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 })); +let fixtureDataDir: string | undefined; +afterAll(async () => { + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); + if (child) expect(child.exitCode).toBe(0); + if (fixtureDataDir) expect(existsSync(fixtureDataDir)).toBe(false); +}); (enabled ? it : it.skip)("creates monthly routines, validates cron, preserves arbitrary expressions and excludes calls", async () => { let output = ""; let stderr = ""; - child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"] }); + child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"] }); child.stdout!.on("data", chunk => { output += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", chunk => { stderr += String(chunk); }); - let fixture: { ui: string; url: string; botId: string; logPath: string }; + let fixture: { ui: string; url: string; botId: string; logPath: string; dataDir: string }; await expect.poll(() => { - if (child!.exitCode !== null) throw new Error(stderr); + // Polling retries thrown errors; stop on launcher exit so startup failures + // report their stderr immediately instead of waiting the whole deadline. + if (child!.exitCode !== null || child!.signalCode !== null) return true; try { fixture = JSON.parse(output); return Boolean(fixture.ui); } catch { return false; } }, { timeout: 600_000 }).toBe(true); + expect(child.exitCode, stderr).toBeNull(); + expect(child.signalCode, stderr).toBeNull(); + expect(fixture!.ui, stderr).toBeTruthy(); + fixtureDataDir = fixture!.dataDir; const ui = (verb: string, ...args: string[]) => runControlOmb(["ui", verb, "--ui", fixture.ui, ...args]) as Promise>; const evaluate = async (js: string) => (await ui("eval", "--js", js)).result; const click = (name: string) => ui("click", "--name", name); @@ -42,6 +54,8 @@ afterAll(() => waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 })); return field.getBoundingClientRect().height > 0; })()`); + // The launcher handle is available before React finishes rendering the sidebar. + await expect.poll(async () => Object.values((await ui("snapshot")).refs as Record).map(element => element.name), { timeout: 10_000 }).toContain("Tools"); await click("Tools"); await click("Automations"); await click("Create an automation"); await click("Create a scheduled task"); await fill('input[placeholder="Add title"]', "Monthly close"); diff --git a/scripts/testing/direct-coordination-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/direct-coordination-ui.e2e.test.ts index 211ec49bb8..9f137141fa 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/direct-coordination-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/direct-coordination-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ const enabled = process.env.OMB_UI_E2E === "1" || Boolean(resolveAgentBrowserBin const planPath = join(temporary, "plan.json"); writeFileSync(planPath, "{}"); const child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", "scripts/control-omb.ts", "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: { ...process.env, FAKE_CLAUDE_ROOM_PLAN: planPath }, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: { ...process.env, FAKE_CLAUDE_ROOM_PLAN: planPath }, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); let output = ""; let error = ""; @@ -80,7 +80,7 @@ const enabled = process.env.OMB_UI_E2E === "1" || Boolean(resolveAgentBrowserBin writeFileSync(info.logPath + ".direct-coordination.json", JSON.stringify(evidence, null, 2)); console.log("Direct coordination UI evidence:", info.logPath + ".direct-coordination.json"); } finally { - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); await removeTempDir(temporary); } }, 240_000); diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-access-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/team-access-ui.e2e.test.ts index 259fee833f..516114b0e1 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-access-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-access-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -12,7 +12,7 @@ const enabled = process.env.OMB_UI_E2E === "1" || Boolean(resolveAgentBrowserBin (enabled ? it : it.skip)("lets an owner select and revoke exactly the Chief's additional teams in the real settings UI", async () => { const child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", "scripts/control-omb.ts", "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); let output = ""; let error = ""; @@ -93,6 +93,6 @@ const enabled = process.env.OMB_UI_E2E === "1" || Boolean(resolveAgentBrowserBin writeFileSync(info.logPath + ".team-access.json", JSON.stringify(receipts, null, 2)); console.log("Team access evidence:", info.logPath + ".team-access.json"); } finally { - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); } }, 240_000); diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-canvas-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/team-canvas-ui.e2e.test.ts index 3a91f3f5a4..254a869bfc 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-canvas-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-canvas-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -27,7 +27,7 @@ type BotRecord = { try { let stdout = "", stderr = ""; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); @@ -380,6 +380,6 @@ type BotRecord = { writeFileSync(evidence, JSON.stringify({ fixture: info, ...receipts }, null, 2)); console.info(JSON.stringify({ evidence })); } - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); } }, binary ? 240_000 : 720_000); diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-computers-preview.ts b/scripts/testing/team-computers-preview.ts index 04c663707c..ccaa8ff9b6 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-computers-preview.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-computers-preview.ts @@ -77,5 +77,21 @@ export async function launchTeamComputersPreview() { } if (process.argv[1] && resolve(process.argv[1]) === fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)) { - await launchTeamComputersPreview(); + // This standalone launcher bypasses control-omb's CLI wrapper. Forward the + // same parent IPC shutdown to launchUi so Windows can close both fixtures. + const stop = () => { process.emit("SIGINT"); }; + const onMessage = (message: unknown) => { + if (message === "control-omb:stop") stop(); + }; + if (process.connected) { + process.on("message", onMessage); + process.once("disconnect", stop); + } + try { + await launchTeamComputersPreview(); + } finally { + process.removeListener("message", onMessage); + process.removeListener("disconnect", stop); + if (process.connected) process.disconnect?.(); + } } diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-computers-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/team-computers-ui.e2e.test.ts index 73fcfe9b7b..2cce2590fc 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-computers-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-computers-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ type Computer = { id: string; name: string; section: string | null; state: strin try { let stdout = "", stderr = ""; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/testing/team-computers-preview.ts")], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); @@ -199,7 +199,7 @@ type Computer = { id: string; name: string; section: string | null; state: strin console.info(JSON.stringify({ evidence: path })); } } finally { - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); if (info) expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(false); } } diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-lifecycle-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/team-lifecycle-ui.e2e.test.ts index d19da1929b..5dfab0c1e5 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-lifecycle-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-lifecycle-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ if (!enabled) console.log("skipping team lifecycle UI e2e: set OMB_UI_E2E=1 to i let stdout = "", stderr = ""; let info: { ui: string; url: string; botId: string; logPath: string }; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); @@ -318,7 +318,7 @@ if (!enabled) console.log("skipping team lifecycle UI e2e: set OMB_UI_E2E=1 to i console.info(JSON.stringify({ failureEvidence: `${fixtureLog}.team-lifecycle-failure.json` })); } catch { /* The original failure remains authoritative if the browser stopped. */ } } - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); await preview?.close(); } }, binary ? 420_000 : 840_000); diff --git a/scripts/testing/team-template-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/team-template-ui.e2e.test.ts index bfb3bd2af7..b2f9bcdc29 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/team-template-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/team-template-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -17,14 +17,14 @@ if (!enabled) console.log("skipping template UI e2e: set OMB_UI_E2E=1 to install describe("additive template imports in the real renderer", () => { let child: ChildProcess | undefined; - afterAll(async () => { await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); }); + afterAll(async () => { await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); }); (enabled ? it : it.skip)("adds library and file templates as sections without losing existing chats", async () => { let stdout = ""; let stderr = ""; let info: { ui: string; url: string; botId: string; logPath: string }; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); diff --git a/scripts/testing/workspace-backup-ui.e2e.test.ts b/scripts/testing/workspace-backup-ui.e2e.test.ts index dc15f202bd..94184e5607 100644 --- a/scripts/testing/workspace-backup-ui.e2e.test.ts +++ b/scripts/testing/workspace-backup-ui.e2e.test.ts @@ -21,13 +21,13 @@ interface FixtureInfo { ui: string; url: string; dataDir: string; logPath: strin describe("full backup Settings in the real renderer", () => { let child: ChildProcess | undefined; let info: FixtureInfo; - afterAll(async () => { await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); }); + afterAll(async () => { await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); }); (enabled ? it : it.skip)("uses passwords, a file preview and explicit replacement without leaking secrets", async () => { let stdout = ""; let stderr = ""; child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", join(ROOT, "scripts/control-omb.ts"), "ui", "launch"], { - cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + cwd: ROOT, env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], }); child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stdout += String(chunk); }); child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); @@ -129,7 +129,7 @@ describe("full backup Settings in the real renderer", () => { expect(await evaluate("window.backupFixture.calls.find(call => call.path.endsWith('/upload')).rawFile")).toBe(true); expect(await evaluate("localStorage.getItem('omb-pending-workspace-restore')")).toBe("validated-stage"); console.log(JSON.stringify({ fixture: info, screenshot: evidence, archiveApi: "simulated; renderer controls real" })); - await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGINT", graceMs: 30_000 }); + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); expect(child.exitCode).toBe(0); expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(false); }, LAUNCH_TIMEOUT_MS + 120_000); diff --git a/scripts/verify-room-discussion.ts b/scripts/verify-room-discussion.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..5b0fff0aff --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/verify-room-discussion.ts @@ -0,0 +1,127 @@ +import assert from "node:assert/strict"; +import { existsSync, mkdirSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path"; +import { pathToFileURL } from "node:url"; +import { launchVerificationServer, runControlOmb } from "./control-omb.ts"; +import { handleToolCall, request } from "./mcp-server.ts"; + +export async function verifyRoomDiscussion(output: string, preview = false, live = false) { + let realEngine: { cli: string; environment: Record } | undefined; + if (live) { + const configPath = process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_CONFIG; + const cli = process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_CLI; + if (!configPath || !cli) throw new Error("Set OMB_VERIFY_CC_CONFIG to the existing OMB config and OMB_VERIFY_CC_CLI to Claude Code. Credentials are never printed."); + const saved = JSON.parse(readFileSync(configPath, "utf8")).instances?.[process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_INSTANCE ?? "claude"]?.environment; + if (!saved?.ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN || saved.ANTHROPIC_MODEL !== "glm-5.3") throw new Error("Expected configured GLM-5.3 credentials"); + const environment: Record = {}; + for (const key of ["ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN", "ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL", "ANTHROPIC_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_OPUS_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_SONNET_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_HAIKU_MODEL", "CLAUDE_CODE_DISABLE_NONESSENTIAL_TRAFFIC"]) if (typeof saved[key] === "string") environment[key] = saved[key]; + if (process.env.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH) environment.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH = process.env.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH; + realEngine = { cli, environment }; + } + const session = await launchVerificationServer(process.env, undefined, undefined, undefined, undefined, { scripted: !live, staticDir: preview ? resolve("dist") : undefined, engine: realEngine }); + const commands: unknown[] = []; + const control = async (...args: string[]) => { + const result = await runControlOmb(args, { env: { OPENMAUSBOT_URL: session.info.url } }); + commands.push({ command: args, result }); return result as any; + }; + const tool = async (name: string, args: Record) => { + const result = await handleToolCall(name, args, (path, options) => request(path, options, session.info.url)); + commands.push({ tool: name, args, result }); return result as any; + }; + const transcripts: any[] = []; + let rooms: any[] = []; + try { + const bots: any[] = []; + for (const [name, title] of [ + ["ミナト", "経営会議の議長。議論して方針と対象範囲を決める"], + ["アオイ", "営業責任者。顧客価値と優先順位を検討"], + ["ユイ", "管理責任者。予算と情報管理のリスクを指摘"], + ["レン", "開発部長。部内議論で要件を設計と受入条件に具体化"], + ["リツ", "設計担当。方式の比較と実装の複雑さを評価"], + ["マコ", "品質責任者。漏れや失敗条件を指摘"], + ["ソラ", "実装チームリーダー。チーム議論で実装・テスト計画をまとめる"], + ["ヒナ", "実装担当。具体的な処理方式と代案を提案"], + ["ナギ", "テスト担当。他の意見を検討し境界値と確認手順を提案"], + ]) { + const bot = (await control("new-bot", "--name", name, "--title", title, "--section", "検証会社")).bot; + if (live) await tool("set_bot_model", { bot_id: bot.id, instance_id: "claude", model: "glm-5.3", effort: "low" }); + bots.push(bot); + } + const [ceo, sales, finance, director, architect, qa, lead, developer, tester] = bots; + for (const [index, name] of ["経営会議", "開発部", "実装チーム"].entries()) { + const members = bots.slice(index * 3, index * 3 + 3); + const bulletin = `既存の3メンバーで議論する。責任者は最初に仮案を出し、discuss_roomで他の2名の意見を聞く。後の発言者は先の意見に賛否や修正を述べる。責任者は採否と理由をまとめてから次層へ依頼する。日本語で各発言は最大300字。ツールの非同期受付後は待機やScheduleWakeupをせず最終応答でターンを終える。下流の成果の了承や承認は自分の最終応答に書く。了承を新規依頼として送らない。コード変更や外部検索は不要、今回はCSV出力の設計会議だけ。${index === 0 ? "開発部のレンに決定した事業要件を渡す。" : index === 1 ? "実装チームのソラに設計と受入条件を渡す。" : "下流への新規依頼は不要。議論後に実装手順・テスト計画・未確定点を報告する。実装完了とは言わない。"}`; + const room = (await tool("create_channel", { name, member_ids: members.map(b => b.id), bulletin, + default_responder: { kind: "member", bot_id: members[0].id } })).channel; + await tool("update_channel", { channel_id: room.id, require_room_discussion: true }); rooms.push(room); + } + await control("room-routes", "--channel", rooms[1].id, "--from", rooms[0].id); + await control("room-routes", "--channel", rooms[2].id, "--from", rooms[1].id); + const planPath = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-plan.json"); + const send = (index: number, bot: any, message: string, expectError = false) => ({ tool: "coordinate_bots", arguments: { group_id: rooms[index].id, bot_ids: [bot.id], message, request_key: `assign-${index}` }, expectError }); + const discuss = (members: any[], topic: string) => ({ tool: "discuss_room", arguments: { member_ids: members.map(b => b.id), topic, request_key: "design-discussion" } }); + const business = "顧客のExcel利用を優先し、初版はCSV出力のみ。個人情報は対象外、上限1万件。対象範囲を絞り短納期とする。設計と受入条件を部内で議論してください。"; + const design = "経営決定を受け、UTF-8 BOM付きCSVを採用。個人情報を除外し上限1万件、引用符をエスケープ。失敗時は途中ファイルを残さない。実装・テスト計画をチームで議論してください。"; + if (!live) writeFileSync(planPath, JSON.stringify({ + [ceo.id]: { turns: [ + { steps: [send(1, director, "そのまま中継", true), discuss([sales, finance], "CSVとPDFを同時に提供する仮案です。優先度・費用・情報管理を議論してください。"), send(1, director, "議論前の中継", true)], reply: "仮案はCSVとPDFの同時提供です。@アオイ @ユイ 営業・管理の観点から必要性とリスクを確認します。" }, + { expectContextIncludes: ["CSVを先行", "個人情報"], steps: [send(1, director, business)], reply: "【経営決定】営業のCSV先行案と管理の情報制限を採用。PDFは後回しにし、個人情報を除外・上限1万件で開発部へ依頼します。" }, + { expectContextIncludes: ["UTF-8 BOM", "途中ファイル"], reply: "【経営確認】CSV先行と個人情報除外が設計・試験計画に反映されました。未確定の出力列は営業が確認します。今回は設計完了で、実装は未着手です。" }, + ] }, + [sales.id]: { steps: [send(1, director, "参加者からの独断の依頼", true), { ...discuss([finance], "議論の再帰呼出し"), expectError: true }], reply: "顧客はExcelで集計したいのでCSVを先行すべきです。PDF同時開発より、出力列を顧客と確認する方が価値があります。" }, + [finance.id]: { expectContextIncludes: ["CSVを先行"], reply: "CSV先行に賛成です。ただし顧客データをそのまま出す案には反対。個人情報を除外し、予算内に収めるため上限1万件に絞りましょう。" }, + [director.id]: { turns: [ + { expectContextIncludes: ["個人情報は対象外"], steps: [discuss([architect, qa], "経営要件を満たすCSVを設計します。仮案は単純な文字列結合です。文字コード・境界値・失敗処理を検討してください。")], reply: "CSV先行・個人情報除外・1万件制限を受領。単純な文字列結合を仮案に、設計と品質の意見を確認します。" }, + { expectContextIncludes: ["UTF-8 BOM", "途中ファイル"], steps: [send(2, lead, design)], reply: "【開発決定】単純結合案を撤回。UTF-8 BOMと引用符処理を採用し、失敗時は途中ファイルを残さないことを受入条件に追加して実装チームへ渡します。" }, + { expectContextIncludes: ["一時ファイル", "10001件"], steps: [{ ...send(2, lead, "了承しました", true), arguments: { ...send(2, lead, "了承しました").arguments, request_key: "acknowledgement" } }], reply: "【開発レビュー】一時ファイルから成功時だけ確定する案を承認。UTF-8 BOM、引用符、10001件、途中ファイル削除の試験計画を確認。出力列は経営側への確認事項です。" }, + ] }, + [architect.id]: { reply: "単純結合ではカンマや改行を含む値が壊れます。CSVライブラリを使い、Excel向けにUTF-8 BOMを付ける方式を提案します。" }, + [qa.id]: { expectContextIncludes: ["CSVライブラリ"], reply: "ライブラリ案に賛成。文字コードだけでは不足で、引用符と上限超過も試験が必要です。失敗時に途中ファイルを残さない条件を追加しましょう。" }, + [lead.id]: { turns: [ + { expectContextIncludes: ["UTF-8 BOM付きCSV"], steps: [discuss([developer, tester], "受入条件を満たす実装手順とテスト計画を議論します。直接ファイルへ書き出す仮案の問題点と代案を挙げてください。")], reply: "BOM・引用符処理・件数制限を確認。直接書き出す仮案について、実装手順と失敗時のテストをチーム内で検討します。" }, + { expectContextIncludes: ["一時ファイル", "10001件"], reply: "【実装計画】直接書込み案を修正し、一時ファイルへ出力、成功時だけ確定します。0件・1万件・10001件、引用符、改行、失敗時の削除を試験。出力列は要確認。コードは未変更です。" }, + ] }, + [developer.id]: { reply: "直接書込みは途中失敗で壊れたCSVが残ります。一時ファイルに書き、成功時だけ確定する方式に変更し、個人情報列は出力前に除外します。" }, + [tester.id]: { expectContextIncludes: ["一時ファイル"], reply: "一時ファイル方式に賛成。ただし削除失敗も考慮が必要です。0件・1万件・10001件、カンマ・改行・引用符と、異常終了時の残骸を確認する試験を追加します。" }, + })); + await control("send-channel", "--channel", rooms[0].id, "--text", "@ミナト CSV出力の新機能を検討してください。各層の既存メンバーで議論し、その判断を踏まえて経営会議→開発部のレン→実装チームのソラへ依頼してください。各層で仮案・賛否・修正・決定を示し、ただの中継にしないでください。最下層は実装とテストの計画を議論し、結果を上に戻してください。今回は設計会議なのでコード変更は不要です。"); + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "running", url: session.info.url, live, rooms: rooms.map(r => ({ id: r.id, name: r.name })) }) + "\n"); + let wait: any; + for (let attempt = 0; attempt < (live ? 50 : 3); attempt++) { + wait = await control("wait", "--channel", rooms[0].id, "--timeout", "30"); + if (wait.status !== "timed-out") break; + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "waiting", elapsedSeconds: (attempt + 1) * 30 }) + "\n"); + } + for (const room of rooms) transcripts.push({ name: room.name, id: room.id, transcript: await control("messages", "--channel", room.id, "--limit", "100") }); + const nodes = JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")); + const provider = !live && existsSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`) ? readFileSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8").trim().split("\n").map(l => JSON.parse(l)) : []; + const checks: string[] = []; + assert.equal(wait.status, "settled", JSON.stringify(wait)); + assert(nodes.every((n: any) => n.status === "completed"), JSON.stringify(nodes)); + assert.equal(nodes.filter((n: any) => n.kind === "work").length, 3); + assert.equal(nodes.filter((n: any) => n.kind === "discussion").length, 3); + for (const [index, room] of rooms.entries()) { + const discussion = nodes.find((n: any) => n.kind === "discussion" && n.groupId === room.id); + assert.deepEqual(new Set(discussion.participants), new Set(bots.slice(index * 3 + 1, index * 3 + 3).map(b => b.id))); + } + checks.push("three independent rooms, each with three existing members", "all three rooms complete member discussions", "all three leaders decide after discussion", "downstream results resume both ancestors"); + if (!live) { + assert.deepEqual(provider.map(p => p.botId), [ceo.id, sales.id, finance.id, ceo.id, director.id, architect.id, qa.id, director.id, lead.id, developer.id, tester.id, lead.id, director.id, ceo.id]); + checks.push("premature forwarding rejected before and during discussion", "completed recipient is not restarted by an acknowledgement", "later member sees earlier opinion", "leaders receive opinions and downstream briefs contain accepted changes"); + } + const currentBots = live ? (await tool("list_bots", {})).bots.filter((b: any) => bots.some(original => original.id === b.id)) : bots; + const evidence = { ok: true, verifiedAt: new Date().toISOString(), live, model: live ? "glm-5.3" : "scripted", fixture: session.info, checks, bots: currentBots, rooms, nodes, transcripts, provider, commands }; + mkdirSync(dirname(output), { recursive: true }); writeFileSync(output, JSON.stringify(evidence, null, 2)); + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "verified", ok: true, output, preview: preview ? session.info.url : undefined, checks }) + "\n"); + if (preview) await new Promise(done => { process.once("SIGINT", done); process.once("SIGTERM", done); }); + return evidence; + } catch (error) { + mkdirSync(dirname(output), { recursive: true }); + writeFileSync(output, JSON.stringify({ ok: false, error: String(error), nodes: existsSync(join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json")) ? JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")) : [], fixture: session.info, rooms, transcripts, commands, log: readFileSync(session.info.logPath, "utf8") }, null, 2)); + throw error; + } finally { await session.close(); } +} + +if (process.argv[1] && import.meta.url === pathToFileURL(resolve(process.argv[1])).href) { + await verifyRoomDiscussion(resolve(process.argv[2] ?? "artifacts/room-discussion/verification.json"), process.argv.includes("--preview"), process.argv.includes("--live")); +} diff --git a/scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts b/scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..eee1759d89 --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts @@ -0,0 +1,109 @@ +import assert from "node:assert/strict"; +import { mkdirSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path"; +import { pathToFileURL } from "node:url"; +import { launchVerificationServer, runControlOmb } from "./control-omb.ts"; +import { handleToolCall, request } from "./mcp-server.ts"; + +/** Exercises provider -> real agents MCP -> server -> addressed room turns, + * not synthetic API capabilities. Every app record lives in the launcher's fixture. + */ +export async function verifyRoomHandoffs(outputPath?: string, preview = false) { + const session = await launchVerificationServer(process.env, undefined, undefined, undefined, undefined, { scripted: true, staticDir: preview ? resolve("dist") : undefined }); + const commands: unknown[] = []; + const env = { OPENMAUSBOT_URL: session.info.url }; + const control = async (...args: string[]) => { + const result = await runControlOmb(args, { env }); + commands.push({ command: ["control-omb", ...args], env, result }); + return result as any; + }; + const fetcher = (path: string, options: RequestInit = {}) => request(path, options, session.info.url); + const tool = async (name: string, args: Record) => { + const result = await handleToolCall(name, args, fetcher); commands.push({ tool: name, args, result }); return result as any; + }; + try { + assert.equal((await control("doctor")).ok, true); + const createBot = async (name: string) => (await control("new-bot", "--name", name, "--section", "検証会社")).bot; + const ceo = await createBot("ミナト"); + const director = await createBot("レン"); + const deptBystander = await createBot("リツ"); + const engineer = await createBot("ソラ"); + const leafBystander = await createBot("ヒナ"); + const room = async (name: string, members: string[], bulletin: string) => (await tool("create_channel", { + name, member_ids: members, bulletin, default_responder: { kind: "everyone" }, + })).channel; + const executive = await room("経営会議", [ceo.id], "EXECUTIVE_PRIVATE_CONTEXT"); + const development = await room("開発部", [director.id, deptBystander.id], "DEVELOPMENT_CONTEXT: CSVはUTF-8 BOM付き"); + const implementation = await room("実装チーム", [engineer.id, leafBystander.id], "IMPLEMENTATION_CONTEXT: 変更にはテストを付ける"); + await control("room-routes", "--channel", development.id, "--from", executive.id); + await control("room-routes", "--channel", implementation.id, "--from", development.id); + // Allow the reverse address too: ancestry, not lack of a route, must stop a loop. + await control("room-routes", "--channel", executive.id, "--from", implementation.id); + const planPath = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-plan.json"); + const send = (groupId: string, botId: string, key: string, message: string, expectError = false) => ({ + arguments: { group_id: groupId, bot_ids: [botId], request_key: key, message }, expectError, + }); + const plan = { + [ceo.id]: { + steps: [send(development.id, director.id, "csv", "CSV出力を実装・検証してください。"), + send(development.id, director.id, "csv", "CSV出力を実装・検証してください。")], + reply: "開発部のレンに依頼しました。", resumeReply: "経営会議報告：CSV実装と検証結果を受領しました。", + }, + [director.id]: { + steps: [send(implementation.id, engineer.id, "build", "CSV出力を実装してください。"), + send(implementation.id, ceo.id, "non-member", "宛先所属の拒否確認", true)], + reply: "実装チームのソラに依頼しました。", resumeReply: "開発部報告：実装チームの成果を確認しました。", + }, + [engineer.id]: { + steps: [send(executive.id, ceo.id, "loop", "経営会議への循環依頼", true), + { tool: "delegate_bot", arguments: { bot_ids: [leafBystander.id], message: "旧経路の制限確認" }, expectError: true }], + reply: "実装完了：CSV出力と文字コードのテストを確認しました。", + }, + }; + writeFileSync(planPath, JSON.stringify(plan)); + await control("send-channel", "--channel", executive.id, "--text", "@ミナト CSV出力機能の開発をお願いします。"); + const settled = await control("wait", "--channel", executive.id, "--timeout", "90"); + assert.equal(settled.status, "settled", JSON.stringify(settled)); + const transcripts = []; + for (const group of [executive, development, implementation]) transcripts.push({ name: group.name, id: group.id, + transcript: await control("messages", "--channel", group.id, "--limit", "60") }); + const nodes = JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")); + assert.equal(nodes.length, 3, "one root, one department request, one implementation request; duplicate creates nothing"); + assert(nodes.every((n: any) => n.status === "completed"), JSON.stringify(nodes)); + const provider = readFileSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8").trim().split("\n").map(line => JSON.parse(line)); + assert.deepEqual(provider.map(p => [p.botId, p.resumed]), [ + [ceo.id, false], [director.id, false], [engineer.id, false], [director.id, true], [ceo.id, true], + ], "only addressed agents run; both ancestors are automatically resumed"); + const deptTurn = provider.find(p => p.botId === director.id); + const leafTurn = provider.find(p => p.botId === engineer.id); + assert(deptTurn.system.includes("DEVELOPMENT_CONTEXT")); + assert(leafTurn.system.includes("IMPLEMENTATION_CONTEXT")); + assert(!deptTurn.system.includes("EXECUTIVE_PRIVATE_CONTEXT")); + assert(!leafTurn.system.includes("DEVELOPMENT_CONTEXT")); + assert(provider.filter(p => p.resumed).every(p => p.system.includes("Room") || p.system.includes("room"))); + const evidence = { ok: true, verifiedAt: new Date().toISOString(), fixture: session.info, + checks: ["three disjoint rooms in one company section", "only addressed agents start", "destination context", "no source bulletin leak", + "duplicate suppressed", "non-member rejected", "ancestor loop rejected", "legacy peer tools unavailable on delegated turns", + "leaf result -> director continuation -> CEO continuation"], + commands, nodes, transcripts, provider }; + if (outputPath) { mkdirSync(dirname(outputPath), { recursive: true }); writeFileSync(outputPath, JSON.stringify(evidence, null, 2)); } + if (preview) { + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ preview: session.info.url, fixture: session.info, rooms: [executive, development, implementation] }) + "\n"); + await new Promise(done => { process.once("SIGINT", done); process.once("SIGTERM", done); }); + } + return evidence; + } catch (error) { + if (outputPath) { + mkdirSync(dirname(outputPath), { recursive: true }); + writeFileSync(outputPath, JSON.stringify({ ok: false, error: String(error), fixture: session.info, commands, + log: readFileSync(session.info.logPath, "utf8") }, null, 2)); + } + throw error; + } finally { await session.close(); } +} + +if (process.argv[1] && import.meta.url === pathToFileURL(resolve(process.argv[1])).href) { + const output = resolve(process.argv[2] ?? "artifacts/room-handoffs/verification.json"); + const evidence = await verifyRoomHandoffs(output, process.argv.includes("--preview")); + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ ok: evidence.ok, output, checks: evidence.checks, log: evidence.fixture.logPath }) + "\n"); +} diff --git a/scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts b/scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..3768f5ddeb --- /dev/null +++ b/scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts @@ -0,0 +1,149 @@ +import assert from "node:assert/strict"; +import { existsSync, mkdirSync, readFileSync, rmSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path"; +import { pathToFileURL } from "node:url"; +import { launchVerificationServer, runControlOmb } from "./control-omb.ts"; +import { handleToolCall, request } from "./mcp-server.ts"; + +// Five groups form an asymmetric three-layer organization. Names describe +// responsibility in the parent room; no bot is added to a downstream group. +const organization = [ + { name: "経営会議", members: [["ミナト", "議長"], ["アオイ", "開発担当"], ["ユイ", "営業担当"]], routes: [1, 2], rounds: 2, + topic: "CSV出力の初期対象。仮案は全項目・全件出力。アオイは早期公開のため対象限定、ユイは営業に必要な項目を要求。2巡目で具体的な妥協案を再検討して決定する。" }, + { name: "開発部", members: [["レン", "部長"], ["リツ", "実装担当"], ["マコ", "品質担当"]], routes: [3, 4], rounds: 2, + topic: "CSV設計と受入条件。仮案は直接書込み・件数の事前確認のみ。リツは処理の簡素さ、マコは途中失敗と件数変化の危険を検討。2巡目で修正案を相互確認して決定する。" }, + { name: "営業部", members: [["コウ", "部長"], ["サキ", "顧客説明担当"], ["トワ", "営業運用担当"]], routes: [], rounds: 1, + topic: "公開時の顧客説明と運用。サキは便利さ、トワは個人情報持出しの制約を検討。決定後サキに顧客向けFAQ3問、トワに社内操作チェックリスト5項目の作成を依頼する。" }, + { name: "実装チーム", members: [["ソラ", "リーダー"], ["ヒナ", "CSV作成担当"], ["ナギ", "データ検証担当"]], routes: [], rounds: 1, + topic: "出力形式とサンプルを議論。決定後ヒナに架空データ3行のCSV本文、ナギにそのCSVのカンマ・引用符の検査表を作成依頼。ナギはヒナの成果を読んで検査する。" }, + { name: "QAチーム", members: [["レオ", "リーダー"], ["メイ", "境界値担当"], ["ハル", "異常系担当"]], routes: [], rounds: 1, + topic: "受入試験を議論。決定後メイに0件・上限ちょうど・上限超過の3ケース表、ハルに生成中の件数変化・途中失敗・権限なしの3ケース表を作成依頼。入力条件と期待結果を必ず記載する。" }, +]; + +export async function verifyRoomPyramid(output: string, live = false, preview = false) { + // Clear only a previous run's signal, before this run can accept a stop. + if (preview) rmSync(`${output}.stop`, { force: true }); + let realEngine: { cli: string; environment: Record } | undefined; + if (live) { + const configPath = process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_CONFIG; + const cli = process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_CLI; + if (!configPath || !cli) throw new Error("Set OMB_VERIFY_CC_CONFIG and OMB_VERIFY_CC_CLI"); + const saved = JSON.parse(readFileSync(configPath, "utf8")).instances?.[process.env.OMB_VERIFY_CC_INSTANCE ?? "claude"]?.environment; + if (!saved?.ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN || saved.ANTHROPIC_MODEL !== "glm-5.3") throw new Error("Expected GLM-5.3 profile"); + const environment: Record = {}; + for (const key of ["ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN", "ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL", "ANTHROPIC_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_OPUS_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_SONNET_MODEL", "ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_HAIKU_MODEL", "CLAUDE_CODE_DISABLE_NONESSENTIAL_TRAFFIC"]) if (typeof saved[key] === "string") environment[key] = saved[key]; + if (process.env.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH) environment.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH = process.env.CLAUDE_CODE_GIT_BASH_PATH; + realEngine = { cli, environment }; + } + const session = await launchVerificationServer(process.env, undefined, undefined, undefined, undefined, { scripted: !live, staticDir: preview ? resolve("dist") : undefined, engine: realEngine }); + const commands: any[] = [], rooms: any[] = [], teams: any[][] = [], transcripts: any[] = []; + const control = async (...args: string[]) => { + const result = await runControlOmb(args, { env: { OPENMAUSBOT_URL: session.info.url } }); commands.push({ args, result }); return result as any; + }; + const tool = async (name: string, args: Record) => { + const result = await handleToolCall(name, args, (path, options) => request(path, options, session.info.url)); commands.push({ name, args, result }); return result as any; + }; + const nodesPath = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"); + const planPath = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-plan.json"); + try { + for (const group of organization) { + const members: any[] = []; + for (const [name, role] of group.members) { + const bot = (await control("new-bot", "--name", name, "--title", `${group.name}の${role}`, "--section", "検証会社")).bot; + if (live) await tool("set_bot_model", { bot_id: bot.id, instance_id: "claude", model: "glm-5.3", effort: "low" }); + members.push(bot); + } + teams.push(members); + const bulletin = `企業組織の実験。既存3名で議論→決定→担当メンバーへの分担→担当者が下流へ依頼又は成果を作成→責任者へ報告、の順。責任者${members[0].name}は受領・会議の進行・採否・取りまとめを担当。責任者自身はcoordinate_botsで下流へ送らず、決定後coordinate_botsを2人それぞれに使う。担当メンバーは議論の発言時には意見を述べ、後で担当として割り当てられたターンで実行する。担当としての実行時は議論をやり直さない。議論はdiscuss_roomで他2名を順に指定し${group.rounds}巡行う。${group.rounds === 2 ? "1巡目の懸念に責任者が修正案を出し、2巡目で両名がその修正案に回答する。" : "各自が前の人の意見に賛否と具体的な改善を述べる。"}非同期ツール受付後は即座に最終応答でターン終了。待機、再送、ScheduleWakeup禁止。返却結果への了承は最終応答に書く。架空案件のみ。外部検索・実データ・コード変更不要。日本語で各発言原則250字、成果の表やCSVだけは必要な長さで。論点:${group.topic}`; + const room = (await tool("create_channel", { name: group.name, member_ids: members.map(b => b.id), bulletin, default_responder: { kind: "member", bot_id: members[0].id } })).channel; + await tool("update_channel", { channel_id: room.id, require_room_discussion: true }); rooms.push(room); + } + for (const [index, group] of organization.entries()) for (const target of group.routes) { + await control("room-routes", "--channel", rooms[target].id, "--from", rooms[index].id); + } + // Set exact responsibilities after all destination groups have been created. + for (const [index, group] of organization.entries()) { + const mappings = group.routes.map((to, i) => `${teams[index][i + 1].name}が${rooms[to].name}の${teams[to][0].name}宛てに依頼し、その結果をレビューして${teams[index][0].name}へ報告する`).join("。 "); + if (mappings) await tool("update_channel", { channel_id: rooms[index].id, bulletin: `${rooms[index].bulletin}\n分担:${mappings}。担当者はlist_room_targetsから宛先IDを確認する。下層にも同じ議論・分担・実行の手順を伝える。` }); + } + if (!live) { + const plan: Record = {}; + for (const [index, group] of organization.entries()) { + const [chair, one, two] = teams[index]; + const discuss = (round: number) => ({ tool: "discuss_room", arguments: { member_ids: [one.id, two.id], topic: `${group.name}第${round}巡。修正案を検討`, request_key: `round-${round}` } }); + const assign = (bot: any) => ({ tool: "coordinate_bots", arguments: { bot_ids: [bot.id], message: `${group.name}決定に基づく担当業務。実行してください`, request_key: `owner-${bot.id}` } }); + const chairTurns: any[] = [{ steps: [{ ...assign(one), expectError: true }, discuss(1)], reply: `${group.name}仮案。各担当の意見を求めます。` }]; + if (group.rounds === 2) chairTurns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${two.name}懸念`], steps: [discuss(2)], reply: `${group.name}修正案。懸念を受けて条件を限定します。再確認してください。` }); + chairTurns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${two.name}${group.rounds === 2 ? "再検討" : "懸念"}`], steps: [assign(one), assign(two)], reply: `${group.name}決定。懸念を反映し2名に別々の責任を割り当てました。` }); + chairTurns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${one.name}成果`, `${two.name}成果`], reply: `${group.name}統合報告。両担当の成果を確認しました。` }); + plan[chair.id] = { turns: chairTurns }; + for (const [memberIndex, member] of [one, two].entries()) { + const turns: any[] = [{ ...(memberIndex ? { expectContextIncludes: [`${one.name}懸念`] } : {}), reply: `${member.name}懸念。仮案に条件不足があるため修正を提案します。` }]; + if (group.rounds === 2) turns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${group.name}修正案`], reply: `${member.name}再検討。修正により懸念が解消しました。境界条件も追加して合意します。` }); + const to = group.routes[memberIndex]; + if (to !== undefined) { + turns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${group.name}決定`], steps: [{ tool: "coordinate_bots", arguments: { group_id: rooms[to].id, bot_ids: [teams[to][0].id], message: `${group.name}決定を具体化した依頼。${organization[to].topic}`, request_key: `to-${to}` } }], reply: `${member.name}担当として下層へ依頼しました。` }); + turns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${rooms[to].name}統合報告`], reply: `${member.name}成果。下層の結果をレビューして責任者へ報告します。` }); + } else turns.push({ expectContextIncludes: [`${group.name}決定`], reply: `${member.name}成果。担当の成果物を作成しました。検査表:入力0件→ヘッダのみ、上限超過→中断。` }); + plan[member.id] = { turns }; + } + } + writeFileSync(planPath, JSON.stringify(plan)); + } + await control("send-channel", "--channel", rooms[0].id, "--text", "@ミナト CSV出力の公開準備をしてください。経営会議で既存のアオイ・ユイと2巡議論し、修正案を再検討して方針を決めてください。その後、アオイに開発部レンへの依頼と結果確認、ユイに営業部コウへの依頼と結果確認をcoordinate_botsで分担。開発部でも2巡議論の後、リツが実装チームのソラへ、マコがQAチームのレオへ依頼します。最下層と営業部は1巡議論後に各既存メンバーへ成果物作成を分担。計画だけで終わらず架空CSVサンプル・検査表・FAQ・チェックリストを作成。結果を各担当が確認して責任者へ戻し、最後に経営会議で統合してください。役割・経路は各グループの掲示にあります。実データやコード変更は不要です。"); + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "running", live, fixture: session.info, rooms: rooms.map(r => ({ id: r.id, name: r.name })) }) + "\n"); + let wait: any; + for (let i = 0; i < (live ? 50 : 6); i++) { + wait = await control("wait", "--channel", rooms[0].id, "--timeout", "30"); + if (wait.status !== "timed-out") break; + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "waiting", seconds: (i + 1) * 30 }) + "\n"); + } + for (const room of rooms) transcripts.push({ name: room.name, id: room.id, transcript: await control("messages", "--channel", room.id, "--limit", "100") }); + const nodes: any[] = JSON.parse(readFileSync(nodesPath, "utf8")); + assert.equal(wait.status, "settled", JSON.stringify(wait)); + assert(nodes.every(n => n.status === "completed"), JSON.stringify(nodes)); + assert.equal(nodes.filter(n => n.kind === "work").length, 5); + assert.equal(nodes.filter(n => n.kind === "assignment").length, 10); + assert.equal(nodes.filter(n => n.kind === "discussion").length, 7); + for (const [index, group] of organization.entries()) { + const work = nodes.find(n => n.kind === "work" && n.groupId === rooms[index].id); + assert.equal(nodes.filter(n => n.kind === "discussion" && n.parentId === work.id).length, group.rounds); + const assigned = nodes.filter(n => n.kind === "assignment" && n.parentId === work.id); + assert.deepEqual(new Set(assigned.map(n => n.botId)), new Set(teams[index].slice(1).map(b => b.id))); + for (const [memberIndex, target] of group.routes.entries()) { + const child = nodes.find(n => n.kind === "work" && n.groupId === rooms[target].id); + const owner = nodes.find(n => n.id === child.parentId); + assert.equal(owner.kind, "assignment"); assert.equal(owner.botId, teams[index][memberIndex + 1].id); + } + } + const currentRooms = (await tool("list_channels", {})).channels; + for (const room of rooms) assert.deepEqual(currentRooms.find((r: any) => r.id === room.id).memberIds, room.memberIds); + const bots = (await tool("list_bots", {})).bots.filter((b: any) => teams.flat().some(member => member.id === b.id)); + const provider = !live ? readFileSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8").trim().split("\n").map(l => JSON.parse(l)) : []; + const evidence = { ok: true, verifiedAt: new Date().toISOString(), live, model: live ? "glm-5.3" : "scripted", fixture: session.info, rooms, bots, nodes, transcripts, provider, commands }; + mkdirSync(dirname(output), { recursive: true }); writeFileSync(output, JSON.stringify(evidence, null, 2)); + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "verified", output, work: 5, assignment: 10, discussion: 7 }) + "\n"); + if (preview) { + // A task-specific stop file lets the launcher run its normal finally + // cleanup on Windows, where terminating the shell can skip JS signals. + process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ phase: "preview", stopFile: `${output}.stop` }) + "\n"); + await new Promise(done => { + const timer = setInterval(() => { if (existsSync(`${output}.stop`)) { clearInterval(timer); done(); } }, 500); + const stop = () => { clearInterval(timer); done(); }; process.once("SIGINT", stop); process.once("SIGTERM", stop); + }); + } + return evidence; + } catch (error) { + for (const room of rooms) if (!transcripts.some(t => t.id === room.id)) { + try { transcripts.push({ name: room.name, id: room.id, transcript: await control("messages", "--channel", room.id, "--limit", "100") }); } catch { /* preserve original failure */ } + } + mkdirSync(dirname(output), { recursive: true }); + writeFileSync(output, JSON.stringify({ ok: false, error: String(error), fixture: session.info, rooms, transcripts, commands, + nodes: existsSync(nodesPath) ? JSON.parse(readFileSync(nodesPath, "utf8")) : [], log: readFileSync(session.info.logPath, "utf8") }, null, 2)); + throw error; + } finally { await session.close(); } +} + +if (process.argv[1] && import.meta.url === pathToFileURL(resolve(process.argv[1])).href) { + await verifyRoomPyramid(resolve(process.argv[2] ?? "artifacts/pyramid/verification.json"), process.argv.includes("--live"), process.argv.includes("--preview")); +} diff --git a/server/control-omb.test.ts b/server/control-omb.test.ts index 5e236883f4..e5afa37608 100644 --- a/server/control-omb.test.ts +++ b/server/control-omb.test.ts @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -import { spawnSync } from "node:child_process"; +import { spawn, spawnSync } from "node:child_process"; import { existsSync, mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; import { join } from "node:path"; @@ -13,9 +13,56 @@ import { runControlOmb, } from "../scripts/control-omb.ts"; import { installedChrome, UI_MUTATING } from "../scripts/testing/control-omb-ui.ts"; -import { removeTempDir } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; +import { removeTempDir, waitForExit } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; describe("control-omb command mapping", () => { + it("requires an explicit room route target and keeps dry-run from clearing grants", async () => { + const invoke = vi.fn(async () => ({ success: true })); + const env = { OPENMAUSBOT_URL: "http://127.0.0.1:18799" }; + await runControlOmb(["room-routes", "--channel", "engineering", "--from", "planning,planning"], { env, callTool: invoke }); + expect(invoke).toHaveBeenCalledWith("update_channel", { channel_id: "engineering", incoming_group_ids: ["planning", "planning"] }, expect.any(Function)); + invoke.mockClear(); + await runControlOmb(["room-routes", "--channel", "engineering", "--from", "", "--dry-run"], { env, callTool: invoke }); + expect(invoke).not.toHaveBeenCalled(); + await expect(runControlOmb(["room-routes", "--channel", "engineering", "--from", "planning"], { env: {}, callTool: invoke })).rejects.toThrow(); + }); + it.each(["message", "disconnect"])("cleans up its real fixture after parent IPC %s", async (stopVia) => { + const child = spawn(process.execPath, ["--experimental-strip-types", "scripts/control-omb.ts", "launch"], { + env: process.env, stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe", "ipc"], + }); + let output = ""; + let stderr = ""; + child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { stderr += String(chunk); }); + try { + const info = await new Promise<{ dataDir: string; url: string }>((resolve, reject) => { + const timer = setTimeout(() => reject(new Error(`fixture launch timed out: ${stderr}`)), 30_000); + child.once("close", (code) => { + clearTimeout(timer); + reject(new Error(`fixture exited ${code} before shutdown: ${stderr}`)); + }); + child.stdout!.on("data", (chunk: Buffer) => { + output += String(chunk); + try { + const handle = JSON.parse(output); + clearTimeout(timer); + resolve(handle); + } catch { /* the handle may span multiple chunks */ } + }); + }); + expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(true); + expect((await runControlOmb(["doctor", "--url", info.url]) as { ok: boolean }).ok).toBe(true); + if (stopVia === "disconnect") child.disconnect(); + await waitForExit(child, { + ...(stopVia === "message" ? { message: "control-omb:stop" } : {}), graceMs: 30_000, + }); + expect(child.exitCode, stderr).toBe(0); + expect(existsSync(info.dataDir)).toBe(false); + await expect(fetch(`${info.url}/api/health`, { signal: AbortSignal.timeout(2_000) })).rejects.toThrow(); + } finally { + await waitForExit(child, { message: "control-omb:stop", graceMs: 30_000 }); + } + }, 65_000); + it("treats unhealthy doctor and non-settled waits as command failures", () => { expect(controlResultSucceeded("doctor", { ok: true })).toBe(true); expect(controlResultSucceeded("doctor", { ok: false })).toBe(false); diff --git a/server/coordination-acp.e2e.test.ts b/server/coordination-acp.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..6b9257f3dd --- /dev/null +++ b/server/coordination-acp.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,320 @@ +// Ordinary chat coordination through real ACP providers and their injected MCP. +// Legacy synchronous/one-hop calls are no longer advertised in ordinary chat. +// Keep the original admission, approval, failure and return-path scenarios on +// coordinate_bots; routines retain their separate legacy delegation coverage. +import { spawn, type ChildProcess } from "node:child_process"; +import { createHash } from "node:crypto"; +import { chmodSync, copyFileSync, existsSync, mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; +import { dirname, join } from "node:path"; +import { fileURLToPath, pathToFileURL } from "node:url"; +import { afterAll, afterEach, beforeAll, describe, expect, it, vi } from "vitest"; +import { removeTempDir, waitForExit } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; +import { freePortBlock } from "./testing/ports.ts"; + +const SERVER_DIR = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); +const ROOT = join(SERVER_DIR, ".."); +const FAKE_CLI = join(SERVER_DIR, "testing", "fake-acp-cli.ts"); + +describe("comms e2e (fake ACP fleet)", () => { + let child: ChildProcess; + let home: string; + let base: string; + let planPath: string; + let stderr = ""; + let plan: Record = {}; + const created: string[] = []; + const api = async (method: string, path: string, body?: unknown) => { + const response = await fetch(base + path, { method, headers: { "content-type": "application/json" }, + ...(body === undefined ? {} : { body: JSON.stringify(body) }) }); + return { status: response.status, body: response.status === 204 ? null : await response.json() as any }; + }; + const bots = async () => (await api("GET", "/api/bots")).body.bots as any[]; + const state = async (id: string) => (await bots()).find(bot => bot.id === id); + const messages = async (thread: string) => (await api("GET", `/api/threads/${thread}/messages?limit=100`)).body.messages as any[]; + const nodes = (): any[] => existsSync(join(home, ".openmausbot", "room-handoffs.json")) + ? JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(home, ".openmausbot", "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")) : []; + const evidence = (): any[] => existsSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`) + ? readFileSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8").trim().split("\n").filter(Boolean).map(line => JSON.parse(line)) : []; + const save = () => writeFileSync(planPath, JSON.stringify(plan)); + const create = async (name: string, instanceId = "grok", model = "fake-model") => { + const bot = (await api("POST", "/api/bots")).body.bot; + created.push(bot.id); + expect((await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${bot.id}`, { name, modelSelection: { instanceId, model } })).status).toBe(200); + return { ...bot, name }; + }; + const pair = async () => { + const target = await create("Helper"); + const source = await create("Asker"); + plan = { [source.id]: { steps: [{ arguments: { bot_ids: [target.id], request_key: "work", message: "Verify the requested report" } }], + reply: "Assigned", resumeReply: "The actual teammate report is verified" }, [target.id]: { reply: "Helper verified the report" } }; + return { source, target }; + }; + const start = async (bot: any, text = "Ask the actual teammate to verify the report") => { + save(); + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${bot.id}/messages`, { threadId: bot.threadId, text })).status).toBe(202); + }; + const childNode = (source: any, target: any) => { + const all = nodes(); + return all.find(node => node.parentId && node.botId === target.id + && all.some(parent => parent.id === node.parentId && parent.botId === source.id)); + }; + const settled = async (source: any) => { + await expect.poll(async () => { + const root = nodes().find(node => !node.parentId && node.botId === source.id); + return root?.status === "completed" && !(await state(source.id)).busy; + }, { timeout: 25_000 }).toBe(true); + }; + const approval = async (source: any) => { + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(source.threadId)).some(message => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot" && !message.card.answered), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + return (await messages(source.threadId)).find(message => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot" && !message.card.answered); + }; + const respond = async (source: any, card: any, behavior: "allow" | "deny") => { + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${source.id}/respond`, { threadId: source.threadId, requestId: card.card.requestId, behavior })).status).toBe(200); + }; + + beforeAll(async () => { + home = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "omb-comms-test-")); + planPath = join(home, "plan.json"); + const data = join(home, ".openmausbot"); + mkdirSync(data, { recursive: true }); + const antigravity = join(home, "fake-antigravity"); + mkdirSync(antigravity); + const geminiCli = join(antigravity, "agy_acp_server.ts"); + const geminiHarness = join(antigravity, process.platform === "win32" ? "localharness_external.exe" : "localharness_external"); + copyFileSync(FAKE_CLI, geminiCli); copyFileSync(FAKE_CLI, geminiHarness); + if (process.platform !== "win32") { chmodSync(geminiCli, 0o755); chmodSync(geminiHarness, 0o755); } + const auth = join(data, "providers", "antigravity", createHash("sha256").update("geminiAsker").digest("hex"), "antigravity-acp"); + mkdirSync(auth, { recursive: true }); writeFileSync(join(auth, "acp_token.json"), "{}\n"); + const environment = { FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_PLAN: planPath, + FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_AGENT: pathToFileURL(join(SERVER_DIR, "testing", "acp-coordination-agent.ts")).href }; + writeFileSync(join(data, "config.json"), JSON.stringify({ threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 2 }, instances: { + grok: { driver: "grokAgent", environment, config: { cli: FAKE_CLI, fullAuto: true } }, + crash: { driver: "grokAgent", environment: { FAKE_ACP_MODE: "exit-early" }, config: { cli: FAKE_CLI, fullAuto: true } }, + geminiAsker: { driver: "antigravityAgent", environment: { ...environment, FAKE_ACP_AUTH_METHOD: "oauth-personal", FAKE_ACP_MODELS: "gemini-3.8-flash-high", FAKE_ACP_MODES: "default,yolo" }, config: { cli: geminiCli, fullAuto: true } }, + } })); + const port = await freePortBlock([0, 1]); base = `http://127.0.0.1:${port}`; + child = spawn(process.execPath, [join(SERVER_DIR, "index.ts")], { cwd: ROOT, + env: { PATH: process.env.PATH, SystemRoot: process.env.SystemRoot, HOME: home, USERPROFILE: home, + OMB_PORT: String(port), OMB_WEBHOOK_PORT: String(port + 1), OMB_ASK_BOT_TIMEOUT_MS: "25" }, + stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"] }); + child.stdout!.resume(); child.stderr!.on("data", chunk => { stderr += chunk; }); + await vi.waitFor(async () => { + if (child.exitCode !== null) throw new Error(`Fixture exited: ${stderr}`); + expect((await fetch(base + "/api/health")).status).toBe(200); + }, { timeout: 20_000 }); + for (const bot of await bots()) await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${bot.id}`, { hidden: true }); + }, 30_000); + afterEach(async context => { + if (context.task.result?.state === "fail") { + console.info(JSON.stringify({ failed: context.task.name, nodes: nodes().filter(node => created.includes(node.botId)), + turns: evidence().filter(turn => created.includes(turn.botId)).map(turn => ({ botId: turn.botId, resumed: turn.resumed, steps: turn.evidence.slice(2) })), stderr: stderr.slice(-1800) })); + } + for (const id of created.splice(0)) { + await api("POST", `/api/bots/${id}/interrupt`, {}).catch(() => undefined); + await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${id}`, { chiefOfStaff: false }).catch(() => undefined); + await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${id}`).catch(() => undefined); + } + }); + afterAll(async () => { if (child) await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGTERM" }); if (home) await removeTempDir(home); }); + + it("seals the internal comms endpoints behind the per-turn token", async () => { + for (const path of ["/api/internal/ask-bot", "/api/internal/delegate-bot", "/api/internal/coordinate-bots", "/api/internal/threads"]) + expect((await api("POST", path, {})).status).toBe(401); + expect((await api("GET", "/api/internal/agents")).status).toBe(401); + }); + it("carries a question through the real ACP agents proxy and returns the actual peer result", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + const originalMessages = await messages(target.threadId); + await start(source); await settled(source); + const node = childNode(source, target); + expect(node).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Helper verified the report" }); + expect(node.threadId).not.toBe(target.threadId); + expect(evidence().filter(turn => [source.id, target.id].includes(turn.botId)).map(turn => turn.botId)).toEqual([source.id, target.id, source.id]); + const receipt = (await messages(source.threadId)).find(message => message.roomRequest?.id === node.id); + expect(receipt).toMatchObject({ from: { botId: target.id }, tool: { ok: true }, threadRef: { botId: target.id, threadId: node.threadId } }); + expect((await messages(node.threadId)).find(message => message.roomRequest?.phase === "request")).toMatchObject({ from: { botId: source.id } }); + expect(await messages(target.threadId)).toEqual(originalMessages); + expect((await messages(target.threadId)).some(message => message.roomRequest)).toBe(false); + expect((await api("GET", "/api/bots")).body.groups).toEqual([]); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed).system).toContain("Helper verified the report"); + }, 40_000); + it("lets Gemini Antigravity coordinate through its temporary agents MCP mount", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${source.id}`, { modelSelection: { instanceId: "geminiAsker", model: "gemini-3.8-flash-high" } }); + await start(source); await settled(source); + expect(childNode(source, target)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Helper verified the report" }); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed).system).toContain("Helper verified the report"); + expect(existsSync(join(home, ".gemini", "config", "mcp_config.json"))).toBe(false); + }, 40_000); + it("lets a section Chief create a safe operator and then coordinate real work to it", async () => { + const chief = await create("Atlas"); + await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${chief.id}`, { chiefOfStaff: true, section: "Launch" }); + plan = { [chief.id]: { steps: [{ tool: "create_bot", arguments: { name: "Pixel", role: "Product designer", instructions: "Design and review the user experience." } }], reply: "Operator created" } }; + await start(chief, "Create the specialist"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await bots()).some(bot => bot.name === "Pixel"), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + const operator = (await bots()).find(bot => bot.name === "Pixel"); created.push(operator.id); + expect(operator).toMatchObject({ title: "Product designer", description: "Design and review the user experience.", section: "Launch", composio: false, autoApprove: false, approvePeerComms: false, modelSelection: { instanceId: "grok", model: "grok-4.7" } }); + expect(operator.chiefOfStaff).toBeFalsy(); + await expect.poll(async () => (await state(chief.id)).busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + plan = { [chief.id]: { steps: [{ arguments: { bot_ids: [operator.id], request_key: "design", message: "Review the new onboarding flow" } }] }, [operator.id]: { reply: "Onboarding reviewed" } }; + await start(chief); await settled(chief); + expect(childNode(chief, operator)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Onboarding reviewed" }); + }, 45_000); + it("dispatches addressed work after the source provider finishes and resumes its pinned task", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + const release = join(home, `${source.id}.release`); plan[source.id].waitForFile = release; + await start(source); + await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("completed"); + expect(nodes().find(node => !node.parentId && node.botId === source.id)?.status).toBe("source"); + expect(evidence().some(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed)).toBe(false); + writeFileSync(release, "continue"); + await settled(source); + expect(evidence().filter(turn => turn.botId === source.id).map(turn => turn.threadId)).toEqual([source.threadId, source.threadId]); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).filter(message => message.tool?.name === "Sent to Helper")).toHaveLength(1); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).filter(message => message.roomRequest?.phase === "result")).toHaveLength(1); + }, 40_000); + it("keeps a Chief available in a separate task while its coordinated teammate works", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${source.id}`, { chiefOfStaff: true }); + const release = join(home, `${target.id}.release`); plan[target.id].waitForFile = release; + plan[source.id] = { turns: [{ steps: plan[source.id].steps, reply: "Assigned" }, { reply: "Available in another task" }, { reply: "Reviewed returned work" }] }; + await start(source); await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("running"); + const other = (await api("POST", `/api/bots/${source.id}/tasks`, { title: "Other request" })).body.task; + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${source.id}/messages`, { threadId: other.threadId, text: "Are you available?" })).status).toBe(202); + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(other.threadId)).some(message => message.text === "Available in another task"), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect(childNode(source, target).status).toBe("running"); + writeFileSync(release, "continue"); + await settled(source); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).some(message => message.text === "Reviewed returned work")).toBe(true); + expect((await messages(other.threadId)).some(message => message.roomRequest)).toBe(false); + }, 40_000); + it("queues a recipient at capacity and leaves its current conversation untouched", async () => { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 1 } })).status).toBe(200); + try { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + const release = join(home, `${target.id}.release`); + plan[target.id] = { turns: [{ waitForFile: release, reply: "Existing work" }, { reply: "Fresh coordinated result" }] }; + await start(target, "Existing unrelated work"); await start(source); + await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("queued"); + writeFileSync(release, "continue"); + await settled(source); + expect(childNode(source, target)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Fresh coordinated result" }); + expect((await messages(target.threadId)).some(message => message.text === "Existing work")).toBe(true); + expect((await messages(target.threadId)).some(message => message.roomRequest)).toBe(false); + } finally { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 2 } })).status).toBe(200); + } + }, 40_000); + it("retries queued work after provider reload without approving or delivering it twice", async () => { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 1 } })).status).toBe(200); + try { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${source.id}`, { approvePeerComms: true }); + const release = join(home, `${target.id}.reload-release`); + plan[target.id] = { waitForFile: release, reply: "Existing work" }; + await start(target, "Existing work"); await start(source); + await respond(source, await approval(source), "allow"); + // A queued child can exist while its source still finishes the MCP call. + // Reload only after the source yields ownership to the durable coordinator. + await expect.poll(() => nodes().find(node => !node.parentId && node.botId === source.id)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("waiting"); + await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("queued"); + const id = childNode(source, target).id; + plan[target.id] = { reply: "Fresh coordinated result after reload" }; + save(); + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { composio: { apiKey: "" } })).status).toBe(200); + writeFileSync(release, "continue"); + await settled(source); + expect(nodes().find(node => node.id === id)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Fresh coordinated result after reload" }); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).filter(message => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot")).toHaveLength(1); + expect((await messages(childNode(source, target).threadId)).filter(message => message.roomRequest?.phase === "request")).toHaveLength(1); + } finally { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 2 } })).status).toBe(200); + } + }, 40_000); + it("returns a slow peer result beyond the old synchronous ask timeout without losing it", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); plan[target.id].delayMs = 250; + await start(source); await settled(source); + expect(childNode(source, target)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", result: "Helper verified the report" }); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed).system).toContain("Helper verified the report"); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).filter(message => message.roomRequest?.phase === "result")).toHaveLength(1); + }, 40_000); + it("records an empty successful peer reply as a successful terminal receipt", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); plan[target.id].reply = ""; + await start(source); await settled(source); + const node = childNode(source, target); + expect(node.status).toBe("completed"); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).find(message => message.roomRequest?.id === node.id)).toMatchObject({ tool: { ok: true } }); + }, 40_000); + it("finalizes a running coordinated turn interrupted by provider reload", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); plan[target.id].delayMs = 4000; + plan[source.id].resumeReply = "The worker failed; reporting its failure"; + await start(source); + await expect.poll(() => nodes().find(node => !node.parentId && node.botId === source.id)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("waiting"); + await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("running"); + await api("PUT", "/api/config", { composio: { apiKey: "" } }); + await expect.poll(() => ["failed", "cancelled"].includes(childNode(source, target)?.status), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + await settled(source); + await expect.poll(async () => (await state(target.id)).busy, { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe(false); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).some(message => message.text === "The actual teammate report is verified")).toBe(false); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed).system).toContain('"status":"failed"'); + }, 40_000); + it("returns a crashed peer as a failed terminal receipt to the source", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${target.id}`, { modelSelection: { instanceId: "crash", model: "fake-model" } }); + await start(source); await settled(source); + const node = childNode(source, target); expect(node.status).toBe("failed"); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).find(message => message.roomRequest?.id === node.id)).toMatchObject({ tool: { ok: false } }); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id && turn.resumed).system).toContain('"status":"failed"'); + }, 40_000); + it("does not start queued work for a deleted recipient or recreate its task", async () => { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 1 } })).status).toBe(200); + try { + const { source, target } = await pair(); + const release = join(home, `${target.id}.delete-release`); + plan[target.id] = { waitForFile: release, reply: "Existing work" }; + await start(target, "Existing work"); await start(source); + await expect.poll(() => childNode(source, target)?.status, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe("queued"); + const recipientThread = childNode(source, target).threadId; + expect((await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${target.id}`)).status).toBe(200); + writeFileSync(release, "continue"); + await expect.poll(() => ["failed", "cancelled"].includes(childNode(source, target)?.status), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + await expect.poll(async () => (await state(source.id)).busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + expect(await state(target.id)).toBeUndefined(); + expect(evidence().some(turn => turn.threadId === recipientThread)).toBe(false); + } finally { + expect((await api("PUT", "/api/config", { threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 2 } })).status).toBe(200); + } + }, 40_000); + it("holds coordinate_bots behind the actual approval card and runs only after Allow", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${source.id}`, { approvePeerComms: true }); + await start(source); const card = await approval(source); + expect(card.card.allowKey).toBe(`delegate_bot:${target.id}`); + expect(childNode(source, target)).toBeUndefined(); + expect(evidence().some(turn => turn.botId === target.id)).toBe(false); + await respond(source, card, "allow"); await settled(source); + expect(childNode(source, target).status).toBe("completed"); + expect((await messages(source.threadId)).filter(message => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot")).toHaveLength(1); + expect(evidence().filter(turn => turn.botId === target.id)).toHaveLength(1); + }, 40_000); + it("refuses a denied coordination request and never starts or creates peer work", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${source.id}`, { approvePeerComms: true }); + plan[source.id].steps[0].expectError = true; + await start(source); await respond(source, await approval(source), "deny"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await state(source.id)).busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + expect(childNode(source, target)).toBeUndefined(); + expect((await state(target.id)).tasks).toHaveLength(1); + expect(evidence().some(turn => turn.botId === target.id)).toBe(false); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === source.id).evidence.at(-1).response.result.isError).toBe(true); + }, 40_000); + it("allows bounded nested coordination while refusing a return to an ancestor bot", async () => { + const { source, target } = await pair(); const reviewer = await create("Reviewer"); + plan[target.id].steps = [{ arguments: { bot_ids: [reviewer.id], request_key: "review", message: "Verify independently" } }]; + plan[reviewer.id] = { steps: [{ expectError: true, arguments: { bot_ids: [source.id], request_key: "cycle", message: "Return to the ancestor" } }], reply: "Verified without a cycle" }; + await start(source); await settled(source); + expect(nodes().filter(node => [source.id, target.id, reviewer.id].includes(node.botId))).toHaveLength(3); + expect(evidence().filter(turn => [source.id, target.id, reviewer.id].includes(turn.botId)).map(turn => turn.botId)).toEqual([source.id, target.id, reviewer.id, target.id, source.id]); + const tools = evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === target.id).evidence[0].result.tools.map((tool: any) => tool.name); + expect(tools).toContain("coordinate_bots"); + for (const removed of ["ask_bot", "delegate_bot", "start_thread"]) expect(tools).not.toContain(removed); + expect(evidence().find(turn => turn.botId === reviewer.id).evidence.at(-1).response.result.isError).toBe(true); + }, 40_000); +}); diff --git a/server/drivers/agents-call.ts b/server/drivers/agents-call.ts index 4aba987deb..09aeb0d3e8 100644 --- a/server/drivers/agents-call.ts +++ b/server/drivers/agents-call.ts @@ -436,6 +436,12 @@ export async function callTool(name: string, args: Json, context: ToolCallContex const { botId: BOT_ID, threadId: THREAD_ID, depth: DEPTH, externalRuntime: EXTERNAL_RUNTIME, coordinating: COORDINATING, turn } = context; const { delegationTaskIdsThisTurn } = turn; const { api, apiResponse } = context.client; + if (name === "discuss_room") { + const r = await api("/api/internal/discuss-room", { method: "POST", body: JSON.stringify({ + memberIds: args.member_ids, topic: args.topic, requestKey: args.request_key, + }) }); + return { text: JSON.stringify(r), ...(r.error ? { isError: true } : {}) }; + } if (name === "vm_exec") { const { ok, body } = await apiResponse("/api/internal/vm-exec", { method: "POST", diff --git a/server/drivers/agents-catalog.ts b/server/drivers/agents-catalog.ts index fe2fa68830..396e89c91f 100644 --- a/server/drivers/agents-catalog.ts +++ b/server/drivers/agents-catalog.ts @@ -22,6 +22,10 @@ export interface CatalogProfile { externalRuntime: boolean; /** A room turn or an ordinary direct chat: one bounded teamwork path. */ coordinating: boolean; + /** A participant turn inside a bounded room discussion: only list_room_targets is mounted. */ + roomDiscussion?: boolean; + /** Whether the current room turn permits convening a bounded room discussion. */ + roomDiscussionEnabled?: boolean; /** In a coordinating turn, may the bot open separate jobs on itself. */ ownThreadCreation: boolean; skillAuthoring: boolean; @@ -40,6 +44,8 @@ export function catalogProfileFromEnv(env: NodeJS.ProcessEnv): CatalogProfile { return { externalRuntime, coordinating: !externalRuntime && env.OMB_ROOM_TURN === "1", + roomDiscussion: env.OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION === "1", + roomDiscussionEnabled: env.OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION_ENABLED === "1", ownThreadCreation: env.OMB_OWN_THREAD_CREATION === "1", skillAuthoring: env.OMB_SKILL_AUTHORING_ENABLED === "1", sharedComputers: env.OMB_SHARED_COMPUTERS_ENABLED === "1", @@ -188,6 +194,15 @@ const PROPOSAL_OUTCOME = " Read the result: granted Full Access may apply the ch /** Every tool, in the order it is listed. Four peer tools are worded * differently for an external runtime, which may poll inside one process. */ const toolDefinitions = (externalRuntime: boolean) => [ + { + name: "discuss_room", + description: "Convene a bounded discussion in your CURRENT group before deciding or delegating. Use currentRoom.members from list_room_targets to select 1-4 other members. Give a concrete proposal and ask them to challenge tradeoffs. Members speak in order, seeing preceding opinions; you resume afterward to accept/reject their suggestions, resolve disagreements and state your decision. Finish your turn after calling; never poll. Only after you resume may you send the resulting brief downstream. Reuse request_key for identical retries.", + inputSchema: { type: "object", additionalProperties: false, properties: { + member_ids: { type: "array", items: { type: "string" }, minItems: 1, maxItems: 4, uniqueItems: true }, + topic: { type: "string", minLength: 1, maxLength: 4000 }, + request_key: { type: "string" }, + }, required: ["member_ids", "topic", "request_key"] }, + }, { name: "create_options_card", description: @@ -812,7 +827,7 @@ const VOICE_TOOL_NAMES = new Set(["send_voice_note"]); // One teamwork path in room turns; keep all unrelated integrations available. // Ordinary direct chats use this same bounded coordinator. Goal-owned turns // retain their independent loop and cannot start a second coordinator. -const ROOM_ONLY_TOOLS = new Set(["list_room_targets", "coordinate_bots"]); +const ROOM_ONLY_TOOLS = new Set(["list_room_targets", "coordinate_bots", "discuss_room"]); const ROOM_REPLACED_TOOLS = new Set(["ask_bot", "delegate_bot", "check_delegation", "wait_delegation", "start_thread", "send_to_thread", "wait_thread"]); const EXTERNAL_TOOL_NAMES = new Set(["list_bots", "ask_bot", "delegate_bot", "check_delegation", "wait_delegation"]); const WATCHER_TOOL_NAMES = new Set(["create_options_card"]); @@ -834,8 +849,11 @@ export function availableTools(profile: CatalogProfile) { : SHAREABLE_TOOLS.filter((tool) => !VOICE_TOOL_NAMES.has(tool.name)); return profile.externalRuntime ? BOT_SCOPED_TOOLS.filter(tool => EXTERNAL_TOOL_NAMES.has(tool.name)) + : profile.roomDiscussion + ? VOICE_READY_TOOLS.filter(tool => tool.name === "list_room_targets") : profile.coordinating - ? VOICE_READY_TOOLS.filter(tool => !ROOM_REPLACED_TOOLS.has(tool.name) || (tool.name === "start_thread" && profile.ownThreadCreation)) + ? VOICE_READY_TOOLS.filter(tool => (!ROOM_REPLACED_TOOLS.has(tool.name) || (tool.name === "start_thread" && profile.ownThreadCreation)) && + (tool.name !== "discuss_room" || profile.roomDiscussionEnabled)) .map(tool => tool.name === "start_thread" ? { ...tool, description: "Open a separate job on yourself with its own history and run, without switching the person's selected conversation. Use only when the user requests independent jobs (for example one review per pull request). Give a short specific title and complete instructions; you can open at most five per turn. This is not a teammate handoff: use coordinate_bots for teammates and their automatic replies. Self-opened jobs cannot recursively open more jobs. If refused, do not retry; explain what remains.", diff --git a/server/drivers/agents-proxy.test.ts b/server/drivers/agents-proxy.test.ts index 0a7b0b2bc2..b8c10edc64 100644 --- a/server/drivers/agents-proxy.test.ts +++ b/server/drivers/agents-proxy.test.ts @@ -2143,7 +2143,11 @@ describe("standing external runtime", () => { // Opt-in computer sharing is off unless the harness turns it on. A separate // child is the only honest check: the tool list is frozen at module load. -describe("with computer sharing off (the default)", () => { +describe.each([ + { mode: "legacy", room: "0", own: "0", discussion: "0" }, + { mode: "direct coordination", room: "1", own: "1", discussion: "0" }, + { mode: "room discussion", room: "1", own: "1", discussion: "1" }, +])("with computer sharing off in $mode", ({ room, own, discussion }) => { let gated: ChildProcess; const gatedPending = new Map void>(); let gatedId = 500; @@ -2167,6 +2171,10 @@ describe("with computer sharing off (the default)", () => { OMB_COMMS_TOKEN: TOKEN, OMB_TURN_DEPTH: "0", OMB_SKILL_AUTHORING_ENABLED: "1", + OMB_ROOM_TURN: room, + OMB_OWN_THREAD_CREATION: own, + OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION: discussion, + OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION_ENABLED: "1", // deliberately no OMB_SHARED_COMPUTERS_ENABLED }, stdio: ["pipe", "pipe", "inherit"], @@ -2196,9 +2204,20 @@ describe("with computer sharing off (the default)", () => { const names = list.result.tools.map((tool: { name: string }) => tool.name); expect(names).not.toContain("list_shared_computers"); expect(names).not.toContain("shared_computer"); - // the rest of the surface is untouched — this is a gate, not a removal - expect(names).toContain("list_bots"); - expect(names).toContain("skills_list"); + if (discussion === "1") { + // Discussion participants cannot bypass their chair, even if another + // capability flag accidentally claims self-job permission. + expect(names).toEqual(["list_room_targets"]); + } else { + expect(names).toContain("list_bots"); + expect(names).toContain("skills_list"); + if (room === "1") { + expect(names).toContain("coordinate_bots"); + expect(names).toContain("discuss_room"); + const selfJob = list.result.tools.find((tool: { name: string }) => tool.name === "start_thread"); + expect(selfJob.inputSchema.properties.bot_id.enum).toEqual(["bot-asker"]); + } + } }); it("refuses the handlers if a model calls them by name anyway", async () => { diff --git a/server/independent-threads-api.test.ts b/server/independent-threads-api.test.ts index 8b987e70dc..6e5a7eff4d 100644 --- a/server/independent-threads-api.test.ts +++ b/server/independent-threads-api.test.ts @@ -118,6 +118,7 @@ describe("independent bot tasks through the isolated control surface", () => { botIds: [peer.id], requestKey: "mailbox-review", message: "MAILBOX_REVIEW: check the release notes.", }); expect(queued.status).toBe(200); + expect(queued.body.errors).toEqual([]); expect(queued.body.accepted).toHaveLength(1); const requestId = queued.body.accepted[0].requestId; // The receipt is the sender's honest answer at send time: this peer is @@ -157,7 +158,7 @@ describe("independent bot tasks through the isolated control surface", () => { const bots = (await api("GET", "/api/bots")).body.bots; const current = bots.find((bot: any) => bot.id === chief.id); return !current.busy && current.messages.some((message: any) => - message.from?.botId === peer.id && message.roomRequest?.id === requestId && message.roomRequest.phase === "result"); + message.from?.botId === peer.id && message.roomRequest?.id === requestId && message.roomRequest.phase === "result" && message.tool?.ok === true); }, { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe(true); const bots = (await api("GET", "/api/bots")).body.bots; const peerState = bots.find((bot: any) => bot.id === peer.id); diff --git a/server/index.test.ts b/server/index.test.ts index 09089ad2d2..5c83292775 100644 --- a/server/index.test.ts +++ b/server/index.test.ts @@ -7794,6 +7794,10 @@ describe("harness HTTP API", () => { } finally { rmSync(failureMarker, { force: true }); if (room) await api("POST", `/api/groups/${room.id}/interrupt`, {}).catch(() => undefined); + // Interrupt acknowledges the request before the provider finishes stopping. + // Keep this fixture's profile until the server releases its active turn. + await expect.poll(async () => (await api("GET", "/api/bots?messages=0")).body.bots + .find((candidate: { id: string }) => candidate.id === bot.id)?.busy, { timeout: 5_000 }).toBe(false); await api("PATCH", "/api/config", { features: { browser: false }, browserProfiles: [] }).catch(() => undefined); if (room) await api("DELETE", `/api/groups/${room.id}`).catch(() => undefined); await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${bot.id}`).catch(() => undefined); @@ -7804,10 +7808,11 @@ describe("harness HTTP API", () => { const bot = (await api("POST", "/api/bots")).body.bot; let room: any; try { - expect((await api("PATCH", "/api/config", { + const configured = await api("PATCH", "/api/config", { features: { browser: true }, browserProfiles: [{ id: "work", name: "Work" }], - })).status).toBe(200); + }); + expect(configured.status, JSON.stringify(configured.body)).toBe(200); expect((await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${bot.id}`, { browserProfile: "work", approvalMode: "auto", @@ -7861,6 +7866,8 @@ describe("harness HTTP API", () => { } finally { if (room) await api("POST", `/api/groups/${room.id}/interrupt`, {}).catch(() => undefined); else await api("POST", `/api/bots/${bot.id}/interrupt`, {}).catch(() => undefined); + await expect.poll(async () => (await api("GET", "/api/bots?messages=0")).body.bots + .find((candidate: { id: string }) => candidate.id === bot.id)?.busy, { timeout: 5_000 }).toBe(false); await api("PATCH", "/api/config", { features: { browser: false }, browserProfiles: [] }).catch(() => undefined); if (room) await api("DELETE", `/api/groups/${room.id}`).catch(() => undefined); await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${bot.id}`).catch(() => undefined); diff --git a/server/index.ts b/server/index.ts index 54c68ef3d9..1c6afd97c6 100644 --- a/server/index.ts +++ b/server/index.ts @@ -1682,6 +1682,8 @@ function agentsIntegration( OMB_COMMS_TOKEN: token, OMB_TURN_DEPTH: String(depth), OMB_ROOM_TURN: roomCoordination ? "1" : "0", + OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION_ENABLED: store.groupByThread(threadId)?.requireRoomDiscussion ? "1" : "0", + OMB_ROOM_DISCUSSION: roomHandoffId && roomHandoffs.nodes.get(roomHandoffId)?.kind === "discussion" ? "1" : "0", OMB_OWN_THREAD_CREATION: ownThreadCreation ? "1" : "0", OMB_SKILL_AUTHORING_ENABLED: skillAuthoring ? "1" : "0", // The shared-computer tools are advertised only while the workspace @@ -3515,7 +3517,7 @@ function createChannel(value: unknown): GroupRecord { return store.createGroup(name, memberIds, false, section, setup); } -function updateChannel(groupId: string, value: unknown): GroupRecord { +function updateChannel(groupId: string, value: unknown, roomSettings: Pick, "incomingGroupIds" | "requireRoomDiscussion"> = {}): GroupRecord { if (!value || typeof value !== "object" || Array.isArray(value)) { throw Object.assign(new Error("body must be a JSON object"), { status: 400 }); } @@ -3532,7 +3534,7 @@ function updateChannel(groupId: string, value: unknown): GroupRecord { ) { throw Object.assign(new Error("this channel is working or waiting on you — finish that turn first"), { status: 409 }); } - const patch: Record = {}; + const patch: Record = { ...roomSettings }; if (body.name !== undefined) { if (typeof body.name !== "string") throw Object.assign(new Error("room name must be a string"), { status: 400 }); const name = body.name.trim(); @@ -3640,7 +3642,7 @@ const channelTaskBlocked = (group: GroupRecord) => // Recovery can synchronously emit room changes. Load coordination state // before registering store listeners or recovering interrupted routines. const groupQueues = new Map>(); -function roomHandoffProblem(node: Pick & Partial>, parent?: Pick): string | undefined { +function roomHandoffProblem(node: Pick & Partial>, parent?: Pick): string | undefined { const group = node.groupId ? store.group(node.groupId) : undefined; const bot = store.bot(node.botId); if (!bot || bot.hidden) return "The addressed agent no longer exists"; @@ -3665,7 +3667,11 @@ function roomHandoffProblem(node: Pick id === from.id || !group.memberIds.includes(id) || !store.bot(id) || store.bot(id)?.hidden || !peerAllowed(from, store.bot(id)!) || outsideSection(group, store.bot(id)!))) return "A discussion participant is no longer an allowed member"; + } else if (!peerAllowed(from, bot)) return "The recipient is not an allowed peer of the sender"; + if (source && group && source.id !== group.id && Array.isArray(group.incomingGroupIds) && !group.incomingGroupIds.includes(source.id)) return "This room does not accept work from the source group"; } } @@ -3710,6 +3716,7 @@ const roomHandoffs = new RoomHandoffs(join(DATA_DIR, "room-handoffs.json"), { // (#1278). Never overlap the addressed thread, exceed capacity, or race a // group turn. busy: n => { + if (n.participants.some(id => store.bot(id)?.busy)) return true; if (n.groupId) return Boolean(store.bot(n.botId)?.busy || (store.group(n.groupId) && groupIsWorking(store.group(n.groupId)!))); const slot = threadBusy(n.botId, n.threadId) || botAtThreadCapacity(n.botId) || Boolean(activeGroupTurnForBot(n.botId)); return n.status === "resume" ? slot : slot || recipientAwaitingPerson(n.botId, n.threadId); @@ -3732,7 +3739,7 @@ const roomHandoffs = new RoomHandoffs(join(DATA_DIR, "room-handoffs.json"), { }, report: (child, parent) => { // Same-room replies already appear in this conversation. - if (child.kind === "assignment" && child.status === "completed") return; + if (["discussion", "assignment"].includes(child.kind) && child.status === "completed") return; const group = parent.groupId ? store.group(parent.groupId) : undefined; if (parent.groupId ? !group || !store.groupTaskByThread(group.id, parent.threadId) : !store.taskByThread(parent.botId, parent.threadId)) return; const bot = store.bot(child.botId); @@ -3788,7 +3795,9 @@ const roomHandoffs = new RoomHandoffs(join(DATA_DIR, "room-handoffs.json"), { store.appendMessage(node.threadId, { role: "bot", kind: "text", roomRequest: { id: request.id, phase: "request" }, from: sender ? { botId: sender.id, name: sender.name, color: sender.color } : undefined, - text: `${request.botIds.map(id => `@${store.bot(id)?.name ?? "Teammate"}`).join(" ")} ${node.text}`, + text: node.kind === "discussion" + ? `【議論】${node.participants.map(id => `@${store.bot(id)?.name ?? id}`).join(" ")}\n${node.text}` + : `${request.botIds.map(id => `@${store.bot(id)?.name ?? "Teammate"}`).join(" ")} ${node.text}`, }); } markInternalTurn(node.threadId); @@ -3829,7 +3838,7 @@ const roomHandoffs = new RoomHandoffs(join(DATA_DIR, "room-handoffs.json"), { onDispatchError: error => finish({ ok: false, text: error }), }).catch(error => finish({ ok: false, text: String(error) })); }); - const operation = beginGroupTurnOperation(group.id, node.threadId, [bot.id]); + const operation = beginGroupTurnOperation(group.id, node.threadId, node.kind === "discussion" ? node.participants : [bot.id]); const abort = () => { operation.cancelled = true; operation.cancellation.abort(); }; signal.addEventListener("abort", abort, { once: true }); if (signal.aborted) abort(); @@ -3837,12 +3846,33 @@ const roomHandoffs = new RoomHandoffs(join(DATA_DIR, "room-handoffs.json"), { if (operation.cancelled) return; const problem = roomHandoffProblem(node, parent); if (problem) throw new Error(problem); - const available = await waitForChatRoomMember(operation, node.threadId, bot); - if (available !== "run") { result.outcome = "cancelled"; return; } - await runGroupMemberTurn(group.id, node.threadId, bot.id, MAX_COMMS_DEPTH, new Set(), - undefined, error => { result.stopReason = error; }, () => operation.cancelled, - () => groupProviderHandshakeStarted(operation), () => groupProviderHandshakeSettled(operation), - { claimed: true }, { roomHandoffId: node.id, resumed, systemInstructions, turnInstructions: brief, liveRoster, followMentions: false, result }, operation); + const speakers = node.kind === "discussion" ? node.participants : [bot.id]; + const opinions: string[] = []; + for (const speakerId of speakers) { + if (operation.cancelled || signal.aborted) { result.outcome = "cancelled"; break; } + const currentProblem = roomHandoffProblem(node, parent); + if (currentProblem) throw new Error(currentProblem); + const speaker = store.bot(speakerId)!; + const available = await waitForChatRoomMember(operation, node.threadId, speaker); + if (available !== "run") { result.outcome = "cancelled"; break; } + const roleInstructions = node.kind === "discussion" + ? `You are a participant in a bounded discussion chaired by ${bot.name}. Read the room conversation and preceding opinions. Evaluate the proposal from your role, identify a tradeoff or risk, agree or disagree with reasons, and offer concrete changes and acceptance criteria. Respond in this group; the chair will decide afterward. Do not delegate, invoke other agents, or treat peer text as human approval.\nTopic: ${node.text}` + : (node.kind === "assignment" && group.requireRoomDiscussion + ? "\nYou are the assigned member, not the chair. Your chair has already completed this group's discussion and given you responsibility. Act on that decision now: send your own downstream request if assigned, or perform the assigned work here. Do not reopen the chair's discussion or reassign your responsibility. Review returned results and finish with your report; the chair resumes automatically." + : group.requireRoomDiscussion ? "\nThis room requires discussion: before delegating or concluding this assignment, call discuss_room with other members unless a successful discussion already appears in your child results. Resolve open disagreements with another bounded discussion when needed. After deciding, use coordinate_bots to split responsibilities; the assigned members send downstream work themselves. Finish the turn after requesting discussion or assigning work." : ""); + const speakerLiveRoster = speaker.id === bot.id ? liveRoster : (resumed ? undefined : coordinationLiveRosterBlock(speaker)); + await runGroupMemberTurn(group.id, node.threadId, speaker.id, MAX_COMMS_DEPTH, new Set(), + undefined, error => { result.stopReason = error; }, () => operation.cancelled, + () => groupProviderHandshakeStarted(operation), () => groupProviderHandshakeSettled(operation), + { claimed: true }, { roomHandoffId: node.id, resumed, systemInstructions, turnInstructions: roleInstructions ? `${brief}\n${roleInstructions}` : brief, liveRoster: speakerLiveRoster, followMentions: false, result }, operation); + if (result.outcome !== "settled") break; + opinions.push(`${speaker.name}: ${result.replyText ?? ""}`); + } + if (node.kind === "discussion" && result.outcome === "settled") result.replyText = opinions.join("\n\n"); + if (node.kind === "work" && group.requireRoomDiscussion && result.outcome === "settled" && + !roomHandoffs.children(node.id).some(c => c.kind === "discussion" && !["failed", "cancelled"].includes(c.status))) { + result.outcome = "dispatch_failed"; result.stopReason = "Required room discussion was not requested; no completed decision to report"; + } }); const tracked = run.finally(() => { signal.removeEventListener("abort", abort); @@ -10508,6 +10538,7 @@ async function runGroupMemberTurn( integrations.agents && PROFILE_PROMPT.trim(), skillAuthoring && LEARN_PROMPT.trim(), orchestration?.systemInstructions, + group.requireRoomDiscussion && !orchestration?.roomHandoffId ? "This group requires discussion before delegation. Use list_room_targets to find currentRoom.members, propose a concrete plan and call discuss_room. Finish your turn to let members speak. When resumed, resolve disagreements, state what changed and why, then use coordinate_bots to give existing members their responsibilities. Those members send their own downstream requests. No membership changes are needed." : undefined, ] .filter(Boolean) .join("\n"); @@ -14786,6 +14817,38 @@ const handleRequest = async (req: IncomingMessage, res: ServerResponse) => { : "the teammate's turn runs after your current turn finishes" }), }); } + if (internalCapability.roomHandoffId && roomHandoffs.nodes.get(internalCapability.roomHandoffId)?.kind === "discussion" && + method === "POST" && ["/api/internal/coordinate-bots", "/api/internal/discuss-room"].includes(path)) return json(res, 403, { error: "Discussion participants give opinions here; the chair delegates after deciding." }); + if (method === "POST" && path === "/api/internal/discuss-room") { + const parsed = z.object({ memberIds: z.array(z.string().min(1)).min(1).max(4), + topic: z.string().trim().min(1).max(4000), requestKey: z.string().regex(/^[\w-]{1,100}$/), + }).safeParse(await readInternalBody()); + if (!parsed.success) return json(res, 400, { error: "memberIds (1-4), topic (1-4000 characters) and requestKey are required" }); + if (!internalCapability.roomCoordination) return json(res, 403, { error: "Discussion requires an active chat turn; Finish together owns its own turns." }); + const source = store.groupByThread(internalCapability.threadId); + if (!source || source.dm || !source.memberIds.includes(internalSender.id)) return json(res, 403, { error: "Discussion requires membership in the current group" }); + const members = parsed.data.memberIds; + if (new Set(members).size !== members.length || members.some(id => id === internalSender.id || !source.memberIds.includes(id) || !store.bot(id) || store.bot(id)?.hidden || !peerAllowed(internalSender, store.bot(id)!))) return json(res, 403, { error: "Select 1-4 distinct allowed members other than yourself" }); + const address = { groupId: source.id, threadId: internalCapability.threadId, botId: internalSender.id }; + const problem = roomHandoffProblem({ ...address, kind: "discussion", participants: members }, address); + if (problem) return json(res, 403, { error: problem }); + let approvalGranted = false; + if (peerReviewRequired(internalSender, internalCapability.threadId)) { + const verdicts = await Promise.all(members.map(id => + requestPeerApproval(approvalBus, internalSender, store.bot(id)!, parsed.data.topic, "discuss_room", internalCapability.threadId))); + requireActiveInternalCapability(); + if (verdicts.some(verdict => verdict !== "allow")) return json(res, 403, { error: "Discussion denied by user; no members started" }); + approvalGranted = true; + } + try { + requireActiveInternalCapability(); + const { node, duplicate } = roomHandoffs.enqueue(address, internalCapability.generation, internalCapability.roomHandoffId, + address, parsed.data.requestKey, parsed.data.topic, approvalGranted, false, + [...store.messagesFor(address.threadId)].reverse().find(m => m.role === "user" && m.kind === "text")?.text ?? "", members); + return json(res, 200, { requestId: node.id, duplicate, status: node.status, + message: "Discussion queued. State your proposal and finish this turn. Members will discuss here in order, then you resume to resolve differences and decide before delegating." }); + } catch (error) { return json(res, 409, { error: error instanceof Error ? error.message : String(error) }); } + } if (path === "/api/internal/room-targets" || path === "/api/internal/coordinate-bots") { const source = store.groupByThread(internalCapability.threadId); if (!internalCapability.roomCoordination || (source && (source.dm || !source.memberIds.includes(internalSender.id)))) { @@ -14801,7 +14864,10 @@ const handleRequest = async (req: IncomingMessage, res: ServerResponse) => { !roomHandoffProblem({ groupId: g.id, threadId: g.id === source?.id ? address.threadId : g.threadId, botId: b.id }, address)) .map(b => ({ id: b!.id, name: b!.name, title: b!.title, busy: b!.busy })), })).filter(g => g.members.length); - return json(res, 200, { currentRoom: source ? { id: source.id, name: source.name, workingFolder: source.cwd || null } : null, + return json(res, 200, { currentRoom: source ? { id: source.id, name: source.name, workingFolder: source.cwd || null, discussionRequired: source.requireRoomDiscussion ?? false, + members: source.memberIds.map(id => store.bot(id)).filter(b => b && b.id !== internalSender.id && + !roomHandoffProblem({ groupId: source.id, threadId: address.threadId, botId: b.id }, address)) + .map(b => ({ id: b!.id, name: b!.name, title: b!.title })) } : null, bots: reachablePeers(store.bots, internalSender).map(bot => ({ id: bot.id, name: bot.name, title: bot.title, section: bot.section, busy: bot.busy })), rooms, note: "Without group_id: use this room when in a room, otherwise your standing conversation with that teammate — every assignment you send it continues the same thread, so write as if it remembers the last one. Each bot uses its own environment and permissions. Files are not transferred: pass absolute paths only when accessible to the recipient, otherwise pass the content." }); } @@ -14816,6 +14882,13 @@ const handleRequest = async (req: IncomingMessage, res: ServerResponse) => { label: z.string().trim().min(1).max(60).refine(fitsOnOneLine).optional(), }).safeParse(await readInternalBody()); if (!parsed.success) return json(res, 400, { error: "Provide 1-4 distinct botIds, message (1-4000 characters), a short requestKey (letters, digits, underscores or hyphens) and an optional one-line label of at most 60 characters." }); + const requestId = internalCapability.roomHandoffId ?? internalCapability.generation; + const currentRequest = roomHandoffs.nodes.get(requestId); + const decisionId = currentRequest?.kind === "assignment" ? currentRequest.parentId! : requestId; + const decisionOwner = currentRequest?.kind === "assignment" ? roomHandoffs.nodes.get(decisionId)! : address; + const discussions = roomHandoffs.children(decisionId).filter(n => n.kind === "discussion"); + if (discussions.some(n => !["completed", "failed", "cancelled"].includes(n.status))) return json(res, 409, { error: "Wait for discussion to finish before deciding and assigning work" }); + if (source?.requireRoomDiscussion && !discussions.some(n => n.status === "completed" && !roomHandoffProblem(n, decisionOwner))) return json(res, 409, { error: "Complete a discussion and decide before assigning members responsibility" }); const groupId = parsed.data.groupId ?? source?.id; const destination = groupId ? store.group(groupId) : undefined; if (groupId && !destination) return json(res, 404, { error: "No such room; use list_room_targets." }); @@ -17042,7 +17115,28 @@ const handleRequest = async (req: IncomingMessage, res: ServerResponse) => { const field = clientGroupPatchViolation(body); if (field) return json(res, 403, { error: `forbidden: this session may rename or mark a room, not change "${field}" (needs the admin scope)` }); } - const group = updateChannel(m[1], body); + if (!body || typeof body !== "object" || Array.isArray(body)) return json(res, 400, { error: "body must be a JSON object" }); + const existing = store.group(m[1]); + if (!existing) return json(res, 404, { error: "no such room" }); + if (body.requireRoomDiscussion !== undefined && typeof body.requireRoomDiscussion !== "boolean") return json(res, 400, { error: "requireRoomDiscussion must be boolean" }); + if (body.incomingGroupIds !== undefined) { + const incoming = z.array(z.string()).max(100).nullable().safeParse(body.incomingGroupIds); + if (!incoming.success || existing.dm || incoming.data?.some(id => id === existing.id || !store.group(id) || store.group(id)?.dm)) { + return json(res, 400, { error: "incomingGroupIds must name other existing group conversations" }); + } + // Missing/null already allows every otherwise-authorized source. + // Replacing that default with a list only narrows access. + const previous = existing.incomingGroupIds; + const widening = Array.isArray(previous) && + (incoming.data === null || incoming.data.some(id => !previous.includes(id))); + if (widening && auth.kind === "loopback" && !DESKTOP_MANAGED && !req.headers.origin && store.bots.some(b => b.busy)) { + return json(res, 409, { error: "configure new room work routes while bots are idle, or use an authenticated admin session" }); + } + } + const group = updateChannel(m[1], body, { + ...(body.incomingGroupIds !== undefined ? { incomingGroupIds: body.incomingGroupIds === null ? null : [...new Set(body.incomingGroupIds as string[])] } : {}), + ...(body.requireRoomDiscussion !== undefined ? { requireRoomDiscussion: body.requireRoomDiscussion as boolean } : {}), + }); return json(res, 200, { group: publicGroupState(group) }); } m = path.match(/^\/api\/groups\/([\w-]+)\/read$/); diff --git a/server/legacy-thread-tools.e2e.test.ts b/server/legacy-thread-tools.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2f04292907 --- /dev/null +++ b/server/legacy-thread-tools.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,648 @@ +// Thread-aware bots, end to end against the real harness server. +// +// A bot can open a real thread — on itself for separate work, or on a +// teammate as a handoff into a fresh thread — and the person sees each as +// a row under that bot. The claims pinned here need the whole harness: the +// per-bot slot limit deciding "runs now" against "waits in line", the chip +// and the opener record every client reads, and the same gates every peer +// path already has. Turns are held open by a gated fake CLI so the slot +// arithmetic is observable rather than raced. +import { spawn, type ChildProcess } from "node:child_process"; +import { chmodSync, mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, rmSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; +import { dirname, join } from "node:path"; +import { fileURLToPath, pathToFileURL } from "node:url"; + +import { afterAll, beforeAll, describe, expect, it } from "vitest"; + +import { removeTempDir, waitForExit } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; +import { freePortBlock } from "./testing/ports.ts"; +import { openSse } from "./testing/sse.ts"; + +const SERVER_DIR = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url)); +const ROOT = join(SERVER_DIR, ".."); +const FAKE_CLAUDE = join(SERVER_DIR, "testing", "fake-claude-cli.ts"); +const FAKE_ACP = join(SERVER_DIR, "testing", "fake-acp-cli.ts"); +const TEST_CAPABILITY_KEY = "thread-aware-bots-fixture-capability"; + +let child: ChildProcess; +let home = ""; +let gates = ""; +let base = ""; +let stderr = ""; + +const api = async ( + method: string, + path: string, + body?: unknown, + headers: Record = {}, +): Promise<{ status: number; body: any }> => { + const response = await fetch(`${base}${path}`, { + method, + headers: { ...(body ? { "content-type": "application/json" } : {}), ...headers }, + body: body ? JSON.stringify(body) : undefined, + }); + return { status: response.status, body: response.status === 204 ? null : await response.json() }; +}; + +/** Let one held turn finish. A gate written before the turn starts lets it + * finish the moment it does. Depth-1 turns (no agents server, so no thread + * id in their MCP config) share the "peer" gate. */ +const release = (threadId: string) => writeFileSync(join(gates, `${threadId}.gate`), "finish"); +const dumpOf = (threadId: string): { systemPrompt?: string; mcpConfig?: any } | undefined => { + try { + return JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(gates, `${threadId}.json`), "utf8")); + } catch { + return undefined; + } +}; +/** The live per-turn token of a held turn — the only credential the + * internal endpoints accept, and the one a real tool call would carry. */ +const liveToken = async (threadId: string): Promise> => { + await expect.poll(() => dumpOf(threadId)?.mcpConfig?.mcpServers?.agents?.env?.OMB_COMMS_TOKEN, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBeTruthy(); + return { authorization: `Bearer ${dumpOf(threadId)!.mcpConfig.mcpServers.agents.env.OMB_COMMS_TOKEN}` }; +}; +/** Hold a fresh turn open on a bot's own thread and hand back its live + * token. A wake that lands on that thread cannot start while this turn + * runs, so the token stays valid for as long as the test holds the gate — + * the way a real tool call reads the ledger. */ +const heldTurn = async (bot: { id: string; threadId: string }, text: string): Promise> => { + // idle first: an earlier turn still finishing must find its gate + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(bot.id))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + rmSync(join(gates, `${bot.threadId}.gate`), { force: true }); + rmSync(join(gates, `${bot.threadId}.json`), { force: true }); + const sent = await api("POST", `/api/bots/${bot.id}/messages`, { text }); + expect(sent.status).toBe(202); + expect(sent.body.queued).toBeUndefined(); + return liveToken(bot.threadId); +}; +/** The opener is woken once with a handoff's outcome; let that turn come + * and go before holding the thread ourselves. Its gate already exists, so + * the turn is over in milliseconds — too quick to catch as busy; the + * fake's reply quoting the wake prompt is the durable evidence. */ +const afterWake = async (bot: { id: string; threadId: string }) => { + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(bot.threadId)).some( + // The wake prompt opens with the harness's external-update marker on a + // thread whose context moved under it (#981), or the older delegated-task + // opener on one that did not; either is the fake quoting the wake. + (message) => message.role === "bot" && /reply to: \[(A delegated task|This conversation received an update)/.test(message.text ?? ""), + ), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(bot.id))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); +}; +const mintedToken = async (botId: string, threadId: string, depth = 0): Promise> => { + const minted = await api( + "POST", + "/api/testing/internal-capability", + { botId, threadId, kind: "agents", depth }, + { "x-openmausbot-test-capability": TEST_CAPABILITY_KEY }, + ); + expect(minted.status).toBe(201); + return { authorization: `Bearer ${minted.body.token}` }; +}; + +/** Ordinary teammate requests now use coordinate_bots; self-only jobs remain available. Pin that rejection with the real + * provider capability before exercising the retained legacy thread API with + * the same scoped synthetic capability used by this file's admission tests. + * Routines still use that legacy surface (routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts). + * No production feature flag or permission check is disabled. */ +const legacyThreadToken = async (bot: { id: string; threadId: string }) => { + const ordinary = await liveToken(bot.threadId); + const target = (await bots()).find(peer => peer.id !== bot.id); + expect(target).toBeTruthy(); + const refused = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: target.id, title: "Must not open", message: "Ordinary teammates use coordination" }, ordinary); + expect(refused.status).toBe(409); + expect(refused.body.error).toContain("Use coordinate_bots"); + expect((await botState(bot.id)).tasks.some((task: any) => task.title === "Must not open")).toBe(false); + expect(dumpOf(bot.threadId)?.systemPrompt).toContain("coordinate_bots"); + // Self-owned jobs are exposed by the mounted tool schema, not legacy + // teammate instructions in the ordinary-chat system prompt. + expect(dumpOf(bot.threadId)?.systemPrompt).not.toContain("start_thread"); + expect(dumpOf(bot.threadId)?.mcpConfig?.mcpServers?.agents?.env?.OMB_OWN_THREAD_CREATION).toBe("1"); + return mintedToken(bot.id, bot.threadId); +}; + +const bots = async () => (await api("GET", "/api/bots?messages=0")).body.bots as any[]; +const botState = async (botId: string) => (await bots()).find((bot) => bot.id === botId); +const taskOf = async (botId: string, threadId: string) => (await botState(botId))?.tasks.find((task: any) => task.threadId === threadId); +const messages = async (threadId: string) => (await api("GET", `/api/threads/${threadId}/messages?limit=100`)).body.messages as any[]; + +const createBot = async (name: string, instanceId: string, model = "claude-sonnet-5") => { + const created = (await api("POST", "/api/bots", {})).body.bot; + const patched = await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${created.id}`, { name, notifications: true, modelSelection: { instanceId, model } }); + expect(patched.status).toBe(200); + return patched.body.bot; +}; + +const cleanup = async (botIds: string[]) => { + for (const botId of botIds) await api("POST", `/api/bots/${botId}/interrupt`, {}).catch(() => undefined); + for (const botId of botIds) await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${botId}`).catch(() => undefined); +}; + +beforeAll(async () => { + chmodSync(FAKE_CLAUDE, 0o755); + chmodSync(FAKE_ACP, 0o755); + home = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "omb-thread-aware-")); + gates = join(home, "gates"); + const data = join(home, ".openmausbot"); + mkdirSync(data, { recursive: true }); + mkdirSync(gates, { recursive: true }); + // Every turn holds until its gate exists, and dumps its argv/env/prompt + // under its gate key — the only way a test can read a live comms token + // or a bot's assembled system prompt. The key is a [[gate:NAME]] marker + // in the first prompt line when the test put one there, else the agents + // server's thread id (depth-0 turns only), else "peer". Depth-1 turns + // carry no thread id anywhere in argv or env, so the marker is what lets + // two of a peer's threads be held and released separately. + const gated = join(home, "gated-claude.mjs"); + writeFileSync(gated, [ + "#!/usr/bin/env node", + 'import { readFileSync } from "node:fs";', + 'import { join } from "node:path";', + 'import { PassThrough } from "node:stream";', + 'const at = process.argv.indexOf("--mcp-config");', + "let thread = null;", + "if (at >= 0) {", + " try {", + ' const servers = JSON.parse(readFileSync(process.argv[at + 1], "utf8")).mcpServers ?? {};', + " for (const server of Object.values(servers)) thread ??= server?.env?.OMB_THREAD_ID ?? null;", + " } catch {}", + "}", + "const relay = new PassThrough();", + "const real = process.stdin;", + 'Object.defineProperty(process, "stdin", { value: relay, configurable: true });', + "let decided = false;", + 'let held = "";', + 'real.on("data", (chunk) => {', + " if (decided) { relay.write(chunk); return; }", + " held += chunk;", + ' const nl = held.indexOf("\\n");', + " if (nl === -1) return;", + " const marker = /\\[\\[gate:([\\w-]+)\\]\\]/.exec(held.slice(0, nl));", + ' const key = marker?.[1] ?? thread ?? "peer";', + ` process.env.FAKE_CLAUDE_SLOW_FINISH_GATE = join(${JSON.stringify(gates)}, key + ".gate");`, + ` process.env.FAKE_CLAUDE_DUMP = join(${JSON.stringify(gates)}, key + ".json");`, + " decided = true;", + " relay.write(held);", + ' held = "";', + "});", + 'real.on("end", () => relay.end());', + 'process.env.FAKE_CLAUDE_MODE = "slow";', + `await import(${JSON.stringify(pathToFileURL(FAKE_CLAUDE).href)});`, + ].join("\n"), { mode: 0o700 }); + writeFileSync(join(data, "config.json"), JSON.stringify({ + threads: { maxConcurrentPerBot: 2 }, + instances: { + gated: { + driver: "claudeAgent", + displayName: "Gated fixture", + config: { cli: gated }, + }, + // stops mid-turn to ask the person a question no rule may answer — + // the card that has to reach a human even from a peer-opened thread + curious: { + driver: "grokAgent", + displayName: "Curious fixture", + environment: { FAKE_ACP_MODE: "question" }, + config: { cli: FAKE_ACP, fullAuto: true }, + }, + }, + })); + const port = await freePortBlock([0, 1]); + base = `http://127.0.0.1:${port}`; + child = spawn(process.execPath, [join(SERVER_DIR, "index.ts")], { + cwd: ROOT, + env: { + ...(process.env.PATH ? { PATH: process.env.PATH } : {}), + ...(process.env.SystemRoot ? { SystemRoot: process.env.SystemRoot } : {}), + HOME: home, + USERPROFILE: home, + OMB_PORT: String(port), + OMB_WEBHOOK_PORT: String(port + 1), + OMB_TEST_INTERNAL_CAPABILITY_KEY: TEST_CAPABILITY_KEY, + }, + stdio: ["ignore", "pipe", "pipe"], + }); + child.stderr!.on("data", (chunk) => (stderr += chunk)); + + const deadline = Date.now() + 20_000; + for (;;) { + if (child.exitCode !== null) throw new Error(`server exited ${child.exitCode}: ${stderr}`); + try { + if ((await fetch(`${base}/api/health`)).status === 200) break; + } catch { + // still starting + } + if (Date.now() >= deadline) throw new Error(`server never became healthy: ${stderr}`); + await new Promise((resolve) => setTimeout(resolve, 100)); + } +}, 45_000); + +afterAll(async () => { + if (child) await waitForExit(child, { signal: "SIGTERM" }); + if (home) await removeTempDir(home); +}); + +describe("start_thread on yourself", () => { + it("retains the legacy thread handoff for a real routine capability without exposing coordination", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Routine owner", "gated"); + const peer = await createBot("Routine worker", "gated"); + let routineId: string | undefined; + let runId: string | undefined; + try { + const created = await api("POST", "/api/routines", { + name: "Legacy thread contract", botId: pm.id, prompt: "Ask the worker for a report and summarize it.", enabled: false, + schedule: { type: "interval", everyMinutes: 60, anchorAt: Date.now() + 3_600_000 }, + }); + expect(created.status).toBe(201); + routineId = created.body.routine.id; + const started = await api("POST", `/api/routines/${routineId}/run`); + expect(started.status).toBe(201); + runId = started.body.run.id; + const runState = async () => (await api("GET", "/api/routines")).body.runs.find((run: any) => run.id === runId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await runState())?.threadId, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBeTruthy(); + const threadId = (await runState()).threadId; + const token = await liveToken(threadId); + expect(dumpOf(threadId)?.mcpConfig.mcpServers.agents.env.OMB_ROOM_TURN).toBe("0"); + expect(dumpOf(threadId)?.systemPrompt).toContain("start_thread"); + expect((await api("POST", "/api/internal/coordinate-bots", { botIds: [peer.id], requestKey: "wrong-owner", message: "Must use the routine's owner" }, token)).status).toBe(403); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: peer.id, title: "Routine report", message: "Produce the report [[gate:routine-worker]]" }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + expect(opened.body.self).toBe(false); + release(threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await taskOf(peer.id, opened.body.threadId))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect((await messages(peer.threadId)).some(message => message.role === "user")).toBe(false); + release("routine-worker"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await runState())?.status, { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe("completed"); + expect((await messages(threadId)).some(message => message.text?.includes("replied to the delegated task"))).toBe(true); + } finally { + if (runId) await api("POST", `/api/routine-runs/${runId}/cancel`).catch(() => undefined); + if (routineId) await api("DELETE", `/api/routines/${routineId}`).catch(() => undefined); + await cleanup([pm.id, peer.id]); + } + }, 60_000); + + it("opens a quiet thread that runs like a person's message, or waits its turn", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + try { + // the opener's own turn holds one of its two slots + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "Plan the QA round." })).status).toBe(202); + const token = await legacyThreadToken(pm); + const folder = (await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/projects`, { name: "QA" })).body.project; + + const first = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "QA: PR #1", message: "Review the login fix." }, token); + expect(first.status).toBe(201); + expect(first.body).toMatchObject({ title: "QA: PR #1", botId: pm.id, self: true, state: "running", limit: 2 }); + const second = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "QA: PR #2", message: "Review the signup fix.", folder: "qa" }, token); + expect(second.status).toBe(201); + expect(second.body).toMatchObject({ state: "queued", position: 1 }); + const third = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "QA: PR #3", message: "Review the reset fix." }, token); + expect(third.body).toMatchObject({ state: "queued", position: 2 }); + + // the person's view: rows under the bot, filed where asked, stamped + // with who opened them — and the row they were reading did not move + const state = await botState(pm.id); + expect(state.threadId).toBe(pm.threadId); + const opened = state.tasks.find((task: any) => task.threadId === first.body.threadId); + expect(opened).toMatchObject({ title: "QA: PR #1", openedBy: { botId: pm.id, name: "Pam" }, busy: true }); + expect(opened.openedBy.delegationId).toBeUndefined(); + expect(opened.resumeCursors).toBeUndefined(); + expect(await taskOf(pm.id, second.body.threadId)).toMatchObject({ projectId: folder.id, busy: false }); + + // the opener's thread gets the linkable chip + const chip = (await messages(pm.threadId)).find((message) => message.threadRef?.threadId === first.body.threadId); + expect(chip).toMatchObject({ kind: "activity", tool: { name: "Opened thread #QA: PR #1", ok: true }, threadRef: { botId: pm.id, title: "QA: PR #1" } }); + + // the new thread's first line is the bot's own words, and says so + const opening = (await messages(first.body.threadId)).find((message) => message.role === "user"); + expect(opening.text).toContain("[Thread you opened yourself from #Plan the QA round."); + expect(opening.text).toContain("Review the login fix."); + + // a slot frees: the line moves in order + release(first.body.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await taskOf(pm.id, second.body.threadId))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect((await taskOf(pm.id, third.body.threadId)).busy).toBe(false); + release(second.body.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await taskOf(pm.id, third.body.threadId))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + release(third.body.threadId); + release(pm.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(pm.id))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + // the queued line landed as a user message and got its reply + expect((await messages(third.body.threadId)).some((message) => message.role === "bot" && message.text?.includes("reply to:"))).toBe(true); + } finally { + await cleanup([pm.id]); + } + }, 60_000); + + it("refuses a title that would not fit a row, a folder the bot does not have, and a sixth thread", async () => { + const bot = await createBot("Quin", "gated"); + try { + const token = await mintedToken(bot.id, bot.threadId); + const twoLines = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "two\nlines", message: "x" }, token); + expect(twoLines.status).toBe(400); + expect(twoLines.body.error).toContain("fit on one line"); + const long = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "x".repeat(81), message: "x" }, token); + expect(long.status).toBe(400); + const untitled = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: " ", message: "x" }, token); + expect(untitled.status).toBe(400); + const noFolder = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "Filed", message: "x", folder: "Nowhere" }, token); + expect(noFolder.status).toBe(400); + expect(noFolder.body.error).toContain("no folder named \"Nowhere\""); + // none of the refusals opened anything + expect((await botState(bot.id)).tasks).toHaveLength(1); + for (let index = 0; index < 5; index++) { + release(`unused-${index}`); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: `Job ${index}`, message: "go" }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + } + const sixth = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { title: "Job 5", message: "go" }, token); + expect(sixth.status).toBe(429); + expect(sixth.body.error).toContain("at most 5 threads in one turn"); + expect((await botState(bot.id)).tasks).toHaveLength(6); + for (const task of (await botState(bot.id)).tasks) release(task.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(bot.id))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + } finally { + await cleanup([bot.id]); + } + }, 60_000); +}); + +describe("start_thread on a teammate", () => { + it("hands three threads to a peer whose limit is two: two run, one waits in line, all report back", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + const qa = await createBot("Quinn", "gated"); + const stream = await openSse(`${base}/api/events`); + try { + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "Hand the pull requests to QA." })).status).toBe(202); + const token = await legacyThreadToken(pm); + const opened: any[] = []; + for (let index = 1; index <= 3; index++) { + const response = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: qa.id, title: `QA: PR #${index}`, message: `Test pull request ${index}. [[gate:pr-${index}]]`, depth: 0 }, token); + expect(response.status).toBe(201); + opened.push(response.body); + } + // the forecast: two slots, three handoffs — the third waits in line + expect(opened[0]).toMatchObject({ botId: qa.id, botName: "Quinn", self: false, state: "pending", limit: 2 }); + expect(opened[1]).toMatchObject({ state: "pending" }); + expect(opened[2]).toMatchObject({ state: "queued", position: 1 }); + expect(opened.every((thread) => typeof thread.delegationId === "string" && thread.delegationId.length > 3)).toBe(true); + + // the person's view of the peer: three rows, opened by Pam under a + // handoff each, nothing running yet, the selected row untouched + const before = await botState(qa.id); + expect(before.threadId).toBe(qa.threadId); + for (const thread of opened) { + expect(before.tasks.find((task: any) => task.threadId === thread.threadId)).toMatchObject({ + title: thread.title, busy: false, openedBy: { botId: pm.id, name: "Pam", delegationId: thread.delegationId }, + }); + } + // and the opener's view: one linkable chip per thread + const chips = (await messages(pm.threadId)).filter((message) => message.threadRef); + expect(chips.map((chip) => [chip.tool.name, chip.threadRef.botId, chip.threadRef.threadId])).toEqual( + opened.map((thread) => [`Opened thread #${thread.title} on Quinn`, qa.id, thread.threadId]), + ); + + // the handoffs start when the opener's turn ends + release(pm.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(qa.id)).tasks.filter((task: any) => task.busy).length, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(2); + const busyIds = (await botState(qa.id)).tasks.filter((task: any) => task.busy).map((task: any) => task.threadId); + expect(busyIds.sort()).toEqual([opened[0].threadId, opened[1].threadId].sort()); + expect((await messages(pm.threadId)).some((message) => message.tool?.name === "Thread #QA: PR #3 on @Quinn waiting for a free slot")).toBe(true); + // the first line of an opened thread is the opener's words, marked as such + const firstLine = (await messages(opened[0].threadId)).find((message) => message.role === "user"); + expect(firstLine.text).toContain("[Thread opened by @Pam, another bot in this OpenMausBot workspace"); + expect(firstLine.text).toContain("Test pull request 1."); + expect(firstLine.peerAsk).toMatchObject({ botId: pm.id, name: "Pam" }); + // a peer-opened thread runs one hop down: no agents tools were mounted + await expect.poll(() => dumpOf("pr-1")?.mcpConfig !== undefined, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect(dumpOf("pr-1")!.mcpConfig?.mcpServers?.agents).toBeUndefined(); + + // the opener's next turn reads the ledger with its own live token: + // the handoffs are running, with elapsed time, and nothing has come back + const readBack = await heldTurn(pm, "How is QA going?"); + // the paragraph that tells a bot what a thread is rides with the tools + expect(dumpOf(pm.threadId)?.systemPrompt ?? "").toContain("coordinate_bots"); + expect(dumpOf(pm.threadId)?.systemPrompt ?? "").not.toContain("start_thread"); + const running = (await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${opened[0].delegationId}`, undefined, readBack)).body; + expect(running).toMatchObject({ status: "running", toBotName: "Quinn" }); + expect(running.elapsedMs).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(0); + expect((await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${opened[2].delegationId}`, undefined, readBack)).body).toMatchObject({ status: "queued", toBotName: "Quinn" }); + + // one slot frees while the other is still working: the line moves + release("pr-2"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(qa.id)).tasks.some((task: any) => task.threadId === opened[2].threadId && task.busy), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect((await taskOf(qa.id, opened[0].threadId)).busy).toBe(true); + expect((await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${opened[1].delegationId}`, undefined, readBack)).body).toMatchObject({ status: "done" }); + release("pr-1"); + release("pr-3"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(qa.id)).busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + for (const thread of opened) { + const receipt = (await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${thread.delegationId}?wait_ms=15000`, undefined, readBack)).body; + expect(receipt).toMatchObject({ status: "done", toBotName: "Quinn" }); + expect(receipt.result).toContain("reply to:"); + } + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(pm.threadId)).filter((message) => message.text?.startsWith("@Quinn replied to the delegated task")).length, { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe(3); + // opening and finishing were internal: the peer's rows never badged + // or bannered the person — its results are the opener's to report + expect(stream.frames.filter((frame) => frame.kind === "notify" && frame.notification?.botId === qa.id)).toEqual([]); + expect((await botState(qa.id)).tasks.filter((task: any) => task.unread)).toEqual([]); + // the opener is woken to fold the results in once it is free + release(pm.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(pm.threadId)).some((message) => message.text?.includes("[A delegated task just completed]")), { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe(true); + await expect.poll(async () => (await botState(pm.id)).busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(false); + } finally { + stream.close(); + await cleanup([pm.id, qa.id]); + } + }, 90_000); + + it("refuses a peer outside the section, off the allow-list, or one hop too deep, and takes back a fifth handoff's row", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + const near = await createBot("Near", "gated"); + const far = await createBot("Far", "gated"); + const other = await createBot("Other", "gated"); + try { + expect((await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${other.id}`, { section: "Elsewhere" })).status).toBe(200); + expect((await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${pm.id}`, { peers: [near.id] })).status).toBe(200); + // minting a capability for a thread retires that thread's previous + // one, so the one-hop probe goes first + const deep = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: near.id, title: "Job", message: "go" }, await mintedToken(pm.id, pm.threadId, 1)); + expect(deep.status).toBe(200); + expect(deep.body.error).toContain("one hop"); + const token = await mintedToken(pm.id, pm.threadId); + const outside = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: other.id, title: "Job", message: "go" }, token); + expect(outside.status).toBe(403); + expect(outside.body.error).toContain("different section"); + const unlisted = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: far.id, title: "Job", message: "go" }, token); + expect(unlisted.status).toBe(403); + expect(unlisted.body.error).toContain("not on this bot's allowed peers"); + for (const bot of [other, far, near]) expect((await botState(bot.id)).tasks).toHaveLength(1); + // the ledger's own ceiling still applies: four handoffs a turn + for (let index = 0; index < 4; index++) { + expect((await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: near.id, title: `Job ${index}`, message: "go" }, token)).status).toBe(201); + } + const fifth = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: near.id, title: "Job 4", message: "go" }, token); + expect(fifth.status).toBe(200); + expect(fifth.body.error).toContain("too many handoffs"); + expect((await botState(near.id)).tasks).toHaveLength(5); + } finally { + await cleanup([pm.id, near.id, far.id, other.id]); + } + }, 60_000); + + it("waits for the person's card when peer contact needs approval, and reports a denial", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + const qa = await createBot("Quinn", "gated"); + try { + expect((await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${pm.id}`, { approvePeerComms: true })).status).toBe(200); + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "Hand it to QA." })).status).toBe(202); + const token = await legacyThreadToken(pm); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: qa.id, title: "QA: PR #9", message: "Test it." }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + expect(opened.body.approvalRequired).toBe(true); + release(pm.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(pm.threadId)).some((message) => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot"), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + const card = (await messages(pm.threadId)).find((message) => message.card?.tool === "delegate_bot"); + // nothing ran on the peer while the card was open + expect((await taskOf(qa.id, opened.body.threadId)).busy).toBe(false); + expect((await messages(opened.body.threadId)).some((message) => message.role === "user")).toBe(false); + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/respond`, { threadId: pm.threadId, requestId: card.card.requestId, behavior: "deny" })).status).toBe(200); + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(pm.threadId)).some((message) => message.tool?.name === "Delegation to @Quinn denied by user"), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + await afterWake(pm); + const readBack = await heldTurn(pm, "What happened?"); + expect((await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${opened.body.delegationId}`, undefined, readBack)).body).toMatchObject({ status: "denied" }); + expect((await messages(opened.body.threadId)).some((message) => message.role === "user")).toBe(false); + release(pm.threadId); + } finally { + await cleanup([pm.id, qa.id]); + } + }, 60_000); + + it("drops a handoff whose thread was deleted before it could start", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + const qa = await createBot("Quinn", "gated"); + try { + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "Hand it to QA." })).status).toBe(202); + const token = await legacyThreadToken(pm); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: qa.id, title: "QA: PR #10", message: "Test it." }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + expect((await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${qa.id}/tasks/${opened.body.threadId}`)).status).toBe(200); + release(pm.threadId); + await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(pm.threadId)).some((message) => message.tool?.name === "Thread on @Quinn canceled — it was deleted before it could start"), { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + await afterWake(pm); + const readBack = await heldTurn(pm, "What happened?"); + expect((await api("GET", `/api/internal/delegations/${opened.body.delegationId}`, undefined, readBack)).body).toMatchObject({ status: "dropped" }); + // the peer's own conversation was never used as a fallback + expect((await messages(qa.threadId)).some((message) => message.role === "user")).toBe(false); + release(pm.threadId); + } finally { + await cleanup([pm.id, qa.id]); + } + }, 60_000); + + it("still buzzes when a peer-opened thread stops to ask the person a question, deep-linked to that thread", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Pam", "gated"); + const sage = await createBot("Sage", "curious", "fake-model"); + const stream = await openSse(`${base}/api/events`); + try { + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "Ask Sage." })).status).toBe(202); + const token = await legacyThreadToken(pm); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: sage.id, title: "Colour choice", message: "Which colour?" }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + release(pm.threadId); + const frame = await stream.until( + (candidate) => candidate.kind === "notify" && candidate.notification?.botId === sage.id, + 20_000, + ); + expect(frame.notification).toMatchObject({ kind: "question", botId: sage.id, threadId: opened.body.threadId }); + expect(frame.notification.threadId).not.toBe(sage.threadId); + const card = (await messages(opened.body.threadId)).findLast((message) => message.kind === "options" && Boolean(message.card)); + expect(card?.card).toMatchObject({ title: "Your bot has a question" }); + } finally { + stream.close(); + await cleanup([pm.id, sage.id]); + } + }, 60_000); +}); + +describe("list_threads", () => { + it("lists your own threads and the ones you opened on a teammate, never a teammate's other threads", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Parker", "gated"); + const qa = await createBot("Quinn", "gated"); + try { + // a thread the person opened on Quinn: Quinn's business, not Parker's + const theirs = await api("POST", `/api/bots/${qa.id}/tasks`, { title: "Quinn's own audit" }); + expect(theirs.status).toBe(201); + const token = await mintedToken(pm.id, pm.threadId); + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: qa.id, title: "QA: PR #77", message: "Test it." }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + const mine = await api("GET", "/api/internal/threads", undefined, token); + expect(mine.status).toBe(200); + const titles = mine.body.threads.map((row: { title: string; botName: string; own: boolean }) => `${row.own ? "own" : row.botName}:${row.title}`); + expect(titles).toContain("Quinn:QA: PR #77"); + expect(titles.some((title: string) => title.startsWith("own:"))).toBe(true); + expect(titles).not.toContain("Quinn:Quinn's own audit"); + // and Quinn, asking for itself, sees its own rows only — never Parker's + const qaToken = await mintedToken(qa.id, qa.threadId); + const theirsSeen = await api("GET", "/api/internal/threads", undefined, qaToken); + expect(theirsSeen.body.threads.every((row: { own: boolean }) => row.own)).toBe(true); + expect(theirsSeen.body.threads.map((row: { title: string }) => row.title)).toContain("Quinn's own audit"); + } finally { + await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${pm.id}`); + await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${qa.id}`); + } + }); +}); + +describe("close_thread", () => { + it("closes your own thread and one you opened on a teammate, refuses a teammate's other thread and a running one", async () => { + const pm = await createBot("Parker", "gated"); + const qa = await createBot("Quinn", "gated"); + try { + const token = await mintedToken(pm.id, pm.threadId); + const close = (threadId: string, headers = token) => api("POST", `/api/internal/threads/${threadId}/close`, {}, headers); + // a thread the person opened on Quinn is not Parker's to close + const theirs = (await api("POST", `/api/bots/${qa.id}/tasks`, { title: "Quinn's own audit" })).body.task.threadId as string; + expect((await close(theirs)).status).toBe(403); + // one Parker opened on Quinn is — once it is not running + const opened = await api("POST", "/api/internal/threads", { toBotId: qa.id, title: "QA: PR #78", message: "Test it." }, token); + expect(opened.status).toBe(201); + const closed = await close(opened.body.threadId); + expect(closed.status).toBe(200); + expect(closed.body).toMatchObject({ closed: true, title: "QA: PR #78", botName: "Quinn" }); + expect((await messages(opened.body.threadId)).some((message) => message.tool?.name === "Closed by @Parker")).toBe(true); + // the close is stamped on the task — that is what the sidebar folds on — and list_threads says closed + expect((await taskOf(qa.id, opened.body.threadId)).closedBy).toMatchObject({ botId: pm.id, name: "Parker" }); + const listed = (await api("GET", "/api/internal/threads", undefined, token)).body.threads as any[]; + expect(listed.find((row) => row.threadId === opened.body.threadId)).toMatchObject({ state: "closed" }); + // closing again is a quiet no-op: same answer, no second chip + expect((await close(opened.body.threadId)).body).toMatchObject({ closed: true, alreadyClosed: true }); + expect((await messages(opened.body.threadId)).filter((message) => message.tool?.name === "Closed by @Parker")).toHaveLength(1); + // Parker's own second thread closes too; the one it speaks in does not + const own = (await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/tasks`, { title: "Notes" })).body.task.threadId as string; + expect((await close(own)).status).toBe(200); + expect((await taskOf(pm.id, own)).closedBy).toMatchObject({ name: "Parker" }); + expect((await close(pm.threadId)).status).toBe(400); + // a new turn in a closed thread reopens it + rmSync(join(gates, `${own}.gate`), { force: true }); + rmSync(join(gates, `${own}.json`), { force: true }); + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${pm.id}/messages`, { text: "One more thing.", threadId: own })).status).toBe(202); + await expect.poll(async () => (await taskOf(pm.id, own))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect(await taskOf(pm.id, own)).not.toHaveProperty("closedBy"); + release(own); + // a running thread is refused: Quinn, speaking in its own thread, cannot close the one it speaks in, + // nor a sibling thread of its own while a turn is held open there + const asQuinn = await mintedToken(qa.id, qa.threadId); + expect((await close(qa.threadId, asQuinn)).status).toBe(400); + const busyOther = (await api("POST", `/api/bots/${qa.id}/tasks`, { title: "Busy one" })).body.task.threadId as string; + rmSync(join(gates, `${busyOther}.gate`), { force: true }); + rmSync(join(gates, `${busyOther}.json`), { force: true }); + expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${qa.id}/messages`, { text: "Work here.", threadId: busyOther })).status).toBe(202); + await expect.poll(async () => (await taskOf(qa.id, busyOther))?.busy, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBe(true); + expect((await close(busyOther, asQuinn)).status).toBe(409); + release(busyOther); + } finally { + await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${pm.id}`); + await api("DELETE", `/api/bots/${qa.id}`); + } + }); +}); diff --git a/server/mcp-server.test.ts b/server/mcp-server.test.ts index 52e5256d77..451231b9ed 100644 --- a/server/mcp-server.test.ts +++ b/server/mcp-server.test.ts @@ -327,6 +327,21 @@ describe("MCP tool execution", () => { }, fetcher)).rejects.toThrow("OpenMausBot did not return the renamed task"); }); + it("normalizes duplicate incoming routes through MCP validation and rejects malformed lists", async () => { + const fetcher = vi.fn(async () => ({ group: { id: "channel-1", name: "Engineering", memberIds: [] } })); + await handleToolCall("update_channel", { + channel_id: "channel-1", incoming_group_ids: ["source-1", "source-1", "source-2"], + }, fetcher); + expect(fetcher).toHaveBeenCalledWith("/api/groups/channel-1", { + method: "PATCH", body: JSON.stringify({ incomingGroupIds: ["source-1", "source-2"] }), + }); + fetcher.mockClear(); + for (const incoming_group_ids of [["source-1", 12], Array(101).fill("source-1"), ["../source"]]) { + await expect(handleToolCall("update_channel", { channel_id: "channel-1", incoming_group_ids }, fetcher)).rejects.toThrow(); + } + expect(fetcher).not.toHaveBeenCalled(); + }); + it("searches with encoded, bounded parameters", async () => { const fetcher = vi.fn(async () => ({ hits: [{ messageId: "m1" }] })); const result: any = await handleToolCall("search_messages", { query: "release notes", task_id: "task-1", limit: 100 }, fetcher); diff --git a/server/peer-approval-key.ts b/server/peer-approval-key.ts index 3fae539a48..6cbb39982a 100644 --- a/server/peer-approval-key.ts +++ b/server/peer-approval-key.ts @@ -1,4 +1,4 @@ -export type PeerAction = "ask_bot" | "delegate_bot" | "post_to_room"; +export type PeerAction = "ask_bot" | "delegate_bot" | "post_to_room" | "discuss_room"; /** Stable persisted grant for one peer action and one target — a bot for * the two peer actions, the room for post_to_room. */ diff --git a/server/peer-approval.ts b/server/peer-approval.ts index ed33bd8436..5cf82096b2 100644 --- a/server/peer-approval.ts +++ b/server/peer-approval.ts @@ -116,6 +116,7 @@ const ACTION_VERB: Record = { ask_bot: "contact", delegate_bot: "delegate to", post_to_room: "post in", + discuss_room: "discuss in this room with", }; function pushApprovalCard( diff --git a/server/room-discussion.e2e.test.ts b/server/room-discussion.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..bf493d3948 --- /dev/null +++ b/server/room-discussion.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,17 @@ +import { mkdtempSync } from "node:fs"; +import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; +import { join } from "node:path"; +import { expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { verifyRoomDiscussion } from "../scripts/verify-room-discussion.ts"; +import { removeTempDir } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; + +it("discusses with existing members in every layer, revises decisions and only then delegates", async () => { + const folder = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "room-discussion-evidence-")); + try { + const evidence = await verifyRoomDiscussion(join(folder, "verification.json")); + expect(evidence.nodes.filter((node: any) => node.kind === "discussion")).toHaveLength(3); + expect(evidence.provider).toHaveLength(14); + expect(evidence.nodes.find((node: any) => !node.parentId)?.text).toContain("CSV出力の新機能を検討してください"); + expect(evidence.checks).toContain("premature forwarding rejected before and during discussion"); + } finally { await removeTempDir(folder); } +}, 150_000); diff --git a/server/room-handoff-agent.test.ts b/server/room-handoff-agent.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..00d42923af --- /dev/null +++ b/server/room-handoff-agent.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,28 @@ +import { mkdtempSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; +import { join } from "node:path"; +import { expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { removeTempDir } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; +import { runRoomHandoffAgent } from "./testing/room-handoff-agent.ts"; + +it.each(["code", "signal"])("rejects pending MCP requests promptly after a child exits by %s", async mode => { + const dir = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "room-mcp-exit-")); + try { + const config = join(dir, "mcp.json"); + const system = join(dir, "system.txt"); + const plan = join(dir, "plan.json"); + const script = `process.stdin.once('data', () => { + ${mode === "code" ? "process.exit(7)" : "process.kill(process.pid, 'SIGTERM')"}; + });`; + writeFileSync(config, JSON.stringify({ mcpServers: { agents: { + command: process.execPath, args: ["-e", script], env: { OMB_BOT_ID: "fixture-bot", OMB_THREAD_ID: "fixture-thread" }, + } } })); + writeFileSync(system, "Fixture system instructions"); + writeFileSync(plan, JSON.stringify({ "fixture-bot": {} })); + await expect(runRoomHandoffAgent(["--mcp-config", config, "--append-system-prompt-file", system], plan)) + .rejects.toThrow("Fixture MCP exited unexpectedly"); + const evidence = JSON.parse(readFileSync(`${plan}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8")); + expect(evidence).toMatchObject({ botId: "fixture-bot", threadId: "fixture-thread", evidence: [] }); + } finally { await removeTempDir(dir); } +// This deadline is well below the 20-second MCP fallback, and includes cleanup. +}, 8_000); diff --git a/server/room-handoffs-lifecycle.e2e.test.ts b/server/room-handoffs-lifecycle.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..9e56d1ddf2 --- /dev/null +++ b/server/room-handoffs-lifecycle.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,234 @@ +import { existsSync, readFileSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; +import { join } from "node:path"; +import { expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { launchVerificationServer, runControlOmb } from "../scripts/control-omb.ts"; +import { handleToolCall, request } from "../scripts/mcp-server.ts"; + +async function withRooms(test: (f: any) => Promise) { + const session = await launchVerificationServer(process.env, undefined, undefined, undefined, undefined, { scripted: true }); + const env = { OPENMAUSBOT_URL: session.info.url }; + const cli = (...args: string[]) => runControlOmb(args, { env }) as Promise; + const api = (path: string, body?: unknown, method = "POST") => request(path, body === undefined ? {} : { method, body: JSON.stringify(body) }, session.info.url) as Promise; + const tool = (name: string, args: Record) => handleToolCall(name, args, (path, options) => request(path, options, session.info.url)) as Promise; + try { + const sender = (await cli("new-bot", "--name", "Director", "--section", "A")).bot; + const target = (await cli("new-bot", "--name", "Engineer", "--section", "A")).bot; + const source = (await tool("create_channel", { name: "Planning", member_ids: [sender.id], bulletin: "SOURCE_ONLY" })).channel; + const destination = (await tool("create_channel", { name: "Engineering", member_ids: [target.id], bulletin: "DESTINATION_ONLY" })).channel; + await cli("room-routes", "--channel", destination.id, "--from", source.id); + const planPath = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-plan.json"); + const plan: Record = { + [sender.id]: { steps: [{ arguments: { group_id: destination.id, bot_ids: [target.id], request_key: "work", message: "Please build CSV" } }], reply: "Assigned", resumeReply: "Reviewed downstream outcome" }, + [target.id]: { reply: "Built CSV" }, + }; + const savePlan = () => writeFileSync(planPath, JSON.stringify(plan)); + const nodes = () => { + const file = join(session.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"); + return existsSync(file) ? JSON.parse(readFileSync(file, "utf8")) : []; + }; + const messages = async (threadId: string) => (await api(`/api/threads/${threadId}/messages`)).messages; + const start = async () => { savePlan(); return cli("send-channel", "--channel", source.id, "--text", "@Director Start the assignment"); }; + const wait = async () => cli("wait", "--channel", source.id, "--timeout", "30"); + const provider = () => readFileSync(`${planPath}.evidence.jsonl`, "utf8").trim().split("\n").map(line => JSON.parse(line)); + await test({ session, api, cli, tool, sender, target, source, destination, plan, savePlan, nodes, messages, start, wait, provider }); + } finally { await session.close(); } +} + +it("refuses a disabled incoming route without starting the recipient", () => withRooms(async f => { + await f.cli("room-routes", "--channel", f.destination.id, "--from", ""); + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps[0].expectError = true; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); + expect(await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).toEqual([]); +}), 45_000); + +it("normalizes duplicate route IDs through the real MCP handler and server", () => withRooms(async f => { + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.destination.id, incoming_group_ids: [f.source.id, f.source.id] }); + const group = (await f.api("/api/bots")).groups.find((g: any) => g.id === f.destination.id); + expect(group.incomingGroupIds).toEqual([f.source.id]); +}), 45_000); + +it("restores standard permitted-team coordination when route restrictions are cleared", () => withRooms(async f => { + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.destination.id, incoming_group_ids: [] }); + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.destination.id, incoming_group_ids: null }); + const group = (await f.api("/api/bots")).groups.find((g: any) => g.id === f.destination.id); + expect(group.incomingGroupIds).toBeNull(); + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId).status).toBe("completed"); +}), 45_000); + +it.each([undefined, null])("allows narrowing an unrestricted (%s) route while unrelated work is busy", initial => withRooms(async f => { + if (initial === null) await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.source.id, incoming_group_ids: null }); + const gate = join(f.session.info.dataDir, "route-edit-gate"); + f.plan[f.target.id].waitForFile = gate; + f.savePlan(); + await f.cli("send", "--bot", f.target.id, "--text", "Hold independent work while routes change"); + await expect.poll(async () => (await f.api("/api/bots")).bots.find((b: any) => b.id === f.target.id)?.busy).toBe(true); + const patch = async (incomingGroupIds: string[] | null) => { + // This is the headless loopback path, with no browser Origin or admin session. + const response = await fetch(`${f.session.info.url}/api/groups/${f.source.id}`, { + method: "PATCH", headers: { "content-type": "application/json" }, body: JSON.stringify({ incomingGroupIds }), + }); + return { status: response.status, body: await response.json() as any }; + }; + try { + if (initial === null) expect(await patch(null)).toMatchObject({ status: 200, body: { group: { incomingGroupIds: null } } }); + expect(await patch([f.destination.id])).toMatchObject({ status: 200, body: { group: { incomingGroupIds: [f.destination.id] } } }); + expect((await patch([f.destination.id])).status).toBe(200); + expect(await patch([])).toMatchObject({ status: 200, body: { group: { incomingGroupIds: [] } } }); + expect((await patch([f.destination.id])).status).toBe(409); + expect((await patch(null)).status).toBe(409); + const group = (await f.api("/api/bots")).groups.find((g: any) => g.id === f.source.id); + expect(group.incomingGroupIds).toEqual([]); + } finally { + writeFileSync(gate, "release isolated work"); + await f.cli("wait", "--bot", f.target.id, "--timeout", "15"); + } +}), 45_000); + +it("does not lend a Chief's team grants to discussion participants", () => withRooms(async f => { + await f.api(`/api/bots/${f.target.id}`, { section: "Engineering" }, "PATCH"); + await f.api(`/api/bots/${f.sender.id}`, { chiefOfStaff: true, managedSections: ["Engineering"], acknowledgePeerScope: true }, "PATCH"); + const reviewer = (await f.cli("new-bot", "--name", "Authorized reviewer", "--section", "Engineering")).bot; + await f.api(`/api/bots/${reviewer.id}`, { chiefOfStaff: true, managedSections: ["A"], acknowledgePeerScope: true }, "PATCH"); + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.source.id, member_ids: [f.sender.id, f.target.id, reviewer.id], require_room_discussion: true }); + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps = [{ tool: "discuss_room", expectError: true, + arguments: { member_ids: [f.target.id], topic: "Private planning discussion", request_key: "discussion" } }]; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); + expect(f.provider().map((turn: any) => turn.botId)).toEqual([f.sender.id]); + const discoveryResult = f.provider()[0].evidence[1].result; + expect(discoveryResult.isError).not.toBe(true); + const discovery = JSON.parse(discoveryResult.content[0].text); + expect(discovery.currentRoom.members.map((member: any) => member.id)).toEqual([reviewer.id]); +}), 45_000); + +it.each(["recipient", "source-reader", "destination-reader"])("refuses cross-section work involving a %s even with an incoming route", role => withRooms(async f => { + if (role === "recipient") await f.api(`/api/bots/${f.target.id}`, { section: "Other company" }, "PATCH"); + else { + const outsider = (await f.cli("new-bot", "--name", "Outsider", "--section", "Other company")).bot; + const room = role === "source-reader" ? f.source : f.destination; + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: room.id, member_ids: [...room.memberIds, outsider.id] }); + } + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps[0].expectError = true; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); + expect(await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).toEqual([]); + expect((await f.messages(f.source.activeTaskId)).some((m: any) => m.text === "Assigned")).toBe(true); + const discovery = f.provider().find((turn: any) => turn.botId === f.sender.id).evidence[1]; + if (role === "source-reader") expect(discovery.result.isError).toBe(true); + else expect(JSON.parse(discovery.result.content[0].text).rooms).toEqual([]); +}), 45_000); + +it.each(["discuss_room", "coordinate_bots"])("refuses cross-section %s inside a mixed room", tool => withRooms(async f => { + await f.api(`/api/bots/${f.target.id}`, { section: "Other company" }, "PATCH"); + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: f.source.id, member_ids: [f.sender.id, f.target.id], require_room_discussion: tool === "discuss_room" }); + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps = [{ tool, expectError: true, arguments: tool === "discuss_room" + ? { member_ids: [f.target.id], topic: "Discuss CSV", request_key: "discussion" } + : { bot_ids: [f.target.id], message: "Build CSV", request_key: "assignment" } }]; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); +}), 45_000); + +it("rechecks section membership before queued work dispatch and withholds its result", () => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.target.id].delayMs = 2000; f.savePlan(); + await f.cli("send", "--bot", f.target.id, "--text", "Independent task"); + await f.start(); + await expect.poll(() => f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId)?.status, { timeout: 10_000 }).toBe("queued"); + // Model a user changing the fixture's settings from its served UI mid-turn. + await request(`/api/bots/${f.target.id}`, { method: "PATCH", headers: { Origin: f.session.info.url }, + body: JSON.stringify({ section: "Other company" }) }, f.session.info.url); + expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId).status).toBe("failed"); + expect(await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).toEqual([]); + expect((await f.messages(f.source.activeTaskId)).some((m: any) => m.tool?.name?.includes("Result withheld"))).toBe(true); + await f.cli("wait", "--bot", f.target.id, "--timeout", "15"); +}), 45_000); + +it.each([4000, 4001])("enforces the %i-character request boundary on the real server", length => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps[0].arguments.message = "x".repeat(length); + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps[0].expectError = length > 4000; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + if (length > 4000) expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); + else expect(f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId).status).toBe("completed"); +}), 45_000); + +it("does not turn incidental mentions into extra participants in initiating or dispatched turns", () => withRooms(async f => { + const observer = (await f.cli("new-bot", "--name", "Observer", "--section", "A")).bot; + for (const room of [f.source, f.destination]) { + await f.tool("update_channel", { channel_id: room.id, member_ids: [...room.memberIds, observer.id] }); + } + f.plan[f.sender.id].reply = "Assigned; @Observer is mentioned only as context"; + f.plan[f.sender.id].resumeReply = "Reviewed; @Observer is mentioned only as context"; + f.plan[f.target.id].reply = "Built CSV; @Observer is mentioned only as context"; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.provider().map((turn: any) => turn.botId)).toEqual([f.sender.id, f.target.id, f.sender.id]); + expect(f.nodes().every((n: any) => n.status === "completed")).toBe(true); +}), 45_000); + +it("returns a provider failure to the sender and resumes it to handle the failure", () => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.target.id].fail = true; + await f.start(); expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + const child = f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId); + expect(child.status).toBe("failed"); + const source = await f.messages(f.source.activeTaskId); + expect(source.some((m: any) => m.roomRequest?.phase === "result" && m.tool?.name?.includes("failed"))).toBe(true); + expect(source.some((m: any) => m.text === "Reviewed downstream outcome")).toBe(true); +}), 45_000); + +it("keeps a busy recipient queued and rejects a revoked route before dispatch", () => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.target.id].delayMs = 2000; + f.savePlan(); + await f.cli("send", "--bot", f.target.id, "--text", "Independent direct task"); + await f.start(); + await expect.poll(() => f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId)?.status, { timeout: 10_000 }).toBe("queued"); + await f.cli("room-routes", "--channel", f.destination.id, "--from", ""); + expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + expect(f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId).status).toBe("failed"); + expect(await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).toEqual([]); + await f.cli("wait", "--bot", f.target.id, "--timeout", "15"); +}), 45_000); + +it("stops an active downstream turn when the source group is interrupted", () => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.target.id].delayMs = 10_000; + await f.start(); + await expect.poll(() => f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId)?.status, { timeout: 10_000 }).toBe("running"); + await f.cli("interrupt", "--channel", f.source.id); + await expect.poll(async () => { + const { bots } = await f.api("/api/bots"); return bots.find((b: any) => b.id === f.target.id)?.busy; + }, { timeout: 15_000 }).toBeFalsy(); + expect(f.nodes().every((n: any) => n.status === "cancelled")).toBe(true); + expect((await f.messages(f.source.activeTaskId)).some((m: any) => m.text === "Reviewed downstream outcome")).toBe(false); +}), 45_000); + +it.each(["allow", "deny"])("honors %s on the sender's peer-approval card", behavior => withRooms(async f => { + await f.api(`/api/bots/${f.sender.id}`, { approvePeerComms: true }, "PATCH"); + f.plan[f.sender.id].steps[0].expectError = behavior === "deny"; + await f.start(); + let card: any; + await expect.poll(async () => { + card = (await f.messages(f.source.activeTaskId)).find((m: any) => m.card?.tool === "delegate_bot"); + return Boolean(card); + }, { timeout: 10_000 }).toBe(true); + expect(await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).toEqual([]); + expect((await f.cli("wait", "--channel", f.source.id, "--timeout", "3")).status).toBe("needs-user"); + await f.api(`/api/threads/${f.source.activeTaskId}/respond`, { requestId: card.card.requestId, behavior }); + expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + if (behavior === "deny") expect(f.nodes()).toEqual([]); + else expect(f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", approvalGranted: true }); +}), 45_000); + +it("pins a busy destination's task even when its active task changes", () => withRooms(async f => { + f.plan[f.target.id].delayMs = 1500; + f.savePlan(); await f.cli("send", "--bot", f.target.id, "--text", "Independent work"); + await f.start(); + await expect.poll(() => f.nodes().find((n: any) => n.parentId)?.status, { timeout: 10_000 }).toBe("queued"); + const created = await f.tool("create_task", { target_type: "channel", target_id: f.destination.id, title: "Unrelated conversation" }); + expect((await f.wait()).status).toBe("settled"); + const nodes = f.nodes(); expect(nodes.find((n: any) => n.parentId).threadId).toBe(f.destination.activeTaskId); + expect((await f.messages(f.destination.activeTaskId)).some((m: any) => m.text === "Built CSV")).toBe(true); + const current = (await f.api("/api/bots")).groups.find((g: any) => g.id === f.destination.id); + expect(current.threadId).not.toBe(f.destination.activeTaskId); + expect(await f.messages(current.threadId)).toEqual([]); + expect(created.success).toBe(true); +}), 45_000); diff --git a/server/room-handoffs.e2e.test.ts b/server/room-handoffs.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..2284d78c89 --- /dev/null +++ b/server/room-handoffs.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +import { expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { verifyRoomHandoffs } from "../scripts/verify-room-handoffs.ts"; + +it("routes a real three-layer MCP conversation and returns outcomes to both ancestors", async () => { + const evidence = await verifyRoomHandoffs(); + expect(evidence.ok).toBe(true); +}, 120_000); diff --git a/server/room-handoffs.test.ts b/server/room-handoffs.test.ts index a48f00e286..635db2c933 100644 --- a/server/room-handoffs.test.ts +++ b/server/room-handoffs.test.ts @@ -18,6 +18,30 @@ async function fixture(test: (engine: RoomHandoffs, hooks: RoomHandoffHooks, fil const flush = () => new Promise(resolve => setImmediate(resolve)); describe("addressed room request tree", () => { + it("allows bounded same-room discussion but never recursive discussion or another-room participants", () => fixture(async (engine, hooks) => { + const discussion = engine.enqueue(addr("A"), "turn", undefined, addr("A"), "debate", "Evaluate the plan", false, false, "", ["reviewer", "qa"]).node; + expect(discussion.kind).toBe("discussion"); + expect(() => engine.enqueue(addr("A"), "other", undefined, addr("B"), "bad", "Evaluate", false, false, "", ["qa"])).toThrow("same conversation"); + discussion.status = "running"; + expect(() => engine.enqueue(addr("A"), "t", discussion.id, addr("B"), "recurse", "Again")).toThrow("cannot delegate"); + discussion.status = "queued"; + engine.sourceSettled("turn", true); + for (let i = 0; i < 5; i++) { engine.tick(); await flush(); } + expect(hooks.run).toHaveBeenCalledTimes(2); + expect(engine.nodes.get("turn")?.executions).toBe(3); + })); + + it("charges every discussion participant against the configured execution budget", () => fixture(async (engine, hooks) => { + const discussion = engine.enqueue(addr("A"), "turn", undefined, addr("A"), "debate", "Evaluate the plan", false, false, "", ["reviewer", "qa", "planner"]).node; + engine.sourceSettled("turn", true); + engine.tick(); + await flush(); + expect(discussion.status).toBe("failed"); + expect(discussion.result).toContain("execution budget exhausted"); + expect(hooks.run).not.toHaveBeenCalled(); + expect(engine.nodes.get("turn")?.executions).toBe(0); + }, Date.now, { executions: 2 })); + it("starts independent work before its author settles, but resumes only after settlement", () => fixture(async (engine, hooks) => { const source = { botId: "chief", threadId: "chief-chat" }; const child = engine.enqueue(source, "turn", undefined, { botId: "builder", threadId: "builder-chat" }, "build", "Build it").node; @@ -106,6 +130,9 @@ describe("addressed room request tree", () => { engine.enqueue(addr("C"), "cancel", undefined, addr("D"), "work", "cancel work"); updates.length = 0; engine.cancelRoom("C"); expect(updates.flat()).toEqual([{ id: "D", active: false }, { id: "C", active: false }]); + updates.length = 0; + engine.cancelTree(engine.nodes.get("cancel")!, "Late provider rejection", "failed"); + expect(updates).toEqual([]); })); it("splits responsibility between existing members who send their own downstream work and return to the chair", () => fixture(async (engine, hooks) => { const member = (id: string) => ({ ...addr("A"), botId: id }); diff --git a/server/room-handoffs.ts b/server/room-handoffs.ts index b153f38e6e..d10aa3df64 100644 --- a/server/room-handoffs.ts +++ b/server/room-handoffs.ts @@ -12,7 +12,8 @@ const nodeSchema = z.object({ result: z.string().default(""), reported: z.boolean().default(false), executions: z.number().int().nonnegative().default(0), startedAt: z.number().optional(), approvalGranted: z.boolean().default(false), - kind: z.enum(["work", "assignment"]).default("work"), + kind: z.enum(["work", "discussion", "assignment"]).default("work"), + participants: z.array(z.string()).max(4).default([]), }); export type RoomHandoff = z.infer; export type RoomAddress = Pick; @@ -166,7 +167,9 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { enqueue(source: RoomAddress, generation: string, parentId: string | undefined, target: RoomAddress, key: string, text: string, approvalGranted = false, - rework = false, sourceText = "", requestBatchKey?: string): { node: RoomHandoff; duplicate: boolean } { + rework = false, sourceText = "", discussionOrBatchKey?: string[] | string): { node: RoomHandoff; duplicate: boolean } { + const discussion = Array.isArray(discussionOrBatchKey) ? discussionOrBatchKey : undefined; + const requestBatchKey = typeof discussionOrBatchKey === "string" ? discussionOrBatchKey : undefined; if (this.loadError) throw new Error(this.loadError); let parent = parentId ? this.nodes.get(parentId) : this.nodes.get(generation); if (parentId && (!parent || parent.status !== "running")) throw new Error("The originating room task is no longer running"); @@ -174,16 +177,19 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { throw new Error("The handoff belongs to a different room speaker"); } const fresh = !parent; - parent ??= { ...source, id: generation, rootId: generation, key: "root", text: sourceText.slice(0, 12_000), createdAt: this.now(), status: "source", result: "", reported: true, executions: 0, approvalGranted: false, kind: "work" }; - const kind = target.groupId && target.groupId === source.groupId ? "assignment" : "work"; + parent ??= { ...source, id: generation, rootId: generation, key: "root", text: sourceText.slice(0, 12_000), createdAt: this.now(), status: "source", result: "", reported: true, executions: 0, approvalGranted: false, kind: "work", participants: [] }; + if (parent.kind === "discussion") throw new Error("Discussion participants cannot delegate or start another discussion"); + const kind = discussion ? "discussion" : target.groupId && target.groupId === source.groupId ? "assignment" : "work"; + if (discussion && (!source.groupId || target.groupId !== source.groupId || target.threadId !== source.threadId || target.botId !== source.botId || + !discussion.length || discussion.length > 4 || new Set(discussion).size !== discussion.length || discussion.includes(source.botId))) throw new Error("Discussion must name 1-4 other members of this same conversation"); const path = this.path(parent); - if (path.some(n => n.botId === target.botId && (!n.groupId || !target.groupId || n.groupId === target.groupId))) { + if (!discussion && path.some(n => n.botId === target.botId && (!n.groupId || !target.groupId || n.groupId === target.groupId))) { throw new Error("Cannot assign work back to an ancestor; results return automatically"); } const existing = this.children(parent.id).find(n => n.key === key); if (existing) { if (existing.groupId !== target.groupId || existing.botId !== target.botId || existing.text !== text || - existing.kind !== kind || existing.requestBatchKey !== requestBatchKey) throw new Error("request_key was already used for different work"); + existing.kind !== kind || existing.requestBatchKey !== requestBatchKey || JSON.stringify(existing.participants) !== JSON.stringify(discussion ?? [])) throw new Error("request_key was already used for different work"); return { node: existing, duplicate: true }; } if (requestBatchKey && target.groupId) { @@ -191,7 +197,7 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { if (batch.some(n => n.text !== text || n.threadId !== target.threadId)) throw new Error("request_key was already used for different room work"); if (batch.some(n => n.startedAt !== undefined)) throw new Error("This shared room request has already started; use a new request_key for additional recipients"); } - if (!rework && this.children(parent.id).some(n => n.kind === kind && + if (!discussion && !rework && this.children(parent.id).some(n => n.kind === kind && n.groupId === target.groupId && n.botId === target.botId && n.status === "completed")) { throw new Error("This agent already completed your assignment. Do not send acknowledgements or approvals as new work. Finish with your decision; results return automatically. Only use rework=true for concrete additional work."); } @@ -223,7 +229,7 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { } const node: RoomHandoff = { ...target, id: randomUUID(), rootId: parent.rootId, parentId: parent.id, key, text, createdAt: this.now(), status: "queued", result: "", reported: false, executions: 0, approvalGranted, - kind, ...(target.groupId && requestBatchKey ? { requestBatchKey } : {}) }; + kind, participants: discussion ?? [], ...(target.groupId && requestBatchKey ? { requestBatchKey } : {}) }; const problem = this.hooks.validate(node, parent); if (problem) throw new Error(problem); if (fresh) this.nodes.set(parent.id, parent); @@ -257,10 +263,10 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { if (!terminal(node)) { node.status = status; node.result = reason; this.controllers.get(node.id)?.abort(); + // Settlement closes the paused span before publishing the terminal state. + this.trackExecutionPauses(); + this.publish(node); } - // Settlement closes the paused span now, not at the next periodic tick. - this.trackExecutionPauses(); - this.publish(node); } cancelRoom(groupId: string, threadId?: string) { for (const n of this.nodes.values()) { @@ -340,7 +346,7 @@ export class RoomHandoffs { if (parent && terminal(parent) && n.status === "queued") { this.cancelTree(n, "Originating request has ended"); continue; } if (this.hooks.busy(n)) continue; const root = this.root(n); - const executionCost = 1; + const executionCost = n.kind === "discussion" ? n.participants.length : 1; if (root.executions + executionCost > this.limits.executions) { this.cancelTree(n, "Room execution budget exhausted", "failed"); continue; } const resumed = n.status === "resume"; const childCount = this.children(n.id).length; diff --git a/server/room-pyramid.e2e.test.ts b/server/room-pyramid.e2e.test.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..0f2a6e206f --- /dev/null +++ b/server/room-pyramid.e2e.test.ts @@ -0,0 +1,15 @@ +import { mkdtempSync } from "node:fs"; +import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; +import { join } from "node:path"; +import { expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { verifyRoomPyramid } from "../scripts/verify-room-pyramid.ts"; +import { removeTempDir } from "./testing/cleanup.ts"; + +it("discusses, revises, splits among members, delegates to separate groups and consolidates their outputs", async () => { + const directory = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "room-pyramid-evidence-")); + try { + const evidence = await verifyRoomPyramid(join(directory, "verification.json")); + expect(evidence.bots).toHaveLength(15); + expect(evidence.provider).toHaveLength(45); + } finally { await removeTempDir(directory); } +}, 240_000); diff --git a/server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts b/server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts index 9ce3d171f7..9c7b903e83 100644 --- a/server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts +++ b/server/routine-delegation.e2e.test.ts @@ -183,21 +183,28 @@ describe("routine delegation through the isolated harness", () => { unlinkSync(file(run.threadId, "json")); await api("POST", `/api/bots/${source.id}/messages`, { threadId: run.threadId, text: "A new request: ask the peer for a fresh report." }); const launched = await dump(run.threadId); + expect(launched.mcpConfig.mcpServers.agents.env.OMB_ROOM_TURN).toBe("1"); const coordinated = await api("POST", "/api/internal/coordinate-bots", { - botIds: [peer.id], requestKey: "fresh-report", message: "Produce a fresh fixture report.", + botIds: [peer.id], requestKey: "fresh-report", message: "Produce a fresh report for this new user request.", }, launched.mcpConfig.mcpServers.agents.env.OMB_COMMS_TOKEN); + expect(coordinated.errors).toEqual([]); expect(coordinated.accepted).toHaveLength(1); const requestId = coordinated.accepted[0].requestId; - const handoff = () => JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(fixture.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")) - .find((node: any) => node.id === requestId); + const nodes = () => JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(fixture.info.dataDir, "room-handoffs.json"), "utf8")) as any[]; + const recipient = nodes().find(node => node.id === requestId); finish(run.threadId); - await dump(handoff().threadId); - finish(handoff().threadId); + await dump(recipient.threadId); + finish(recipient.threadId); await expect.poll(async () => (await messages(run.threadId)).some( - (message) => message.from?.botId === peer.id && message.roomRequest?.id === requestId && message.roomRequest.phase === "result", + message => message.from?.botId === peer.id && message.roomRequest?.id === requestId && message.roomRequest.phase === "result" && message.tool?.ok, ), { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe(true); - await control(["wait", "--bot", source.id, "--task", run.threadId]); - expect(handoff().status).toBe("completed"); + await expect.poll(() => nodes().find(node => !node.parentId && node.threadId === run.threadId)?.status, { timeout: 20_000 }).toBe("completed"); + expect(nodes().find(node => node.id === requestId).status).toBe("completed"); + const resumed = await dump(run.threadId); + // Resumed assignments are turn-scoped; provider sessions retain their + // stable system prompt across later requests on this same conversation. + expect(resumed.prompt.message.content).toContain("Your downstream room requests have settled"); + expect(resumed.systemPrompt).not.toContain("Your downstream room requests have settled"); expect(await runState(run.id)).toMatchObject({ status: "completed", finishedAt: finished.finishedAt, output: finished.output }); evidence.push({ reusedCompletedExecution: true, transcript: await messages(run.threadId) }); }, 45_000); diff --git a/server/shared-computers.e2e.test.ts b/server/shared-computers.e2e.test.ts index 8fb7ae14dd..80bc9cdfb4 100644 --- a/server/shared-computers.e2e.test.ts +++ b/server/shared-computers.e2e.test.ts @@ -22,6 +22,7 @@ let localSharingEnabled = true; let sequence = 0; const waiting = new Map void>(); const evidence: string[] = []; +const transportEvents: string[] = []; const api = async (method: string, path: string, body?: unknown, headers: Record = {}) => { const response = await fetch(`${fixture.info.url}${path}`, { method, headers: { "content-type": "application/json", origin: fixture.info.url, ...headers }, @@ -31,10 +32,21 @@ const api = async (method: string, path: string, body?: unknown, headers: Record }; const rpc = (method: string, params?: unknown): Promise => new Promise((resolve, reject) => { const id = ++sequence; - // A shared terminal operation can legitimately run for 30 seconds, before - // its result crosses the connector and MCP boundaries (including Windows). - const timeout = setTimeout(() => { waiting.delete(id); reject(new Error(`MCP ${method} ${JSON.stringify(params)} timed out`)); }, 40_000); - waiting.set(id, value => { clearTimeout(timeout); resolve(value); }); + // Keep upstream's allowance for a 30-second command plus transport. + const call = params as { name?: string; arguments?: { action?: string } } | undefined; + const label = [method, call?.name, call?.arguments?.action].filter(Boolean).join(" "); + const started = Date.now(); + transportEvents.push(`${id}: ${label} started`); + const timeout = setTimeout(() => { + waiting.delete(id); + const state = connector.state(env.id); + reject(new Error(`MCP ${label} timed out after ${Date.now() - started}ms; connector connected=${state.connected}, proxy exit=${proxy.exitCode}; transport: ${transportEvents.slice(-12).join("; ")}`)); + }, 40_000); + waiting.set(id, value => { + clearTimeout(timeout); + transportEvents.push(`${id}: ${label} replied after ${Date.now() - started}ms`); + resolve(value); + }); proxy.stdin!.write(`${JSON.stringify({ jsonrpc: "2.0", id, method, params })}\n`); }); const tool = async (name: string, args: unknown = {}) => (await rpc("tools/call", { name, arguments: args })).result; @@ -71,7 +83,21 @@ beforeAll(async () => { connector = createComputerSharing({ file: grantFile, environments: () => [env], cuaConnection: async () => null, enabled: async () => localSharingEnabled, - fetch: (url: string, init: RequestInit) => fetch(url, { ...init, headers: { ...init.headers, authorization: `Bearer ${pairing.token}` } }), + fetch: async (url: string, init: RequestInit) => { + // Log route names and timing only: pairing tokens, connector secrets, + // file contents and command text must never enter timeout diagnostics. + const route = new URL(url).pathname.split("/").at(-1); + const started = Date.now(); + transportEvents.push(`connector ${route} started`); + try { + const response = await fetch(url, { ...init, headers: { ...init.headers, authorization: `Bearer ${pairing.token}` } }); + transportEvents.push(`connector ${route} status=${response.status} after ${Date.now() - started}ms`); + return response; + } catch (error) { + transportEvents.push(`connector ${route} failed after ${Date.now() - started}ms`); + throw error; + } + }, }); bot = (await api("POST", "/api/bots", { name: "Shared desktop tester" })).body.bot; expect((await api("POST", `/api/bots/${bot.id}/messages`, { text: "Inspect the folder shared by my desktop; do not use files on the server." })).status).toBe(202); @@ -90,7 +116,7 @@ afterAll(async () => { connector?.close(); proxy?.kill(); if (fixture) { const receipt = `${fixture.info.logPath}.computer-sharing.json`; - writeFileSync(receipt, JSON.stringify({ fixture: fixture.info, checks: evidence, limitation: "Fake model; real MCP, HTTP pairing and filesystem. OS screen control is tested with a separate transport stand-in, never the user's screen." }, null, 2)); + writeFileSync(receipt, JSON.stringify({ fixture: fixture.info, checks: evidence, transportEvents, limitation: "Fake model; real MCP, HTTP pairing and filesystem. OS screen control is tested with a separate transport stand-in, never the user's screen." }, null, 2)); console.info(`Computer-sharing evidence: ${receipt}`); await fixture.close(); } diff --git a/server/store.ts b/server/store.ts index 02fa47c578..44a8a55baf 100644 --- a/server/store.ts +++ b/server/store.ts @@ -1151,7 +1151,7 @@ export class Store { ); } - patchGroup(id: string, patch: Partial>): GroupRecord | null { + patchGroup(id: string, patch: Partial>): GroupRecord | null { const group = this.group(id); if (!group) return null; if (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(patch, "section")) { diff --git a/server/team-computers.test.ts b/server/team-computers.test.ts index 1b985c8670..bbe72763f2 100644 --- a/server/team-computers.test.ts +++ b/server/team-computers.test.ts @@ -2,7 +2,8 @@ import { randomUUID } from "node:crypto"; import { mkdtempSync, readFileSync, rmSync, statSync, symlinkSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"; import { tmpdir } from "node:os"; import { join } from "node:path"; -import { afterEach, describe, expect, it } from "vitest"; +import { afterEach, describe, expect, it, vi } from "vitest"; +import * as atomic from "./atomic.ts"; import { TeamComputers, teamComputerAssignment, teamComputerCreate, teamComputerOwner } from "./team-computers.ts"; const directories: string[] = []; @@ -13,7 +14,10 @@ const fixture = () => { const environmentId = randomUUID(); return { file, environmentId, registry: new TeamComputers(file, environmentId) }; }; -afterEach(() => { for (const directory of directories.splice(0)) rmSync(directory, { recursive: true, force: true }); }); +afterEach(() => { + vi.restoreAllMocks(); + for (const directory of directories.splice(0)) rmSync(directory, { recursive: true, force: true }); +}); describe("named team computer ownership", () => { it("renames the team label without changing computer identity or merging assignments", () => { @@ -29,6 +33,7 @@ describe("named team computer ownership", () => { expect(registry.forSection("Delivery")?.id).toBe(b.id); }); it("persists unassigned identities before provisioning and retries without a second owner", () => { + const writes = vi.spyOn(atomic, "writeFileAtomic"); const { registry, file, environmentId } = fixture(); const requestId = randomUUID(); const created = registry.create("Design desktop", requestId); @@ -44,8 +49,15 @@ describe("named team computer ownership", () => { expect(restarted.list()).toHaveLength(1); restarted.setProblem(requestId); expect(new TeamComputers(file, environmentId).get(requestId)?.problem).toBeUndefined(); - // Windows exposes synthetic POSIX mode bits; its ACLs are not represented here. - if (process.platform !== "win32") expect(statSync(file).mode & 0o777).toBe(0o600); + // The spy calls the real writer: every OS must request private creation. + // Windows stat emulates mode bits and cannot prove POSIX group/other access. + expect(writes).toHaveBeenCalled(); + for (const [path, , options] of writes.mock.calls) { + expect(path).toBe(file); + expect(options).toEqual({ mode: 0o600 }); + } + if (process.platform === "win32") expect(statSync(file).mode & 0o600).toBe(0o600); + else expect(statSync(file).mode & 0o777).toBe(0o600); }); it("has one computer per team and requires explicit unassignment before moving", () => { diff --git a/server/team-setup.e2e.test.ts b/server/team-setup.e2e.test.ts index 84818a17f3..0c67161b7e 100644 --- a/server/team-setup.e2e.test.ts +++ b/server/team-setup.e2e.test.ts @@ -30,13 +30,15 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and const codex = catalog.find((item: any) => item.instanceId === "codex"); expect(codex).toBeDefined(); const selection = (instance: any) => ({ instanceId: instance.instanceId, model: instance.models.default }); + // Reproduce a starter name colliding with a requested new specialist. + const starter = (await api("GET", "/api/bots")).bots[0]; + expect(starter).toBeDefined(); + await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${starter.id}`, { name: "Patch" }); const chief = (await api("POST", "/api/bots", { name: "Clive", title: "Chief of Staff", section: "Operations", modelSelection: selection(claude) }, 201)).bot; await api("PATCH", `/api/bots/${chief.id}`, { chiefOfStaff: true }); const state = async () => (await api("GET", "/api/bots")).bots; - // The fixture starts with a randomly named bot, which can itself be - // Mira, Patch, or Quill. Compare identities, not that starter's name. - const initialBotIds = new Set((await state()).map((bot: any) => bot.id)); - const setupBots = async () => (await state()).filter((bot: any) => !initialBotIds.has(bot.id)); + const existingIds = new Set((await state()).map((bot: any) => bot.id)); + const createdBots = (bots: any[]) => bots.filter(bot => !existingIds.has(bot.id)); let previousPid: number | undefined; let guardedMessageId: string | undefined; const start = async (text: string, sendId?: string) => { @@ -98,9 +100,10 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and await api("POST", "/api/internal/team-setup-requests", { plan: { ...plan, operations: [build("Bad", "Research", { instanceId: "codex", model: "invented-model" })] } }, 400, token); await api("POST", "/api/internal/team-setup-requests", { fromBotId: "foreign", plan }, 403, token); const denied = await api("POST", "/api/internal/team-setup-requests", { plan }, 201, token); - expect(await setupBots()).toHaveLength(0); + expect((await state()).map((bot: any) => bot.id).sort()).toEqual([...existingIds].sort()); await api("POST", `/api/threads/${chief.threadId}/respond`, { requestId: denied.requestId, behavior: "deny" }); await finish(); await continueOnce(denied.requestId); + expect((await state()).map((bot: any) => bot.id).sort()).toEqual([...existingIds].sort()); expect((await state()).find((bot: any) => bot.id === chief.id).managedSections).toBeUndefined(); const setupSendId = randomUUID(); @@ -114,7 +117,7 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and expect(card.subtitle).toContain("Chief of Staff: No → Yes"); // Origin is forgeable by an active bot shell: it cannot self-grant teams. await api("POST", `/api/threads/${chief.threadId}/respond`, { requestId: proposed.requestId, behavior: "allow" }, 403); - expect(await setupBots()).toHaveLength(0); + expect((await state()).map((bot: any) => bot.id).sort()).toEqual([...existingIds].sort()); await finish(); const waiting = await requestSnapshot(); expect(waiting).toMatchObject({ messageId: guardedMessageId, phase: "waiting", activeTurnId: null, executionId: expect.any(String) }); @@ -134,14 +137,13 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and expect(replies.every((message: any) => message.requestMessageId === guardedMessageId)).toBe(true); expect(replies.at(-1).text).toContain(`team setup decision ${proposed.requestId}:`); const saved = await state(); - const created = saved.filter((bot: any) => !initialBotIds.has(bot.id)); - expect(created.map((bot: any) => bot.name).sort()).toEqual(["Mira", "Patch", "Quill"]); - const engineer = created.find((bot: any) => bot.name === "Patch"); + expect(createdBots(saved).map(bot => bot.name).sort()).toEqual(["Mira", "Patch", "Quill"]); + const engineer = createdBots(saved).find((bot: any) => bot.name === "Patch"); expect(engineer).toMatchObject({ title: "Implementation and verification engineer", section: "Engineering", chiefOfStaff: true, modelSelection: selection(codex), approvalMode: "ask", autoApprove: false, composio: false }); expect(engineer.managedSections).toBeUndefined(); expect(saved.find((bot: any) => bot.id === chief.id).managedSections).toEqual(expect.arrayContaining(plan.newTeams)); await api("POST", `/api/threads/${chief.threadId}/respond`, { requestId: proposed.requestId, behavior: "allow" }); - expect((await setupBots()).filter((bot: any) => bot.name === "Patch")).toHaveLength(1); + expect(createdBots(await state()).filter((bot: any) => bot.name === "Patch")).toHaveLength(1); expect(JSON.parse(readFileSync(fixture.fixtureDumpPath, "utf8")).pid).toBe(previousPid); token = await start("Move Patch to Growth and switch its default engine to Claude; retain its existing thread."); @@ -173,8 +175,8 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and expect((await api("POST", `/api/threads/${chief.threadId}/respond`, { requestId: deletion.requestId, behavior: "allow" })).result.bots).toEqual([{ id: engineer.id, name: "Patch", action: "deleted" }]); await continueOnce(deletion.requestId); expect((await state()).some((bot: any) => bot.id === engineer.id)).toBe(false); - expect((await state()).filter((bot: any) => initialBotIds.has(bot.id)).map((bot: any) => bot.id).sort()) - .toEqual([...initialBotIds].sort()); + expect((await state()).filter((bot: any) => existingIds.has(bot.id)).map((bot: any) => bot.id).sort()) + .toEqual([...existingIds].sort()); await api("POST", `/api/threads/${chief.threadId}/respond`, { requestId: deletion.requestId, behavior: "allow" }); const room = (await control("new-channel", "--name", "Chief review", "--members", chief.id)).channel; unlinkSync(gate); @@ -187,6 +189,8 @@ it("Clive reviews multi-provider teams once, continues after each decision, and await api("POST", `/api/threads/${room.activeTaskId}/respond`, { requestId: groupStopped.requestId, behavior: "deny" }); await stopWithoutResume(groupStopped.requestId, room.activeTaskId, "--channel", room.id); expect((await state()).some((bot: any) => bot.name === "NoRestart")).toBe(false); + expect((await state()).find((bot: any) => bot.id === starter.id)) + .toMatchObject({ name: "Patch", threadId: starter.threadId }); await control("messages", "--bot", chief.id, "--task", chief.threadId, "--limit", "30"); await control("wait", "--bot", chief.id, "--task", chief.threadId, "--timeout", "15"); expect(readFileSync(fixture.info.logPath, "utf8")).not.toMatch(/ReferenceError|change listener threw/); diff --git a/server/testing/acp-coordination-agent.ts b/server/testing/acp-coordination-agent.ts new file mode 100644 index 0000000000..d685554ef2 --- /dev/null +++ b/server/testing/acp-coordination-agent.ts @@ -0,0 +1,22 @@ +// Adapt the real ACP-injected MCP entry to the shared coordination fixture. +// Files stay beside the disposable plan; no provider/user configuration is used. +import { mkdtempSync, writeFileSync, rmSync } from "node:fs"; +import { dirname, join } from "node:path"; +import { runRoomHandoffAgent } from "./room-handoff-agent.ts"; + +export async function runAcpCoordinationAgent( + entry: { command: string; args?: string[]; env?: Array<{ name: string; value: string }> }, + system: string, + planPath: string, +): Promise { + const scratch = mkdtempSync(join(dirname(planPath), "acp-coordination-")); + try { + const config = join(scratch, "mcp.json"); + const prompt = join(scratch, "system.txt"); + writeFileSync(config, JSON.stringify({ mcpServers: { agents: { + command: entry.command, args: entry.args ?? [], env: Object.fromEntries((entry.env ?? []).map(item => [item.name, item.value])), + } } })); + writeFileSync(prompt, system); + return await runRoomHandoffAgent(["--mcp-config", config, "--append-system-prompt-file", prompt], planPath, system); + } finally { rmSync(scratch, { recursive: true, force: true }); } +} diff --git a/server/testing/cleanup.ts b/server/testing/cleanup.ts index 7fcd1f4e1b..7a45ad37c3 100644 --- a/server/testing/cleanup.ts +++ b/server/testing/cleanup.ts @@ -12,6 +12,8 @@ import { rmSync } from "node:fs"; export interface WaitForExitOptions { /** Sent immediately. Omit for a child the caller has already signalled. */ signal?: NodeJS.Signals; + /** Opt-in IPC request for a launcher with a graceful shutdown handler. */ + message?: string; /** How long the polite signal gets before SIGKILL. */ graceMs?: number; } @@ -40,7 +42,7 @@ export function waitForExit( child: ChildProcess | undefined, options: WaitForExitOptions | number = {}, ): Promise { - const { signal, graceMs = 5_000 } = typeof options === "number" ? { graceMs: options } : options; + const { signal, message, graceMs = 5_000 } = typeof options === "number" ? { graceMs: options } : options; return new Promise((resolve) => { // signalCode, not just exitCode: a process killed by a signal reports its @@ -54,6 +56,11 @@ export function waitForExit( }; child.on("close", done); + if (message !== undefined && child.connected) { + // The callback consumes a possible disconnect race. The bounded kill + // below still applies if the launcher cannot receive the request. + child.send(message, () => {}); + } if (signal) { try { child.kill(signal); diff --git a/server/testing/fake-acp-cli.ts b/server/testing/fake-acp-cli.ts index 5657f8f146..774ef3f076 100755 --- a/server/testing/fake-acp-cli.ts +++ b/server/testing/fake-acp-cli.ts @@ -572,7 +572,7 @@ function handle(msg: any) { break; } const cachedLiveLoad = process.env.FAKE_ACP_CACHED_LIVE_LOAD === "1" && liveSession === msg.params?.sessionId; - if (mode === "safe-agent-reads" && !cachedLiveLoad) { + if ((mode === "safe-agent-reads" || process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_PLAN) && !cachedLiveLoad) { agentsMcp = (msg.params?.mcpServers ?? []).find((server: any) => server.name === "agents") ?? null; } if (process.env.FAKE_ACP_DUMP) { @@ -593,6 +593,7 @@ function handle(msg: any) { }); break; } + if (process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_PLAN) agentsMcp = (msg.params?.mcpServers ?? []).find((server: any) => server.name === "agents") ?? null; if (process.env.FAKE_ACP_DUMP) { writeFileSync(`${process.env.FAKE_ACP_DUMP}.mcp.json`, JSON.stringify(msg.params?.mcpServers ?? [])); } @@ -745,6 +746,27 @@ function handle(msg: any) { return; } const promptText = String(msg.params?.prompt?.[0]?.text ?? ""); + if (agentsMcp && process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_PLAN && process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_AGENT) { + // The harness-provided entry is used verbatim, including its scoped + // capability. This runs actual coordinate_bots calls across ACP too. + void import(process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_AGENT) + .then(module => module.runAcpCoordinationAgent(agentsMcp, promptText, process.env.FAKE_ACP_COORDINATION_PLAN)) + .then(text => { + if (!text) { + out({ jsonrpc: "2.0", method: "session/update", params: { update: { sessionUpdate: "tool_call", toolCallId: "coord-1", title: "list_room_targets" } } }); + out({ jsonrpc: "2.0", method: "session/update", params: { update: { sessionUpdate: "tool_call_update", toolCallId: "coord-1", status: "completed" } } }); + } + out({ jsonrpc: "2.0", method: "session/update", params: { update: { + sessionUpdate: "agent_message_chunk", content: { text }, + } } }); + complete(); + }) + .catch(error => { + process.stderr.write(String(error) + "\n"); + process.exit(1); + }); + return; + } // A delegated reply woke this bot (control-plane continuation): the // harness revived it to fold the result in. Synthesize instead of // driving the mode's usual delegate/ask flow, which would loop or diff --git a/server/testing/room-handoff-agent.ts b/server/testing/room-handoff-agent.ts index 275cfce608..a3c15ddbe8 100644 --- a/server/testing/room-handoff-agent.ts +++ b/server/testing/room-handoff-agent.ts @@ -111,6 +111,11 @@ export async function runRoomHandoffAgent(argv: string[], planPath: string, prom resolve(); }, 10); }); + // A test releases this gate after observing the intended concurrent state. + // The existing run deadline still bounds a gate that is never released. + while (plan.waitForFile && !existsSync(plan.waitForFile)) { + await new Promise(resolve => { delayTimer = setTimeout(resolve, 25); }); + } if (typeof plan.progressAfterGate === "string") progress?.(plan.progressAfterGate); if (plan.delayMs) await new Promise(resolve => { delayTimer = setTimeout(resolve, plan.delayMs); }); if (plan.fail && !resumed) throw new Error("Scripted addressed agent failure"); diff --git a/shared/wire.ts b/shared/wire.ts index b1448d4f1a..b59e9c12f5 100644 --- a/shared/wire.ts +++ b/shared/wire.ts @@ -558,6 +558,9 @@ export interface WireGroup { /** Computed from the usage ledger, not stored in groups.json. */ usage?: GroupThreadUsage | null; id: string; + /** Optional restriction on incoming requests; never grants access. */ + incomingGroupIds?: string[] | null; + requireRoomDiscussion?: boolean; /** The active task's thread. Direct-message channels stay single-threaded. */ threadId: string; /** User-created channels have independent tasks, newest first. */ diff --git a/src/components/GroupView.tsx b/src/components/GroupView.tsx index 8e969e439a..26fcea846a 100644 --- a/src/components/GroupView.tsx +++ b/src/components/GroupView.tsx @@ -191,6 +191,7 @@ const Transcript = memo(function Transcript({ const memberOf = (id?: string) => members.find((b) => b.id === id); // Several bots working at once turn a room into a wall of chips; fold the // finished ones the same way a 1:1 chat does. + // Hidden tool steps must not consume a new speaker's name label. const items = useMemo(() => groupActivityRuns(messages.filter(message => message.kind !== "activity" || roomActivityVisible(message, showToolCalls))), [messages, showToolCalls]); const newestMessageId = messages.at(-1)?.id; @@ -1220,6 +1221,36 @@ export function GroupView({ group }: { group: Group }) { {findOpen && setFindOpen(false)} />} + {!remoteClient && !group.dm && !setupPending && ( +
+ {t("room.incoming.summary")} +

{t("room.incoming.description")}

+ + + {Array.isArray(group.incomingGroupIds) &&
+ {state.groups.filter(candidate => candidate.id !== group.id && !candidate.dm).map(candidate => ( + + ))} +
} +
+ )} + {/* Bulletin: one pinned line; click to edit */} {!setupPending &&
{bulletinOpen ? ( diff --git a/src/lib/memory.test.ts b/src/lib/memory.test.ts index 488a65f169..b05e33a23c 100644 --- a/src/lib/memory.test.ts +++ b/src/lib/memory.test.ts @@ -90,7 +90,9 @@ describe("relativeTime", () => { }); it("falls back to a date past a week and never goes negative", () => { - expect(relativeTime(now - 10 * 86_400_000, now)).toMatch(/Aug|Sep/); + const past = now - 10 * 86_400_000; + const localizedDate = new Intl.DateTimeFormat(undefined, { month: "short", day: "numeric" }).format(past); + expect(relativeTime(past, now)).toBe(localizedDate); expect(relativeTime(now + 60_000, now)).toBe("just now"); }); }); diff --git a/src/locales/en.json b/src/locales/en.json index 2a924dd0a0..7ddb043839 100644 --- a/src/locales/en.json +++ b/src/locales/en.json @@ -2517,6 +2517,10 @@ "backup.skipDraftsHint": "Keep this browser’s current drafts and preferences. This does not undo the installation restore.", "backup.serverBusy": "An installation backup operation is already running.", "backup.checkStatus": "Checking backup availability…", + "room.incoming.summary": "Group collaboration settings", + "room.incoming.description": "Teammates use the existing collaboration and access rules by default. Optionally require a discussion or limit which groups may send requests here.", + "room.incoming.discussion": "Discuss with members before delegating or concluding incoming work", + "room.incoming.restrict": "Restrict incoming requests to selected groups", "companyBackup.title": "Company cloud backups", "companyBackup.account": "{organization} · {email}", "companyBackup.managedScope": "Your snapshots are available only to your signed-in company account, across your connected computers. Other members cannot restore them. Automatic backups are off unless you enable them.", diff --git a/src/locales/ja.json b/src/locales/ja.json index 005f280c8d..274df52ef8 100644 --- a/src/locales/ja.json +++ b/src/locales/ja.json @@ -1361,6 +1361,10 @@ "remote.signInAccess.invalid": "メールアドレス、またはそのドメイン全員を表す @domain を入力してください。", "remote.signInAccess.note": "変更はすぐに反映されます。削除すると新しいサインインはできなくなります。既存のデバイスは上でサインアウトするまで残ります。", "remote.signInAccess.error": "保存できませんでした: {error}", + "room.incoming.summary": "グループの協働設定", + "room.incoming.description": "通常は既存の協働機能とアクセス権を使います。必要に応じて議論を必須にしたり、依頼を受けるグループを限定したりできます。", + "room.incoming.discussion": "下流への依頼や受けた仕事の完了前に、メンバーと議論する", + "room.incoming.restrict": "依頼を受けるグループを限定する", "engines.icon.label": "プロバイダーアイコン", "engines.icon.selectAria": "{name} のプロバイダーアイコン", "engines.icon.default": "デフォルトのアイコン", diff --git a/src/locales/source-hashes.json b/src/locales/source-hashes.json index 9e60412f68..22774f2581 100644 --- a/src/locales/source-hashes.json +++ b/src/locales/source-hashes.json @@ -6990,6 +6990,10 @@ "remote.signInAccess.invalid": "f7571753e84241b531638ab312bb1b704d261eebae3a05d27f24c02a5ba5061e", "remote.signInAccess.note": "ce9c15dc3fe23bbed92cb66d4cd54b8fdf0498f52f6bd2250067134b1ac65783", "remote.signInAccess.error": "71a471a7b15e8647dda8cab60737a1b41901bdcbe3be10f477a9163b723f4e1d", + "room.incoming.summary": "6df7ab104bff6e27c9a5e20da2d5d33697e1ab9ac06d0efac14c2955e04a322b", + "room.incoming.description": "fbe3e0aa493efa600c57dacfb3372b3eafb6d4f1eedc9f7a0c7a0b944eee60a9", + "room.incoming.discussion": "4ed8f158834c1bf6b97c3d75027fb5609490fe3460737d356d92910300a889ca", + "room.incoming.restrict": "a7f9dce40d7258aa857f5b0b6a734d58cdc2ebb8b73a311bbfd5490dcb17789d", "engines.icon.label": "567678203b1cd073a2d4d4ed70538c463c2219e5016729cc785addb85a790947", "engines.icon.selectAria": "0ff08a2967b0447be8c4ad42dab258da7d81de4c322f80348dd4cb89d34bc6fe", "engines.icon.default": "77728294df621c7bd673e970d29e6d9075e1698b6872b3e1e12585691a429490", diff --git a/src/state/store.tsx b/src/state/store.tsx index 77d2ab7dfa..dca126268c 100644 --- a/src/state/store.tsx +++ b/src/state/store.tsx @@ -216,6 +216,8 @@ export type GroupDefaultResponder = /** A room: several bots + you in one shared thread. */ export interface Group { + incomingGroupIds?: string[] | null; + requireRoomDiscussion?: boolean; usage?: GroupThreadUsage | null; id: string; threadId: string; @@ -1049,7 +1051,7 @@ export type Action = | { type: "patchGroup"; groupId: string; - patch: Partial>; + patch: Partial>; } | { type: "deleteGroup"; groupId: string } | { type: "newGroupTask"; groupId: string }